📜 Liberty and the Republic™
Courses

Liberty and the Republic · Module 107

🛡 COVID and Liberty™: Hero Profiles

Hero Profiles

Hero profiles of people who stood up to COVID-era orders and mandates from 2020 to 2022, and what they won. A Meridian mother arrested at a closed playground, the Central District Health physician who took the board seat and kept it, the Idaho Legislature and voters who took back the special session, the Sandpoint group whose suit ended the federal transit mask rule, pastors in Louisiana, California and Alberta, the worship cases at the Supreme Court, a Dallas salon owner, a Michigan barber, a New Jersey gym, a Florida wife who took a dishwasher job to see her husband, fired nurses and doctors, the Great Barrington authors, the Navy SEALs, the businesses and landlords who won at the Supreme Court and the Freedom Convoy organizers. Each profile is told from the public record, with a dated timeline, what the other side said, and every ruling cited.

23 lessons · about 15.6 hours · about 142,400 words ·

Updated November 7, 2026

Start lesson 1

How to read this module

Each lesson after the first is a profile: who the person was before, the order or mandate they faced, what they did, what it cost them, and how it ended, with a dated timeline. The voice admires courage and says so. The module praises the stand on liberty (the limits of emergency power, due process, the free exercise of religion, free speech, the right to earn a living, and the right of families to be with the sick and dying), never a medical claim. Where a person made medical claims, they are stated as that person's, dated, with what official bodies said, in one short note.

Every profile is built from the public record: the orders, statutes, court rulings and official releases, the person's own public statements, and at least two news outlets for news facts. Each carries a labeled box, "What the other side said," so the reader hears the argument the person faced in the words of the officials and courts who made it, and a "Still disputed" line. Facts from a person's later record that bear on the story are stated briefly and sourced. Lesson 1 sets out the emergency orders of 2020, lesson 22 sums up what the stands won in law, and lesson 23 holds the full timeline of rulings, the glossary and the sources.

Related courses: Pierson's framework of legitimate authority and lawful resistance is in Ordered Liberty; the First Amendment is taught in the Constitution course; Calvary Chapel's history is in Church History, Part C; how to speak at a public meeting is in Testifying and Public Comment; and Idaho's recall and initiative process is in Recalls and the Initiative Process.

Status: built and fact checked November 7, 2026. Items that could not be confirmed against a primary source are listed at the end of each lesson under "Still open."

  1. 1Emergency Power in 2020: The Orders, Who Signed Them, and How People Pushed BackIn March 2020 the President, every governor and state health directors issued emergency orders that closed churches, businesses and playgrounds and told whole states to stay home. This lesson names who signed Idaho's orders and others, quotes the statutes and rulings, and maps the stands profiled in lessons 02 to 21. It shows the four lawful paths people used to push back: suits, defenses to charges, legislatures, and public comment and the ballot.40 min
  2. 2Sara Walton Brady and the Closed Playground (Meridian, Idaho)On April 21, 2020, Meridian mother Sara Walton Brady asked police to arrest her at a playground the city had closed by summary order, and they did. She pleaded not guilty and waited more than two and a half years; in January 2023 Attorney General Raúl Labrador moved to dismiss and the court agreed. This profile tells her stand, its costs, her apology for a protest at an officer's home, and her 2023 tort claim.35 min
  3. 3Dr. Ryan Cole: The Pathologist Who Took the Seat and Kept It (Central District Health)In 2021 Ada County commissioners replaced the Central District Health board's longtime physician, who had backed the pandemic restrictions, with Dr. Ryan Cole, a Garden City pathologist who had spoken out against lockdowns and mandates. He took the seat over the objection of much of the medical establishment, kept it through a Washington disciplinary order, license lapses and a malpractice suit, and in 2026 was reappointed without dissent to a term through June 2031.40 min
  4. 4Idaho Takes Back the Special Session: SJR 102 and the 2021 Emergency Powers FightIn 2020 the Idaho Legislature could not meet unless the governor called it. In 2021 legislators passed limits on emergency powers, lost an override by one vote, won four narrower laws, and sent SJR 102 to the voters, who approved it in November 2022 by 287,194 to 267,623. This profile honors the legislators and voters who restored the people's branch.45 min
  5. 5The Travelers Who Ended the Federal Transit Mask Rule: Ana Daza, Sarah Pope and the Health Freedom Defense Fund (Sandpoint, Idaho)Two Florida travelers, Ana Carolina Daza and Sarah Pope, joined a nonprofit headquartered in Sandpoint, Idaho, to challenge the CDC's 2021 rule requiring masks on all public transportation. On April 18, 2022, Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle held the rule beyond the CDC's power, issued without required public comment and inadequately explained, and vacated it nationwide. The rule was never restored; in 2023 the Eleventh Circuit found the case moot after the emergency ended and vacated the judgment without reaching the merits.40 min
  6. 6Pastor Tony Spell and Life Tabernacle (Central, Louisiana)Pastor Tony Spell kept Life Tabernacle in Central, Louisiana open in March 2020 while Gov. John Bel Edwards's orders capped worship but exempted offices, factories and airports. He was charged on six counts and fought them for two years, and on May 13, 2022 the Louisiana Supreme Court ruled 5-2 in State v. Spell that the orders violated his free exercise of religion as applied; every 2020 charge was dismissed. This profile also states the separate 2020 bus charge (never prosecuted), the federal suit he lost on a waived argument, and the 2026 battery arrest and protective order (no charge filed as of November 2026).40 min
  7. 7Pastor Mike McClure and Calvary Chapel San Jose (California)Pastor Mike McClure and Calvary Chapel San Jose kept meeting indoors, singing and unmasked through Santa Clara County's 2020 and 2021 bans, caps and mask rules, under daily-doubling fines, a court injunction and two contempt orders. On Aug. 15, 2022 the Sixth District Court of Appeal held the injunctions facially unconstitutional and annulled the contempt orders, and the California Supreme Court refused to restore the sanctions. The county's separate mask fines, cut from about $2.87 million to $1,228,700, were upheld in 2025, and the church's U.S. Supreme Court petition (No. 25-703) was still pending in November 2026.40 min
  8. 8John MacArthur and Grace Community Church (Sun Valley, California)In July 2020 John MacArthur and the elders of Grace Community Church reopened their Sun Valley sanctuary in open defiance of California's ban on indoor worship. Los Angeles County sued, won a stay and an injunction, and ended the church's parking lot lease, but the church kept meeting. After the Supreme Court ruled that worship could not be treated worse than comparable secular activity, the county and state agreed on August 31, 2021 to pay $800,000 in attorney fees.40 min
  9. 9The Worship Cases at the Supreme Court: Diocese of Brooklyn, Agudath Israel, South Bay Pentecostal and TandonA Catholic diocese, an Orthodox Jewish organization and its synagogues, a Pentecostal church in Chula Vista, a Pasadena church network, and two Bible study hosts in Santa Clara County took their worship to the Supreme Court in 2020 and 2021. They lost the first round, 5 to 4, then won in Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn v. Cuomo, South Bay II and Tandon v. Newsom. Tandon's rule, that government may not treat any comparable secular activity better than worship without meeting strict scrutiny, now protects every congregation.40 min
  10. 10Pastor James Coates and GraceLife Church (Alberta)James Coates, pastor of GraceLife Church west of Edmonton, kept holding full Sunday services under Alberta's 2020 to 2021 worship limits. He spent 35 days in the Edmonton Remand Centre rather than sign a release condition he could not keep in conscience, and Alberta Health Services fenced off his church for nearly three months. After a 2023 court ruling that the province's health orders had been made unlawfully, he and the church were acquitted of the remaining charges.40 min
  11. 11Shelley Luther and Salon a la Mode (Dallas, Texas)A Dallas salon owner reopened in April 2020, refused a judge's demand that she call herself selfish, and went to jail rather than close. Two days later the governor removed jail as a COVID-19 penalty and the Supreme Court of Texas ordered her freed; in 2021 that court held the order she was jailed under void for vagueness. She later lost two races and then won a seat in the Texas House.40 min
  12. 12Karl Manke, the 77-Year-Old Barber of Owosso (Michigan)A 77-year-old barber reopened his Owosso shop on May 4, 2020, and kept cutting hair through police citations, a health department closure order, a license suspension and a court injunction. The Michigan Supreme Court vacated the order to close him on June 5, 2020, and on October 2, 2020 held the governor's post-April 30 orders without lawful basis; his criminal charges were then dropped. He lost the separate licensing case, which ended in $9,000 in fines after his appeal was filed late.40 min
  13. 13Ian Smith, Frank Trumbetti and Atilis Gym (Bellmawr, New Jersey)On May 18, 2020, Ian Smith and Frank Trumbetti reopened their small gym in Bellmawr, New Jersey, in open defiance of Gov. Phil Murphy's closure orders, and kept it open through a state closure order, contempt findings, an arrest, barricades and the loss of their license. The outcome was mixed: the courts upheld $123,982.08 in sanctions and the license revocation, and both owners pleaded guilty to one count of contempt, but the borough's dozens of summonses were dismissed in 2024 and the gym never closed for good.40 min
  14. 14Mary Daniel, the Dishwasher Who Went Back to Her Husband (Jacksonville, Florida)Florida's March 2020 emergency order shut Mary Daniel out of her husband Steve's memory care home for 114 days. She took a part-time dishwashing job there to hold him again, then refused to stop with her own family: she founded Caregivers for Compromise, won a seat on the governor's task force, and saw her essential caregiver idea written into Florida's September 2020 order and, in 2022, into the No Patient Left Alone Act.35 min
  15. 15Jennifer Bridges and the Houston Methodist 117 (Texas)In 2021 Houston Methodist nurse Jennifer Bridges refused her employer's COVID-19 vaccine requirement, testified for a bill at the Texas Senate, led a deadline-day walkout and became lead plaintiff for 117 co-workers. She lost in every court from June 2021 to January 2026, and 153 employees resigned or were fired, but Texas later barred private employer COVID-19 vaccine mandates. This profile tells the record, the court's findings in its own words, and why her open refusal took courage.40 min
  16. 16Dr. Aaron Kheriaty, Fired for Natural Immunity (California)Dr. Aaron Kheriaty, a UC Irvine psychiatry professor and director of its medical ethics program, had recovered from COVID-19 and sued the University of California in August 2021 over a vaccine policy that gave prior infection only a 90-day deferral. He was suspended without pay and dismissed in December 2021, and the Ninth Circuit upheld the policy under rational basis review in 2022. He went on to join Hoeg v. Newsom, which blocked California's doctor misinformation law, and Missouri v. Biden, decided as Murthy v. Missouri.40 min
  17. 17Five Doctors Against California's Speech Law: Hoeg v. NewsomIn 2022 California made it unprofessional conduct for a doctor to give a patient COVID-19 "misinformation" contrary to "contemporary scientific consensus." Drs. Tracy Beth Høeg, Ram Duriseti, Aaron Kheriaty, Pete Mazolewski and Azadeh Khatibi sued the board that licenses them, and on Jan. 25, 2023 Judge William B. Shubb blocked the law as unconstitutionally vague. The Legislature repealed it in SB 815, effective Jan. 1, 2024, and the courts dismissed the remaining suits as moot.40 min
  18. 18The Great Barrington Three: Bhattacharya, Kulldorff and GuptaOn Oct. 4, 2020, epidemiologists Martin Kulldorff (Harvard), Sunetra Gupta (Oxford) and Jay Bhattacharya (Stanford) signed the Great Barrington Declaration, calling for an end to general lockdowns and for Focused Protection of the vulnerable. NIH Director Francis Collins privately called for a "devastating published take down," The Lancet's John Snow Memorandum called the approach "a dangerous fallacy," and Kulldorff lost his Harvard post after refusing a vaccine mandate. By 2026 Bhattacharya led the NIH, Kulldorff had chaired the federal vaccine committee and joined HHS, and Gupta remained at Oxford.40 min
  19. 19The Navy SEALs and the Military MandateThirty-five anonymous Navy SEALs, combat-craft crewmen, divers and a bomb technician asked for religious exemptions from the 2021 military COVID-19 vaccine mandate, were refused by form letter, and sued. A federal judge called the Navy's process "theater," the Supreme Court let the Navy limit their deployments, a Navy-wide class of about 4,095 sailors was protected from discharge, Congress ended the mandate, and the Navy settled in 2024 by clearing records and changing its religious accommodation policy.40 min
  20. 20Small Businesses and Landlords at the Supreme Court: NFIB v. OSHA and Alabama Association of Realtors v. HHSTwo Alabama and Georgia landlords, Danny Fordham and Robert Gilstrap, and their state Realtor associations ended the CDC's nationwide eviction moratorium in Alabama Association of Realtors v. HHS (Aug. 26, 2021). Five months later the National Federation of Independent Business, 25 other trade associations and 27 States, Idaho among them, stopped OSHA's vaccine-or-test rule for 84 million workers in NFIB v. OSHA (Jan. 13, 2022). Biden v. Missouri, decided the same day for a narrower health care rule, shows where the Court drew the line: Congress, not an agency, decides questions of vast economic and political significance.40 min
  21. 21Tamara Lich, Chris Barber and the Freedom Convoy (Canada)Tamara Lich, a laid-off logistics administrator from Medicine Hat, and Chris Barber, a Saskatchewan trucker, helped lead the 2022 Freedom Convoy to Parliament Hill against the cross-border trucker vaccine mandate, asked their followers for peace, and were arrested after Canada invoked the Emergencies Act for the first time. Two federal courts have since held the invocation unlawful and its measures contrary to the Charter, and the Supreme Court of Canada will hear the final appeal. Lich and Barber were convicted of mischief in 2025 and given conditional sentences; the convictions stand while appeals proceed.40 min
  22. 22What the Stands Won: Emergency Power, Due Process, Worship and Speech After 2020, and What a Local Official Can Do DifferentlyThe people profiled in this module changed American law: the Supreme Court's most-favored-nation rule for worship, limits on agencies that stretch old statutes, state rulings against open-ended emergency decrees, and new laws in dozens of states, including Idaho's SJR 102. This lesson counts what they won and what they lost, scores every profile from lesson 02 to 21, and gives county commissioners, health board members, mayors, sheriffs and school trustees six practices for the next emergency.40 min
  23. 23Timeline, Glossary, Sources and the Record of Every RulingThe record book of the module: every ruling from 2020 to 2026 behind the profiles, with court, citation, vote or judge, holding and lesson link, plus the statutes and orders that changed the rules, a dated timeline of the profiles, a 54-term glossary and a reading guide by lesson. The record shows how often people who stood their ground were proved right, and where they were not.60 min