📜 Liberty and the Republic™
Courses › COVID and Liberty™

Lesson 23 of 23 · about 60 minutes

Timeline, Glossary, Sources and the Record of Every Ruling

Updated November 7, 2026

You'll be able to

  • Find any ruling in the module by date, court and citation, and state its holding in one sentence
  • Explain how the Supreme Court's worship cases moved from South Bay (May 2020) to Tandon (April 2021)
  • Tell a ruling on the merits from a case ended as moot or on standing
  • Name the statutes and votes that changed the rules after 2020, including Idaho SJR 102 and section 525 of the 2023 NDAA
  • State the main arguments governments made, in their own words, and how the courts answered them
  • Use the glossary and reading guide to go to the primary records for each lesson

Start here: the short version

This lesson is the record book of the module. It gathers, in one place, every court ruling the profiles rest on, from a Dallas contempt hearing in May 2020 to the Federal Court of Appeal of Canada in January 2026, with the court, the citation or docket number, the vote or the judge, a one-sentence holding and a link to the lesson that tells the story.12 It adds the statutes and orders that changed the rules (Idaho's SJR 102, Michigan's repeal of its 1945 emergency law, section 525 of the 2023 defense authorization act, California's SB 815 and Florida's No Patient Left Alone Act), a dated timeline of the profiles, a glossary of 54 terms and a reading guide by lesson.34567

The record shows something the headlines of 2020 did not: people who stood their ground often won. A salon owner jailed for opening her shop had the order that jailed her declared void.1 A Louisiana pastor's charges were quashed by his state's highest court.8 The Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn and Agudath Israel of America, a home Bible study in California, a group of landlords and a federation of small businesses all won at the Supreme Court of the United States.9101112 Many others lost in court and still changed the law through legislatures and voters. Every one of them had to accept the risk of arrest, fines, lost jobs or years of litigation before anyone knew how the cases would end. That is why the record is worth keeping.

The National Archives Building in Washington, D.C., a large stone building with tall columns, seen from the street
The National Archives Building in Washington, D.C. Court opinions, statutes and orders like the ones collected in this lesson are the public record that the profiles in this module rest on. Photo: David Samuel, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

How to read this record

Each row of the table below is one decision. The "Outcome" column states whether the ruling went for the people who challenged the order (won), against them (lost), partly each way (mixed), or ended the case without deciding it because the order had expired or been repealed (moot). The holding is stated in one sentence from the opinion, the order or, where the opinion itself could not be opened, from at least one news report named in the footnote. The "Lesson" column links to the profile that tells the full story, and the "No." column matches the numbers on the ruling timeline.

Three cautions apply to every row. First, emergency orders from the Supreme Court of the United States, such as South Bay, Brooklyn and Tandon, were decided on applications for emergency relief, not after full briefing and argument; Chief Justice Roberts made this point himself in May 2020 when he wrote that such relief requires that "the legal rights at issue are indisputably clear."13 Second, a case that ends as moot is not a loss on the merits: the Eleventh Circuit vacated the transit mask ruling only because the mask order had expired with the public health emergency on May 11, 2023.14 Third, the counts in the outcome chart describe the rulings collected here for the profiles in this module, not every COVID-19 case decided in the United States and Canada.

The record of every ruling, 2020 to 2026

The ruling timeline places each decision by date and by court. Green circles cluster in 2020 and 2021 in the state courts and at the Supreme Court, when the challenges went to the power to close churches and businesses; red and gray circles gather in the lower federal courts from 2022 onward, when the challenges went to employer vaccine rules and when expiring orders mooted the cases.

No.DateCourtCaseCitation or docketVote or judgeHoldingOutcomeLesson
1May 5, 2020Dallas County district court, Texas (trial court)City of Dallas v. Luther (contempt hearing)Judgment of Contempt and Order of ConfinementTrial courtHeld Shelley Luther and her salon in criminal and civil contempt of an April 28 temporary restraining order; ordered Luther confined for seven days and fined the salon $500 for each day the court found it had violated the order.1Lost11
2May 7, 2020Supreme Court of TexasIn re Shelley Luther (order)No. 20-0363Order of the CourtGranted Luther's motion for emergency relief and ordered her released on personal bond while her habeas petition was pending.181Won11
3May 13, 2020Supreme Court of WisconsinWisconsin Legislature v. Palm2020 WI 424-3Struck down the April 16, 2020 statewide stay-at-home order of Health Services Secretary Andrea Palm as unlawful, invalid and unenforceable; later statewide restrictions had to go through the Legislature's rule-review process.19Won01, 22
4May 29, 2020Supreme Court of the United StatesSouth Bay United Pentecostal Church v. Newsom (I)590 U.S. 966; No. 19A10445-4 (denied)Denied a church's request to block California's limit on worship attendance (25 percent of capacity or 100 people); Chief Justice Roberts concurred in the denial, four justices would have granted it.1320Lost09
5June 5, 2020Michigan Supreme CourtAttorney General v. Manke (order)Order on applicationOrder; Viviano, J., concurringVacated the Court of Appeals order and the Shiawassee County order that had told Karl Manke to close his barbershop, and sent the case back to the Court of Appeals.2122Won12
6July 24, 2020Supreme Court of the United StatesCalvary Chapel Dayton Valley v. Sisolak591 U.S. 1042; No. 19A10705-4 (denied)Denied a Nevada church's application for relief from a 50-person cap on worship; Justices Alito, Gorsuch and Kavanaugh wrote dissents.20Lost09
7Oct. 2, 2020Michigan Supreme CourtIn re Certified Questions (Midwest Institute of Health v. Governor)No. 1614927-0 on the Emergency Management Act question; 4-3 on the EPGAHeld that Gov. Gretchen Whitmer had no authority under the Emergency Management Act to renew the emergency after April 30, 2020, and that the Emergency Powers of the Governor Act of 1945 unconstitutionally delegated legislative power.234Won12, 22
8Nov. 25, 2020Supreme Court of the United StatesRoman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn v. Cuomo, with Agudath Israel of America v. Cuomo592 U.S. 14; Nos. 20A87, 20A905-4, per curiamBarred New York from enforcing the 10-person and 25-person worship caps of Executive Order 202.68 against the applicants while their appeals went forward.915Won09
9Feb. 5, 2021Supreme Court of the United StatesSouth Bay United Pentecostal Church v. Newsom (II)592 U.S. 1244; No. 20A1366-3 on the indoor ban (granted in part)Barred California's Tier 1 total ban on indoor worship as applied to the church, but left in place a 25 percent capacity limit and the ban on indoor singing and chanting.2416Mixed09
10Apr. 9, 2021Supreme Court of the United StatesTandon v. Newsom593 U.S. 61; No. 20A1515-4, per curiamBarred California's three-household limit as applied to at-home Bible study and prayer, and stated the rule that a regulation triggers strict scrutiny whenever it treats any comparable secular activity more favorably than religious exercise.1015Won09, 22
11Apr. 9, 2021Supreme Court of TexasIn re Shelley Luther (opinion)No. 20-0363Per curiamHeld the April 28, 2020 temporary restraining order void for failing to state the required conduct and its legal basis in clear, specific terms, so the contempt judgment built on it was void too; the court granted the writ of habeas corpus and ordered Luther discharged.1Won11
12June 12, 2021U.S. District Court, Southern District of TexasBridges v. Houston Methodist HospitalNo. 4:21-cv-01774Judge Lynn N. HughesDismissed the suit of Jennifer Bridges and other employees against the hospital's vaccination requirement.25Lost15
13Aug. 26, 2021Supreme Court of the United StatesAlabama Association of Realtors v. Department of Health and Human Services594 U.S. 758; No. 21A236-3, per curiamVacated the stay of a district court judgment that had set aside the CDC's nationwide eviction moratorium, ending the moratorium; held that Congress must specifically authorize such a measure.1115Won20, 22
14Dec. 2021U.S. District Court, Central District of CaliforniaKheriaty v. Regents of the University of CaliforniaDistrict court caseJudge James SelnaDismissed Dr. Aaron Kheriaty's challenge to the University of California vaccination policy, which had argued that his prior infection should count.26Lost16
15Jan. 3, 2022U.S. District Court, Northern District of TexasU.S. Navy SEALs 1-26 v. Biden578 F. Supp. 3d 822; No. 4:21-cv-01236Judge Reed O'ConnorGranted a preliminary injunction to 35 Naval Special Warfare plaintiffs under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, finding the Navy's exemption process largely "theater."27Won19
16Jan. 13, 2022Supreme Court of the United StatesNational Federation of Independent Business v. Department of Labor, OSHA595 U.S. 109; Nos. 21A244, 21A2476-3, per curiamStayed OSHA's vaccine-or-test rule for about 84 million workers, holding that the agency's statute covers workplace safety standards and does not plainly authorize a broad public health measure.12Won20, 22
17Jan. 13, 2022Supreme Court of the United StatesBiden v. Missouri595 U.S. 87; Nos. 21A240, 21A2415-4, per curiamAllowed the Department of Health and Human Services to enforce its vaccination rule for staff of facilities that take Medicare and Medicaid money.28Lost20
18Mar. 25, 2022Supreme Court of the United StatesAustin v. U.S. Navy Seals 1-26595 U.S. 1301; No. 21A4776-3 (partial stay granted)Stayed the January 3 injunction insofar as it kept the Navy from considering the plaintiffs' vaccination status in deployment, assignment and other operational decisions.2717Lost19
19Mar. 28, 2022U.S. District Court, Northern District of TexasU.S. Navy SEALs 1-26 v. Biden (class order)No. 4:21-cv-01236Judge Reed O'ConnorCertified a class of 4,095 sailors who had sought religious exemptions and extended the injunction against discipline and separation to the class.29Won19
20Apr. 18, 2022U.S. District Court, Middle District of FloridaHealth Freedom Defense Fund v. BidenNo. 8:21-cv-01693Judge Kathryn Kimball MizelleVacated the CDC's mask order for airplanes, trains, buses and transit hubs: the order exceeded the agency's statutory power, skipped notice and comment, and failed to explain itself.30Won05
21May 13, 2022Supreme Court of LouisianaState of Louisiana v. Mark Anthony SpellNo. 2021-KK-008765-2 (Crain, J.)Held the gathering limits and stay-at-home provisions of Gov. John Bel Edwards's executive orders unconstitutional as applied to Pastor Tony Spell and granted his motion to quash the charges.8Won06
22June 13, 2022U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth CircuitBridges v. Methodist Hospital (I)No. 21-20311 (unpublished)Jolly, Elrod, Haynes (concurring in the judgment)Affirmed the dismissal of the Houston Methodist employees' 2021 suit.3132Lost15
23Aug. 15, 2022California Court of Appeal, Sixth DistrictPeople v. Calvary Chapel San Jose, with Calvary Chapel San Jose v. Superior Court and McClure v. Superior CourtH048708, H048734, H048947 (published)Greenwood, P.J., with Bamattre-Manoukian and Danner, JJ.Held the worship injunctions facially unconstitutional under the Supreme Court's 2020 and 2021 worship rulings, annulled both contempt orders against Calvary Chapel San Jose and Pastor Mike McClure in their entirety, and reversed the monetary sanctions.3334Won07
24Nov. 23, 2022U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth CircuitKheriaty v. Regents of the University of CaliforniaNinth Circuit appealMurguia, Parker and Lee, JJ.Affirmed the dismissal, applying rational-basis review because no fundamental right to refuse a workplace vaccine requirement was shown.26Lost16
25Jan. 2023Ada County court, Idaho (magistrate division)State of Idaho v. Sara BradyMisdemeanor trespass caseDismissed on the state's motionDismissed the 2020 trespass charge after Attorney General Raul Labrador moved to dismiss; the case closed and her cash bond was exonerated.3536Won02
26Jan. 25, 2023U.S. District Court, Eastern District of CaliforniaHoeg v. NewsomNo. 2:22-cv-01980Judge William B. ShubbPreliminarily enjoined enforcement of AB 2098, the law that made spreading COVID-19 "misinformation" a ground for discipline of physicians, as unconstitutionally vague.637Won17
27Mar. 15, 2023New Jersey Superior Court, Appellate DivisionPersichilli v. Atilis Gym of BellmawrA-3186-20Appellate panelAffirmed $123,982.08 in fines against Atilis Gym for eight days of violations and upheld Gov. Phil Murphy's gym restrictions.3839Lost13
28June 22, 2023U.S. Court of Appeals, Eleventh CircuitHealth Freedom Defense Fund v. President of the United StatesNo. 22-11287 (published)Wilson, Jordan, BrasherHeld the appeal moot because the mask order had expired with the public health emergency on May 11, 2023, vacated the district court's judgment and ordered the case dismissed.14Moot05
29July 31, 2023Alberta Court of King's BenchIngram v Alberta (Chief Medical Officer of Health)2023 ABKB 453Justice Barbara RomaineHeld the challenged health orders invalid (ultra vires) because Cabinet, not the Chief Medical Officer of Health, made the decisions; rejected the Charter claims as justified limits.4041Mixed10
30Jan. 23, 2024Federal Court of CanadaCanadian Frontline Nurses v. Canada (Attorney General), with related applications2024 FC 42Justice Richard MosleyHeld the February 2022 invocation of the Emergencies Act unreasonable and found that the economic measures infringed sections 2(b) and 8 of the Charter.42Won21
31Feb. 29, 2024U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth CircuitMcDonald v. LawsonNo. 22-56220Three-judge panelHeld a parallel challenge to AB 2098 moot after the law's repeal, vacated the district court's order and directed dismissal.4344Moot17
32Apr. 2, 2024U.S. District Court, Eastern District of CaliforniaHoeg v. Newsom (dismissal)No. 2:22-cv-01980Judge William B. ShubbDismissed the doctors' suit as moot after the repeal of AB 2098 and held nominal damages barred by sovereign immunity.37Moot17
33June 26, 2024Supreme Court of the United StatesMurthy v. Missouri603 U.S. 43; No. 23-4116-3 (Barrett, J.)Held that neither the individual plaintiffs (including Drs. Bhattacharya, Kulldorff and Kheriaty) nor the states had standing to seek an injunction against the federal officials.45Lost16, 18
34Apr. 15, 2025California Court of Appeal, Sixth DistrictPeople v. Calvary Chapel San Jose (mask fines)H051860 (unpublished)Appellate panelAffirmed $1,228,700 in administrative fines tied to the county's face-covering orders.4647Lost07
35Apr. 3, 2025Ontario Court of JusticeR. v. Lich and Barber (verdict)Ottawa trialJustice Heather Perkins-McVeyConvicted Tamara Lich and Chris Barber of mischief arising from the 2022 Freedom Convoy (Barber also of counselling disobedience of a court order) and acquitted them of intimidation and obstruction counts; the Crown has appealed the acquittals.484950Lost21
36June 17, 2025U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth CircuitBridges v. Methodist Hospital (II)No. 24-20483 (unpublished)Three-judge panelAffirmed dismissal of the former employees' second federal suit: a private hospital's vaccination policy was not state action.51Lost15
37July 16, 2025Supreme Court of CaliforniaPeople v. Calvary Chapel San JoseS291092Review deniedDenied review of the $1,228,700 fine, with no recorded dissents.46Lost07
38Oct. 7, 2025Ontario Court of JusticeR. v. Lich and Barber (sentence)Ottawa sentencingJustice Heather Perkins-McVeyImposed 18-month conditional sentences (12 months of house arrest, then 6 months of curfew) instead of the 7 and 8 years of prison the Crown sought.4849Mixed21
39Jan. 16, 2026Federal Court of AppealCanada (Attorney General) v. Canadian Civil Liberties Association2026 FCA 6Three-judge panelUpheld Justice Mosley: the invocation was unreasonable and the section 2(b) and section 8 Charter breaches were not justified. The Supreme Court of Canada granted leave to appeal on Oct. 22, 2026.25253Won21

Key orders and statutes

Courts were one road. Legislatures, voters and executives changed the rules too, and several of those changes came directly out of the stands told in this module.

DateBodyMeasureWhat it didVote or signerLesson
Mar. 3, 2021Idaho SenateSenate Joint Resolution 102Adopted a proposed amendment to Article III, Section 8 of the Idaho Constitution so the Legislature can convene itself in special session.35424-11-0; floor sponsor Sen. Chuck Winder304
Apr. 20, 2021Idaho House of RepresentativesSJR 102Adopted the same resolution and sent it to the Secretary of State for the 2022 ballot.354-15-1; floor sponsor Rep. Jason Monks304
Nov. 8, 2022Idaho votersSJR 102 (constitutional amendment)Approved the amendment: the Legislature "must also be convened in special session" by the Senate president pro tempore and the House speaker "upon receipt of a joint written petition of at least sixty percent of the membership of each house, specifying the subjects to be considered."5455287,194 yes to 267,623 no (about 51.8 percent yes)5504
Oct. 2, 2020Michigan Supreme CourtRuling on the Emergency Powers of the Governor Act (Public Act 302 of 1945)Held that the 1945 act delegated legislative power to the governor in violation of the Michigan Constitution.2344-32312, 22
July 15 and 21, 2021Michigan Senate and HouseInitiated law repealing Public Act 302 of 1945 (Public Act 77 of 2021)Adopted a citizen-initiated petition repealing the 1945 act; an initiated law is not subject to the governor's veto.4Senate July 15; House July 21412, 22
May 7, 2020Governor of TexasModification of COVID-19 executive ordersRemoved jail as a penalty for violating the orders, retroactive to April 2, 2020, and overrode local orders that conflicted.56Gov. Greg Abbott5611
Apr. 6, 2022FloridaCS/CS/SB 988, the No Patient Left Alone Act (chapter 2022-34, Laws of Florida)Guaranteed visitation rights for patients and their families in hospitals and long-term care facilities, including during emergencies.7Gov. Ron DeSantis714
Dec. 23, 2022CongressJames M. Inhofe National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2023, Public Law 117-263, section 525Directed the Secretary of Defense, within 30 days, to "rescind the mandate that members of the Armed Forces be vaccinated against COVID-19" issued by the memorandum of August 24, 2021.5Approved Dec. 23, 2022519
Jan. 10, 2023Secretary of DefenseRescission memorandumSecretary Lloyd Austin formally ended the military COVID-19 vaccination requirement, as the act required.57Signed by the Secretary5719
Apr. 10, 2023CongressJoint resolution ending the national emergency, Public Law 118-3Terminated the COVID-19 national emergency; the separate public health emergency declaration expired May 11, 2023.14Signed by President Biden1405
Sept. 30, 2023CaliforniaSB 815Repealed AB 2098, the law that had made COVID-19 "misinformation" a ground for physician discipline, effective January 1, 2024.6Gov. Gavin Newsom617
Feb. 14, 2022Government of CanadaDeclaration of a public order emergency under the Emergencies ActInvoked federal emergency powers against the Freedom Convoy protests and blockades.52Federal cabinet5221
Feb. 17, 2023Public Order Emergency CommissionReport of Commissioner Paul S. RouleauConcluded that "the very high threshold required for the invocation of the Act was met."58Commissioner Rouleau5821

What the rulings held, court by court

The table gives one sentence per ruling. This section gives the reasoning, in the courts' own words where the opinion was opened for this lesson, so that a reader can see why the law moved the way it did.

The Supreme Court and houses of worship

The white marble front of the United States Supreme Court building with its columns and wide steps
The Supreme Court of the United States in Washington, D.C., which decided the worship cases of 2020 and 2021 on emergency applications. Photo: Kjetil Ree, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

The worship cases began with a loss. On May 29, 2020, the Court denied South Bay United Pentecostal Church's request to block California's limit of "25% of building capacity or a maximum of 100 attendees" for places of worship.13 Chief Justice Roberts supplied the fifth vote and wrote that the restrictions "appear consistent with the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment" because "[s]imilar or more severe restrictions apply to comparable secular gatherings."13 Justice Kavanaugh, joined by Justices Thomas and Gorsuch, dissented: "The Church and its congregants simply want to be treated equally to comparable secular businesses."13 On July 24, 2020, the Court denied a Nevada church's application by the same 5-4 margin.20

By November the majority had changed. In Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn v. Cuomo, decided with Agudath Israel of America v. Cuomo on November 25, 2020, the Court barred New York from enforcing the "10- and 25-person occupancy limits" of Executive Order 202.68 against the applicants.9 The unsigned opinion said the rules "single out houses of worship for especially harsh treatment" and that the applicants' churches and synagogues "have admirable safety records."9 It then wrote the sentence most often quoted from the whole period: "But even in a pandemic, the Constitution cannot be put away and forgotten."9 Justice Gorsuch, concurring, put it more bluntly: "Government is not free to disregard the First Amendment in times of crisis."9 The Chief Justice and Justices Breyer, Sotomayor and Kagan dissented.9

On February 5, 2021, in the second South Bay order, the Court barred California's Tier 1 "prohibition on indoor worship services" against the church, while leaving a 25 percent capacity limit and the ban on singing and chanting in place.24 The Chief Justice, who had sided with the state in May, now wrote that a rule "that the maximum number of adherents who can safely worship in the most cavernous cathedral is zero" reflected "insufficient appreciation or consideration of the interests at stake," and closed: "Deference, though broad, has its limits."24

Tandon v. Newsom, on April 9, 2021, finished the work. A home Bible study and prayer group had been held to a three-household limit while California let "hair salons, retail stores, personal care services, movie theaters" and "indoor restaurants" bring together more than three households.10 The unsigned opinion stated the rule that now governs: "government regulations are not neutral and generally applicable, and therefore trigger strict scrutiny under the Free Exercise Clause, whenever they treat any comparable secular activity more favorably than religious exercise."10 Lawyers call it the most-favored-nation rule. Lessons 09 and 22 explain it in full.

The Supreme Court and federal agencies

The second set of Supreme Court cases asked a different question: whether federal agencies had the power Congress was said to have given them. On August 26, 2021, the Court ended the CDC's nationwide eviction moratorium in Alabama Association of Realtors v. HHS.11 "It is up to Congress, not the CDC, to decide whether the public interest merits further action here," the Court wrote, and: "If a federally imposed eviction moratorium is to continue, Congress must specifically authorize it."11 It added a sentence that answers much of the emergency-power debate: "our system does not permit agencies to act unlawfully even in pursuit of desirable ends."11

On January 13, 2022, the Court stayed OSHA's rule requiring employers with at least 100 employees to make roughly 84 million workers be vaccinated or tested weekly.12 "The Act empowers the Secretary to set workplace safety standards, not broad public health measures," the Court held, and it noted that OSHA "in its half century of existence, has never before adopted a broad public health regulation of this kind."12 The same day, in Biden v. Missouri, a 5-4 Court allowed the health-care staff rule for Medicare and Medicaid facilities, reasoning that protecting patients from infection fits "the fundamental principle of the medical profession: first, do no harm."28 The two rulings side by side show the line the Court drew: an agency may regulate within its field, and may not stretch a narrow grant into a general power over daily life.

On March 25, 2022, the Court stayed part of the Navy SEALs injunction, allowing the Navy to consider vaccination status "in making deployment, assignment, and other operational decisions."27 Justice Alito, joined by Justice Gorsuch, dissented, writing that the 35 service members "appear to have been treated shabbily by the Navy, and the Court brushes all that aside," and noting that "more than 4,000 exemption requests had been submitted by February 15, 2022" without a single approval when the complaint was filed.27 Justice Thomas would have denied the stay entirely.27 Congress ended the military mandate nine months later.5

The last Supreme Court case in the module went the other way. On June 26, 2024, in Murthy v. Missouri, the Court held that neither the states nor the individual plaintiffs, who included Drs. Jay Bhattacharya, Martin Kulldorff and Aaron Kheriaty, had standing to seek an injunction against federal officials over social media moderation.45 The Court described them as "doctors who questioned the wisdom of then-prevailing COVID-19 policies, including lockdowns and mask and vaccine mandates."45 The ruling decided who could sue, not whether the government's conduct was lawful.

The state high courts

State supreme courts gave the challengers their most consistent wins. On May 13, 2020, the Wisconsin Supreme Court, 4-3, struck down the state health secretary's extended stay-at-home order as "unlawful, invalid, and unenforceable."19 On October 2, 2020, the Michigan Supreme Court unanimously held that Gov. Gretchen Whitmer had no authority under the Emergency Management Act to keep renewing her emergency after April 30, 2020, and held, 4-3, that the 1945 Emergency Powers of the Governor Act was itself unconstitutional because it delegated legislative power to the executive.234 Months earlier, on June 5, 2020, the same court had vacated the orders that told Karl Manke to close his barbershop in Owosso.2122

The building of the Supreme Court of Texas in Austin, a multistory stone building with a row of windows
The Supreme Court of Texas building in Austin. The court ordered Shelley Luther released on May 7, 2020, and in April 2021 held the order that jailed her void. Photo: WhisperToMe, Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

In Texas, the record is unusually complete. The City of Dallas sued Shelley Luther and her salon on April 28, 2020, and the trial court entered a temporary restraining order the same day; on May 5 the trial court held her in criminal and civil contempt and ordered her confined for seven days.1 She petitioned the Supreme Court of Texas on May 6, and on May 7 the court ordered her released on personal bond.118 The same day, Gov. Greg Abbott removed jail as a penalty for violating the COVID-19 orders, saying: "Throwing Texans in jail who have had their businesses shut down through no fault of their own is nonsensical."56 Eleven months later, on April 9, 2021, the court decided the case: "We now conclude that the temporary restraining order failed to set forth the conduct required and the legal basis for its issuance in clear, specific, and unambiguous terms. Accordingly, we hold that the temporary restraining order was void, making the Contempt Judgment based on that order void as well."1

The Louisiana Supreme Court building in New Orleans, a large white classical building on a city street
The Louisiana Supreme Court building in New Orleans, where the court ruled for Pastor Tony Spell on May 13, 2022. Photo: MusikAnimal, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

On May 13, 2022, the Louisiana Supreme Court, in an opinion by Justice Crain with Chief Justice Weimer and Justice Griffin dissenting, held that provisions of two executive orders, "as applied to defendant, violate his fundamental right to exercise religion, do not survive strict scrutiny, and are thus unconstitutional," and granted Pastor Tony Spell's motion to quash.8 In California, the Sixth District Court of Appeal annulled the contempt orders against Calvary Chapel San Jose and Pastor McClure and reversed the court sanctions on August 15, 2022, and on November 30, 2022 the California Supreme Court denied Santa Clara County's petition for review (No. S276560), leaving in place the reversal of sanctions the Bay Area News Group reported at $217,500.3334 A separate set of administrative fines of $1,228,700 tied to the county's face-covering orders was affirmed by the Sixth District in an unpublished opinion, and the California Supreme Court denied review on July 16, 2025.46 The church petitioned the Supreme Court of the United States on December 12, 2025 (No. 25-703).4759

The lower federal courts

The lower federal courts were harder ground, especially for employees of private institutions. Judge Lynn N. Hughes dismissed the Houston Methodist employees' suit on June 12, 2021; the employees could, in his words as reported by Bloomberg Law, "freely choose to accept or refuse a Covid-19 vaccine," but if they refused they "will simply need to work somewhere else."25 The Fifth Circuit affirmed on June 13, 2022, and affirmed again on June 17, 2025 in a second suit, holding that a private hospital's vaccination policy was not state action.3151 The Ninth Circuit upheld the dismissal of Dr. Aaron Kheriaty's suit against the University of California in November 2022, applying rational-basis review.26

The wins came where the government itself had gone beyond its authority. Judge Reed O'Connor enjoined the Navy's treatment of 35 Naval Special Warfare plaintiffs on January 3, 2022, and on March 28, 2022 certified a class of 4,095 sailors who had sought religious exemptions.2729 The Navy had received 3,320 religious accommodation requests from active-duty sailors and 864 from the Navy Reserve by March 2022 and approved none of them, and the case settled in July 2024 with records corrected and $1.5 million in attorneys' fees.60 Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle vacated the CDC's transit mask order on April 18, 2022, writing that the order "is best understood not as sanitation" and that the CDC had improperly skipped public comment.30 In California, Judge William B. Shubb enjoined AB 2098, the physician "misinformation" law, before the legislature repealed it; the Ninth Circuit and Judge Shubb then dismissed the remaining challenges as moot in 2024.6434437

The Canadian courts

In Alberta, Justice Barbara Romaine of the Court of King's Bench held on July 31, 2023 in Ingram v Alberta that the challenged health orders were invalid because the Public Health Act required the Chief Medical Officer of Health, not Cabinet, to make the decisions, while rejecting the Charter claims.4041 A month later, after the Crown said the ruling made a conviction unlikely, Pastor James Coates and GraceLife Church were acquitted of the remaining public health charges; their lawyers at the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms announced the acquittal on August 30, 2023.61

In Ottawa, Justice Richard Mosley of the Federal Court held on January 23, 2024 that there was "no national emergency justifying the invocation of the Emergencies Act" and that the economic measures infringed sections 2(b) and 8 of the Charter.42 A three-judge panel of the Federal Court of Appeal affirmed him on January 16, 2026, writing that the protests and blockades "fell well short of a threat to national security."253 The Supreme Court of Canada granted the federal government leave to appeal on October 22, 2026.53 The individual organizers fared differently: Justice Heather Perkins-McVey of the Ontario Court of Justice convicted Tamara Lich and Chris Barber of mischief on April 3, 2025 and on October 7, 2025 imposed 18-month conditional sentences, 12 months of house arrest followed by six months of curfew, rejecting the Crown's request for seven and eight years.4849 Lich has appealed her conviction, and the Crown has appealed the sentence and the intimidation acquittals.4950

Timeline of the profiles, 2020 to 2026

This timeline follows the people rather than the courts: when they acted, when they were arrested, fined or fired, and when their cases ended. Every date is footnoted to the record; dates found only in the profile lessons and not opened for this lesson are left to those lessons.

DateEvent
Apr. 21, 2020Sara Brady, with other parents and children at a closed playground in Meridian's Julius M. Kleiner Memorial Park, argues with police, asks to be arrested and is charged with misdemeanor trespass (02).35
Apr. 28, 2020The City of Dallas sues Shelley Luther and Salon a la Mode; a temporary restraining order issues the same day (11).1
May 5 to 7, 2020Luther is held in contempt and jailed, petitions the Supreme Court of Texas, and is ordered released; Gov. Abbott removes jail as a penalty (11).156
May 13, 2020The Wisconsin Supreme Court strikes down the extended stay-at-home order (22).19
May 29, 2020South Bay United Pentecostal Church loses its first emergency application, 5-4 (09).13
June 5, 2020The Michigan Supreme Court vacates the orders closing Karl Manke's barbershop (12).21
Oct. 2, 2020The Michigan Supreme Court holds Gov. Whitmer's emergency orders after April 30, 2020 without authority and the 1945 act unconstitutional (12).23
Oct. 4, 2020Drs. Martin Kulldorff, Sunetra Gupta and Jay Bhattacharya author and sign the Great Barrington Declaration in Great Barrington, Massachusetts (18).62
Nov. 25, 2020The Diocese of Brooklyn and Agudath Israel win at the Supreme Court, 5-4 (09).9
Feb. 5, 2021The Supreme Court bars California's total ban on indoor worship (09).24
Feb. 15 to 16, 2021Pastor James Coates of GraceLife Church is arrested and taken to the Edmonton Remand Centre (10).41
Mar. 3, 2021The Idaho Senate adopts SJR 102, 24-11 (04).3
Mar. 22, 2021Coates is released after 35 days in jail (10).41
Apr. 7, 2021Authorities fence off and close the GraceLife Church building (10).41
Apr. 9, 2021Tandon v. Newsom is decided, and the Supreme Court of Texas holds the order that jailed Luther void (09, 11).101
Apr. 20, 2021The Idaho House adopts SJR 102, 54-15 (04).3
June 12, 2021Judge Hughes dismisses the Houston Methodist employees' suit (15).25
Aug. 26, 2021The Supreme Court ends the CDC eviction moratorium (20).11
Aug. 31, 2021Los Angeles County and the State of California agree to pay $400,000 each, $800,000 in all, to Grace Community Church (08).6364
Jan. 3, 2022Judge O'Connor enjoins the Navy's action against 35 Naval Special Warfare plaintiffs (19).27
Jan. 13, 2022The Supreme Court stays the OSHA vaccine-or-test rule (20).12
Feb. 14, 2022Canada invokes the Emergencies Act against the Freedom Convoy (21).52
Mar. 28, 2022The Navy case becomes a class of 4,095 sailors (19).29
Apr. 6, 2022Florida's No Patient Left Alone Act is signed (14).7
Apr. 18, 2022The federal transit mask order is vacated in the Health Freedom Defense Fund case (05).30
May 13, 2022The Louisiana Supreme Court rules for Pastor Tony Spell, 5-2 (06).8
Aug. 15, 2022The Sixth District annuls the contempt orders against Calvary Chapel San Jose and Pastor McClure and reverses the sanctions (07).33
Nov. 8, 2022Idaho voters approve SJR 102 (04).55
Dec. 23, 2022The defense authorization act orders the military vaccine mandate rescinded (19).5
Jan. 2023Attorney General Raul Labrador moves to dismiss the charge against Sara Brady, and the case is closed (02).3536
Mar. 15, 2023The Appellate Division upholds $123,982.08 in fines against Atilis Gym (13).38
Aug. 30, 2023Coates and GraceLife are acquitted of the remaining public health charges after the Crown says the Ingram ruling makes a conviction unlikely (10).61
Sept. 30, 2023SB 815 repeals California's physician speech law, effective Jan. 1, 2024 (17).6
Jan. 23, 2024The Federal Court holds the Emergencies Act invocation unreasonable (21).42
June 26, 2024Murthy v. Missouri is decided on standing (18).45
July 24, 2024The Navy settlement is announced (19).60
Apr. 3, 2025Lich and Barber are convicted of mischief in Ottawa (21).4849
Oct. 7, 2025Lich and Barber receive conditional sentences (21).4849
Jan. 16, 2026The Federal Court of Appeal affirms Justice Mosley (21).2
Oct. 22, 2026The Supreme Court of Canada grants leave to appeal in the Emergencies Act case (21).53
The Michigan Hall of Justice in Lansing, a wide modern stone building with a curved glass front under a blue sky
The Michigan Hall of Justice in Lansing. On October 2, 2020, the Michigan Supreme Court held the state's 1945 emergency powers law unconstitutional, and the Legislature repealed the law by citizen initiative in July 2021. Photo: Grosscha, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0.

Why the record honors courage

A table of rulings can make the outcomes look settled from the start. They were not. When Shelley Luther opened her salon, no court had told her the restraining order against her was void; that came eleven months after she sat in a Dallas jail.1 When South Bay United Pentecostal Church went to the Supreme Court in May 2020, it lost.13 When the 35 Naval Special Warfare plaintiffs sued, they faced an order the Navy said was punishable by "dishonorable discharge and confinement," as Justice Alito described the policy, and none of the more than 4,000 religious exemption requests had been approved when they sued.27 Pastor Coates spent 35 days in jail before the Alberta court held the orders invalid.4140

The people in these lessons did not wait for the law to be clear. They put their freedom, their businesses, their careers and their congregations on the line for principles that the courts later recognized in their favor more often than not: that worship may not be treated worse than the hair salon down the street, that an agency may not claim power Congress never gave it, that an order must say plainly what it forbids before a person can be jailed for breaking it, and that an emergency does not suspend the Constitution.101119 Where they lost in court, as the Houston Methodist employees and the Atilis Gym owners did, the record still shows people who accepted the cost of their convictions openly, under their own names.3138 Where they won, their wins now protect neighbors who never had to take the same risk. That is the debt this record is meant to keep in view.

The same courage reached the statehouse and the ballot box. Idaho legislators who voted for SJR 102 and the voters who approved it in 2022 changed the state's constitution so that the people's representatives can call themselves back into session; Michigan citizens petitioned to repeal their 1945 emergency law and saw the Legislature adopt it in July 2021; Congress ended the military mandate in December 2022.35545 Lesson 22 weighs what those changes won.

What the other side said

Governments defending the orders relied first on Jacobson v. Massachusetts (1905), which upheld a smallpox vaccination law and held that courts may strike down a health measure only if it "has no real or substantial relation to those objects, or is, beyond all question, a plain, palpable invasion of rights secured by the fundamental law."65 Their second argument was deference to elected officials in an emergency, stated most fully by Chief Justice Roberts in South Bay on May 29, 2020: "The precise question of when restrictions on particular social activities should be lifted during the pandemic is a dynamic and fact-intensive matter subject to reasonable disagreement. Our Constitution principally entrusts '[t]he safety and the health of the people' to the politically accountable officials of the States 'to guard and protect.'" He added: "Where those broad limits are not exceeded, they should not be subject to second-guessing by an 'unelected federal judiciary,' which lacks the background, competence, and expertise to assess public health and is not accountable to the people."13 In the Navy case, Justice Kavanaugh wrote that "the President of the United States, not any federal judge, is the Commander in Chief of the Armed Forces."27 In the eviction case, Justice Breyer's dissent relied on the CDC's finding that a surge in evictions could spread COVID-19 "when the highly transmissible Delta variant is driving COVID-19 cases at an unprecedented rate."11 In Canada, Commissioner Paul Rouleau concluded that "the very high threshold required for the invocation of the Act was met."58 Legal scholars Erin Fuse Brown and James Hodge criticized the transit mask ruling as a misreading of public health law.66

Still disputed: The Emergencies Act case is on appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, and the Lich and Barber appeals are pending.534950 Calvary Chapel San Jose's petition to the Supreme Court of the United States over the $1,228,700 fine (No. 25-703) was filed December 12, 2025 and distributed for the Court's conference of April 24, 2026; the docket showed no ruling on it as of November 2026.47 Whether Jacobson still sets the standard for emergency health orders, or whether Roman Catholic Diocese and Tandon replaced it for worship cases, is argued by judges and scholars; the Supreme Court has not overruled Jacobson.6510 And because so many cases ended as moot, several questions (such as whether the CDC's transit mask order was lawful) were never decided by an appellate court on the merits.14

Glossary

Terms are listed in the order a reader meets them: power and its limits first, then the tests courts apply, the procedures and remedies, and the Canadian terms last.

Emergency powers
Authority a constitution or statute gives an executive (a governor, a president, a health officer) to act quickly in a declared emergency, often by order rather than by law. The profiles turn on the limits of those powers, such as Michigan's 1945 act, held unconstitutional in 2020.23
Police power
The general power of a state to protect public health, safety and welfare. It belongs to the states, not the federal government, and was the basis of most state COVID-19 orders.
Jacobson v. Massachusetts
The 1905 Supreme Court decision upholding a smallpox vaccination law; it allows courts to set aside a health measure that is a "plain, palpable invasion of rights secured by the fundamental law."65
Free Exercise Clause
The part of the First Amendment that forbids laws prohibiting the free exercise of religion. It was the basis of the worship cases in lessons 06 to 10.
Neutral and generally applicable
A law that does not target religion and applies to everyone alike. Such a law usually needs only a rational basis; a law that fails the test must meet strict scrutiny.10
Strict scrutiny
The most demanding test courts apply: the government must show a compelling interest and that the rule is narrowly tailored to it. The Louisiana Supreme Court held that Pastor Spell's orders did not survive it.8
Rational basis review
The most lenient test: a rule stands if it is rationally related to a legitimate purpose. The Ninth Circuit applied it to Dr. Kheriaty's suit.26
Most-favored-nation rule
The rule from Tandon v. Newsom: a regulation triggers strict scrutiny "whenever" it treats "any comparable secular activity more favorably than religious exercise."10
Comparable secular activity
A nonreligious activity that poses similar risks to the interest the government asserts. Tandon held that comparability is judged against that interest, not by the reasons people gather.10
Major questions doctrine
The rule that Congress must speak clearly when it gives an agency power over decisions of vast economic and political significance; NFIB v. OSHA applied it to the vaccine-or-test rule.12
Nondelegation doctrine
The principle that a legislature may not hand its lawmaking power to the executive without adequate limits. Michigan's 1945 emergency act failed it under the state constitution.4
Separation of powers
The division of government into legislative, executive and judicial branches, each checking the others. The emergency-power cases asked how long a governor may govern by order without the legislature.
Executive order
A directive issued by a governor or president under authority given by a constitution or statute, such as New York's Executive Order 202.68.9
Public health order
An order issued by a health officer or agency, such as Wisconsin's April 16, 2020 stay-at-home order or the CDC's transit mask order.1930
Special session
A meeting of a legislature outside its regular session. Since 2022, Idaho's Legislature must be convened in special session on a joint written petition of at least 60 percent of each house.54
Joint resolution
A measure adopted by both houses of a legislature. In Idaho a senate joint resolution (SJR) proposes a constitutional amendment for the voters; in Congress a joint resolution can become law, as Public Law 118-3 did.314
Constitutional amendment
A change to a constitution's text. SJR 102 amended Article III, Section 8 of the Idaho Constitution after voter approval in 2022.5455
Initiated law
A law proposed by citizen petition. In Michigan the Legislature may adopt it without the governor's signature, as it did with the repeal of the 1945 emergency act in July 2021.4
National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA)
The annual law setting defense policy. Section 525 of the act for fiscal year 2023 ordered the military COVID-19 vaccine mandate rescinded.5
Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA)
A federal law that bars the federal government from substantially burdening religious exercise unless it uses the least restrictive means to further a compelling interest. The Navy SEALs case was brought under it.27
Religious accommodation
An exception to a rule granted because of sincere religious belief. The Navy received 4,184 requests by March 2022 and approved none.60
Administrative Procedure Act (APA)
The federal law that governs how agencies make rules and lets courts set aside agency action that exceeds statutory authority or skips required procedures.30
Notice and comment
The APA's usual requirement that an agency publish a proposed rule and accept public comments before adopting it; the transit mask order was vacated in part for skipping it.30
Ultra vires
Latin for "beyond the powers": an act taken without legal authority. In Ingram, Alberta's health orders were ultra vires because Cabinet made decisions the statute gave to the Chief Medical Officer of Health.40
Preliminary injunction
A court order that stops an action while a case is pending, granted when the challenger is likely to win and would suffer irreparable harm, as in Hoeg v. Newsom and the Navy SEALs case.27
Temporary restraining order (TRO)
A short-term order, often issued the day a suit is filed, that holds things in place until a hearing. The TRO against Shelley Luther was held void.1
Injunction pending appeal
Emergency relief that blocks a rule while an appeal goes forward. The Supreme Court granted it in Brooklyn and Tandon.910
Emergency application
A request to the Supreme Court for immediate relief, decided without full briefing or argument. Most of the worship cases came to the Court this way.13
Stay
An order suspending another court's order. The Supreme Court stayed OSHA's rule and part of the Navy injunction.1227
Per curiam
An opinion issued by the court as a whole, unsigned. Brooklyn, Tandon, Alabama Realtors and NFIB were per curiam.1512
Concurring opinion
A separate opinion by a judge who agrees with the result, sometimes for different reasons, such as Chief Justice Roberts's South Bay concurrence.13
Dissenting opinion
An opinion by a judge who disagrees with the result, such as Justice Alito's dissent in the Navy SEALs order.27
Vacatur
An order that wipes out a judgment or a rule. The district court vacated the CDC transit mask order; the Eleventh Circuit later vacated that judgment as moot.3014
Mootness
The doctrine that courts decide only live disputes. A case becomes moot when the order expires or is repealed, as with the transit mask order and AB 2098.1437
Standing
The requirement that a plaintiff show an injury traceable to the defendant that a court can redress. The plaintiffs in Murthy v. Missouri lost on standing.45
Contempt of court
Disobeying a court order. Criminal contempt punishes past disobedience; civil contempt pressures future compliance. Shelley Luther was held in both.1
Habeas corpus
A petition asking a court to order release from unlawful confinement. The Supreme Court of Texas granted Luther's.1
Personal bond
Release on a promise to appear, without cash bail; Luther was released on personal bond on May 7, 2020.1
Motion to quash
A request to throw out a criminal charge before trial; Pastor Spell's was granted by the Louisiana Supreme Court.8
As-applied challenge
A claim that a law is unconstitutional as used against a particular person, rather than in every case. The Spell ruling was as applied.8
Vagueness doctrine
The due process rule that a law is void if ordinary people cannot tell what it forbids. The Luther opinion rested on a related principle: an order must state its terms clearly before a person can be punished for violating it.1
State action
The rule that constitutional rights limit the government, not private employers; the Fifth Circuit held Houston Methodist's policy was not state action.51
Class action
A suit on behalf of a group with common claims. The Navy SEALs case became a class of 4,095 sailors.29
Settlement
An agreement ending a lawsuit. Grace Community Church received $800,000 from the state and county; the Navy agreed to correct records and pay $1.5 million in fees.6360
Certiorari
The Supreme Court's discretionary review of a lower court decision; Calvary Chapel San Jose petitioned for it in December 2025.47
Unpublished opinion
An appellate decision not designated as precedent, such as the Fifth Circuit's Bridges rulings.3151
Sovereign immunity
The rule that the government cannot be sued for damages without its consent; it barred nominal damages in Hoeg v. Newsom.37
Emergencies Act (Canada)
The federal statute that lets the Canadian government declare a public order emergency and adopt special measures; invoked February 14, 2022 and held unreasonably invoked by two federal courts.5242
Public Order Emergency Commission
The inquiry led by Commissioner Paul Rouleau that reviewed the Emergencies Act invocation and reported on February 17, 2023 that the threshold was met.58
Public Health Act (Alberta)
Alberta's statute under which COVID-19 orders were issued; in Ingram the court held it gives the decisions to the Chief Medical Officer of Health.40
Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms
Canada's constitutional bill of rights. Section 2(b) protects expression, section 8 protects against unreasonable search and seizure, and section 1 allows reasonable limits.52
Conditional sentence
A Canadian sentence served in the community under conditions such as house arrest and curfew, as imposed on Lich and Barber.48
Mischief
The Canadian Criminal Code offense of interfering with the lawful use or enjoyment of property; Lich and Barber were convicted of it.48
Tier 1 (California Blueprint)
The most restrictive tier of California's reopening plan in 2020 and 2021, which banned indoor worship until the Supreme Court's February 2021 order.24

Sources and reading guide by lesson

The guide lists, for each lesson, the primary records a reader should open first and the order in which to read them. Court opinions and statutes come first; news reports are listed only where no primary record was available online. Each lesson's own footnotes carry its full source list, and the consolidated list for this lesson appears below the quiz.

Idaho: lessons 01 to 05

  • 01 Emergency power in 2020: begin with the Michigan and Wisconsin rulings in the record table and the Michigan Senate Fiscal Agency's summary of Public Act 77 of 2021, which explains in two pages how a 1945 emergency law was struck down and then repealed.419
  • 02 Sara Walton Brady: the Idaho Press and Idaho Reports coverage of the January 2023 dismissal, then the Attorney General's statement quoted there ("This case should have never been prosecuted").3536
  • 03 Dr. Ryan Cole: the lesson's footnotes list the Central District Health board records and the 2026 reappointment reporting.
  • 04 SJR 102: read the resolution's text, then the Legislature's roll calls, then the Secretary of State's 2022 canvass.54355
  • 05 The transit mask case: the Eleventh Circuit opinion is short (11 pages) and recounts the district court's grounds before explaining why the appeal was moot.14

Worship: lessons 06 to 10

  • 06 Pastor Tony Spell: the Louisiana Supreme Court opinion and both dissents, in one PDF with the court's news release.8
  • 07 Calvary Chapel San Jose: the 2022 and 2025 reports, then the petition history.334647
  • 08 Grace Community Church: the Thomas More Society's account of the settlement, checked against the Roys Report.6364
  • 09 The worship cases: read them in order, South Bay (May 2020), Brooklyn, South Bay (February 2021), Tandon. Read together, they show the Court changing course between May 2020 and April 2021.1392410
  • 10 Pastor James Coates: the ABlawg analysis of Ingram, then the Global News report on the dropped charges.4061

Livelihood and family: lessons 11 to 15

  • 11 Shelley Luther: the Supreme Court of Texas per curiam opinion of April 9, 2021 lays out the whole story from the city's suit to the contempt judgment.1
  • 12 Karl Manke: the ABA Journal report on the June 5, 2020 order, then the Michigan Supreme Court's October 2 opinion.2123
  • 13 Atilis Gym: the Inquirer report links the Appellate Division's 38-page opinion (A-3186-20).38
  • 14 Mary Daniel: the governor's signing release for SB 988.7
  • 15 Jennifer Bridges: the two Fifth Circuit opinions, 2022 and 2025.3151

Speech, science and the military: lessons 16 to 19

  • 16 Dr. Aaron Kheriaty and 18 the Great Barrington three: Murthy v. Missouri, especially the pages on the individual doctors, then the Declaration itself.4562
  • 17 Hoeg v. Newsom: the Ninth Circuit's McDonald v. Lawson opinion explains why the repeal ended the cases.43
  • 19 The Navy SEALs: Justice Alito's dissent from the March 25, 2022 stay describes the 50-step exemption process; section 525 of Public Law 117-263 is one paragraph long.275

National and synthesis: lessons 20 to 22

  • 20 Small businesses and landlords: Alabama Association of Realtors, then NFIB v. OSHA, then Biden v. Missouri for the contrast.111228
  • 21 The Freedom Convoy: Commissioner Rouleau's report, then the Federal Court and Federal Court of Appeal rulings that reached the opposite conclusion.58422
  • 22 What the stands won: Tandon, Alabama Realtors and the Michigan ruling are the three holdings this record returns to most often, one each on worship, federal agencies and state emergency statutes.101123

Hard questions and answers

If so many challengers lost in court, why call them heroes?

Because the courage was in the stand, not in the verdict. The chart shows 15 losses among the 38 rulings from 2020 through 2025, and several of the losses were in cases that later helped change the law: the Navy's partial win at the Supreme Court in March 2022 was followed by Congress ending the mandate that December.275 The Houston Methodist employees lost twice in the Fifth Circuit, and the record shows that they challenged their employer openly and accepted the cost.3151

Did the Supreme Court overrule Jacobson v. Massachusetts?

No. Jacobson remains on the books, and Chief Justice Roberts relied on it in May 2020.13 What changed is that Brooklyn and Tandon held that a rule treating worship worse than comparable secular activity must meet strict scrutiny, whatever the emergency.910 Jacobson itself said courts must act against a health law that is "a plain, palpable invasion of rights secured by the fundamental law."65

Does a moot case count as a loss?

No, and it is not a win either. The Eleventh Circuit vacated the transit mask judgment because the order "would have expired by its own terms on May 11, 2023," not because the district court was wrong; the order was gone, which was what the travelers had sought.14 The chart counts moot cases separately for that reason.

Why did state high courts rule for challengers more often than federal appeals courts?

Partly because of the questions they were asked. The state cases asked whether a governor or health officer had the power under state law to issue the order at all, as in Wisconsin and Michigan, or whether a criminal charge or contempt judgment met basic standards, as in Louisiana and Texas.192381 The federal appeals in this module mostly asked whether a private or university employer could require vaccination, a question on which courts applied lenient review.2651

What would a public health officer say about this record?

The officials' own arguments are in the box above: that elected officials and health experts, not judges, should decide fast-changing health questions, as the Chief Justice wrote in May 2020.13 The record answers that the Court itself came to say "Deference, though broad, has its limits."24 The most useful lesson for an officer is in lesson 22: orders that state their legal basis, treat worship equally and give clear notice of what they forbid have held up better than orders that did not.

Where does the Canadian record stand?

Divided. Two federal courts held the Emergencies Act invocation unreasonable, while the public inquiry held the threshold met, and the Supreme Court of Canada will now decide.4225853 The convoy organizers' mischief convictions stand while their appeals proceed.4950

A page of the original handwritten Constitution of the United States on aged parchment with columns of script
A page of the engrossed Constitution of the United States (the third page, as described on Wikimedia Commons). Constitutional Convention, Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Still open

These items could not be confirmed against a primary source before publication. The lesson states them as open, and they stay on the fact-check list.

  • The vote on the Michigan Supreme Court's June 5, 2020 order in the Manke case is not stated in the reports used here; only Justice Viviano's concurring statement is confirmed.
  • The exact day in January 2023 on which the court dismissed the trespass charge against Sara Brady is not given in the reports; the Attorney General moved to dismiss on January 5 and the case was closed by January 12, 2023.
  • The month of the district court's dismissal of Dr. Kheriaty's suit against the University of California (December 2021, Judge James Selna) rests on one news report.
  • The appeals of Tamara Lich and Chris Barber, and the Crown's appeal of the sentences and acquittals, were pending in the Court of Appeal for Ontario as of November 2026; the Crown appeal is reported through a summary of a Canadian Press story.
  • Sources differ on the day of the 2023 acquittal of Pastor Coates and GraceLife Church: the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms announced it on August 30, 2023, and Global News reported the court appearance in an August 31, 2023 story.

Learn more

Notes

  1. Supreme Court of Texas, In re Shelley Luther, No. 20-0363, per curiam opinion of Apr. 9, 2021, and case docket (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  2. Jim Bronskill, The Canadian Press, "Appeal court finds federal use of Emergencies Act during Freedom Convoy protests unreasonable," CP24, Jan. 16, 2026 (Canada (Attorney General) v. Canadian Civil Liberties Association, 2026 FCA 6; quoting the panel that the protests "fell well short of a threat to national security") (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  3. Idaho Legislature, 2021 Session, SJR 102 bill history and vote record (Senate 24-11-0, Mar. 3, 2021; House 54-15-1, Apr. 20, 2021) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  4. Michigan Senate Fiscal Agency, Public Act 77 of 2021, Summary as Enacted (initiated law repealing PA 302 of 1945), completed Sept. 1, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  5. James M. Inhofe National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2023, Public Law 117-263, section 525, 136 Stat. 2571 to 2572, approved Dec. 23, 2022, GovInfo (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  6. Becker's Hospital Review, "California's COVID-19 misinformation law is dead," 2023 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  7. Executive Office of the Governor of Florida, "Governor Ron DeSantis Signs Bill to Guarantee Visitation Rights for Patients and Their Families," Apr. 6, 2022 (SB 988, No Patient Left Alone Act) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  8. Supreme Court of Louisiana, State of Louisiana v. Mark Anthony Spell, No. 2021-KK-00876, May 13, 2022 (Crain, J.; Weimer, C.J., and Griffin, J., dissenting), with News Release #023, PDF (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  9. Supreme Court of the United States, Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn v. Cuomo, No. 20A87 (with Agudath Israel of America v. Cuomo, No. 20A90), per curiam, Nov. 25, 2020, 592 U.S. 14, slip opinion PDF (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  10. Supreme Court of the United States, Tandon v. Newsom, No. 20A151, per curiam, Apr. 9, 2021, 593 U.S. 61, slip opinion PDF (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  11. Supreme Court of the United States, Alabama Assn. of Realtors v. Department of Health and Human Services, No. 21A23, per curiam, Aug. 26, 2021, 594 U.S. 758, preliminary print PDF (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  12. Supreme Court of the United States, National Federation of Independent Business v. Department of Labor, OSHA, Nos. 21A244 and 21A247, per curiam, Jan. 13, 2022, 595 U.S. 109, slip opinion PDF (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  13. Supreme Court of the United States, South Bay United Pentecostal Church v. Newsom, No. 19A1044, order of May 29, 2020, with Roberts, C.J., concurring and Kavanaugh, J., dissenting, 590 U.S. 966 (2020), slip opinion PDF (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  14. U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit, Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. President of the United States, No. 22-11287, published opinion, June 22, 2023 (Wilson, Jordan and Brasher, JJ.) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  15. Supreme Court of the United States, Opinions of the Court, October Term 2020 (Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn v. Cuomo, 592 U.S. 14; Tandon v. Newsom, 593 U.S. 61; Alabama Assn. of Realtors v. HHS, 594 U.S. 758) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  16. Supreme Court of the United States, Opinions Relating to Orders, October Term 2020 (South Bay United Pentecostal Church v. Newsom, No. 20A136, Feb. 5, 2021, 592 U.S. 1244) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  17. Supreme Court of the United States, Opinions Relating to Orders, October Term 2021 (Austin v. U.S. Navy Seals 1-26, No. 21A477, Mar. 25, 2022, 595 U.S. 1301) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  18. Supreme Court of Texas, Orders Pronounced May 7, 2020, No. 20-0363, In re Shelley Luther (relator ordered released) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  19. Supreme Court of Wisconsin, Wisconsin Legislature v. Palm, 2020 WI 42, No. 2020AP765-OA, May 13, 2020 (4-3), paragraphs 3 and 59 and mandate ("Palm's Emergency Order 28 is declared unlawful, invalid, and unenforceable"), PDF (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  20. Supreme Court of the United States, Opinions Relating to Orders, October Term 2019 (South Bay United Pentecostal Church v. Newsom, 590 U.S. 966; Calvary Chapel Dayton Valley v. Sisolak, No. 19A1070, July 24, 2020, 591 U.S. 1042) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  21. ABA Journal, "Top state court vacates order shutting down defiant barber's shop during COVID-19 crisis," June 8, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  22. Associated Press, "Michigan's top court throws out orders against Owosso barber," The Washington Times, June 5, 2020 (headline and date as listed) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  23. Michigan Supreme Court, In re Certified Questions from the U.S. District Court, Western District of Michigan (Midwest Institute of Health, PLLC v. Governor), No. 161492, Oct. 2, 2020, opinion text as posted by Hall Approved (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  24. Supreme Court of the United States, South Bay United Pentecostal Church v. Newsom, No. 20A136 (20-746), order of Feb. 5, 2021, with Roberts, C.J., concurring, Barrett, J., concurring, and Kagan, J., dissenting, slip opinion PDF (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  25. Bloomberg Law, "Houston Methodist Workers Lose Challenge to Vaccine Mandate," June 14, 2021 (Bridges v. Houston Methodist Hospital, S.D. Tex. No. 4:21-cv-01774, Hughes, J., June 12, 2021) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  26. NTD News, "Appeals Court Upholds Dismissal of Complaint Challenging University of California's COVID-19 Vaccine Mandate," Nov. 30, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  27. Supreme Court of the United States, Austin v. U.S. Navy Seals 1-26, No. 21A477, order of Mar. 25, 2022, with Kavanaugh, J., concurring and Alito, J., dissenting, 595 U.S. 1301, in the preliminary print of 595 U.S. part 2, orders section, PDF pages 89 to 96 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  28. Supreme Court of the United States, Biden v. Missouri, Nos. 21A240 and 21A241, per curiam, Jan. 13, 2022, 595 U.S. 87, slip opinion PDF (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  29. USNI News, "Navy Stops COVID-19 Vaccine Separations for 4,095 Sailors Who Requested Religious Exemptions," Mar. 30, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  30. Daily Montanan (States Newsroom), "Federal judge in Florida throws out national mask mandate for travelers," Apr. 18, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  31. U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, Bridges v. Methodist Hospital, No. 21-20311, June 13, 2022 (unpublished; Jolly, Elrod and Haynes, JJ.), opinion text (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  32. Becker's Hospital Review, "Former Houston Methodist employees lose appeal in vaccination mandate case," 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  33. Court of Appeal of California, Sixth Appellate District, People v. Calvary Chapel San Jose (H048708), Calvary Chapel San Jose v. Superior Court (H048734) and McClure v. Superior Court (H048947), filed Aug. 15, 2022 (Greenwood, P.J., with Bamattre-Manoukian and Danner, JJ.), opinion PDF (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  34. Jason Green and Gabriel Greschler, "San Jose church won't have to pay $217,500 in COVID fines after California Supreme Court denies petition," Bay Area News Group, distributed by Tribune News Service via inkl, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  35. Idaho Press, "Meridian park mom cleared after Labrador's move to dismiss charges," Jan. 12, 2023 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  36. Idaho Reports (Idaho Public Television), "AG Labrador dismissed trespassing case against Sara Brady," Jan. 5, 2023 (title and date as listed) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  37. Bloomberg Law, "Doctors' Covid-19 Speech Suit Rendered Moot by California Repeal," Apr. 3, 2024 (Hoeg v. Newsom, E.D. Cal. No. 2:22-cv-01980, Shubb, J.) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  38. The Philadelphia Inquirer, report on the Appellate Division decision upholding the Atilis Gym fines, Mar. 15, 2023 (Appellate Division docket A-3186-20) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  39. NJ 101.5, "NJ gym owners who violated pandemic orders lose appeal over $124K fines," March 2023 (headline as listed) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  40. Lorian Hardcastle, "The Next Chapter in the Role of Alberta's Chief Medical Officer of Health," ABlawg (University of Calgary Faculty of Law), Oct. 17, 2023 (Ingram v Alberta (Chief Medical Officer of Health), 2023 ABKB 453) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  41. Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, "Pastor spent 5 weeks in jail for holding church services" (case page with updates through Aug. 30, 2023) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  42. CBC News, "Ottawa's use of Emergencies Act against convoy protests was unreasonable, violated Charter, court rules," Jan. 23, 2024 (2024 FC 42, Mosley J.) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  43. U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, McDonald v. Lawson, No. 22-56220, 2024, opinion as posted by Justia (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  44. Rick Jaffe, "The 9th Circuit Just Tossed Two of the AB 2098 cases; Now What?," Mar. 2, 2024 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  45. Supreme Court of the United States, Murthy v. Missouri, No. 23-411, June 26, 2024, 603 U.S. 43 (Barrett, J., for the Court; Alito, J., dissenting, joined by Thomas and Gorsuch, JJ.), PDF (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  46. David S. Ettinger, "Supreme Court leaves standing million-dollar pandemic health violation fine against church," At The Lectern (Horvitz and Levy), July 16, 2025 (People v. Calvary Chapel San Jose, S291092; Court of Appeal H051860) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  47. Supreme Court of the United States, docket No. 25-703, Calvary Chapel San Jose v. California (petition filed Dec. 12, 2025; distributed for conference of Apr. 24, 2026), with Religious Liberty TV, "Church fined $1.2 million for worship during COVID restrictions asks Supreme Court for relief," Dec. 19, 2025 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  48. JURIST, "Ontario court orders Freedom Convoy leaders to conditional 18-month sentence," October 2025 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  49. The Canadian Press via CTV News, "Tamara Lich appeals mischief conviction arising from role in 'Freedom Convoy'," Nov. 4, 2025 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  50. Ground News summary of The Canadian Press report, "Crown Files Appeal Against Sentencing, Acquittals of Freedom Convoy Organizers Lich and Barber," Nov. 5, 2025 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  51. U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, Bridges v. Methodist Hospital, No. 24-20483, June 17, 2025 (not designated for publication), opinion text (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  52. JURIST, "Canada appeals court finds 2022 Emergencies Act invocation unreasonable," January 2026 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  53. The Canadian Press via CP24, "Supreme Court to hear federal appeal over use of Emergencies Act," Oct. 22, 2026 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  54. Idaho Legislature, Senate Joint Resolution No. 102 (2021), text (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  55. Idaho Secretary of State, Statewide Election Results by Precinct, General Election Nov. 8, 2022, ballot questions (grand total for the constitutional amendment: Yes 287,194, No 267,623) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  56. KCBD News Channel 11, "Texas Supreme Court orders release of Dallas salon owner who was jailed for ignoring shutdown order," May 7, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  57. Military Times, "Austin ends the military's COVID-19 vaccine mandate," Jan. 10, 2023 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  58. Public Order Emergency Commission, "Public Order Emergency Commission releases report," Feb. 17, 2023 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  59. The Daily Signal, "California Church Appeals to SCOTUS Over $1.2M in COVID-19 Fines," Dec. 21, 2025 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  60. Military.com, "Navy SEALs, Sailors Who Refused COVID Vaccine Will Have Records Expunged After Legal Settlement," July 24, 2024 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  61. Global News, report on Alberta prosecutors dropping the public health charges against GraceLife Church and pastor James Coates, Aug. 31, 2023 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  62. Great Barrington Declaration, official site (text, signing date and authors) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  63. Thomas More Society, "Big Religious Liberty Win for John MacArthur and Grace Church," Sept. 1, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  64. The Roys Report, report on the $800,000 settlement between California, Los Angeles County and Grace Community Church, Aug. 31, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  65. Supreme Court of the United States, Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11 (1905), text at Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  66. Connecticut Public (NPR), "The judge who tossed mask mandate misunderstood public health law, legal experts say," Apr. 19, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩

Check yourself

1. Which ruling stated that a regulation triggers strict scrutiny whenever it treats any comparable secular activity more favorably than religious exercise?

2. Why did the Supreme Court of Texas hold Shelley Luther's contempt judgment void on April 9, 2021?

3. What did section 525 of the defense authorization act for fiscal year 2023 require?

4. By how many votes did Idaho voters approve SJR 102 on November 8, 2022?

5. Why did the Eleventh Circuit vacate the district court's judgment in the transit mask case?

6. Which statement best describes Chief Justice Roberts's view in the February 5, 2021 South Bay order?

7. What did Justice Romaine hold in Ingram v Alberta (2023)?

8. What did the Federal Court of Appeal decide on January 16, 2026?

Terms in this lesson

Emergency powers
Authority a constitution or statute gives an executive (a governor, a president, a health officer) to act quickly in a declared emergency, often by order rather than by law. The profiles turn on the limits of those powers, such as Michigan's 1945 act, held unconstitutional in 2020.
Police power
The general power of a state to protect public health, safety and welfare. It belongs to the states, not the federal government, and was the basis of most state COVID-19 orders.
Jacobson v. Massachusetts
The 1905 Supreme Court decision upholding a smallpox vaccination law; it allows courts to set aside a health measure that is a "plain, palpable invasion of rights secured by the fundamental law."
Free Exercise Clause
The part of the First Amendment that forbids laws prohibiting the free exercise of religion. It was the basis of the worship cases in lessons 06 to 10.
Strict scrutiny
The most demanding test courts apply: the government must show a compelling interest and that the rule is narrowly tailored to it. The Louisiana Supreme Court held that Pastor Spell's orders did not survive it.
Most-favored-nation rule
The rule from Tandon v. Newsom: a regulation triggers strict scrutiny "whenever" it treats "any comparable secular activity more favorably than religious exercise."
Major questions doctrine
The rule that Congress must speak clearly when it gives an agency power over decisions of vast economic and political significance; NFIB v. OSHA applied it to the vaccine-or-test rule.
Nondelegation doctrine
The principle that a legislature may not hand its lawmaking power to the executive without adequate limits. Michigan's 1945 emergency act failed it under the state constitution.
Special session
A meeting of a legislature outside its regular session. Since 2022, Idaho's Legislature must be convened in special session on a joint written petition of at least 60 percent of each house.
Joint resolution
A measure adopted by both houses of a legislature. In Idaho a senate joint resolution (SJR) proposes a constitutional amendment for the voters; in Congress a joint resolution can become law, as Public Law 118-3 did.
Initiated law
A law proposed by citizen petition. In Michigan the Legislature may adopt it without the governor's signature, as it did with the repeal of the 1945 emergency act in July 2021.
Preliminary injunction
A court order that stops an action while a case is pending, granted when the challenger is likely to win and would suffer irreparable harm, as in Hoeg v. Newsom and the Navy SEALs case.
Temporary restraining order (TRO)
A short-term order, often issued the day a suit is filed, that holds things in place until a hearing. The TRO against Shelley Luther was held void.
Emergency application
A request to the Supreme Court for immediate relief, decided without full briefing or argument. Most of the worship cases came to the Court this way.
Per curiam
An opinion issued by the court as a whole, unsigned. Brooklyn, Tandon, Alabama Realtors and NFIB were per curiam.
Vacatur
An order that wipes out a judgment or a rule. The district court vacated the CDC transit mask order; the Eleventh Circuit later vacated that judgment as moot.
Mootness
The doctrine that courts decide only live disputes. A case becomes moot when the order expires or is repealed, as with the transit mask order and AB 2098.
Standing
The requirement that a plaintiff show an injury traceable to the defendant that a court can redress. The plaintiffs in Murthy v. Missouri lost on standing.
Contempt of court
Disobeying a court order. Criminal contempt punishes past disobedience; civil contempt pressures future compliance. Shelley Luther was held in both.
Habeas corpus
A petition asking a court to order release from unlawful confinement. The Supreme Court of Texas granted Luther's.

Full glossary · Module glossary · Ordered Liberty

Sources