šŸ“œ Liberty and the Republicā„¢
Courses › COVID and Libertyā„¢

Lesson 11 of 23 Ā· about 40 minutes

Shelley Luther and Salon a la Mode (Dallas, Texas)

Updated November 7, 2026

You'll be able to

  • Tell the story of Shelley Luther's reopening, contempt hearing and jailing in April and May 2020 from the court record and two news outlets for each news fact.
  • Quote and explain the state orders GA-18, GA-21 and GA-22 and the penalty in Texas Government Code 418.173 as the orders recited it.
  • Explain why the Supreme Court of Texas held in In re Luther (No. 20-0363, April 9, 2021) that the restraining order and the contempt judgment were void under Rule 683.
  • State plainly what her stand cost, what it won, and what remains disputed, including her later campaigns for office.
  • Describe what a local official can learn from the case about clear orders and the least restrictive penalty.

Start here: the short version

Shelley Luther owned Salon a la Mode, a hair and nail salon in Far North Dallas. After a month with no income, she reopened on Friday, April 24, 2020, while state, county and city orders still kept salons closed. She was cited, sent a cease-and-desist letter, sued by the City of Dallas and ordered closed by a judge. She stayed open. On May 5, 2020, state District Judge Eric Moye offered to spare her jail if she would admit she had been "selfish" and close until the governor allowed salons to open. She answered that "feeding my kids is not selfish" and went to jail on a seven-day sentence.1 Two days later Governor Greg Abbott removed jail as a penalty for breaking any COVID-19 order, and the Supreme Court of Texas ordered her released.23 On April 9, 2021, the same court held that the restraining order behind her jailing was too vague to enforce and that the contempt judgment was void.4 She later ran for the Texas Senate and lost, ran for the Texas House and lost, then ran again and won; she has served in the Texas House since January 2025.5 Her stand took courage because she put her own liberty on the table in open view, in front of a judge who had the power to keep her in jail, for the right to earn a living and to keep her stylists earning theirs.

Who they were before

Before April 2020, Shelley Luther was a small business owner with no public record in politics. The Dallas Morning News, which interviewed people who knew her and reviewed her public records in May 2020, described her as a salon owner, makeup artist, musician and mother whose Facebook page was mostly before-and-after pictures of clients, along with her daughters and her dogs. The paper found she had not given money to any political candidate since at least 2014, and that she had opened her salon in 2017 under the business name Hot Mess Enterprises.6 The court record names the business as S&B Hot Mess Enterprises, LLC, doing business as Salon A La Mode, on Belt Line Road in Dallas.4 She was 46 years old when she went to jail; the Morning News reported that she would turn 47 on Sunday, May 10, 2020, which was also Mother's Day.6

Her salon worked the way many salons work: stylists rented chairs and space from her. She told reporters the salon had 19 stylists, and the Morning News reported that nearly 20 stylists rented space there.76 When the salon closed, the stylists' income stopped along with hers. Her partner told the Morning News that she had long rescued animals, most recently horses, and that the family was two months behind on its mortgage by early May.6

The salon closed on March 22, 2020. "Our salon and other small businesses were closed down on Mar. 22, and we have not had any income since," she said at the rally where she tore up the county's letter.8 She told The Texan that she had applied for every loan program she could find in the first days they opened and had heard nothing back. Faced with a choice between paying the salon's rent and paying her mortgage, she paid the rent.7 She also told that outlet what had puzzled her about the rules: her salon was "non-essential," while the pet groomer next door stayed open the whole time.7

Dealey Plaza in downtown Dallas, with grass, trees, streets and downtown buildings
Dealey Plaza in downtown Dallas, photographed in 2003. Dallas County's courts and offices are nearby in downtown Dallas. Photo by Brodie319. Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

The order they faced

Three governments had rules that touched her salon at the same time: the State of Texas, Dallas County and the City of Dallas. The Supreme Court of Texas later described the result. Governor Abbott issued a disaster proclamation for every Texas county in March 2020 and then "a flurry of lengthy and detailed executive orders." Between March 19 and April 28, 2020, the court counted "a dozen more executive orders" from the governor. In the same weeks the Dallas County Judge "issued more than twenty orders," and the City of Dallas "contributed another four sets of regulations."4 The court's own summary was that "the regulations in place during March and April 2020 were not only complex and in flux," and that the newer state orders had shifted toward reopening.4

The state order: GA-18

When she reopened on April 24, the governor's orders then in force, among them GA-14 of March 31 and GA-16 of April 17, did not let salons open.94 Three days later Governor Abbott signed Executive Order GA-18, on April 27, 2020, to run through May 15. It let retail stores, restaurants, movie theaters, malls, museums and libraries reopen at reduced capacity starting May 1, 2020. Salons were left out. The order said, word for word: "People shall avoid visiting bars, gyms, public swimming pools, interactive amusement venues such as bowling alleys and video arcades, massage establishments, tattoo studios, piercing studios, or cosmetology salons."9 The penalty came from state law, which the order quoted: "under Section 418.173, failure to comply with any executive order issued during the COVID-19 disaster is an offense punishable by a fine not to exceed $1,000, confinement in jail for a term not to exceed 180 days, or both fine and confinement."9 GA-18 also said it superseded "any conflicting order issued by local officials," but only where a local order restricted services the state had reopened.9 Since the state had not reopened salons, the county and city closures still stood.

Some local officials had asked whether GA-18 let salons open. A top lawyer in Attorney General Ken Paxton's office told county judges that it did not include barbershops and hair salons.10

The county letter and the city lawsuit

On the afternoon of her first day open, Friday, April 24, Dallas County Judge Clay Jenkins sent her a cease-and-desist letter ordering the salon closed.8 She told The Texan that the letter warned that criminal and civil charges would be filed against her if she did not close.7 Dallas police had already issued her a citation that day.11

On April 28, 2020, the City of Dallas sued her and her business, alleging that the salon was operating in violation of COVID-19 regulations. The trial court signed a temporary restraining order the same day.4 The Texas Tribune reported that state District Judge Eric Moye signed the order, and the Supreme Court of Texas docket lists the trial court as the 14th District Court of Dallas County, Judge Eric Moye.1012 The order's command, as the Supreme Court of Texas later quoted it, read:

IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Defendants are immediately ordered to cease and desist from operating the Salon A La Mode business for in-person services located at 7989 Belt Line Road, Ste. 139-1C, Dallas, Texas in violation of State of Texas, Dallas County, and City of Dallas emergency regulations related to the COVID-19 pandemic[.]4

The order did not name any particular state, county or city rule. In another sentence of the same order, the judge had written "/or" by hand after the word "and," so that it spoke of regulations of the state, county "and/or" city.4 Those two facts became the whole case a year later.

What they did

The reopening

On Friday, April 24, 2020, she opened Salon a la Mode for the first time since March. Dallas police came by and issued her a citation; an Associated Press photograph that day shows her holding the citation while she talks with an officer.11 She told The Texan that every officer who visited "was very gracious and respectful," and added, "I don't in any way disparage them as they are just sent when others want to hide."7

She did not reopen carelessly, by her own account and by the court record. The Texan reported that she let only one client at a time inside to be served, set chairs six feet apart outside for those waiting, wiped each chair between people, and had the stylists wear masks.7 At the contempt hearing she testified that she had limited the number of workers and customers inside, required masks, enforced distancing in waiting areas and added sanitizer stations.4 When the governor publicly warned salon owners that the state could take their licenses, she answered him on Facebook: "How dare you threaten my license and assume that I'm not practicing strict, CDC recommended, guidelines for my business when you've never been there."7

Tearing up the letter

The next day, Saturday, April 25, she spoke at an "Open Texas" rally in Frisco and tore Judge Jenkins's cease-and-desist letter to pieces in front of the crowd and the cameras.86 CBS Texas reported that she began that day by opening her salon "for a second day in a row."8 The torn letter made her a public figure. It also made clear, to everyone watching, that she knew what the county wanted and was refusing on purpose.

Staying open under the restraining order

The City of Dallas sued on April 28 and the judge signed the restraining order the same day.4 She kept the salon open. A Morning News photographer recorded her at the front window of the salon on Wednesday, April 29, and the paper reported that she opened that morning despite the judge's order of the day before.6 At the contempt hearing she "conceded that she had notice of the temporary restraining order," in the words of the Supreme Court of Texas.4 She never pretended otherwise.

The hearing on May 5

The judge had set a hearing on a temporary injunction for May 11, but he called the parties in early, on May 5, on the city's motion to hold her in contempt.4 The hearing was held by video.11 A Dallas code inspector and a Dallas police officer testified that they had seen clients getting haircuts and manicures inside the salon over the previous seven days, and city attorneys argued that she had "willfully and flagrantly" violated the order.1 She took the stand and said: "I have no choice. I need to feed my family, and my stylists could not feed their families."1 The hearing took a brief recess during Governor Abbott's news conference that day, at which he announced that salons could reopen statewide that Friday, May 8.13

Then the judge made his offer. Two outlets recorded his words, with small differences. CBS Texas reported him saying: "If you would like to take this opportunity to acknowledge that your own actions were selfish, putting your own interest ahead of those in the community in which you live."14 FOX 4 in Dallas reported: "Your actions were selfish, putting your own interests ahead of the community in which you live. You disrespected the orders of the state, the county and this city."13 Both outlets reported that he would consider a fine alone, with no jail, if she apologized and kept the salon closed until Friday.1413 The Associated Press reported the same offer.11 The Texas Tribune, reporting with WFAA-TV, quoted another line from the bench: "The rule of law governs us. People cannot take it upon themselves to determine what they will and will not do."1

Her answer, as CBS Texas transcribed it:

"I have much respect for this court and laws. I have never been in this position before and it's not someplace that I want to be. But I have to disagree with you sir, when you say that I'm selfish because feeding my kids -- is not selfish. I have hair stylists that are going hungry because they'd rather feed their kids. So sir, if you think the law is more important than kids getting fed, then please go ahead with you decision but I am not going to shut the salon."14

FOX 4 and the Associated Press reported the same answer in nearly the same words.1311 In a Facebook video before the hearing she had already said what she would do: if she had to "go to jail to prove a point that what they're doing is totally unconstitutional, then that's what happens."15

The judge found her and her company in both criminal and civil contempt and ordered her confined for seven days.4 The written judgment, as the Associated Press quoted it, said: "The defiance of the court's order was open, flagrant and intentional," and that she "expressed no contrition, remorse or regret."11 To purge the contempt, the judgment required her to "publicly express contrition" for the violations "[i]n a manner commensurate with the previous expressions of defiance of the mandate of Dallas County."4 She was taken into custody that afternoon and booked into the Dallas County jail.11

What it cost

Jail

She was sentenced to seven days in jail. FOX 4 reported that the court imposed seven days on the criminal contempt and seven on the civil contempt, to run at the same time, one day for each day the salon was open after the order.13 She served less than two days. The Associated Press counted it as "less than 48 hours behind bars."16 She was booked on Tuesday, May 5, and walked out on Thursday, May 7.10 For a mother with no criminal record, the Morning News noted, the sentence would have carried her through her 47th birthday and Mother's Day if no one had intervened.6

Fines

The fines were real, though the reports of the amount differ. The Supreme Court of Texas, describing the judgment, wrote that "the salon was ordered to pay a $500 fine for each of the days the trial court determined the salon violated the order."4 CBS Texas reported that the judge set the amount at $3,500 plus $500 for every additional day the salon stayed open until Friday, under a headline figure of $7,000.14 FOX 4 reported $1,000 for each day open, totaling $7,000.13 The Texas Tribune later wrote simply that she "was fined $7,000."15 The court's own description, $500 a day, is the most reliable statement of the order. Lieutenant Governor Dan Patrick publicly offered to pay her fine and to serve seven days of house arrest in her place.15 When the Supreme Court of Texas later held the contempt judgment void, the legal basis for the fine fell with it.4

Before May 7, a violation of the governor's orders was a crime punishable by up to 180 days in jail and a $1,000 fine.9 Her license was also exposed. She told The Texan that other salon owners had reported her to the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation and urged that her license be revoked, and that she had heard the governor say the state could revoke her business license "forever."7 Even after the jail penalty was removed, the governor's spokesman said that "other punishments such as fines or license suspensions, still apply."10

The landlord and the public

She told The Texan that her landlord asked her to close, that the city or county was naming the property owner in a lawsuit as well, and that the landlord sent her a 15-day notice to "fix the non-compliance or leave the building."7 The salon's phone, a volunteer manager told the Morning News while Luther was in jail, rang with calls "from supporters and haters" from across the country and abroad.6 She became, overnight, a national symbol, praised by some as a patriot and condemned by others as reckless. That kind of fame has costs of its own that no court counts.

What came in

The cost was matched by an outpouring of help. A GoFundMe page set up for her met its $500,000 goal, CBS Texas reported; the Associated Press counted more than $440,000 in the largest fundraiser by the evening of May 6.1711 On May 8, the day after her release, she told reporters she planned to give part of it away: "We have already planned on spreading some of that gift today in South Dallas. I've already reached out, trying to get in contact with the two ladies in Laredo and I would like to pay for any of their attorney fees, any citations they have, and maybe give them a little bit of head-start money."17 The two Laredo women had been arrested on April 15, 2020, accused of offering beauty services from their homes.17

How it ended

The statewide response

The jailing drew an immediate response from the state's top officials. On May 6, Attorney General Paxton wrote to Judge Moye asking for her release. "I find it outrageous and out of touch that during this national pandemic, a judge, in a county that actually released hardened criminals for fear of contracting COVID-19, would jail a mother for operating her hair salon in an attempt to put food on her family's table," he said.11 He called the order "a shameful abuse of judicial discretion."10 Governor Abbott said the same day: "Compliance with executive orders during this pandemic is important to ensure public safety; however, surely there are less restrictive means to achieving that goal than jailing a Texas mother."11 Her lawyers, Warren Norred and state Representative Briscoe Cain, filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus and an emergency motion in the Supreme Court of Texas on May 6.104

May 7: GA-22 and the release order

On Thursday, May 7, 2020, Governor Abbott signed Executive Order GA-22, "Relating to confinement during the COVID-19 disaster." Its operative words were:

All existing executive orders relating to COVID-19 are hereby amended to eliminate confinement in jail as an available penalty for any violation of the executive orders. No jurisdiction can confine a person in jail as a penalty for violating any executive order, or any order issued by local officials, in response to the COVID-19 disaster.3

The order made the change retroactive to April 2, 2020, superseded any contrary local order, and reached back to amend GA-21 so that salons were treated as reopened, retroactive to April 2, "to the extent necessary to supersede and nullify the existence of any prior or existing state or local executive order, the violation of which could form the basis for confinement in jail."3 The governor's statement that day named her: "Throwing Texans in jail who have had their businesses shut down through no fault of their own is nonsensical, and I will not allow it to happen. ... This order is retroactive to April 2nd, supersedes local orders and if correctly applied should free Shelley Luther."18 He also named the two Laredo women who had been arrested, Ana Isabel Castro-Garcia and Brenda Stephanie Mata.18

Lawyers pointed out a gap. Contempt of court is punishment for disobeying a judge, which is different from punishment for disobeying the governor. "Court orders are always potentially enforceable by jail," Dallas appellate lawyer David Coale told the Tribune, calling the comparison "apples and oranges."10 The gap was closed the same morning by the Supreme Court of Texas. Its orders list for May 7, 2020 reads: "20-0363 IN RE SHELLEY LUTHER; from Dallas County / relator's motion for emergency relief granted / response requested due by 4:00 p.m., May 11, 2020," with the note that "The petition for writ of habeas corpus remains pending before this Court."2 The court later described that order as releasing her "from confinement on personal bond pending the final disposition of the case."4 She walked out of the jail that afternoon to a crowd chanting "Shelley's free." "I just want to thank all of you who I just barely met, and now you're all my friends," she told them. "You mean so much to me, and this would have been nothing without you."1019

Four people in formal evening wear posing in a room of the White House with blue walls
President Donald J. Trump and First Lady Melania Trump with Texas Governor Greg Abbott and Cecilia Abbott in the Blue Room of the White House on Feb. 9, 2020, three months before Abbott signed GA-22. Official White House Photo by Andrea Hanks. Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

May 8: the salons open

The governor's order of May 5, GA-21, had already set the date for every salon in Texas. It allowed, "Starting at 12:01 a.m. on Friday, May 8, 2020," the reopening of "Cosmetology salons, hair salons, barber shops, nail salons/shops, and other establishments where licensed cosmetologists or barbers practice their trade," with at least six feet between work stations.2021 On that Friday, United States Senator Ted Cruz flew to Dallas from Houston for his first haircut in three months, at Salon a la Mode.16 She told reporters that day what she believed the fight had done: "I had to do what I felt was right in this situation, and whether they support it or not... if they're a salon owner, they are getting to open 10 days earlier."17 Whether her stand moved the date is not something the record can prove, and it is listed below as disputed. Before May 5 the governor had said mid-May was his goal for salons, and the May 8 date was earlier than that.11

The appeal that became moot

Her company also appealed the restraining order itself to the Fifth District Court of Appeals in Dallas. That appeal was dismissed as moot on July 15, 2020, because the governor's new order "expressly allowed cosmetology salons to reopen."4 Her habeas case in the Supreme Court of Texas did not become moot, because she remained on bond under a contempt judgment. The court ordered full briefing on the merits on August 28, 2020, and the briefs were filed that fall.12

April 9, 2021: the order was void

On April 9, 2021, the Supreme Court of Texas granted her petition in a per curiam opinion, without oral argument. It began with the plain holding: "We now conclude that the temporary restraining order failed to set forth the conduct required and the legal basis for its issuance in clear, specific, and unambiguous terms. Accordingly, we hold that the temporary restraining order was void, making the Contempt Judgment based on that order void as well."4

The court relied on Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 683, which requires that every restraining order "shall set forth the reasons for its issuance; shall be specific in terms; [and] shall describe in reasonable detail and not by reference to the complaint or other document, the act or acts sought to be restrained." Those requirements, the court said, "are mandatory and must be strictly followed."4 It quoted its own older warning that "Contempt is strong medicine -- the alleged contemnor's very liberty is often at stake -- and so it should be used only as a last resort."4 Then it applied the rule to the order that had jailed her:

The temporary restraining order in this case does not meet these standards. It requires Defendants to cease and desist from conducting in-person services at the salon "in violation of State of Texas, Dallas County, and City of Dallas emergency regulations related to the COVID-19 pandemic." But it nowhere specifies any particular state, county, or city regulation that Luther has violated, is threatening to violate, or is being commanded to stop violating.4

The court added that "Luther could not know without analyzing a multitude of regulations -- state, county, and city emergency orders referenced in the temporary restraining order, plus the federal guidelines they referenced -- what conduct was prohibited at any given time the temporary restraining order was in effect."4 (The court's dashes appear here as double hyphens.) The handwritten "and/or" made things worse: the court said it had "discouraged the use of 'and/or' because the term 'inherently leads to ambiguity and confusion.'"4

In a footnote the court went further, about the apology the judge had demanded. Because a contempt order "must spell out exactly what duties and obligations are imposed and what the contemnor must do to purge the contempt," the court wrote, "The Contempt Judgment's lack of specificity regarding what sort of public apology would suffice to purge the contempt appears to render the Contempt Judgment invalid." She had not raised that point, so the decision did not rest on it.4 The court also declined to reach her constitutional challenges to the COVID-19 orders themselves, because they "would not afford Luther any greater relief," citing its rule that "As a rule, we only decide constitutional questions when we cannot resolve issues on nonconstitutional grounds."4 Its closing words were the ones she had waited eleven months to hear: "we grant Luther's petition for writ of habeas corpus and order that Luther is and shall remain discharged from custody."4 The Texas Tribune reported the ruling the same day under the headline that the court had voided the orders that jailed her.15

A multi-story stone government building with rows of windows and trees in front
The building of the Supreme Court of Texas in Austin, which ordered Luther released on May 7, 2020 and voided the contempt judgment on April 9, 2021. Photo by WhisperToMe. Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Her later campaigns

The fame led straight into politics, and the record of her campaigns is plain. In 2020 she ran in a special election for Texas Senate District 30 in North Texas. In the first round on September 29, 2020, she finished first in a six-candidate field with 32.0 percent (22,242 votes), just ahead of state Representative Drew Springer with 31.9 percent (22,127 votes). In the runoff on December 19, 2020, Springer won, 56.5 percent to 43.5 percent (32,761 votes to 25,235).5 The Texas Tribune described the margin as 13 percentage points.15

In 2022 she challenged state Representative Reggie Smith in the Republican primary for Texas House District 62 and lost on March 1, 2022, with 41.3 percent (10,912 votes to his 15,510).522 She ran against him again and won the primary on March 5, 2024, with 53.4 percent (16,971 votes to 14,803). On November 5, 2024, she won the general election with 77.7 percent (67,062 votes) over Democrat Tiffany Drake.522 She took office on January 14, 2025.523 She was unopposed in the Republican primary on March 3, 2026, and was on the ballot for re-election on November 3, 2026, against Democrat Catherine Thorne.5 The certified result of that race was not available to this lesson when it was written in early November 2026, so it is not stated here.

Timeline

DateEvent
March 13, 2020Governor Abbott issues a disaster proclamation for all Texas counties.4
March 22, 2020Salon a la Mode closes; by her account it had no income from that day on.8
April 24, 2020She reopens the salon; Dallas police issue a citation; Dallas County Judge Clay Jenkins sends a cease-and-desist letter.118
April 25, 2020She tears up the letter at an "Open Texas" rally in Frisco.8
April 27, 2020GA-18 reopens retail and restaurants from May 1 but keeps salons closed.9
April 28, 2020The City of Dallas sues; the court signs a temporary restraining order the same day.4
April 29, 2020She opens again despite the order.6
May 5, 2020GA-21 sets May 8 for salons to reopen statewide. Judge Moye holds her in criminal and civil contempt; seven days in jail; she is booked.20411
May 6, 2020Paxton and Abbott call for her release; twelve Dallas County civil district judges answer Paxton by letter; her habeas petition is filed.11104
May 7, 2020GA-22 removes jail as a penalty, retroactive to April 2. The Supreme Court of Texas orders her released on personal bond; she leaves jail.3210
May 8, 2020Salons reopen statewide; Senator Ted Cruz gets a haircut at Salon a la Mode.2016
July 15, 2020The Dallas Court of Appeals dismisses the appeal of the restraining order as moot.4
August 28, 2020The Supreme Court of Texas orders full merits briefing.12
September 29, 2020She finishes first in the Senate District 30 special election and goes to a runoff.5
December 19, 2020She loses the runoff to Drew Springer, 43.5 to 56.5 percent.5
April 9, 2021The Supreme Court of Texas holds the order and the contempt judgment void and grants the writ.4
March 1, 2022She loses the House District 62 primary to Reggie Smith.5
March 5, 2024She defeats Smith in the House District 62 primary.522
November 5, 2024She wins the House District 62 seat with 77.7 percent.522
January 14, 2025She takes office in the Texas House.5
March 3, 2026Unopposed in the Republican primary for re-election.5

Why it took courage

A great many people disagreed with the closure orders in the spring of 2020. Very few were willing to stand in front of a judge, on the record, and say they would keep disobeying while the judge held the keys to the jail. Shelley Luther did exactly that. The judge offered her a clean way out: say the word "selfish" about herself, close for three more days, pay a fine, go home. She refused it because the apology would have been false, and she would not say something false to stay out of jail. That is the old courage of the dissenter who will accept the penalty but will not confess to a wrong she does not believe she committed.

What she defended was a liberty that runs deep in American law: the right to work at a lawful trade and to support a family by it. Her salon was not an unlawful business. It was a licensed shop doing what it had done for years, under sanitation rules her stylists already trained to follow, now with masks, spacing and one client at a time. The orders that closed it let a pet groomer next door stay open, and let big stores open before her. She asked a fair question in a free country: why is my living less essential than theirs? She asked it in the one way that could not be ignored.

She also defended, without planning to, a basic rule of due process. A person may be jailed for disobeying a court only when the court has told her plainly what she must do. The Supreme Court of Texas held that the order she disobeyed never told her that. It pointed to a cloud of more than thirty state, county and city orders, plus federal guidance, and left her to sort out which ones applied on which day. A citizen who refuses such an order and takes the consequences forces the courts to say whether the order was ever lawful. Her refusal produced a per curiam ruling, issued for the whole court, that protects every Texan who is ever ordered to obey a vague command on pain of jail.4 The ruling is a lesson for every county commissioner and judge: an order that cannot be read cannot be enforced.

And she risked a great deal. She was a mother with a mortgage, a business and a crew of stylists depending on her. She had no political career and no organization behind her when she opened on April 24; the rally and the fundraising came after. She did not know the governor would change his order or that the high court would act in two days. She went into the jail on a seven-day sentence with the open threat of more if she kept the salon open, and she told the judge she would keep it open. That is courage in the plainest sense: doing the hard thing while not knowing how it will end. The praise here is for the stand on liberty and due process; it makes no claim about the virus.

What the other side said

The judge. Judge Eric Moye said from the bench that her "actions were selfish," that she had "disrespected the orders of the state, the county and this city," and that "The rule of law governs us. People cannot take it upon themselves to determine what they will and will not do."131 His written judgment found that "The defiance of the court's order was open, flagrant and intentional."11 Earlier he had found that her business posed "adverse public health effects" from the spread of COVID-19, according to FOX 4.13

The City of Dallas. City attorneys argued at the hearing that how she ran the salon did not matter, and that the only question was whether she was open in violation of the order.1 In the Supreme Court of Texas the city argued that strict compliance with Rule 683 was not required when an order restrains "a 'public nuisance,'" relying on a 1971 case, and that the court should deny the petition because she had not first gone to the court of appeals. The court rejected both arguments.4

The Dallas County judges. On May 6, Judge Moye and the eleven other civil district judges of Dallas County signed a letter to Attorney General Paxton calling his letter "an ex parte communication about a pending case." It said: "In this context, for you to 'Urge' a Judge towards a particular substantive outcome in this matter is most inappropriate and equally unwelcome. Please do not communicate with the Court in this manner further."10

The Texas Democratic Party. Spokesman Abhi Rahman said on May 7 that Governor Abbott was pushing "Texans to focus on the trivial" and that Abbott "dangles political red meat for his base while ignoring his own established guidelines and executive orders."10

Still disputed: Whether her stand moved up the May 8 reopening of Texas salons (she said it did; the governor's order of May 5 gives no reason for the date, and he had earlier named mid-May as his goal)1711; whether GA-22 by itself could have freed a person jailed for contempt of court (the governor said it should; Dallas lawyers said a court's contempt power was separate)1810; and the exact amount of the fine, which news outlets reported as $7,000 or as $3,500 plus $500 a day, while the high court described it as $500 per day of violation.41314

Medical note: In April 2020 she said she followed "strict, CDC recommended, guidelines" and asked state officials to "show the data you claim to have of salons spreading the virus" (Facebook post quoted by The Texan, April 2020).7 The state's position through May 7, 2020 was that cosmetology salons should stay closed under its orders, and when they reopened they had to keep six feet between work stations; the Texas Tribune reported in April 2021 that CDC guidance still said people providing services to clients in hair salons were at risk of contracting COVID-19.92015

Some facts in her story are unflattering, and they belong in the record. She knew of the restraining order and kept the salon open anyway, and she said in advance she would keep doing so; the high court's ruling turned on the order's vagueness, not on any finding that she misunderstood it.4 She testified that she had received a federal loan; the Tribune later reported it as $18,000 in Paycheck Protection Program money received days before the hearing, which she said she was unsure how she was allowed to spend.1115 One of her lawyers, Warren Norred, said after the hearing: "If you're not willing to die for your fellow countrymen then it's you that is selfish."13 And the fame that came with her stand became a political career, as the campaign record above shows.

Hard questions and answers

She broke a court order on purpose. Why call that heroic?

Because she broke it openly, accepted the consequence, and the order turned out to be void. Civil disobedience in the American tradition does not hide; it stands in the open and takes the penalty, and the penalty puts the law itself on trial. The Supreme Court of Texas held that the order "nowhere specifies any particular state, county, or city regulation" she had violated, and that the contempt judgment was void.4 A citizen is not bound to obey a void order. Lesson 08 of Ordered Liberty covers the lawful forms of resistance; her case is one of the clearest modern examples.

Didn't she win only on a technicality?

The rule that a person can be jailed only for breaking an order that tells her plainly what to do is no technicality. It is the core of due process in contempt cases. The court called contempt "strong medicine" because "the alleged contemnor's very liberty is often at stake," and said orders enforced by jail "must not be susceptible of different meanings or constructions."4 It is true that the court did not decide whether the COVID-19 orders themselves were constitutional; it said it decides constitutional questions only when it must.4

A defender of the order asks: what else could the city do with someone who said she would never comply?

The city had civil fines, the license process and an ordinary injunction hearing set for May 11. The governor himself said on May 6 that "surely there are less restrictive means to achieving that goal than jailing a Texas mother."11 If the city wanted an order enforceable by jail, Rule 683 told it how to write one: name the regulation and describe the act forbidden.4

A civil liberties advocate asks: why did the apology matter so much?

Because compelled confession is a different thing from compelled obedience. A judge may order a person to close a shop; a judge ordering a person to declare herself "selfish" is ordering speech. The Supreme Court of Texas noted that the demand to "publicly express contrition" was so vague that it "appears to render the Contempt Judgment invalid" on its own.4 Her refusal to say words she did not believe is the part of her stand most people remember.

A public health officer asks: doesn't this teach people to ignore emergency orders?

It teaches officials to write orders people can read and to use the least severe penalty that works. The governor's own GA-22 said officials "should look for the least restrictive means of combatting the threat to public health."3 Texas kept fines and license actions after May 7; it removed jail.10 Orders that are clear, limited and fair are more likely to be obeyed than a pile of overlapping rules that even a high court found hard to follow.

Was she running for office all along?

The record says no. The Dallas Morning News found she had made no political donations since at least 2014 and was not politically active before she reopened; her partner said in May 2020 that he did not foresee a political career for her.6 Her first campaign began months after the jailing. She lost twice before she won, which is a record of persistence, not of a plan that went smoothly.5

Still open

These items could not be confirmed against a primary source before publication. The lesson states them as open, and they stay on the fact-check list.

  • The exact contempt fine: the Supreme Court of Texas described it as $500 per day of violation; CBS Texas reported $3,500 plus $500 a day; FOX 4 and the Texas Tribune reported $7,000. The written contempt judgment itself was not found.
  • Judge Moye's exact words at the May 5, 2020 hearing: CBS Texas and FOX 4 quote them slightly differently; no hearing transcript was found, so both versions are given and attributed.
  • That she opened again on April 29, 2020 rests on a Dallas Morning News report and photo caption.
  • The exact publication date of The Texan's late-April 2020 interview with her was not shown on its page.
  • Election vote counts are as listed by Ballotpedia; they were not compared with the Texas Secretary of State's official canvass.
  • The result of the November 3, 2026 general election for Texas House District 62 (Luther vs. Catherine Thorne) was not available as of November 7, 2026.

Learn more

Notes

  1. Rebecca Lopez and Eline de Bruijn (WFAA-TV), "Dallas salon owner who refused to close sentenced to seven days in jail, ordered to pay fines," The Texas Tribune, May 5, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  2. Supreme Court of Texas, Orders Pronounced May 7, 2020, Miscellaneous: "20-0363 IN RE SHELLEY LUTHER; from Dallas County, relator's motion for emergency relief granted" (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  3. Governor Greg Abbott, Executive Order GA-22, "Relating to confinement during the COVID-19 disaster," May 7, 2020, filed with the Texas Secretary of State (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  4. Supreme Court of Texas, In re Shelley Luther, No. 20-0363, per curiam opinion on petition for writ of habeas corpus, delivered April 9, 2021, pp. 1 to 10 (quoting the April 28, 2020 temporary restraining order and describing the May 5, 2020 contempt judgment) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  5. Ballotpedia, "Shelley Luther" (election results for Texas State Senate District 30, 2020, and Texas House District 62, 2022, 2024 and 2026; date taking office) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Vote counts as listed there; the Texas Secretary of State canvass was not opened for this lesson. Read it online. ↩
  6. The Dallas Morning News, "Meet the Dallas salon owner whose decision to reopen put her in the middle of a national debate," May 6, 2020, with photo captions of April 29, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  7. The Texan, "'Every Business is Essential,' Dallas Salon Owner Defies County Shelter Order," April 2020 (published the day of the governor's late-April reopening announcement, per its text) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  8. CBS Texas (KTVT), "Salon Owner Rips Cease And Desist Letter From Dallas Judge Ordering Her To Close," April 25, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  9. Governor Greg Abbott, Executive Order GA-18, "Relating to the expanded reopening of services as part of the safe, strategic plan to Open Texas," April 27, 2020, pp. 2 to 5 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  10. Cassandra Pollock, "Dallas salon owner released from county jail after defying orders by reopening early," The Texas Tribune, May 7, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  11. Associated Press, "Dallas salon owner jailed for defying virus shutdown order," May 6, 2020, as published by KSAT, with AP photo captions of April 24 and May 5, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  12. Supreme Court of Texas, case docket, No. 20-0363, In re Shelley Luther (case events: merits briefing, opinion issued and habeas granted April 9, 2021; trial court: 14th District Court, Dallas County, Judge Eric Moye, No. DC-20-06131) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  13. FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth, "Dallas salon owner gets 7 days in jail for reopening in defiance of countywide restrictions," May 5, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  14. CBS Texas (KTVT), "Salon A La Mode Owner, Shelley Luther Arrested: 'Feeding My Kids Isn't Selfish, I'm Not Closing The Salon'," May 5, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  15. Neelam Bohra, "Texas Supreme Court voids orders that jailed Dallas salon owner for disregarding COVID-19 precautions," The Texas Tribune, April 9, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  16. Associated Press, "Ted Cruz gets haircut at salon whose owner arrested for keeping salon open in COVID-19," May 8, 2020, as published by ABC13 Houston (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  17. CBS Texas (KTVT), "Shelley Luther Says She Wants To Spread GoFundMe Money, Help 2 Laredo Women Arrested For Opening Beauty Services," May 8, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  18. Office of the Texas Governor, "Governor Abbott Modifies COVID-19 Executive Orders To Eliminate Confinement As A Punishment," press release, May 7, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  19. NBC News, "Salon owner jailed for reopening during Texas lockdown released after governor intervenes," May 7, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  20. Governor Greg Abbott, Executive Order GA-21, May 5, 2020, item 12(a) (salons from 12:01 a.m., May 8, 2020) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  21. Office of the Texas Governor, "Governor Abbott Expands Business Openings In Texas, Announces Surge Response Teams To Combat COVID-19," press release, May 5, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  22. FOX 4 Dallas-Fort Worth, "Shelley Luther, former Dallas salon owner jailed during COVID-19, wins in TX House Dist. 62," November 2024 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
  23. Texas House of Representatives, "Rep. Luther, Shelley - District 62," official member page (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩

Check yourself

1. On what date did Shelley Luther reopen Salon a la Mode?

2. What did Judge Eric Moye offer at the May 5, 2020 hearing?

3. What did Executive Order GA-22 (May 7, 2020) do?

4. What did the Supreme Court of Texas order on May 7, 2020?

5. Why did the Supreme Court of Texas hold the restraining order void on April 9, 2021?

6. Which statement about the constitutional challenges in In re Luther is correct?

7. What happened in the December 19, 2020 runoff for Texas Senate District 30?

8. When did she take office as the member for Texas House District 62?

Terms in this lesson

Temporary restraining order (TRO)
A short-term court order, often entered the day a suit is filed, that forbids a party from acting until a hearing can be held. In Texas, Rule 683 requires it to state its reasons and describe the restrained acts specifically.
Contempt of court
Disobedience to or disrespect of a court. Criminal contempt punishes past disobedience; civil contempt pressures a person to comply, and the person can end it by complying (purging).
Purge
The act a person held in civil contempt can perform to end the punishment. Here the judgment required her to publicly express contrition, which the high court said was likely too vague.
Writ of habeas corpus
A court order requiring that a person held in custody be released if the custody is unlawful. Texas courts use it to review contempt jailings.
Relator
The party who brings an original proceeding, such as a habeas petition, in an appellate court. Luther was the relator in No. 20-0363.
Per curiam
An opinion issued by the court as a whole rather than signed by one judge.
Void order
An order with no legal force. A person cannot be held in contempt for disobeying a void order.
Moot
No longer a live dispute because events have made a ruling pointless. The appeal of her restraining order was dismissed as moot after salons were allowed to reopen.
Executive order (Texas)
An order of the governor issued under the Texas Disaster Act, which gives such orders the force and effect of law during a declared disaster.
Texas Government Code 418.173
The statute that made failure to comply with a disaster executive order an offense punishable by up to a $1,000 fine and 180 days in jail, as recited in GA-18 and GA-21.
Ex parte communication
A communication to a judge about a pending case made without the other parties present. The Dallas civil judges called Attorney General Paxton's letter one.
Rule 683
The Texas Rule of Civil Procedure requiring that every injunction and restraining order set forth its reasons, be specific in terms and describe the acts restrained in reasonable detail.

Full glossary Ā· Module glossary Ā· Ordered Liberty

Sources