Lesson 10 of 23 · about 40 minutes
Pastor James Coates and GraceLife Church (Alberta)
Updated November 7, 2026
You'll be able to
- Describe the Alberta worship rules of early 2021 and the steps Alberta Health Services and the RCMP took to enforce them against GraceLife.
- Explain why Coates stayed in custody for 35 days and what he pleaded guilty to on March 22, 2021.
- Summarize the June 7, 2021 Charter ruling and the July 31, 2023 Ingram decision, including what Ingram did and did not decide.
- Explain how the Public Health Act charges ended in acquittal on August 30, 2023.
- State fairly the arguments of AHS, the RCMP, the government and the judges who ruled against Coates.
- Evaluate why declining a conditional release took courage.
Start here: the short version
James Coates is the pastor-teacher of GraceLife Church of Edmonton, a congregation of roughly 400 people that meets on Highway 627 in Parkland County, just west of Edmonton, Alberta.12 In the winter of 2020 to 2021 Alberta limited worship services to 15 percent of a building's capacity and required masks and distancing. GraceLife kept holding full services every Sunday. Alberta Health Services ordered compliance, a judge ordered compliance, and AHS ordered the church closed; the church kept meeting.3 In February 2021 the RCMP charged Coates, and when he would not sign a release condition that would have kept him from leading his church's services, he was held in the Edmonton Remand Centre for 35 days, from February 16 to March 22, 2021.45 He was released after pleading guilty to breaching the undertaking and being fined $1,500, all of it credited by his time in custody.56 On April 7, 2021, Alberta Health Services, with RCMP officers present, fenced off the church building; the congregation met in secret places until the property was returned on July 1.37 A provincial court judge rejected his Charter challenge in June 2021, but after the Alberta Court of King's Bench ruled on July 31, 2023, in Ingram v. Alberta, that the province's COVID-19 health orders had been made unlawfully, the Crown stopped prosecuting, and on August 30, 2023 Coates and GraceLife Church were acquitted of the remaining Public Health Act charges.8910 His stand took courage because he could have walked out of jail any day by signing a promise, and he chose a cell over a promise his conscience would not let him keep.

Who they were before
GraceLife Church began as Grace Reformed Baptist Church of Edmonton, incorporated in November 2005, and has been known as GraceLife since 2012, according to the Edmonton Journal's April 2021 account of the church's history.2 It describes itself as non-denominational, holds to a literal reading of the Bible and borrowed some of its bylaws from John MacArthur's Grace Community Church in Los Angeles.2 Its building stands on Highway 627 in Parkland County, outside Edmonton's city limits near Spruce Grove, and by 2021 the congregation numbered about 400 people.123
James Coates began serving as a pastor at the church in 2010.2 He is a graduate of The Master's Seminary in Los Angeles, the school MacArthur founded in 1986, and holds both a Master of Divinity and a Doctor of Ministry from it.211 Grace Community Church's own speaker biography describes him as "the pastor-teacher at GraceLife Church of Edmonton in Alberta, Canada."11 Religion News Service reported in April 2021 that MacArthur, his former teacher, had cheered Coates's stand and prayed for him while he was in jail.12 The two stories in this module are linked: the lesson on John MacArthur and Grace Community Church tells how the teacher defied California's worship ban in 2020, and this lesson tells how the student defied Alberta's in 2021.
Before 2020 Coates was a local pastor with no public profile outside his congregation and the circle of churches that share its theology. He had no record of political activity. He is married to Erin Coates, who later filed a sworn affidavit in his bail case and spoke publicly about his detention.213 In court in March 2021 he described himself in a single sentence: "I'm simply here in obedience to Jesus Christ, and it's my obedience to Christ that has put me at odds with the law."614
Like most churches, GraceLife first complied. After the pandemic began in March 2020 it moved to livestreamed services for the first few months, and it resumed in-person worship over the summer of 2020.14 The conflict began in the fall and winter, when Alberta tightened its rules on worship again.
The order they faced
Alberta's COVID-19 restrictions were issued as orders of the Chief Medical Officer of Health, Dr. Deena Hinshaw, under section 29 of the Public Health Act, which gives a medical officer of health power to "take whatever other steps are, in the medical officer of health's opinion, necessary in order to lessen the impact of the public health emergency."9 The orders that applied to GraceLife in early 2021 are listed in the Court of King's Bench decision that later struck them down. CMOH Order 02-2021, Part 4, section 18, required "faith leaders" to limit attendance at worship services to "15% of the total operational occupant load"; CMOH Order 26-2020 required people to keep two meters apart, "including when attending worship services, weddings or funerals"; and CMOH Order 02-2021, Part 5, section 23 required face coverings, again "including when attending worship services, weddings or funerals."9 The province's published guidance for places of worship put the capacity rule plainly: "In-person attendance for regular worship services is limited to 15% of fire code occupancy."15
Enforcement came in steps, and AHS later published its own list of them.3
- December 13, 2020: RCMP officers and a health inspector entered the church during a service; the inspector watched from the balcony.2
- December 17, 2020: AHS issued an order directing the church to require face coverings, keep households two meters apart, report the building's capacity and stay within 15 percent of it. The order said that "In the auditorium, it appeared members of different households were not distanced at least two metres apart."1
- December 20, 2020: Parkland RCMP, acting for AHS, issued Coates a $1,200 ticket under section 73.1 of the Public Health Act.1
- January 21, 2021: AHS obtained a Court of Queen's Bench order requiring the church to comply with the December 17 order.3
- January 29, 2021: AHS issued a closure order requiring the church to close until it complied.3
- February 7, 2021: the RCMP released Coates on an undertaking with conditions, which the RCMP said included complying with the health orders.4
The rules allowed worship, but only at a fraction of the usual congregation. A church that seated several hundred could admit 15 percent of its fire-code capacity, masked and distanced. Alberta officials stressed that churches were never closed outright. The province said it had allowed GraceLife and other churches to keep gathering within the orders, and Premier Jason Kenney said no one had been fined for preaching and encouraged congregations to gather within the guidelines.14 GraceLife's position was that the orders were unjust and that the church had no authority to turn worshippers away from the Lord's Day service. Coates preached on February 14, 2021 from Romans 13:1 to 4, in a sermon titled "Directing the Government to Its Duty."14
What they did
Sunday after Sunday
From December 2020 onward GraceLife held its regular Sunday services in defiance of the orders, with hundreds of people attending each week, despite the January closure order.168 The church did not require masks or distancing and did not limit attendance to 15 percent.8 It did not hide what it was doing. The services were held in its own building, in daylight, with the doors open. The church said it had met every Sunday "without incident."14
Alberta Health Services counted 105 public complaints about the church between July 10, 2020 and April 6, 2021, and conducted 18 inspections in that period, reporting violations at each one.3 RCMP officers attended services on two consecutive Sundays in February 2021, told Coates he was breaking the health orders and asked him to stop.4
The sermon of February 14, 2021
On Sunday, February 14, 2021, RCMP and AHS officials again came to the church, this time to "assess compliance in relation to conditions issued to the pastor on Feb. 7." The RCMP reported afterward: "Observations were made that James Coates was not complying with his undertaking release conditions."4 That morning Coates preached from Romans 13:1 to 4, the passage Christians have long read as the charter of civil government, in a sermon titled "Directing the Government to Its Duty." On the question of whether what was happening to his church was persecution, he told the congregation, as the Edmonton Journal reported: "I am quite content to let the Lord Jesus Christ himself decide whether or not this is persecution. He's the one that blesses, and I'm content to leave that in his court."14
The cell instead of the promise
The Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, which represented him, says the RCMP arrested Coates on February 15, 2021, the day after the service.5 The RCMP said he turned himself in on Tuesday, February 16, and was charged with two counts of contravening the Public Health Act and one count under the Criminal Code of failing to comply with a condition of his undertaking.4
At his bail hearing before a justice of the peace, which the Justice Centre dates to February 16, Coates was offered release on conditions. One condition would have barred him from conducting services that broke the health orders, which in practice meant he could not lead his church as it had been meeting. He refused to agree to it. The Justice Centre said he would be released only if he agreed to stop holding church services in that way, or if the prosecutor withdrew the condition, and that he could not agree to it in good conscience.417 He was held in the Edmonton Remand Centre from February 16.513
That choice is the center of this story. No judge refused Coates bail. He was offered release and declined it, because the price of release was a written promise he believed he could not keep without disobeying God. A man in that position holds the key to his own cell. Every day for five weeks he could have signed and gone home to his family. He stayed.

The bail review
His lawyers took the condition to the Court of Queen's Bench. On March 5, 2021, Justice Peter Michalyshyn dismissed the bail review, leaving Coates in custody until his trial, then set for May.13 The judge wrote: "The law that Mr. Coates clearly intends not to be bound by remains valid and enforceable against him," and "Mr. Coates's strongly held religious beliefs and convictions do not overcome those valid and enforceable laws."13 His lawyer James Kitchen argued that keeping a man in jail to enforce a health order before trial was "putting the cart before the horse, doing things backwards."13 In a sworn affidavit, Erin Coates told the court that her husband had lost weight and had neck pain in custody and that the family was under great strain.13 GraceLife kept holding its weekend services while its pastor was in jail.6
Release on March 22, 2021
On March 17, 2021, the Justice Centre announced that the Crown had agreed to withdraw all but one of the Public Health Act charges, along with the criminal charge tied to the February 7 condition, and that Coates expected to be freed "without any conditions" at his next appearance in Stony Plain.17 On Monday, March 22, he appeared before Provincial Court Judge Jeffrey Champion and pleaded guilty to breaching his undertaking.618 The Crown prosecutor, Peter Mackenzie, and the defence lawyer, Leighton Grey of the Justice Centre, jointly proposed a $100 fine. Judge Champion rejected the joint proposal and imposed $1,500, and he credited the 35 days Coates had spent in custody against the full amount, so nothing more was owed and he walked out without conditions.618
In court that day Coates told the judge: "I'm simply here in obedience to Jesus Christ, and it's my obedience to Christ that has put me at odds with the law." He added: "I'm not a political revolutionary."618 One charge remained: a Public Health Act count alleging that he had held services that broke the gathering limit. It was set for trial in May.6 About two weeks earlier, GraceLife Church itself had been charged as well.6
Six days later, on Sunday, March 28, Coates was back with his congregation for the first time in six weeks. He gave the opening and closing prayers and left the sermon to associate pastor Jacob Spenst, and he told the church: "I'm excited to hug you, embrace you and express my love and affection to you in a personal way."16
The fence
Before 8 a.m. on Wednesday, April 7, 2021, RCMP officers and AHS staff arrived at GraceLife Church, and crews put up chain-link fencing around the building and blocked the parking stalls.319 AHS said it had "physically closed GraceLife Church and has prevented access to the building" until the church could "demonstrate the ability to comply with Alberta's Chief Medical Officer of Health's restrictions."319 The Justice Centre later described three layers of fences and barricades around the building and grounds and said the government held the building for more than two months.20 The closure came days after the church had packed its parking lot on Good Friday and Easter Sunday.3
The congregation did not stop meeting. The next Sunday it gathered at an undisclosed location and posted the service online.12 Outside the fenced building, about 400 people rallied against the closure on Sunday, April 11, many of them not members of GraceLife.12 Some of them pulled down part of the fence while RCMP officers stood on the other side; other protesters tried to put it back up and scolded those who had torn it down. One person was later charged with mischief and obstruction.21
On June 10, 2021, the Justice Centre announced that GraceLife had gone to court against AHS, Health Minister Tyler Shandro and Dr. Hinshaw, asking the Court of Queen's Bench to strike down the worship restrictions under sections 2 and 7 of the Charter, to return the building immediately and to bar officials from breaking up its services.20 Alberta lifted its health restrictions on July 1, 2021, and AHS told reporters that the fence would come down, the closure orders would be revoked and the property returned to the church that day.7
What it cost
Thirty-five days in custody. Coates spent five weeks in the Edmonton Remand Centre, from February 16 to March 22, 2021, without having been convicted of anything when he went in.56 His wife told the court of his weight loss and neck pain and of the strain on their family.13 He missed five Sundays in his own pulpit.16
A guilty plea and a fine. He pleaded guilty to breaching the conditions of his February 7 release. The Justice Centre had said the Criminal Code charge would be withdrawn and replaced with a lesser charge carrying a $100 penalty; The Canadian Press reported the plea as one to breaching bail, and CTV News, in a correction, described it as a plea to breaching health rules.17610 A judge who rejected the prosecutor's own suggestion of a $100 fine imposed $1,500 instead, satisfied by the time he had already served.6 The December 2020 ticket was $1,200.1
The church building. From April 7 to July 1, 2021, GraceLife could not enter its own property. The congregation worshipped at undisclosed locations while its building sat behind three layers of fence.12207
Two and a half years under prosecution. The remaining Public Health Act charges against Coates and the church were not resolved until August 30, 2023. His lawyer Hart Spencer told the court: "Pastor Coates and his congregation had these charges hanging over them for close to three years."810
Public condemnation. The judge who sentenced him spoke sharply to him from the bench (his words are in the box below). Faith leaders in Alberta, including the minister of a Calgary United Church congregation, publicly welcomed the closure of his church: "I think it was long overdue and it needed to be done," the Rev. Greg Glatz of Knox United Church told Religion News Service.12
Three unflattering facts belong in a true account, stated briefly. First, GraceLife disobeyed not only health orders but a Court of Queen's Bench order of January 21, 2021 requiring it to comply.3 Second, testifying at his trial in May 2021, Coates called masking "hilarious" and described the restrictions as "an agenda to transform the nation."2223 Third, on April 11, 2021, some of the people who came to protest the closure tore down part of the fence the government had put up; Religion News Service reported that many in the crowd were not GraceLife members, and other protesters tried to put the fence back up.1221
How it ended
The Charter ruling of June 7, 2021
Coates's trial on the remaining Public Health Act charge opened in Stony Plain provincial court in May 2021, and his lawyers argued that the ticket issued on December 20, 2020 violated his and his congregants' freedom of religion and peaceful assembly, and that it had been issued on the day of a sermon critical of the province in order to censor him and "impose a chilling effect."23 On Monday, June 7, 2021, Provincial Court Judge Robert Shaigec dismissed that part of the challenge. Asked whether enforcement had violated Coates's religious freedom, he answered: "The answer is no."2223 He found that the government was responding to many public complaints, not targeting the church, and that the ticket followed numerous attempts to get GraceLife to comply. Of the censorship claim he wrote: "These claims are unsupported by and wholly inconsistent with the facts of this case." And he said: "Individual rights and freedoms are not absolute."23 The Justice Centre reported that the judge also rejected the argument that Coates's liberty had been violated by his detention, reasoning that he could have complied with his undertaking.5 The judge ordered the trial to reconvene to consider whether Alberta's limits on worship attendance were themselves constitutional.2223
Waiting on Ingram
That second question was never decided in Coates's case. Proceedings were put over repeatedly; in November 2022 CTV News Edmonton reported that court proceedings for GraceLife Church had again been "put over until the new year."24 Prosecutions of Coates, of the Northcott family's rodeo near Bowden and of others were in practice waiting on a larger case in Calgary, brought by gym owner Rebecca Ingram, Heights Baptist Church, Northside Baptist Church and others, which asked the Court of King's Bench to rule on the validity of the health orders themselves.109
The Ingram decision of July 31, 2023
On July 31, 2023, Justice Barbara Romaine of the Court of King's Bench of Alberta decided Ingram v. Alberta (Chief Medical Officer of Health), 2023 ABKB 453.9 The holding was short: "I find that the impugned Orders were ultra vires the Public Health Act."9 The reason was who had made the decisions. "The final decisions implemented by the impugned Orders in this case were made by the cabinet," she wrote, and the Chief Medical Officer "deferred the final decision making to cabinet," a delegation of her authority that "is not permitted by section 29" of the Act.9 Justice Romaine added: "While involvement of elected officials in these important decisions may be desirable and even necessary, this involvement should have been structured in such a way as to mitigate the risk of political priorities interfering with the informed and well-qualified judgment of the CMOH."9 She declared the orders invalid.9
The decision was not a clean sweep for the challengers on the Charter. Justice Romaine wrote that, had the orders been validly made by the Chief Medical Officer, "these limitations were amply and demonstrably justified as reasonable limits in a free and democratic society" under section 1 of the Charter. She found that the orders had infringed the religious freedom (section 2(a)) of one applicant, Torry Tanner, while dismissing other Charter claims; of Rebecca Ingram she found she "was not prevented from attending church services: she was prevented from doing so in her preferred way."9 The case was won on the law of who may make a health order, which is the ground that freed Coates.
Acquittal, August 30, 2023
About three weeks after Ingram, the Alberta Crown Prosecution Service announced that it had concluded "there is no longer a reasonable likelihood of conviction" in Public Health Act prosecutions tied to the orders, and named the cases of Coates and GraceLife Church, of cafe owner Christopher Scott and of Ty Northcott among those to go before judges for stays or acquittals.25 Prosecutor Karen Thorsrud, the same prosecutor the Justice Centre had named in 2021 as asking that Coates be kept in jail, said she would "invite the court to acquit both defendants of all charges."2517
On Wednesday, August 30, 2023, in Stony Plain, the Crown closed its case without calling further evidence, and the judge acquitted both James Coates and GraceLife Church.105 Hart Spencer, who represented Coates and the church, said in a statement: "I am pleased with the result and Pastor Coates and his church should feel a degree of vindication."8 He told CTV News that Coates was "very pleased with the results," though not "fully vindicated," and that he "has every right to feel very miffed, if you will."10 John Carpay, president of the Justice Centre, said it had been "a great honour to assist and stand with courageous Albertans."5
The acquittal ended the remaining Public Health Act charges; it did not undo the guilty plea of March 22, 2021 to breaching the conditions of his release, whose fine had already been satisfied by time served.106 The province responded to Ingram by changing the law. Justice Minister Mickey Amery tabled Bill 6 to amend section 29 of the Public Health Act so that cabinet would have the final say over public health orders that apply to the general population, with medical officers of health keeping authority over orders aimed at specific persons or places.26
Coates after the case
Coates kept pastoring GraceLife. He co-wrote, with Nathan Busenitz of The Master's Seminary, the book God vs. Government: Taking a Biblical Stand When Christ and Compliance Collide, and he has preached at Grace Community Church's Shepherds Conference for pastors, including a 2022 session titled "God vs Government," a 2023 general session on "The Persecution of the Remnant" and a 2024 message titled "Leading with Courage: The Biblical Blueprint for Pastoral Boldness."11 As of his most recent listed sermon there, in March 2025, Grace Community Church still described him as the pastor-teacher of GraceLife Church of Edmonton.11

Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| November 2005 | Grace Reformed Baptist Church of Edmonton is incorporated; it takes the name GraceLife in 2012.2 |
| 2010 | James Coates begins serving as a pastor at the church.2 |
| Spring to summer 2020 | GraceLife livestreams services, then resumes in-person worship over the summer.14 |
| December 13, 2020 | RCMP and a health inspector attend a GraceLife service.2 |
| December 17, 2020 | AHS orders the church to require masks, distance households and keep to 15 percent of capacity.1 |
| December 20, 2020 | RCMP issue Coates a $1,200 ticket under the Public Health Act.1 |
| January 21, 2021 | Court of Queen's Bench order requires compliance with the AHS order.3 |
| January 29, 2021 | AHS closure order.3 |
| February 7, 2021 | RCMP release Coates on an undertaking with conditions.4 |
| February 14, 2021 | RCMP and AHS attend; Coates preaches "Directing the Government to Its Duty."414 |
| February 15 to 16, 2021 | Coates is charged (February 15, per the Justice Centre) and turns himself in (February 16, per the RCMP).54 |
| February 16, 2021 | At his bail hearing (dated February 16 by the Justice Centre) he refuses the release condition and is held in the Edmonton Remand Centre.417 |
| March 5, 2021 | Justice Peter Michalyshyn dismisses the bail review.13 |
| March 17, 2021 | Crown agrees to withdraw all but one Public Health Act charge.17 |
| March 22, 2021 | Coates pleads guilty to breaching his undertaking; Judge Jeffrey Champion fines him $1,500, credited by 35 days in custody; he is released.618 |
| March 28, 2021 | Coates returns to his congregation.16 |
| April 7, 2021 | AHS and RCMP fence off and close the church building.319 |
| April 11, 2021 | About 400 people rally outside; part of the fence is pulled down.1221 |
| May 2021 | Trial on the remaining Public Health Act charge opens in Stony Plain.23 |
| June 7, 2021 | Judge Robert Shaigec dismisses Coates's Charter application.2223 |
| June 10, 2021 | The Justice Centre announces GraceLife's court application against AHS, the health minister and the Chief Medical Officer for return of the building.20 |
| July 1, 2021 | Health restrictions lifted; fence removed and building returned.7 |
| July 31, 2023 | Ingram v. Alberta, 2023 ABKB 453: the orders were ultra vires the Public Health Act.9 |
| August 30, 2023 | Coates and GraceLife Church acquitted in Stony Plain after the Crown calls no further evidence.105 |
Why it took courage
Most acts of civil disobedience end quickly: a person refuses, is arrested, is processed and goes home. Coates's ended differently because the system offered him a way out every day, and the way out was a promise. He would have been free at once had he signed an undertaking to stop leading his church's services as it had been meeting. He refused, he stayed in remand for 35 days, and a Court of Queen's Bench justice upheld his detention in the meantime.413 There is a particular kind of courage in declining a release that is being held out to you, and it is the kind that conscience requires when the release has a price conscience cannot pay.
He did it with no promise of vindication. In February and March 2021 every court that looked at his case, from the justice of the peace at his bail hearing to the Court of Queen's Bench, ruled against him.41713 In June 2021 the provincial court rejected his Charter arguments.23 The decision that freed him did not come until more than two years later, in a different case, on a ground almost no one discussed in 2021: that the health orders had been made by the wrong people.9
The liberty he defended is one Canada's Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees in its first operative words: freedom of conscience and religion, and freedom of peaceful assembly, in section 2. His congregation's stand also defended something more basic, which Ingram confirmed: that a government restricting fundamental freedoms must do it through the legal process the legislature set out, by the official the law names, rather than by decisions made elsewhere and issued under that official's signature.9 Rule of law means the rules bind the rulers too. The orders that put a pastor in jail and a fence around his church were, a judge later held, not validly made.
Coates said repeatedly that he was not a political revolutionary and that he did not seek to make a point.614 He went to every hearing, pleaded openly, accepted the penalty a judge imposed and kept preaching. That is the shape of lawful, conscientious refusal that the ordered liberty module describes: open, peaceful, accountable and willing to bear the cost. A pastor who sat in a cell for five weeks rather than sign away his congregation's worship, and who came out still gentle enough to tell his church he was "excited to hug you," gave his people and his country an example of steady courage.16
What the other side said
Alberta Health Services said that GraceLife "has decided not to follow these mandatory restrictions," that it had tried education, orders and a court order first, and that it closed the building only after 18 inspections and 105 complaints.3 Health Minister Tyler Shandro said AHS and the police had dealt with the church at arm's length, that they "did try with education, they did try it through court orders," and that there had been "a lot of recalcitrance over an extended period of time."3 RCMP Inspector Mike Lokken said: "To be very clear, the RCMP's objective is not to interrupt church services, prohibit services," but "merely to ensure that public health restrictions are adhered to while doing so."4 Premier Jason Kenney said no one had been fined for preaching and urged congregations to meet within the rules; in April 2021 Religion News Service quoted him telling Albertans: "if you believe in the sanctity of human life, please act accordingly."1412 At sentencing, Judge Jeffrey Champion told Coates: "It is an issue when someone makes a decision that can affect the health and the lives of thousands of people," "You don't get to make that decision for everyone else," and "The shepherd ought to protect his flock."618 Justice Michalyshyn held that "Mr. Coates's strongly held religious beliefs and convictions do not overcome those valid and enforceable laws."13 Judge Shaigec found the government was answering public complaints, not targeting the church.23 And even in the decision that struck the orders down, Justice Romaine wrote that, if validly made, the limits "were amply and demonstrably justified as reasonable limits in a free and democratic society."9
Still disputed: Whether Alberta's worship limits would have survived the Charter had they been validly made: Justice Romaine said yes in Ingram, but because the orders were invalid on other grounds that question was never decided in Coates's own case.9 Whether the bail condition that kept Coates in jail was a proper use of the bail power: Justice Michalyshyn upheld it and Judge Shaigec found no violation of his liberty, while the Justice Centre has argued the condition "should never have been imposed on him by the RCMP, or by the Court."13517 Whether the April 2021 seizure of the church building was lawful was never ruled on, because the building was returned on July 1, 2021 before the church's application was decided.720
Medical note: In a statement reported in June 2021, GraceLife said it had acted "recognizing COVID-19 was much less severe than the government had initially projected," and Coates, testifying in May 2021, called masking "hilarious."722 Those were the church's and the pastor's views. Alberta's Chief Medical Officer of Health, Dr. Deena Hinshaw, said in March 2021 that no outbreak had yet been directly linked to GraceLife, but warned that "It just takes one infectious person for that spread to happen," and she had said in December 2020 that "the measures in place right now are the best way to care for our neighbours and for our communities."161 This lesson honors the stand for worship and takes no position on these medical claims.
Hard questions and answers
Why didn't he just sign the undertaking and fight the charges from home?
Because, in his words, his obedience to Christ "put me at odds with the law," and signing would have meant promising to stop leading his church's services as it had been meeting.64 Many people sign conditions they intend to break; Coates declined to make a promise he did not intend to keep. That is the honest course for a man of conscience, and it is why he went to jail. His lawyers also argued that holding a man in custody before trial to enforce a health order reversed the normal order of things.13
Didn't he plead guilty? How is that a victory?
He pleaded guilty to breaching his undertaking, the promise he had made on February 7, and he accepted the penalty.6 Owning the breach is consistent with his stand: he never pretended he had complied. The Justice Centre reported before the plea that the Crown had agreed to replace the criminal charge with a lesser one carrying a $100 penalty, and the Crown and defence jointly proposed $100; the judge chose $1,500 and credited it entirely to time served.176 The charges about the services themselves, under the Public Health Act, ended in acquittal for both Coates and the church in 2023.10
Wasn't Ingram just a technicality?
Ingram held that the officials who actually made the decisions were not the official the statute authorized to make them.9 In a free country, who may restrict your freedom, and by what process, is the substance of liberty under law. A legislature that gives emergency power to a named medical officer has decided where that power lives; when others exercise it, the restriction lacks legal authority no matter how wise it may be. Alberta itself treated the point as serious enough to change the statute with Bill 6.26 Justice Romaine also found, it is true, that the limits would have been justified under the Charter if validly made, and a full account of the case says so.9
Other churches complied. Why should GraceLife get a different rule?
GraceLife was held to the same rule as every other church, refused it, and paid more for refusing. The question is whether the refusal was right. Other churches kept gathering within the orders, as the province pointed out,14 and Religion News Service reported a Calgary United Church minister welcoming the closure.12 GraceLife believed the rule itself exceeded the government's authority over worship, and it bore the consequences openly. Ingram later held that the rule had in fact been made without legal authority.9
What should a civil liberties advocate take from the case?
Two things. First, bail conditions can become a tool for enforcing the very conduct a person is charged with before any trial, which is why the Justice Centre argued the condition should never have been imposed.17 Second, a government that fences a congregation out of its own building is using the state's most visible power against worship, and the legal basis for doing so should be clear and tested in court; in GraceLife's case it never was, because the building was returned first.720
What would a public health officer say?
That GraceLife received education, written orders, a court order and a closure order before any fence went up, that AHS logged 105 complaints, and that a 15 percent limit still allowed worship.3 Dr. Hinshaw's warning that "It just takes one infectious person" states the concern.16 The lesson for health officials is the one Justice Romaine drew: decisions restricting fundamental freedoms must be made by the official the law names, with political involvement structured so it cannot override that official's judgment.9 The module's lesson on what the stands won sets out what local officials can do differently.
Related lessons
- John MacArthur and Grace Community Church (Sun Valley, California), the teacher's stand in 2020
- Pastor Tony Spell and Life Tabernacle (Central, Louisiana)
- Pastor Mike McClure and Calvary Chapel San Jose (California)
- The Worship Cases at the Supreme Court, the American rule for comparison
- Tamara Lich, Chris Barber and the Freedom Convoy (Canada), the other Canadian profile
- What the Stands Won
- Ordered Liberty: Legitimate Authority and Its Limits and Forms of Lawful Resistance
- The First Amendment, the American counterpart to section 2 of the Charter
Still open
These items could not be confirmed against a primary source before publication. The lesson states them as open, and they stay on the fact-check list.
- No published written decision was found for Judge Shaigec's June 7, 2021 ruling, Justice Michalyshyn's March 5, 2021 bail review or Judge Champion's March 22, 2021 sentence; those are quoted from news reports.
- Arrest date: the Justice Centre says Coates was arrested February 15, 2021 and held from February 16; the RCMP said he turned himself in on February 16. Both are stated.
- Bail hearing date: the Justice Centre dates it February 16, 2021; a Global News report posted February 17 describes it without a clear date.
- The exact offence to which Coates pleaded guilty on March 22, 2021: The Canadian Press reported breach of bail; CTV News, in a correction, said breaching health rules; the Justice Centre said on March 17 that the Criminal Code charge would be replaced by a lesser charge with a $100 penalty. The court record was not found.
- The name of the judge who acquitted Coates and GraceLife on August 30, 2023 was not found in the sources.
- Whether Alberta appealed Ingram (2023 ABKB 453) was not confirmed; none of the sources cited mentions an appeal.
- The date Bill 6 (amending section 29 of the Public Health Act) was tabled in 2023, and whether and when it passed, were not confirmed.
- The outcome of GraceLife's June 2021 application against AHS, the minister and the CMOH was not found; the building was returned July 1, 2021.
- The fence removal on July 1, 2021 is confirmed only through Christianity Daily, citing CityNews and an AHS statement.
- It is not confirmed that the building in the Edmonton Remand Centre photograph is the facility where Coates was held in 2021.
- Coates's place of birth and life before 2010 were not found in the sources.
Learn more
- Ingram v Alberta (Chief Medical Officer of Health), 2023 ABKB 453: The full decision that held the orders ultra vires; read paras. 1 to 7 and 56 to 57 for the holding.
- Global News, Mar. 5, 2021 (bail review): The court's reasons for keeping Coates in custody, in its own words.
- CTV News Edmonton, Aug. 30, 2023 (acquittal): How the case ended in Stony Plain.
- Grace Community Church speaker page, James Coates: His later preaching on church and government, including God vs Government (2022).
Notes
- Phil Heidenreich, report on the Alberta Health Services order of Dec. 17, 2020 to Grace Life Church of Edmonton and the $1,200 ticket of Dec. 20, 2020, Global News, Dec. 21, 2020 (updated May 4, 2021) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Edmonton Journal, "Church and State," Apr. 17, 2021, p. 1 feature on GraceLife Church and James Coates (PressReader edition) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Caley Gibson, with files from Morgan Black and The Canadian Press, report on the closure of GraceLife Church by Alberta Health Services, Global News, Apr. 7, 2021 (updated Nov. 3, 2022), quoting the AHS statement and its list of enforcement steps (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Emily Mertz, "Alberta pastor who defied COVID-19 rules refuses bail conditions, remains in custody," Global News, Feb. 17, 2021 (updated Feb. 19, 2021), quoting RCMP statements (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, "Pastor James Coates and GraceLife Church acquitted following Ingram decision," news release, Stony Plain, Aug. 30, 2023 (the organization represented Coates) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- The Canadian Press, report on Coates's plea and sentence before Provincial Court Judge Jeffrey Champion, published by National Observer, Mar. 23, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Sarah Mae Saliong, "GraceLife Church to regain possession of property, fences to be removed July 1," Christianity Daily, June 23, 2021 (citing CityNews, June 22, 2021, and an AHS statement) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- The Canadian Press, "After dramatic protests, public health charges against GraceLife pastor James Coates dismissed," Global News, Aug. 31, 2023 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Ingram v Alberta (Chief Medical Officer of Health), 2023 ABKB 453 (Court of King's Bench of Alberta, Romaine J., July 31, 2023), paras. 1 to 7, 17, 56, 57, 124, 164; filed copy published by the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms (also reported on CanLII as 2023 ABKB 453) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- CTV News Edmonton, "Edmonton-area pastor, church acquitted in Alberta COVID-19 rules case," Aug. 30, 2023 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Grace Community Church (Los Angeles), speaker page for Dr. James Coates, with biography and list of messages (Shepherds Conference 2022, 2023, 2024; Sojourners, Mar. 9, 2025) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Religion News Service, "Protesters rally to cause of jailed Canadian church as pastor awaits trial," Apr. 15, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Fakiha Baig, The Canadian Press, report on the dismissal of Coates's bail review by Justice Peter Michalyshyn of the Court of Queen's Bench, Global News, Mar. 5, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Christianity Today, report on the arrest and release of Pastor James Coates, posted Feb. 19, 2021 and updated Mar. 23, 2021 (quoting the Edmonton Journal on the Feb. 14, 2021 sermon) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Government of Alberta, "COVID-19 relaunch guidance: places of worship" (March 2021 edition, marked out of date), p. 1 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- CBC News Edmonton, "Return to the pulpit for Alberta pastor charged with breaking COVID-19 health measures," Mar. 28, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, "Pastor James Coates to be released from jail as Crown withdraws charges," news release, Mar. 17, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Fakiha Baig, The Canadian Press, report on Coates's release, Global News, Mar. 22, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- CTV News Edmonton, "Fence goes up around Alta. church refusing to follow COVID-19 orders," Apr. 7, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, "GraceLife takes Alberta Health Services to court, seeking return of Church," news release, June 10, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Slav Kornik, "1 person arrested and charged outside GraceLife Church," Global News, Apr. 18, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- CBC News Edmonton, "GraceLife Church pastor's religious freedoms not violated, Alberta judge rules," June 7, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Fakiha Baig, The Canadian Press, report on Judge Robert Shaigec's dismissal of Coates's Charter application, Global News, June 7, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- CTV News Edmonton, "COVID-19 case delayed for GraceLife pastor James Coates," Nov. 2, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- CBC News, "Albertans on trial for breaching Public Health Act during pandemic to see charges dropped: Crown," August 2023, quoting the Alberta Crown Prosecution Service (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- CBC News, "Alberta government tables bill to clarify decision-making during public health emergencies" (Bill 6, amending section 29 of the Public Health Act), 2023 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ↩
Check yourself
1. What capacity limit did Alberta's CMOH Order 02-2021 place on worship services?
Part 4, section 18 of CMOH Order 02-2021 required faith leaders to limit attendance to 15% of the total operational occupant load.
2. Why did James Coates stay in custody for 35 days?
He was offered release on conditions and declined, saying he could not agree in good conscience.
3. Who dismissed Coates's bail review on March 5, 2021?
Justice Michalyshyn held that the law remained valid and enforceable against Coates despite his religious convictions.
4. What happened on March 22, 2021?
Judge Jeffrey Champion rejected a joint $100 proposal, imposed $1,500, credited the 35 days in custody and released him.
5. What did Alberta Health Services do on April 7, 2021?
AHS, with RCMP present, put up fencing and said it had physically closed the church until it could show it would comply.
6. What did Ingram v. Alberta (2023 ABKB 453) hold?
Justice Romaine found the CMOH had deferred the final decision to cabinet, which section 29 does not permit.
7. How did the Public Health Act charges against Coates and GraceLife end?
After the Crown concluded there was no reasonable likelihood of conviction, the judge acquitted both defendants in Stony Plain.
8. When was the GraceLife building returned to the church?
AHS said the fence would come down and the property be returned when the CMOH restrictions were rescinded on July 1, 2021.
Terms in this lesson
- Chief Medical Officer of Health (CMOH)
- Alberta's senior public health official; in 2020 to 2021, Dr. Deena Hinshaw, in whose name the COVID-19 orders were issued.
- CMOH Order 02-2021
- The early-2021 Alberta order that, among other things, limited worship attendance to 15 percent of the total operational occupant load and required face coverings.
- Public Health Act (Alberta)
- The provincial statute, RSA 2000, c. P-37, under which medical officers of health issue orders; section 29 sets out their emergency powers.
- Ultra vires
- Latin for "beyond the powers": an act done without the legal authority the law requires. Ingram held the CMOH orders ultra vires the Public Health Act.
- Undertaking
- In Canadian criminal procedure, a written promise to comply with conditions in exchange for release; Coates was charged with breaching one and refused to sign another.
- Bail review
- An application to a superior court judge to review a lower court's release or detention decision; Justice Michalyshyn dismissed Coates's on March 5, 2021.
- Edmonton Remand Centre
- The provincial jail in Edmonton where people awaiting trial are held; Coates was held there from February 16 to March 22, 2021.
- Charter of Rights and Freedoms, section 2
- The part of Canada's constitution protecting freedom of conscience and religion, expression, peaceful assembly and association.
- Section 1 (Charter)
- The clause allowing reasonable limits on Charter rights that are prescribed by law and demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society.
- Closure order
- An order by a public health authority requiring premises to close; AHS issued one to GraceLife on January 29, 2021.
- Crown prosecutor
- The government lawyer who prosecutes offences in Canada; the Alberta Crown Prosecution Service ended the COVID-19 health prosecutions after Ingram.
- Acquittal
- A finding of not guilty that ends a charge; Coates and GraceLife were acquitted on August 30, 2023.
Sources
- Ingram v Alberta (Chief Medical Officer of Health), 2023 ABKB 453 (2023-07-31) checked 2026-11-07
- Alberta, COVID-19 relaunch guidance: places of worship (March 2021) (2021-03) checked 2026-11-07
- Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, Mar. 17, 2021 release (2021-03-17) checked 2026-11-07
- Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, June 10, 2021 release (2021-06-10) checked 2026-11-07
- Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms, Aug. 30, 2023 release (2023-08-30) checked 2026-11-07
- Grace Community Church speaker page, James Coates (2025) checked 2026-11-07
- Global News, Dec. 21, 2020 (2020-12-21) checked 2026-11-07
- Global News, Feb. 17, 2021 (2021-02-17) checked 2026-11-07
- Global News, Mar. 5, 2021 (2021-03-05) checked 2026-11-07
- Global News, Mar. 22, 2021 (2021-03-22) checked 2026-11-07
- National Observer / Canadian Press, Mar. 23, 2021 (2021-03-23) checked 2026-11-07
- Christianity Today, Feb. 19 / Mar. 23, 2021 (2021-03-23) checked 2026-11-07
- CBC News, Mar. 28, 2021 (2021-03-28) checked 2026-11-07
- Global News, Apr. 7, 2021 (2021-04-07) checked 2026-11-07
- CTV News Edmonton, Apr. 7, 2021 (2021-04-07) checked 2026-11-07
- Religion News Service, Apr. 15, 2021 (2021-04-15) checked 2026-11-07
- Edmonton Journal, Apr. 17, 2021 (2021-04-17) checked 2026-11-07
- Global News, Apr. 18, 2021 (2021-04-18) checked 2026-11-07
- CBC News, June 7, 2021 (2021-06-07) checked 2026-11-07
- Global News, June 7, 2021 (2021-06-07) checked 2026-11-07
- Christianity Daily, June 23, 2021 (2021-06-23) checked 2026-11-07
- CTV News Edmonton, Nov. 2, 2022 (2022-11-02) checked 2026-11-07
- CBC News, Crown statement, August 2023 (2023-08) checked 2026-11-07
- CTV News Edmonton, Aug. 30, 2023 (2023-08-30) checked 2026-11-07
- Global News / Canadian Press, Aug. 31, 2023 (2023-08-31) checked 2026-11-07
- CBC News, Bill 6, 2023 (2023) checked 2026-11-07