Lesson 5 of 23 Ā· about 40 minutes
The Travelers Who Ended the Federal Transit Mask Rule: Ana Daza, Sarah Pope and the Health Freedom Defense Fund (Sandpoint, Idaho)
Updated November 7, 2026
You'll be able to
- You'll be able to state what the CDC's February 2021 transit mask order required, whom it bound, and how it could be enforced.
- You'll be able to explain the three grounds on which Judge Mizelle vacated the rule on April 18, 2022.
- You'll be able to explain why the court read "sanitation" in 42 U.S.C. 264(a) narrowly, and why that reading protects the line between Congress and agencies.
- You'll be able to describe what the Eleventh Circuit did in June 2023 and what mootness and vacatur mean for the case today.
- You'll be able to identify the plaintiffs and the Sandpoint, Idaho tie from the court record.
- You'll be able to judge why bringing a lawful challenge under one's own name against a federal rule took courage.
Start here: the short version
For fourteen months, from February 2021 to April 2022, federal law required every traveler in the United States to wear a mask on airplanes, trains, buses, ride-shares and boats and in airports and stations, on pain of removal, fines and even criminal penalties.1 The rule came from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, issued without the public notice and comment the law ordinarily requires.1 On July 12, 2021, two Florida women who flew to see their families, Ana Carolina Daza and Sarah Pope, joined with a small nonprofit headquartered in Sandpoint, Idaho, the Health Freedom Defense Fund, and sued.2 On April 18, 2022, U.S. District Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle of the Middle District of Florida held that the mask rule exceeded the CDC's power, skipped required procedures and was not adequately explained, and she declared it unlawful and vacated it nationwide.3 The government appealed, but the rule was never restored; in June 2023 the Eleventh Circuit dismissed the case as moot because the public health emergency on which the rule depended had ended, and it vacated the district court's judgment under its ordinary practice.4 Two travelers and a nonprofit from Sandpoint, Idaho, took on the federal government over a rule that bound millions of people, and they won the day that mattered.

Who they were before
The Health Freedom Defense Fund
The Health Freedom Defense Fund described itself to the court as "a not-for-profit public benefit Wyoming corporation with its headquarters in Sandpoint, Idaho," a member organization "that seeks to advocate for and educate the public on the topics of medical choice, bodily autonomy, and self-determination, and that opposes laws and regulations that force individuals to submit to the administration of medical products, procedures, and devices against their will."2 The case that ended a nationwide federal rule began, on paper, in Sandpoint.
The group's founder and president is Leslie Manookian, who describes herself on the organization's site as a former Wall Street executive whose finance career took her from New York to London with Goldman Sachs and later to Alliance Capital in London, where she ran its European Growth Portfolio Management and Research businesses.5 She is also a documentary filmmaker; in 2011 she released The Greater Good, a film she wrote and produced about the debate over vaccines.5 The organization says it was founded as 2020 unfolded, out of concern that legislation already on the books "would facilitate further erosion of the rights of Americans."5 It describes itself as a 501(c)(3) nonprofit that educates the public on informed consent and challenges mandates "when necessary" in court, and it asks its supporters "to stand up for their rights, and to do so peacefully and nonviolently."5
Ana Daza and Sarah Pope
The two individual plaintiffs were ordinary travelers, and they are named here because they put their own names on a federal lawsuit. According to the complaint, Ana Carolina Daza of Pinellas County, Florida, had traditionally flown once a year to visit family abroad. Pandemic travel restrictions and repeated flight cancellations had kept her from flying since February 2020, and she was planning a trip in August 2021. She "strenuously objects" to being required to wear a mask, the complaint said; she suffers from anxiety when wearing one, and although her physician had diagnosed the anxiety and provided a note, her condition did not qualify her for the rule's narrow disability exemption.2 Judge Mizelle later summarized the point: Daza alleged that "the government does not recognize [her] anxiety as a basis for a[ medical] exemption" from the rule.1
Sarah Pope of Hillsborough County, Florida, still flew regularly to see family and wore a mask when required, the complaint said, but she had begun avoiding long flights because she could not tolerate a mask for extended periods, and she had given up joining her family on a long trip because the prospect of masking for the whole flight gave her anxiety.2 The court found that Pope "flew regularly before the pandemic, but has done so less since the CDC imposed the Mask Mandate as the 'constricted breathing from wearing a mask' provokes or exacerbates her panic attacks."1
Neither woman was a public figure. Nothing else about them is used in this lesson. What matters is what they did: they agreed to stand as named plaintiffs against the President, the Secretary of Health and Human Services, the CDC and the United States, in a case that would be reported around the country.
Their lawyers
The complaint was signed by Brant C. Hadaway of Hadaway, PLLC in Miami, with George R. Wentz, Jr. of The Davillier Law Group in New Orleans.2 A case of this kind does not need a large firm; it needs a careful reading of a statute and the patience to build a record. They provided both.
The order they faced
The executive order
On January 21, 2021, the day after taking the oath of office, President Joseph R. Biden issued Executive Order 13998, "Promoting COVID-19 Safety in Domestic and International Travel." It directed the secretaries of several agencies to "immediately take action, to the extent appropriate and consistent with applicable law, to require masks to be worn in compliance with CDC guidelines in or on" airports, commercial aircraft, trains, public maritime vessels, intercity bus services and other forms of public transportation.41
The CDC order
The CDC acted on that direction with an order dated January 29, 2021,2 published in the Federal Register on February 3, 2021 as "Requirement for Persons to Wear Masks While on Conveyances and at Transportation Hubs," 86 Fed. Reg. 8025.6 Its central command reads:
"Until further notice, under 42 U.S.C. 264(a) and 42 CFR 70.2, 71.31(b), and 71.32(b), unless excluded or exempted as set forth in this Order, a person must wear a mask while boarding, disembarking, and traveling on any conveyance into or within the United States. A person must also wear a mask at any transportation hub that provides transportation within the United States."6
The order drafted private businesses as enforcers. "Conveyance operators traveling into or within the United States may transport only persons wearing masks and must use best efforts to ensure that masks are worn when embarking, disembarking, and throughout the duration of travel," it said, and operators of transportation hubs had the same duty for anyone on their premises.6 The rule reached aircraft, trains, road vehicles including ride-sharing services, vessels and "other means of transport," and every "airport, bus terminal, marina, seaport or other port, subway station, terminal ... , train station, U.S. port of entry, or any other location that provides transportation subject to the jurisdiction of the United States," Judge Mizelle noted.1
The exceptions were narrow: children under two; people with a disability within the scope of the Americans with Disabilities Act that prevented them from safely wearing a mask; personal, non-commercial vehicles and commercial vehicles with a single occupant; and brief moments such as eating, drinking, taking medication, verifying identity, catching one's breath or speaking with someone who is hearing impaired.1 Anxiety did not count.
The order set no end date. It would "remain in effect unless modified or rescinded based on specific public health or other considerations, or until the Secretary of Health and Human Services rescinds the determination under section 319 of the Public Health Service Act (42 U.S.C. 247d) that a public health emergency exists."6 And it skipped public comment. "Considering the public health emergency caused by COVID-19," the CDC wrote, "it would be impracticable and contrary to the public's health, and by extension the public's interest, to delay the issuance and effective date of this Order."6
The penalties
The order said the CDC "does not intend to rely primarily on these criminal penalties" and "strongly encourages and anticipates widespread voluntary compliance," but it reserved "the right to enforce through criminal penalties."6 Judge Mizelle laid out what that meant: under the statute, a person who violates regulations issued under section 264 may be fined a thousand dollars, imprisoned for up to a year, or both, and federal regulations provide for fines of up to $100,000 if a violation does not cause a death and up to $250,000 if it does.7 In practice, the main penalty for a traveler was simpler and more immediate: the airline or bus line, bound to use "best efforts," could refuse to carry a passenger or remove him.1
What they did
They sued in Tampa
On July 12, 2021, the Health Freedom Defense Fund, Daza and Pope filed a complaint for declaratory relief in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida, Tampa Division, against President Biden, Secretary of Health and Human Services Xavier Becerra, the Department of Health and Human Services, the CDC, CDC Director Rochelle Walensky, Dr. Martin Cetron of the CDC's Division of Global Migration and Quarantine, and the United States.2 They did not ask for an emergency injunction. They asked the court to declare the rule unlawful and to set it aside.23
Their claims were legal, not medical. The amended complaint, filed December 13, 2021, alleged that the rule exceeded the CDC's authority under the Public Health Service Act; that the CDC had improperly invoked the "good cause" exception to skip notice and comment under the Administrative Procedure Act; that the rule was arbitrary and capricious; and, in the alternative, that if the statute did authorize the rule, Congress had unconstitutionally delegated its legislative power to the agency.81 They first challenged the President's executive order as well, then withdrew those counts so the case could focus on the CDC's rule; with that withdrawal the President was dropped as a defendant.1
The government tried to move the case. It asked to transfer it to a different division of the Middle District of Florida, where a separate challenge brought without a lawyer was pending. Judge Mizelle denied the transfer in 2021, noting among other differences that the other plaintiff had sought emergency injunctions and these plaintiffs had not.3
Building the record
The case was then decided on the administrative record, the documents the CDC itself relied on. The government moved for summary judgment on January 18, 2022. The plaintiffs filed their cross-motion on February 17, 2022, and briefing closed on March 31, 2022.1 The government did not dispute that at least some plaintiffs had standing, conceding that the rule "imposes a legal obligation on the individual Plaintiffs to wear masks when using public transportation."1 The Health Freedom Defense Fund showed that at least one of its members had standing in her own right, so it could sue on behalf of its members as well.1
The plaintiffs' central argument was a matter of plain words. Section 264(a) of the Public Health Service Act of 1944 lets the CDC, to prevent the spread of communicable disease between states and from abroad, "provide for such inspection, fumigation, disinfection, sanitation, pest extermination, destruction of animals or articles found to be so infected or contaminated as to be sources of dangerous infection to human beings, and other measures."9 The government said a mask rule for every traveler was a form of "sanitation." The plaintiffs said it was not, and that the statute's list described things done to property, not orders that bind people.9
What it cost
The cost of this case was of a different kind than the jail cells and license fights in other lessons of this module, and it should not be inflated. Nobody was arrested. The cost was paid in exposure and in time.
Daza and Pope lived under the rule for the whole fourteen months it was in force. By the complaint's account, Daza had not flown since February 2020 and faced a mask on every flight to see her family, and Pope had given up long trips with her family because she could not face a long flight in a mask.2 They put their names, their home counties and their medical histories into the public record of a federal case to make the point that the rule had no room for people like them.21
They also took on a heavy opponent. The other side was the United States, represented by Justice Department lawyers and the United States Attorney for the Middle District of Florida.10 The plaintiffs were two individuals and a young nonprofit. Litigation of this kind takes months of filings, a full administrative record and the risk of losing in public on a question that, in 2021, most institutions treated as settled. Taking that risk, under their own names, with no promise of success and against the weight of official opinion, is the price this lesson honors.

How it ended
April 18, 2022
Judge Mizelle's 59-page order opens with the travelers' point of view: "As travelers have been reminded for more than a year, federal law requires wearing a mask in airports, train stations, and other transportation hubs as well as on airplanes, buses, trains, and most other public conveyances in the United States. Failure to comply may result in civil and criminal penalties, including removal from the conveyance."1 Her holding came on the second page: "The Court concludes that the Mask Mandate exceeds the CDC's statutory authority and violates the procedures required for agency rulemaking under the APA. Accordingly, the Court vacates the Mandate and remands it to the CDC."1 She found three independent defects.
First: beyond the CDC's power
The court read "sanitation" as Congress used it in 1944. Using dictionaries of the period and a search of how the word was used in American English between 1930 and 1944, the court concluded that the meaning of "sanitation" in section 264(a) is "that of active cleaning," measures that change the condition of a thing or place by cleaning it, and that a mask, which keeps something clean, does not fit.9 The court also held that subsection (a) reaches property, while the following subsections, which address individuals, reach persons. Because the mask rule "regulates an individual's behavior," the court wrote, "it imposes directly on liberty interests, not the property interests contemplated in subsection (a)."9
The court then looked at history. The government's broad reading would make the 1944 law a source of sweeping new federal power, but "when Congress passed the statute in 1944 it did so to codify the federal government's historic role in quarantine," the court wrote, and "This history suggests that the power the government sees in § 264(a) is a mirage."9 Public health regulation of whole populations, the court observed, "was traditionally understood" as "a function of state police power," and "Section 264(a) has no 'unmistakably clear' language indicating that Congress intended for the CDC to invade the traditionally State-operated arena of population-wide, preventative public-health regulations."9 Because the court found the rule beyond the statute, it did not reach the plaintiffs' alternative argument that Congress had unconstitutionally delegated its power.7
Second: no good cause to skip public comment
The Administrative Procedure Act ordinarily requires an agency to publish a proposed rule and accept public comment for at least thirty days before it becomes binding. The good cause exception, the court noted, "is to be 'narrowly construed and only reluctantly countenanced.'"7 The CDC's stated reason was the sentence quoted above. The court found the timing told against it: when the CDC issued the rule, "the COVID-19 pandemic had been ongoing for almost a year and COVID-19 case numbers were decreasing," and the CDC issued it "almost two weeks after the President called for a mandate, eleven months after the President had declared COVID-19 a national emergency, and almost thirteen months since the Secretary of Health and Human Services had declared a public health emergency."7 The court also explained why public comment mattered most here: "the Mandate governs the conduct of private individuals in their daily lives," and "the public has a heightened interest in participating in a regulation that would constrain their choices and actions via threats of civil and criminal penalties."7 For a rule that told every traveler in the country what to wear, the public had been given no voice at all.
Third: not adequately explained
Finally, the court held the rule arbitrary and capricious because the CDC did not explain the choices it made about exceptions. "In sum, irrespective of whether the CDC made a good or accurate decision, it needed to explain why it acted as it did," the order said; since the CDC "did not explain its decision to compromise the effectiveness of its Mandate by including exceptions or its decision to limit those exceptions," the decision had to be set aside.11 The court was careful to decide this point on the CDC's reasoning, not on whether masks work.11
The remedy
The court then explained why the right remedy was to vacate the rule for everyone. Vacatur is the ordinary remedy under the Administrative Procedure Act, the court held, and it was also needed to give the plaintiffs complete relief. "The difficulty of distinguishing the named Plaintiffs from millions of other travelers," the court wrote, "almost ensures that a limited remedy would be no remedy at all. How is the ride-sharing driver, flight attendant, or bus driver to know someone is a Plaintiff to this lawsuit with permission to enter mask-free?"3 The court took notice that the Health Freedom Defense Fund had members around the country.3
Its conclusion, in full:
"'It is indisputable that the public has a strong interest in combating the spread of [COVID-19].' Ala. Ass'n of Realtors, 141 S. Ct. at 2490. In pursuit of that end, the CDC issued the Mask Mandate. But the Mandate exceeded the CDC's statutory authority, improperly invoked the good cause exception to notice and comment rulemaking, and failed to adequately explain its decisions. Because 'our system does not permit agencies to act unlawfully even in pursuit of desirable ends,' id., the Court declares unlawful and vacates the Mask Mandate."3
The order granted the plaintiffs' motion for summary judgment on Counts I, II and III, denied the government's motion, declared the rule unlawful, vacated it, remanded it to the CDC, dropped the President as a defendant and directed entry of final judgment. It was signed in Tampa on April 18, 2022.3 The clerk entered judgment for the plaintiffs the same day.12 The judge cited lesson 20's case, Alabama Association of Realtors v. HHS, the Supreme Court's 2021 ruling against the CDC's eviction moratorium, for both of the quoted lines; see Small Businesses and Landlords at the Supreme Court.

The appeal
Two days later, on April 20, 2022, the government filed its notice of appeal to the Eleventh Circuit, signed for Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Brian M. Boynton and United States Attorney Roger B. Handberg.10 No order putting the rule back in force appears in the record reviewed for this lesson, and the Eleventh Circuit's opinion treats the district court's vacatur as the last word on the rule until the emergency ended.4 The government argued on appeal for "the legality of the Mandate and the sufficiency of the procedures by which it was promulgated," while the plaintiffs "sought to defend the relief they had obtained from the district court and ensure their lives were no longer impacted by the Mandate."4
Before the appeal was decided, the emergency ended. On April 10, 2023, President Biden signed a joint resolution of Congress ending the national emergency, and on May 11, 2023, the HHS Secretary's declaration of a public health emergency expired.4 Because the rule by its own terms lasted only as long as that declaration, the Eleventh Circuit held, it would have expired by May 11, 2023 "even had the district court sided with the government."4
On June 22, 2023, a panel of Circuit Judges Wilson, Jordan and Brasher, in an opinion by Judge Wilson, held the case moot. "A Mandate that, as we write, no longer exists," the court wrote; "there is no longer any Mandate for us to set aside or uphold." Even a reversal in the government's favor, the court added, would leave "no Mandate to reinstate."4 The court rejected the plaintiffs' arguments that the case fell within the exceptions for voluntary cessation and for wrongs "capable of repetition, yet evading review," finding "not a grain of evidence that the CDC has any plans to promulgate an identical mandate."4 It then followed its "ordinary practice" for moot cases: "Accordingly, the order and judgment of the district court are VACATED, and the district court is instructed to DISMISS the case as MOOT."4 The opinion is published at 71 F.4th 888.13
The result needs to be stated precisely. The Eleventh Circuit did not reverse Judge Mizelle or say she was wrong; it never reached the merits. It vacated her judgment because the dispute had ended, which means her April 2022 order no longer binds anyone as a judgment. But the mask rule itself was gone from April 18, 2022 on and was never reinstated, and the appeals court found no sign the CDC planned to issue another one.4 The travelers won the relief they sued for, for the whole remaining life of the rule.
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| January 31, 2020 | HHS Secretary determines that a public health emergency exists.1 |
| March 13, 2020 | President Trump declares the COVID-19 outbreak a national emergency.1 |
| January 21, 2021 | President Biden issues Executive Order 13998 on masks in travel.1 |
| January 29, 2021 | Date of the CDC order requiring masks on conveyances and at transportation hubs.2 |
| February 3, 2021 | CDC order published, 86 Fed. Reg. 8025, without notice and comment.6 |
| July 12, 2021 | Health Freedom Defense Fund, Ana Carolina Daza and Sarah Pope file suit in Tampa.2 |
| December 13, 2021 | Plaintiffs file their amended complaint.8 |
| January 18, 2022 | Government moves for summary judgment.1 |
| February 17, 2022 | Plaintiffs file their cross-motion for summary judgment.1 |
| March 31, 2022 | Briefing completed.1 |
| April 18, 2022 | Judge Mizelle declares the rule unlawful and vacates it; judgment entered for the plaintiffs.312 |
| April 20, 2022 | Government files notice of appeal to the Eleventh Circuit.10 |
| April 10, 2023 | President signs the joint resolution ending the national emergency (Pub. L. 118-3).4 |
| May 11, 2023 | HHS public health emergency declaration expires.4 |
| June 22, 2023 | Eleventh Circuit holds the appeal moot, vacates the judgment and directs dismissal (71 F.4th 888).413 |

Why it took courage
In 2021 the transit mask rule was federal law, ordered by the President and the CDC and enforced by every airline, railroad and bus line under the rule's "best efforts" command.6 Two women who were neither lawyers nor activists by trade, and a nonprofit from a small Idaho town, decided to test it in court anyway. They did not refuse to comply and they did not disrupt flights; Pope kept wearing a mask when she was required to.2 They took the lawful road this module honors in every profile: they went to court and asked a judge to measure the rule against the law. Lesson 52's Forms of Lawful Resistance describes that road; this case is a model of it.
The liberty they defended is the oldest one in American government: that the people are bound only by laws their representatives make, and that an agency can do only what Congress has given it power to do. The court put it in the language of the statute books. A rule that "regulates an individual's behavior" imposes "directly on liberty interests," and Congress had never given the CDC that power through a 1944 law about fumigation and pest extermination.9 The court also vindicated the public's right to be heard before it is regulated: a rule governing "the conduct of private individuals in their daily lives" had been imposed with no chance for comment.7 The court relied on the Supreme Court's rulings against the CDC's eviction moratorium and the OSHA vaccine-or-test rule, told in lesson 20, and the principle protects everyone, whatever they think of masks.9
They also defended the people the rule forgot. The rule's exemptions left no room for a traveler whose anxiety or panic attacks made a mask on a long flight unbearable.12 Daza and Pope could have quietly stayed home, as Pope had already begun to do with long trips. Instead they put their own medical conditions into a public court file so that the rule would have to answer for people like them.
And they defended local initiative. A nonprofit from Sandpoint, Idaho, with a founder who had left a finance career to work on medical freedom, won a judgment ending a federal rule nationwide.253 That is a lesson in what a few determined citizens can do.
What the other side said
The CDC, in its order. The CDC explained that COVID-19 "spreads very easily and sustainably between people who are in close contact," mainly by respiratory droplets, and concluded that masks are "one of the most effective strategies available for reducing COVID-19 transmission."1 It found that "it would be impracticable and contrary to the public's health, and by extension the public's interest, to delay the issuance and effective date of this Order" for public comment.6 The rule followed a direct instruction from the President in Executive Order 13998.4
The government, in court. The Justice Department argued that the rule was authorized by section 264(a). It defined sanitation as "the promotion of hygiene and prevention of disease by maintenance of sanitary conditions," and called masking a "conventional 'sanitation' measure."9 It offered hand sanitizer and sanitizing wipes as examples of sanitation measures.9 It argued that it had good cause to skip notice and comment because of the emergency, it addressed the propriety of vacatur in only a single sentence of its brief, the court noted, and it argued that the plaintiffs were estopped from seeking an injunction; the court rejected that argument.3 On appeal the government continued "to defend the legality of the Mandate and the sufficiency of the procedures by which it was promulgated."4
The Eleventh Circuit. The appeals court did not side with either party on the merits. It held the case moot, vacated the district court's judgment, and directed dismissal, observing that "in a case born of extraordinary circumstances, we conclude with a familiar routine."4 Under that ruling the April 2022 judgment no longer stands, and the legal question of how far section 264(a) reaches was left for another day.
Still disputed: Whether the CDC has power under section 264(a) of the Public Health Service Act to require masks of travelers was never decided by an appeals court; the Eleventh Circuit vacated the district court's judgment as moot without reaching the merits, so the question remains legally open.4 Whether the CDC could validly skip notice and comment in the emergency was likewise left undecided on appeal.4
Medical note: The plaintiffs' complaint of July 12, 2021 stated that Daza suffers anxiety, headaches and shortness of breath when wearing a mask and compared those symptoms to findings about health care workers after prolonged mask use, and that masking provokes Pope's panic attacks; these were their own accounts and the complaint's assertions.2 The CDC's order stated that masks are "one of the most effective strategies available for reducing COVID-19 transmission."1 The court decided the case on statutory authority and procedure and did not rule on whether masks work; it said its explanation holding applied "irrespective of whether the CDC made a good or accurate decision."11
Cautions about the Health Freedom Defense Fund
The Health Freedom Defense Fund's positions go well beyond masks on airplanes, and readers should know them. The group says it opposes any law or policy that forces a person "to put something into their body against their will," and it calls bodily autonomy "the most sacred and precious of human rights."5 Its founder's 2011 film explores the debate over vaccines.5 In 2021 it also sued over an Idaho school mask mandate and over the Los Angeles school district's staff vaccine mandate, the court noted.3 Its own website describes its cases as challenges to "mask mandates, mandates of experimental drug injections, violations of religious and conscientious beliefs."14 Those positions are the group's own, and this lesson does not adopt them. The case told here is about a legal question of agency power, and on that question the group won.
Hard questions and answers
Did the Eleventh Circuit not wipe out the win?
It wiped out the judgment as a precedent, but not the result. The appeals court vacated Judge Mizelle's judgment because the case had become moot, without saying she was wrong.4 Meanwhile the rule had been off the books from April 18, 2022 until it would have expired anyway in May 2023, and the appeals court found "not a grain of evidence" that the CDC planned to bring it back.4 The plaintiffs sued to be free of the rule; they were, for its entire remaining life.
A defender of the rule asks: should one district judge be able to end a national rule?
Judge Mizelle took the objection seriously, writing that she "admittedly shares some of the skepticism" about nationwide injunctions.3 Her answer was that vacatur of an unlawful rule is a different and long-established remedy under the Administrative Procedure Act, and that no narrower remedy could work: a flight attendant has no way to know which passengers are plaintiffs.3 The government could have sought a stay on appeal; the record reviewed for this lesson shows only a notice of appeal.10
A public health officer asks: in a pandemic, does speed not justify skipping public comment?
Sometimes it does, and the law's good cause exception exists for real emergencies. The court's point was that the CDC had not shown it here: it waited almost two weeks after the President asked for the rule, eleven months into the national emergency, and it could have issued an interim rule and taken comment at the same time.7 A rule binding millions of people every day is the kind of rule on which the public most deserves a hearing.7
A civil liberties advocate asks: why does a 1944 word matter so much?
Because in the American system an agency has only the power Congress gives it, and Congress speaks through words. The court quoted the Supreme Court: "[a]dministrative agencies are creatures of statute" and "possess only the authority that Congress has provided."9 If "sanitation" could mean any measure that promotes hygiene, the court reasoned, the rest of the statute's list would add nothing.9 Reading the word as Congress used it in 1944 keeps the line between the lawmakers the people elect and the officials they do not.
Were Daza and Pope refusing to follow the law?
No. By the complaint's own account, Pope wore a mask when required, and Daza planned her travel knowing she would have to mask; both chose to challenge the rule in court instead of defying it.2 That is lawful resistance in its plainest form.
What is the Idaho connection?
The lead plaintiff, the Health Freedom Defense Fund, told the court it was headquartered in Sandpoint, Idaho.2 The same group also brought an Idaho school mask case in federal court in Idaho in 2021.3 For Idaho readers, the case shows that a small organization in their own state can test a federal rule and prevail.
Related lessons
- Emergency Power in 2020: The Orders, Who Signed Them, and How People Pushed Back
- Small Businesses and Landlords at the Supreme Court (the eviction moratorium and OSHA cases Judge Mizelle relied on)
- The Worship Cases at the Supreme Court
- Dr. Ryan Cole: The Pathologist Who Took the Seat and Kept It (another Idaho stand)
- Idaho Takes Back the Special Session: SJR 102
- What the Stands Won and Timeline, Glossary, Sources and the Record of Every Ruling
- Legitimate Authority and Its Limits and Forms of Lawful Resistance
- The Tenth Amendment (state police power over public health)
Still open
These items could not be confirmed against a primary source before publication. The lesson states them as open, and they stay on the fact-check list.
- The reporter citation 599 F. Supp. 3d 1144, often given for the April 18, 2022 order, was not checked against the printed reporter; the lesson cites the order by docket and document number. The Eleventh Circuit opinion is cited as 71 F.4th 888.
- The lesson does not describe the CDC's, TSA's or airlines' public response in the days after the April 18, 2022 ruling. Whether the government asked any court for a stay pending appeal was not confirmed; the court records cited here show only the notice of appeal.
- The date of Judge Mizelle's order denying transfer (cited in the opinion as 2021 WL 5416688) was not confirmed; the lesson says 2021.
- Biographical details of Leslie Manookian come from the Health Freedom Defense Fund's own site and are attributed to it.
Learn more
- Judge Mizelle's order of April 18, 2022 (Doc. 53): The full 59-page opinion; the discussion of "sanitation" and the remedy section reward a careful read.
- Eleventh Circuit opinion, No. 22-11287 (June 22, 2023): A short, clear explanation of mootness and why the appeals court vacated the judgment.
- The CDC order, 86 Fed. Reg. 8025 (Feb. 3, 2021): The rule itself, with its exceptions, its enforcement duties and its good cause statement.
- The complaint, July 12, 2021 (Doc. 1): How the plaintiffs framed their case, and the Sandpoint headquarters allegation.
Notes
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693-KKM-AEP (M.D. Fla. Apr. 18, 2022) (Mizelle, J.), Order, Doc. 53, pp. 1 to 8 (introduction, background, the plaintiffs, standing, the government's concession) and p. 4 (CDC findings quoted from 86 Fed. Reg. 8026 to 8028). Scanned filing; text read by optical character recognition and checked against the page images (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693 (M.D. Fla.), Complaint for Declaratory Relief, Doc. 1, filed July 12, 2021, paragraphs 1, 8 to 12, 49 and 50, and signature page (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693-KKM-AEP (M.D. Fla. Apr. 18, 2022) (Mizelle, J.), Order, Doc. 53, pp. 54 to 59 (remedy, footnotes 4 and 5, conclusion and ordering paragraphs; signed in Tampa, Apr. 18, 2022) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Health Freedom Defense Fund v. President of the United States, No. 22-11287 (11th Cir. June 22, 2023) (published opinion of Wilson, J., for a panel of Wilson, Jordan and Brasher, JJ.), Doc. 95-1, pp. 1 to 11 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, "About" page (mission statement and biography of founder and president Leslie Manookian) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, "Requirement for Persons to Wear Masks While on Conveyances and at Transportation Hubs," 86 Fed. Reg. 8025 (Feb. 3, 2021), FR Doc. 2021-02340, including the order text, the good cause statement and note 33 on criminal penalties (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693-KKM-AEP (M.D. Fla. Apr. 18, 2022) (Mizelle, J.), Order, Doc. 53, pp. 31 to 46 (end of Part III.A and Part III.B, the good cause exception; criminal penalties under 42 U.S.C. 271(a) and 42 C.F.R. 70.18 and 71.2) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693 (M.D. Fla.), Amended Complaint for Declaratory Relief, Doc. 39, filed Dec. 13, 2021 (Counts I to VI) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693-KKM-AEP (M.D. Fla. Apr. 18, 2022) (Mizelle, J.), Order, Doc. 53, pp. 9 to 31 (Part III.A, the Mask Mandate exceeds the CDC's authority under the Public Health Services Act, including the text of 42 U.S.C. 264(a), the meaning of "sanitation," the property and liberty reading, and the history of the statute) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693-KKM-AEP (M.D. Fla.), Defendants' Notice of Appeal, Doc. 55, filed Apr. 20, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693-KKM-AEP (M.D. Fla. Apr. 18, 2022) (Mizelle, J.), Order, Doc. 53, pp. 46 to 50 (Part III.C, arbitrary and capricious for failure to explain) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Health Freedom Defense Fund v. Becerra et al., No. 8:21-cv-1693-KKM-AEP (M.D. Fla.), Judgment in a Civil Case, Doc. 54, filed Apr. 18, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- CourtListener, citation lookup for 71 F.4th 888, resolving to Health Freedom Defense Fund v. President of the United States (11th Cir. 2023) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, home page (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
Check yourself
1. What federal statute did the CDC rely on for the transit mask rule?
The order cited 42 U.S.C. 264(a) and CDC regulations; the court held it did not authorize the rule.
2. Where did the Health Freedom Defense Fund tell the court it was headquartered?
The complaint describes it as a Wyoming nonprofit corporation headquartered in Sandpoint, Idaho.
3. Which was NOT one of the three grounds for Judge Mizelle's April 18, 2022 ruling?
The court decided on statutory authority and the Administrative Procedure Act; it did not rule on any First Amendment claim and did not reach the non-delegation claim.
4. How did the court read the word "sanitation" in the 1944 statute?
Using 1940s dictionaries and usage, the court read it as active cleaning, and held subsection (a) reaches property, not persons.
5. Why did the court vacate the rule for everyone instead of only the plaintiffs?
The court asked how a ride-sharing driver, flight attendant or bus driver could know who was a plaintiff.
6. When did the government file its notice of appeal?
Doc. 55, the notice of appeal, was filed April 20, 2022.
7. What did the Eleventh Circuit decide on June 22, 2023?
The rule had expired with the public health emergency on May 11, 2023, so the court followed its ordinary practice for moot cases.
8. What is still legally open after the appeal?
Because the appeals court did not reach the merits, no appellate court decided the scope of section 264(a) in this case.
Terms in this lesson
- Administrative Procedure Act (APA)
- The 1946 federal law that sets the procedures agencies must follow to make rules and lets courts set aside unlawful agency action.
- Notice and comment
- The APA process in which an agency publishes a proposed rule and accepts public comments for at least thirty days before the rule binds anyone.
- Good cause exception
- The narrow APA exception that lets an agency skip notice and comment if it finds them impracticable, unnecessary or contrary to the public interest.
- Arbitrary and capricious
- The APA standard under which a court sets aside agency action that is not the product of reasoned, adequately explained decision-making.
- 42 U.S.C. 264(a)
- Section 361(a) of the Public Health Service Act of 1944, letting federal health officials make regulations to stop the spread of communicable disease between states or from abroad, through inspection, fumigation, disinfection, sanitation, pest extermination and similar measures.
- Vacatur
- A court order setting aside an agency action or a judgment, so that it has no legal effect.
- Summary judgment
- Decision of a case without trial when there is no genuine dispute of material fact; in agency cases it is decided on the administrative record.
- Standing
- The requirement that a plaintiff have a concrete injury caused by the challenged action that a court can remedy.
- Associational standing
- The rule that an organization may sue for its members if at least one member would have standing in his own right.
- Mootness
- The doctrine that a court may not decide a case once the dispute has ended and the court can no longer give meaningful relief.
- Munsingwear vacatur
- The ordinary practice, from United States v. Munsingwear (1950), of vacating a lower court judgment when a case becomes moot on appeal.
- Capable of repetition, yet evading review
- A narrow exception to mootness for short-lived actions likely to recur against the same party.
Sources
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693-KKM-AEP (M.D. Fla. Apr. 18, 2022) (Mizelle, J.), Order, Doc. 53 (59 pages) (2022-04-18) checked 2026-11-07
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693 (M.D. Fla.), Complaint for Declaratory Relief, Doc. 1, filed July 12, 2021, paragraphs 1, 8 to 12, 49 and 50, and signature page (2021-07-12) checked 2026-11-07
- Health Freedom Defense Fund v. President of the United States, No. 22-11287 (11th Cir. June 22, 2023) (published opinion of Wilson, J., for a panel of Wilson, Jordan and Brasher, JJ.), Doc. 95-1, pp. 1 to 11 (2023-06-22) checked 2026-11-07
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, "About" page (mission statement and biography of founder and president Leslie Manookian) (2026-11-07) checked 2026-11-07
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, "Requirement for Persons to Wear Masks While on Conveyances and at Transportation Hubs," 86 Fed. Reg. 8025 (Feb. 3, 2021), FR Doc. 2021-02340, including the order text, the good cause statement and note 33 on criminal penalties (2021-02-03) checked 2026-11-07
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693 (M.D. Fla.), Amended Complaint for Declaratory Relief, Doc. 39, filed Dec. 13, 2021 (Counts I to VI) (2021-12-13) checked 2026-11-07
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, Inc. v. Biden, No. 8:21-cv-1693-KKM-AEP (M.D. Fla.), Defendants' Notice of Appeal, Doc. 55, filed Apr. 20, 2022 (2022-04-20) checked 2026-11-07
- Health Freedom Defense Fund v. Becerra et al., No. 8:21-cv-1693-KKM-AEP (M.D. Fla.), Judgment in a Civil Case, Doc. 54, filed Apr. 18, 2022 (2022-04-18) checked 2026-11-07
- CourtListener, citation lookup for 71 F.4th 888, resolving to Health Freedom Defense Fund v. President of the United States (11th Cir. 2023) (2023-06-22) checked 2026-11-07
- Health Freedom Defense Fund, home page (2026-11-07) checked 2026-11-07