Lesson 13 of 23 Ā· about 40 minutes
Ian Smith, Frank Trumbetti and Atilis Gym (Bellmawr, New Jersey)
Updated November 7, 2026
You'll be able to
- You'll be able to explain what Executive Orders 103, 104, 107, 157 and 181 required of New Jersey gyms in 2020, and who signed them.
- You'll be able to trace the four legal tracks of the Atilis Gym case (civil sanctions, criminal contempt, municipal summonses and the license) and state how each ended.
- You'll be able to quote the Appellate Division's key holdings of March 15, 2023 and July 24, 2024, including why the gym's challenges to the orders were not properly before the court.
- You'll be able to separate the State's collection figures from Frank Trumbetti's own figure for what the fight cost.
- You'll be able to state what liberty the owners defended and why their open, named defiance took courage, while stating the unflattering facts accurately.
Start here: the short version
Ian Smith and Frank Trumbetti owned Atilis Gym, a small gym in Bellmawr, a borough in Camden County, New Jersey. Gov. Phil Murphy's executive orders had closed every gym in the state in March 2020. On the morning of May 18, 2020, after two months of closure, the two men opened the doors to their members in front of a crowd of supporters and the press, and they said they would not close again.1 For the rest of that summer they kept the gym open through a state closure order, a string of court orders, a contempt finding, an arrest, plywood barricades, the loss of their municipal business license and fines that a judge set at $15,497.76 for each day they stayed open.23
The outcome was mixed, and this lesson says so plainly. The state won in court: the Appellate Division upheld $123,982.08 in civil sanctions in March 2023 and upheld the revocation of the gym's license in July 2024, and both owners pleaded guilty in October 2021 to one count of fourth-degree contempt and received probation.23 The owners won something too: in the spring of 2024 a municipal judge dismissed the dozens of borough summonses that had followed them for nearly four years, and the gym itself never closed for good.45 Two small business owners stood in their own doorway against the full weight of a state government, in public, under their own names, and paid for it. That is why the stand took courage.

Who they were before
Atilis Gym was a neighborhood gym in Bellmawr. Inside the building were a vitamin and nutrition store and a clothing and apparel store, which a court order would later allow to keep operating while the gym floor was closed.2 A separate business, Fight Fit Fight Strong, ran kickboxing classes there, and its owner stood with the gym's owners on the day they reopened.1 The gym's legal name in later filings was Triple Threat Gym, LLC, doing business as Atilis Gym Bellmawr, and the court records describe Smith and Trumbetti as its two owners.3
Ian Smith was 33 years old in July 2020 and lived in Delanco Township, in neighboring Burlington County.6 In a candidate questionnaire he filled out in 2022 he listed Arizona State University as his education and co-owner of Atilis Gym as his occupation, and he wrote that he had "built that business from the ground up."7 Before the pandemic made him a public figure, Smith had already made several appearances on national cable news to argue that small businesses were being treated worse than large corporations under the closure orders.1
Smith's earlier life included a grave wrong that he has spoken about in public. On April 28, 2007, at age 20, he ran a stop sign in Galloway and caused a crash that killed Kevin Ade, a 19-year-old Galloway man. Smith pleaded guilty to second-degree vehicular homicide and in 2008 was sentenced to five years and six months in prison.8 He has described waking up "after a night of drinking in my college apartment," and in a social media post quoted by New Jersey 101.5 he wrote that there was "justifiably a great deal of hated and resentment towards me."98 This lesson states that history because it is part of the public record of the man, and because a hero story has to be true to stand.
Frank Trumbetti was 51 years old in July 2020 and lived in Williamstown, in Gloucester County.6 He was the older partner and, as the case went on, signed several of the sworn certifications filed for the gym in court.2 In the summer of 2020 he told NBC News that his mother had died of COVID-19 that May, a loss he made public himself while still insisting that the gym should be allowed to open with precautions.10 The two men later had a falling out, and in 2022 Smith sold his share of the gym to Trumbetti, who became its sole owner.11
Neither man held public office or had a background in law. They were small business owners whose income depended on members walking through the door, in a state where a single executive order had made it a crime for those members to do so.
The order they faced
On March 9, 2020, Gov. Murphy signed Executive Order 103, declaring both a public health emergency under New Jersey's Emergency Health Powers Act and a state of emergency under the Disaster Control Act.2 A week later, Executive Order 104 of March 16, 2020 ordered "[g]yms and fitness centers and classes" closed to the public.12 Then came the order that would govern Atilis Gym for the next five months. Executive Order 107, signed by Murphy on March 21, 2020 and effective at 9:00 p.m. that Saturday, sorted businesses into essential and non-essential and closed the second group. Its paragraph 9 read, word for word:
"All recreational and entertainment businesses, including but not limited to the following list, must close to the public as long as this Order remains in effect. The State Director of Emergency Management, who is the Superintendent of State Police, shall have the discretion to make additions, amendments, clarifications, exceptions, and exclusions to this list: ... c. Gyms and fitness centers and classes."13
Paragraph 25 named the teeth: "Penalties for violations of this Executive Order may be imposed under, among other statutes, N.J.S.A. App. A:9-49 and -50," the penalty sections of the Disaster Control Act.13 The order was signed "/s/ Philip D. Murphy, Governor," attested by his chief counsel, Matthew J. Platkin, and was to "remain in effect until revoked or modified by the Governor."13 No legislative vote, hearing or end date stood behind it. The Appellate Division would later say that the Emergency Health Powers Act "grants the Commissioner broad authority" once the governor declares a public health emergency.2
Over the summer the rules changed several times. Executive Order 157 of June 26, 2020 let gyms open their indoor space only "to offer individualized indoor instruction by appointment only where an instructor is offering training to an individual, and the individual's immediate family members, household members, caretakers, or romantic partners," with masks for everyone indoors.14 Executive Order 181 of August 27, 2020 finally allowed gyms and fitness centers to "open their indoor premises as of 6:00 a.m. on Tuesday, September 1, 2020," under a list of conditions that began, "Limit occupancy of any indoor premises to 25 percent of the stated maximum capacity."15 By then, Atilis Gym had been open in defiance of the orders for more than three months.
The executive orders were the first layer. The second was a set of orders aimed at Atilis Gym by name. On May 20, 2020, Health Commissioner Judith Persichilli issued an "Emergency Closure Order" directing the gym to "remain closed until further notice" with "[n]o members of the public" allowed inside. It warned that failure to comply could bring "criminal sanctions and/or civil penalties."2 The Commissioner followed with a "Modified Order" on July 1, 2020 that conformed to Executive Order 157, and a third order on August 28, 2020 that applied the conditions of Executive Order 181.2 Each order said it could be appealed directly to the Appellate Division, a detail that would decide the case three years later.2
For the broader story of how governors used emergency statutes in 2020, see Emergency Power in 2020. For the older question of when a citizen may lawfully refuse an order, see Legitimate Authority and Its Limits and Forms of Lawful Resistance in Ordered Liberty.

What they did
The morning of May 18, 2020
Supporters began arriving in the parking lot at 5 a.m. on Monday, May 18, 2020. When the doors opened shortly after 8 a.m., the owners admitted members only, capped at 44 people, about 20 percent of capacity. Members had their temperatures taken and filled out a health questionnaire and a waiver; masks were required except during sets; each member got a spray bottle to clean equipment; no new members were signed up that day.1 Bellmawr police watched the lot all morning. Around 11 a.m., a police captain told the owners they were violating the executive order and left. Less than two hours later another officer served Smith and Trumbetti with summonses for a disorderly persons offense, returnable in municipal court.1
The two men were honest about what they felt. "Frank and I have been scared this entire time," Smith told The Philadelphia Inquirer. "I'm still scared. We don't know if we're out of the woods yet." Trumbetti said: "We firmly believe that everything we are doing is constitutional. It's our right, and we have not broken any laws." And then the line that defined the summer: "I didn't open up today to close tomorrow."1
Gov. Murphy answered from his daily briefing the same day: "If you show up at that gym again tomorrow, there's going to be a different reality than showing today." He added, "These aren't just words. We've got to enforce this. But I also don't want to start World War III."1 State Attorney General Gurbir S. Grewal commended the police and condemned violations of the governor's orders.1
Closure orders and court orders
Police issued more summonses on May 19. On May 20 the Commissioner's Emergency Closure Order arrived. The gym did not appeal it and stayed open. On May 22 the Commissioner went to the Chancery Division in Mercer County with a verified complaint, and Judge Robert T. Lougy entered temporary restraints the same day.216 At that first hearing the gym's side argued it had been given no due process before being ordered closed, that it was not unsanitary or unsafe, and that the line between "essential" and "non-essential" businesses denied equal protection.2
The gym filed no written opposition to the complaint, and on June 8, 2020 the court ordered it to comply with the closure order and authorized the State to secure the premises. A consent order on June 15 let the owners run only the vitamin and apparel shops inside the building. The Appellate Division denied the gym's request for an emergency appeal of the May 20 order.2 The owners also filed a federal suit against the governor and Commissioner; according to the gym's own certification, the federal court sent the case back to state court on June 19, 2020.2
On July 15, county health inspectors and Bellmawr police counted about forty people using equipment at once. Trumbetti told them 348 people had "come through" that day and that he was "not closing" the gym.2 On July 20, Judge Lougy ruled that the Commissioner's July 1 order had replaced the May closure order, which meant the earlier contempt motion could not go forward; he ordered Atilis to obey the July 1 order and said the court would "not accept" the gym "ma[king] a mockery of" it.2 The next day, Trumbetti told reporters the gym was "not going to comply with their non-laws," and Smith went on national television to say the two men had taken the gym's doors off their hinges and meant to stay open.2 The Commissioner told the court that the owners had posted signs calling the building "an anti-Murphy autonomous zone."2
On July 22, health officials and police tried to inspect the gym and were refused entry. Asked about the more than 100 people seen going in, the owners told investigators that everyone inside was a "romantic partner," a reference to the wording of Executive Order 157.2 On July 24, Judge Lougy found the gym had violated his July 20 order and held it in contempt, with monetary sanctions "to be determined."2
The arrest and the barricades
After the contempt finding, the owners and supporters stayed inside the building from July 24 through the morning of Monday, July 27, 2020. That morning officers took Smith and Trumbetti into custody. As reported that day, each faced one count of fourth-degree contempt, one count of obstruction and one count of violating the Disaster Control Act. They were taken to the Bellmawr Police Department, charged and released.617 NBC News later reported they were held about three hours.10 A Facebook post quoted by CBS Philadelphia said that "the law enforcement officers were polite & respectful."6
The State then put plywood over the entrance. On July 30, Smith spoke at a protest at the State House in Trenton and said he would take the barriers down; he posted that the owners would be "reopening Atilis" on August 1 to "push[] back against these oppressive lockdown measures." On August 1 they did exactly that, removing the barriers and reopening. Camden County detectives reported people entering without masks.2 The State's later filings said Trumbetti and Smith "personally kicked down" the barricade, and the trial judge found the gym had operated "in a willful and contumacious manner," including "[k]icking down the barrier" the court had authorized.2
The license and the campaign office
Bellmawr's government joined the fight in late July. The borough issued the gym's mercantile license on July 28, 2020, backdated to June 1, and on the same day gave notice of a special meeting to consider revoking it. A letter of July 29 cited the borough ordinance allowing revocation, after notice and a hearing, for failure to follow laws protecting people using a business. After one postponement the hearing was held on August 11, 2020; four unsworn witnesses spoke, and the council voted five to one to revoke the license.3 The council did not adopt a resolution putting that vote in writing until May 27, 2021, nine months later, and in the meantime the borough wrote more summonses for operating without a license.3
On August 21, 2020, the owners announced that the gym had become an official location of the U.S. Senate campaign of Rik Mehta, that it had stopped charging membership fees and that everyone who entered was a campaign volunteer, which in their view put the building outside the gym rules and under the First Amendment's protection of political assembly.2 The trial court did not accept it. The judge found that the gym's own posts and its own expert report "substantially undercut[] the suggestion that indoor fitness activities" were not taking place, and that the gym's "own statement" confirmed that "they are a gym."2
Through all of it the gym raised money from the public. By August 4, 2020, its GoFundMe page had collected over $152,000; later in 2020 the State told the court the total had passed $263,000; and by 2023 the page showed $530,390.211 On the campaign page the owners had written that one use of the donations was to "support the [gym's] efforts to reopen and stay open," words the courts would later use against them.2
What it cost
The price came in several currencies at once: money, freedom, criminal records, a license and years of litigation.
The sanctions
On August 18, 2020, Judge Lougy granted the Commissioner's motion to enforce, awarded the State its attorney's fees and imposed a sanction of $15,497.76 for every day of non-compliance, a figure the State had asked for in writing. The court said the sanction was for the "express and sole purpose" of compelling compliance and was not punitive, and it found the amount within the gym's means because of its fundraising.2 Law360 reported that the order came to about $134,000 at once, made up of $123,981 in sanctions and $10,481 in counsel fees, plus the cost of building a new barrier.16 The State's motion had said plainly what the daily figure was for: the sanction was calculated to deplete the gym's donations, its "war chest" in the court's words, in about ten days.210 The gym answered that it had grossed only $8,352 in July 2020, so a sanction of more than $15,000 a day was punishment beyond its ability to pay.2
On May 11, 2021, the court entered a second judgment, this time against the gym, Trumbetti and Smith "jointly and severally," for $123,982.08, eight days of the daily sanction for violating its October 8, 2020 order. The judge pierced the corporate veil, finding that the two owners' "culpability and responsibility" for the gym's "ongoing and willful non-compliance is indisputable and uncontroverted."2 That made the debt personal.
How much was actually taken? In March 2023 an Attorney General's Office spokesperson told The Philadelphia Inquirer that the State had collected $174,457.92: $134,463.08 that satisfied the first judgment and $39,994.84 toward the second, leaving $83,987.24 of the second judgment uncollected. Trumbetti told the same reporter the State had seized $173,000 plus another $39,000.11 In May 2024 the Attorney General's office gave New Jersey 101.5 the same figures: about $174,457 paid and $83,987 still owed.5 Trumbetti's own total for what the gym paid in fines and court fees, as he told NBC10 Philadelphia in May 2024, was about $269,000. That figure is his; it has not been matched to a court record, and it is larger than the State's collection figure because, by his account, it includes fees as well as sanctions.4 In 2021 Smith said the State had seized "all of the gym's assets," a claim of about $165,000 that an Attorney General's spokesman called inaccurate.5
The criminal case and probation
On July 27, 2020, the borough issued criminal complaint-summonses against the owners for disorderly persons obstruction, fourth-degree contempt of a judicial order and impeding a function under the Disaster Control Act.3 Those complaints led to an indictment charging four counts of fourth-degree contempt of a judicial order, for "kicking in plywood barricades put in place by law enforcement, opening the gym, removing a door to prevent DOH from placing a lock on it, and failing to adhere to an advisement of county health officials."3 In the Appellate Division's words: "On October 4, 2021, plaintiffs pled guilty to one count of the indictment."3 In late January 2022 each man was sentenced to one year of probation; the offense carried a maximum of 18 months in prison and a $10,000 fine. Trumbetti called the sentence an "absolute joke."18199 The two owners did not avoid a criminal conviction; they accepted one for breaking a court order, which is what they had done openly and on camera.
The license, the years and the reputation
Losing the mercantile license meant the gym could not lawfully charge members, though it stayed open.9 It also meant that, from August 2020 to February 2021, the borough wrote dozens of complaints for operating without a license, each of which had to be answered in court.20 The cases ran for years. Trumbetti counted it out for NBC10 in May 2024: "1,528 days ago, they actually shut us down, asked for 14 days to flatten the curve."4
Public life brought its own costs. Smith ran for Congress in New Jersey's Third District in 2022 and lost the Republican primary to Bob Healey.21 In March 2022, during that campaign, Cinnaminson police arrested him on a drunk-driving charge. A judge cleared him of driving while intoxicated in October 2022, but he pleaded guilty to refusing a breath test and to careless driving and was required to use an ignition interlock device for nine months.22 Those facts belong to Smith's later life, not to the 2020 stand, and are stated here briefly because they are part of the public record.
Trumbetti carried something else into the fight. In August 2020, with his mother dead of the disease three months earlier, he told NBC News, "We're not going to back down," and that "this is not about opening up a gym." "This is about our constitutional rights, and he has violated them," he said. He also said, "They made the mistake of thinking we're two dumb gym owners."10
How it ended
The Atilis Gym fight ran on four tracks at once, and they ended differently. Reading them together is the only honest way to say who won.
The fines upheld: March 15, 2023
The gym appealed the sanctions. On March 15, 2023, a three-judge panel of the Appellate Division (Judges Sumners, Geiger and Berdote Byrne) affirmed everything in an unpublished per curiam opinion, Persichilli v. Atilis Gym of Bellmawr, No. A-3186-20.2 The gym had raised six points: that the court should have paused the civil case until the criminal charges were resolved, to protect the owners' Fifth Amendment right not to incriminate themselves; that the fines were punitive; that the campaign office was protected by the First Amendment; and three attacks on the orders and statutes themselves, including that the Disaster Control Act and the Emergency Health Powers Act gave the governor too much legislative power.2
The panel's summary of its holding, word for word: "We conclude that Atilis' collateral attacks on the DOH orders are not properly brought in this appeal, and, finding no substantive merit in Atilis' arguments, affirm each of the orders that it challenges, including the monetary sanctions imposed and attorney's fees awarded."2
The decisive point was procedure. Every Health Department order had said it could be appealed directly to the Appellate Division. The gym had not appealed the May 20 closure order, and this appeal was filed on July 9, 2021, well past the 45-day limit for challenging the 2020 orders. The panel held that "while an individual or entity subject to an agency order may seek review of that order in the Appellate Division, absent a stay or reversal of the order by this court, parties are 'not free to ignore' the order, which may be enforced in a proceeding brought by the agency before a trial court."2 On the Fifth Amendment, the panel found no abuse of discretion, quoting the New Jersey Supreme Court's rule that "when relief is sought to prevent continued injury to the public . . . the civil proceedings should not be stayed except in the most unusual circumstances."2 On the campaign office, it noted that "none of Atilis' social media accounts mentioned the Mehta campaign" while the gym posted videos of people using workout equipment.2
On the size of the fines, the panel approved counting the GoFundMe donations: "Had it considered only the membership fees, Atilis would have been left with a large stockpile of money to fund future non-compliance." It added: "Had Atilis wished to retain a portion of the donations and use them for lawful purposes such as paying its bills, it had only to come into compliance."2
Although it said the challenges to the orders were not properly before it, the panel addressed them "[f]or the sake of completeness" and rejected them, relying on Worthington v. Fauver (1982), which upheld the Disaster Control Act's delegation of emergency power, and on two 2021 and 2022 Appellate Division rulings about other COVID-19 executive orders. Its conclusion: "Applying these principles, we hold the EOs restricting the operation of gyms during the pandemic are constitutional."2 The opinion is marked not for publication; under New Jersey's court rules it binds only the parties and does not "constitute precedent."2
The reactions were blunt. A Department of Health spokesperson said the opinion "speaks for itself." Trumbetti called it "a joke at this point" and said he was "fighting for our constitutional rights and our freedoms." Smith said, "Murphy tried to shut down our gym and the gym stayed open."1121
The summonses dismissed: spring 2024
The municipal cases went the other way. The borough's license complaints were moved to the Winslow Township municipal court in August 2021. According to the owners' later federal complaint, as reported by the Courier-Post, Municipal Judge Carol Fabietti dismissed all of them at Trumbetti's request in March 2024, finding that Bellmawr officials "failed to cooperate with (Winslow's) municipal court and prosecutors for over three years" and that they had lacked authority to cite the gym for operating without a license.20 On May 18, 2024, four years to the day after the reopening, Smith posted that "80+ municipal citations" had been "dropped by the courts WITH prejudice," and the owners' lawyer, John McCann, confirmed the dismissals.5 NBC10 Philadelphia reported the dismissals on May 22, 2024; Trumbetti told the station the ruling came on April 24 and that the State's time to appeal had passed. "It's a big relief because it's been held over our heads for over four years," he said. "I want someone to be held accountable for it, what they've done."4 The sources differ on the exact date of the ruling (March or April 2024); none of them names a court order that could be opened, so this lesson gives the season and both accounts.
The license revocation upheld: July 24, 2024
The owners had sued the borough in September 2020 to restore the license, arguing that the August 11 hearing denied them due process (unsworn witnesses, no notice of a right to cross-examine, no evidence shared in advance, no neutral decision maker), that the refusal to postpone the hearing until the criminal case ended violated the Fifth Amendment, and that the revocation punished them for their speech.3 Assignment Judge Deborah Silverman Katz dismissed the suit on December 9, 2021. On July 24, 2024, the Appellate Division (Judges Gilson, DeAlmeida and Berdote Byrne) affirmed in Smith v. Borough of Bellmawr, No. A-1489-21, another unpublished opinion.3 It agreed that "defendants were not required to conduct a trial-type hearing with sworn testimony," that "[t]here were no adjudicative facts in dispute," and that the record held no evidence of retaliation for speech. On the owners' claim to a right to earn a living, it wrote: "Plaintiffs willfully and repeatedly violated the Governor's COVID-19-related EOs, which were meant to protect public safety during a widespread health emergency." Its disposition was one word: "Affirmed."3 In that case Smith certified that despite "250,000 visits" to the gym, "not one single COVID-19 case [had] been traced to [its] location"; the panel found the attacks on the science behind the orders lacked "sufficient merit" for discussion.3
The federal suit: 2025
On April 24, 2025, Trumbetti filed a 33-page suit in federal court in Camden seeking $10 million from Bellmawr Mayor Chuck Sauter, the council members who voted to revoke the license, borough police officers and the municipal solicitor, claiming retaliation for protected speech, denial of due process and malicious prosecution. His lawyer, John McCann, said: "If the First Amendment means anything, Frank will prevail." Borough officials declined to comment on pending litigation.20 No ruling in that case was found for this lesson as of November 2026.
And the gym? It stayed open. On the day the fines were upheld in 2023, Trumbetti told the Inquirer the gym was paying through membership dues and T-shirt sales.11 The State won the cases about its orders. The owners kept their doors open and, four years later, walked away from every borough summons.
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| March 9, 2020 | Gov. Murphy signs Executive Order 103, declaring a public health emergency and a state of emergency.2 |
| March 16, 2020 | Executive Order 104 closes gyms and fitness centers to the public.12 |
| March 21, 2020 | Executive Order 107 classifies gyms as non-essential "recreational and entertainment businesses" that "must close to the public."13 |
| May 18, 2020 | Atilis Gym reopens to members; Smith and Trumbetti receive summonses; Murphy warns of "a different reality."1 |
| May 20, 2020 | Health Commissioner Persichilli issues an Emergency Closure Order to the gym.2 |
| May 22, 2020 | The Commissioner sues to enforce; the Chancery Division enters temporary restraints.2 |
| June 8 and 15, 2020 | Court orders compliance and lets only the vitamin and apparel shops operate.2 |
| June 26, 2020 | Executive Order 157 allows only one-on-one indoor instruction by appointment.14 |
| July 24, 2020 | Judge Lougy holds the gym in contempt, sanctions "to be determined."2 |
| July 27, 2020 | Smith and Trumbetti are taken into custody, charged and released the same day.617 |
| August 1, 2020 | The owners remove the State's barriers and reopen.2 |
| August 11, 2020 | Bellmawr council votes five to one to revoke the gym's mercantile license.3 |
| August 18, 2020 | Court sets sanctions of $15,497.76 per day and awards fees, about $134,000 at once.216 |
| September 1, 2020 | Under Executive Order 181, gyms statewide may reopen indoors at 25 percent capacity.15 |
| May 11, 2021 | Judgment of $123,982.08 entered against the gym and both owners jointly.2 |
| October 4, 2021 | Both owners plead guilty to one count of fourth-degree contempt.3 |
| December 9, 2021 | Trial court dismisses the owners' suit to restore the license.3 |
| Late January 2022 | Each owner is sentenced to one year of probation.1819 |
| March 15, 2023 | Appellate Division affirms the sanctions and holds the gym orders constitutional.2 |
| March or April 2024 | Municipal judge dismisses the borough summonses; the dismissal becomes public in May.2045 |
| July 24, 2024 | Appellate Division affirms the license revocation.3 |
| April 24, 2025 | Trumbetti files a $10 million federal suit against Bellmawr officials.20 |

Why it took courage
It is easy, years later, to forget how lonely that May morning was. In mid-May 2020 most of the country was still closed. The governor of the state had the power, by his own signature, to make it a crime to lift a barbell in a gym, and the Attorney General was publicly praising the police who came to the door. Two men with no political office and no corporate backing opened a small business anyway, under their own names, in front of television cameras, and said they would accept what came. What came was a closure order, a contempt finding, an arrest, a criminal indictment, the loss of a license and a judgment that made them personally liable for well over $100,000. They did not hide from any of it. When the governor warned of "a different reality," Trumbetti had already given his answer: "I didn't open up today to close tomorrow."1
The liberty they defended is an old one: the right to earn a living at an honest trade without being shut down by one official's decree for months on end, with no hearing, no vote of the legislature and no end date. Executive Order 107 sorted every business in New Jersey into "essential" and "non-essential" by a governor's list. Grocery stores, pharmacies and the other businesses on the essential list stayed open.13 A gym that had taken its members' temperatures, capped its numbers and handed out spray bottles was told it was a danger and must stay dark. The owners argued from the start that they had been given no chance to show the gym was safe before it was closed, and that the essential and non-essential line denied equal protection.2 Those are serious constitutional questions, and the owners raised them at real cost to themselves when almost no one else in the state would.
They also kept faith with something many people lost in 2020: the idea that a free citizen answers to law, not to fear. Smith admitted being scared. Trumbetti had lost his mother to the disease that spring.10 They opened anyway, and they kept opening, and they bore the penalties openly instead of slipping out the back. That is the old tradition of civil disobedience: break the rule in public, give your name, take the consequence, and let the public judge whether the rule was just. They paid in money, in a criminal record, in years of their lives, and they stood their ground. The gym never closed for good. The borough's dozens of summonses were dismissed. Supporters who had never met them gave more than half a million dollars to their fund.11
Honest admiration includes honest limits. The owners lost the cases about the orders, partly because they did not appeal the Health Department's closure orders in time by the direct route those orders spelled out, and partly because the courts held the orders lawful. Some of their tactics, such as the "romantic partners" answer and the campaign office claim, did not persuade the courts. But courage is not measured by winning. It is measured by what a person was willing to risk for what he believed was right, and by that measure the two owners of a small gym in Bellmawr showed more of it than most.
What the other side said
Health Commissioner Judith Persichilli's closure order called gyms "particularly high-risk settings for the spread of COVID-19," because exercise increases breathing and can "increase the amount of respiratory droplets or aerosols in a confined setting," because gyms bring prolonged close contact, and because they "necessitate the communal use of equipment."2 In court the Commissioner argued that letting one gym set its own rules would "open[] the door for any other businesses . . . to make whatever social distancing rules they think are appropriate."2 The State's sanctions motion said, "Severe monetary sanctions are necessary to coerce compliance."10 Gov. Murphy said on May 18, 2020, "These aren't just words. We've got to enforce this."1 The Appellate Division held in 2023 that a business "may seek review" of an agency order but is "not free to ignore" it, and that "the EOs restricting the operation of gyms during the pandemic are constitutional."2 In 2024 the same court wrote that the owners "willfully and repeatedly violated the Governor's COVID-19-related EOs, which were meant to protect public safety during a widespread health emergency."3
Still disputed: Whether a governor's executive order may close a lawful business for months without a hearing or a legislative vote is still argued in New Jersey; the Appellate Division upheld the gym orders in an unpublished opinion that binds only the parties and is not precedent.2 The exact amount the owners paid is disputed: the State reported $174,457.92 collected, while Trumbetti puts fines and court fees at about $269,000.114 The date and written grounds of the 2024 municipal dismissal, and Trumbetti's 2025 federal claims, are not settled in any record found for this lesson.20
Medical note: At the May 22, 2020 hearing the gym's side argued there was "a 99.6 percent recovery rate for COVID-19"; in July 2020 its filings cited European research that people "allowed to return to their gyms" did not contract the disease; in 2020 Trumbetti said no one he knew of had tested positive after more than 20,000 check-ins; and Smith later certified that "250,000 visits" had produced "not one single COVID-19 case" traced to the gym.2103 These are the owners' claims. New Jersey's Health Commissioner and Executive Order 157 described indoor gyms as higher-risk settings because of heavy breathing and shared equipment, and the courts declined to weigh the science in the enforcement cases.214 This lesson praises the owners' stand on liberty and takes no position on these medical claims.
Hard questions and answers
They broke court orders and pleaded guilty. How can that be heroic?
Civil disobedience has always meant breaking a rule in the open and accepting the penalty. The owners did not deny what they did; they announced it in advance, put their names to it and took the consequences, including a guilty plea to one count of contempt and a year of probation.318 A skeptic can fairly say that disobeying a judge is a more serious step than disobeying an executive order, because courts are how a free people settles disputes without force, and the record shows the judges warned the owners many times. The admiration in this lesson is for the willingness to stand and pay, not a claim that every tactic was wise. Forms of Lawful Resistance in Ordered Liberty sets out the difference between lawful protest and open defiance.
Did the courts ever rule that the governor's orders were unconstitutional?
No. The Appellate Division held the opposite in 2023: "we hold the EOs restricting the operation of gyms during the pandemic are constitutional."2 It said so, though, in a part of the opinion it introduced "[f]or the sake of completeness," after holding that the gym's challenges were not properly before it at all, and the opinion is unpublished and not precedent.2 The owners' stronger legal arguments never got a full hearing on the merits, largely because the gym never filed a timely direct appeal of the closure order.
Weren't the fines just punishment for speaking out?
The owners argued that, and the 2024 opinion found nothing in the record showing retaliation for speech in the license case.3 On the fines, the 2023 panel held the sanctions were coercive, aimed at compliance, and measured to the gym's donations.2 A civil liberties advocate would point out that the court counted money that citizens gave to support a public protest as a reason to raise the fines, which can chill support for unpopular causes. The court's answer was that the gym itself had said the donations were to help it "stay open" in defiance of the orders.2 Trumbetti's 2025 federal suit raises the speech-retaliation question again against borough officials.20
A public health officer asks: what if every business had done this?
That was the Commissioner's own argument in court, that one gym's defiance would "open[] the door" for every business to set its own rules.2 The owners' answer was that they had set rules (temperature checks, limited numbers, cleaning) and asked only for the chance to show the gym was safe.1 A free society generally lets a business open and punishes proven harm; an emergency order closes first and asks later. Which rule is right for a declared emergency, and for how long, is the question this whole module keeps asking. New Jersey itself reopened gyms at 25 percent capacity on September 1, 2020, with rules very close to what Atilis said it was already doing in May.151
Why include Smith's 2007 conviction at all?
Because the module's rule is that hero stories must be true and complete enough to trust. The conviction is a matter of public record and of Smith's own public account, and readers who later learn of it should not feel the story was hidden from them.8 It does not change the facts of 2020: the gym's stand was a stand for the right to work, and Smith served his sentence for the 2007 crime long before.
So who won?
On the law, the State: the closure orders, the sanctions and the license revocation were all upheld, and the owners have criminal convictions.23 In the borough's municipal court, the owners: every license summons was dismissed.420 In the public square, the answer depends on the reader. The gym stayed open, the owners became symbols of resistance far beyond Bellmawr, and the questions they raised about one-person emergency rule are the ones What the Stands Won takes up.
Related lessons
- Emergency Power in 2020: The Orders, Who Signed Them, and How People Pushed Back
- Shelley Luther and Salon a la Mode (Dallas, Texas), another owner jailed for contempt after reopening
- Karl Manke, the 77-Year-Old Barber of Owosso (Michigan), a business owner whose license fight ended after the state's highest court ruled
- Small Businesses and Landlords at the Supreme Court
- What the Stands Won and Timeline, Glossary, Sources and the Record of Every Ruling
- Ordered Liberty: module home, Legitimate Authority and Its Limits and Forms of Lawful Resistance
- The Fourteenth Amendment (due process and equal protection) and The First Amendment (speech and assembly)
- Testifying at County Commissions and City Councils, for anyone facing a license hearing before a local council
Still open
These items could not be confirmed against a primary source before publication. The lesson states them as open, and they stay on the fact-check list.
- The exact date and written grounds of the 2024 municipal dismissal: the Courier-Post (citing Trumbetti's federal complaint) says Judge Carol Fabietti dismissed the charges in March 2024; Trumbetti told NBC10 the ruling came April 24; Smith posted on May 18, 2024. The written dismissal order has not been published.
- The number of municipal summonses: "80+" per Smith and NBC10; 34 operating-without-a-license complaints per the federal complaint as reported by the Courier-Post. The lesson says "dozens."
- Trumbetti's figure of about $269,000 in fines and court fees is his own (NBC10, May 22, 2024) and was not matched to a court record. The State reported $174,457.92 collected.
- The status of Trumbetti's April 24, 2025 federal suit against Bellmawr officials as of November 2026: no ruling was found in public reports or court databases checked for this lesson.
- The exact sentencing date (reported in late January 2022) and sentencing judge were not confirmed from a court record.
- The NBC News article (footnoted as August 2020) did not show a date in the fetched text; the month is inferred from its reference to the arrest "last month."
- Smith's sale of his share to Trumbetti is reported only by The Philadelphia Inquirer (Mar. 15, 2023) as "last year."
- The Bellmawr mayor's surname is spelled Sauter by the Courier-Post (2025) and Saulter by the Inquirer (2020); the lesson uses Sauter.
Learn more
- Persichilli v. Atilis Gym of Bellmawr (App. Div. 2023), full opinion: The most complete day-by-day record of the summer of 2020, with the court's reasoning on the Fifth Amendment, the fines and the emergency statutes.
- Smith v. Borough of Bellmawr (App. Div. 2024), full opinion: How a municipal license hearing works, and why the court found it fair.
- New Jersey Executive Order No. 107: Read the order itself to see how a single signature sorted every business in the state into essential and non-essential.
- Ordered Liberty: Forms of Lawful Resistance: The difference between lawful protest, civil disobedience and defiance of a court.
Notes
- Ellie Rushing, "A Bellmawr gym reopened despite Gov. Murphy's orders. The owners were issued a citation but plan to continue operating," The Philadelphia Inquirer, May 18, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Persichilli v. Atilis Gym of Bellmawr, No. A-3186-20 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. Mar. 15, 2023) (per curiam, not for publication), on appeal from Chancery Division, Mercer County, No. C-000048-20. Opinion PDF posted by the New Jersey Courts; read from the archived copy of that PDF (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Smith and Trumbetti, on behalf of Triple Threat Gym, LLC, d/b/a Atilis Gym Bellmawr v. Borough of Bellmawr, No. A-1489-21 (N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. July 24, 2024) (per curiam, not for publication), on appeal from Law Division, Camden County, No. L-3175-20 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Hayden Mitman and Brian Sheehan, "NJ gym owner cleared of charges after opening during pandemic," NBC10 Philadelphia, May 22, 2024 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Erin Vogt, "4 years later, defiant NJ gym owner declares a win over Murphy," New Jersey 101.5, May 21, 2024 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- CBS Philadelphia (KYW), "Authorities Arrest Owners Of Atilis Gym In Bellmawr After Continuously Defying New Jersey Shutdown Order," July 27, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Janel Miller, candidate profile of Ian Smith, U.S. House, Third District, Patch (Cinnaminson), May 8, 2022, updated May 10, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Dan Alexander, report on Ian Smith's 2007 crash and 2008 sentence, New Jersey 101.5, Feb. 26, 2021 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Noah Zucker, report on Ian Smith's congressional campaign, PhillyVoice, Feb. 5, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- NBC News, "Facing massive fines and jail, N.J. gym owner says nothing will make him close his doors," August 2020 (date inferred from the article's reference to the arrest "last month") (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Robert Moran, "Atilis Gym in Bellmawr must pay nearly $124,000 in fines for defying COVID restrictions, appeals court rules," The Philadelphia Inquirer, Mar. 15, 2023, updated Mar. 16, 2023 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- State of New Jersey, Executive Order No. 104 (Gov. Philip D. Murphy, Mar. 16, 2020), 52 N.J.R. 550(a) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- State of New Jersey, Executive Order No. 107 (Gov. Philip D. Murphy, Mar. 21, 2020), paragraphs 9, 25 and 26, 52 N.J.R. 554(a) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- State of New Jersey, Executive Order No. 157 (Gov. Philip D. Murphy, June 26, 2020), 52 N.J.R. 1455(a) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- State of New Jersey, Executive Order No. 181 (Gov. Philip D. Murphy, Aug. 27, 2020), paragraph 1, 52 N.J.R. 1712(a) (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Jeannie O'Sullivan, "NJ Gym Fined $134K Over COVID-19 Shutdown Defiance," Law360, Aug. 19, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- FOX 29 Philadelphia, "Atilis Gym owners charged after being taken into custody, released Monday," July 27, 2020 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Andy Berg, "Gym Owners Get Probation for Defying COVID Lockdown," Athletic Business, Feb. 1, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Virginia Aabram, "Gym owners who wouldn't comply with lockdowns sentenced to probation," Washington Examiner, Jan. 28, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Jim Walsh, "Atilis Gym Bellmawr defied COVID shutdown orders. Owner is now suing for $10M," Cherry Hill Courier-Post (republished by Yahoo News), updated Apr. 30, 2025 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Jen Ursillo, "NJ gym owners who violated pandemic orders lose appeal over $124K fines," New Jersey 101.5, Mar. 15, 2023 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
- Michelle Rotuno-Johnson, report on the dismissal of Ian Smith's drunk-driving charge, Patch (Cinnaminson), Oct. 14, 2022 (retrieved Nov. 7, 2026). Read it online. ā©
Check yourself
1. Which executive order, signed March 21, 2020, listed "Gyms and fitness centers and classes" among businesses that "must close to the public"?
Executive Order 107, paragraph 9, closed all recreational and entertainment businesses, listing gyms at item c. Order 103 declared the emergency; 157 and 181 later loosened the rules.
2. What daily sanction did the Chancery Division set on August 18, 2020?
Judge Lougy imposed $15,497.76 for each day of non-compliance, an amount the State said would deplete the gym's donations in about ten days.
3. Why did the Appellate Division say in 2023 that the gym's attacks on the executive orders were not properly before it?
Under Rule 4:67-6, an agency order's validity is not justiciable in an enforcement case; a party must appeal the order directly, within 45 days. This appeal was filed July 9, 2021, well past that limit for orders issued in 2020. Absent a stay or reversal, parties are "not free to ignore" the order.
4. What happened in the criminal case against the two owners?
The 2024 opinion records the guilty plea of October 4, 2021; news reports of late January 2022 record the probation sentence.
5. How did the Bellmawr council vote on revoking the gym's mercantile license on August 11, 2020?
The council voted five to one to revoke after hearing four unsworn witnesses, and adopted the written resolution nine months later.
6. According to the Attorney General's office, how much had the State collected from the gym by March 2023?
The State reported $174,457.92 collected. $269,000 is Trumbetti's own figure for fines and fees, $530,390 was the GoFundMe total, and $8,352 was the gym's July 2020 gross.
7. What happened to the borough's municipal summonses against the gym?
After the cases were moved to Winslow municipal court, a judge dismissed them in 2024; the owners reported more than 80 citations dropped with prejudice.
8. What did the 2023 opinion say about counting the GoFundMe donations when setting the fines?
The panel held the trial court properly considered the donations, and added that the gym "had only to come into compliance" to keep them for lawful uses.
Terms in this lesson
- Executive order
- A written directive signed by a governor or president. In 2020 New Jersey's governor used executive orders under emergency statutes to close businesses without a legislative vote.
- Disaster Control Act
- New Jersey's Civilian Defense and Disaster Control Act, N.J.S.A. App. A:9-33 to -63, which lets the governor issue emergency orders and sets penalties for violating them.
- Emergency Health Powers Act
- New Jersey's statute, N.J.S.A. 26:13-1 to -36, giving the Health Commissioner broad authority once the governor declares a public health emergency.
- Emergency Closure Order
- The May 20, 2020 order by Health Commissioner Judith Persichilli directing Atilis Gym to remain closed until further notice.
- Rule 1:10-3 (enforcement of litigant's rights)
- A New Jersey court rule letting a party ask the court to compel compliance with an order, including by monetary sanctions meant to coerce rather than punish.
- Coercive sanction
- A fine or other penalty meant to force future compliance with an order; the person can stop it by complying. A punitive sanction punishes past conduct.
- Contempt of court
- Disobeying a court order. It can be handled civilly, to coerce compliance, or criminally; fourth-degree contempt of a judicial order is a crime under N.J.S.A. 2C:29-9(a).
- Collateral attack
- Challenging the validity of an order in a different proceeding, such as an enforcement case, instead of by direct appeal. New Jersey's rules bar it in agency enforcement cases.
- Mercantile license
- A municipal license to operate a business in a town. Bellmawr's ordinance allowed revocation after notice and a hearing.
- Piercing the corporate veil
- A court's decision to hold the owners of a company personally liable for its debts, as the trial court did with Smith and Trumbetti in May 2021.
- Per curiam, not for publication
- An opinion issued by the court as a whole without a named author and not published as precedent; in New Jersey it binds only the parties.
- Dismissal with prejudice
- A dismissal that bars the same charges or claims from being brought again.
Sources
- Persichilli v. Atilis Gym of Bellmawr, No. A-3186-20 (App. Div. Mar. 15, 2023) (2023-03-15) checked 2026-11-07
- Smith v. Borough of Bellmawr, No. A-1489-21 (App. Div. July 24, 2024) (2024-07-24) checked 2026-11-07
- New Jersey Executive Order No. 104 (2020-03-16) checked 2026-11-07
- New Jersey Executive Order No. 107 (2020-03-21) checked 2026-11-07
- New Jersey Executive Order No. 157 (2020-06-26) checked 2026-11-07
- New Jersey Executive Order No. 181 (2020-08-27) checked 2026-11-07
- The Philadelphia Inquirer, reopening report (2020-05-18) checked 2026-11-07
- CBS Philadelphia, arrest report (2020-07-27) checked 2026-11-07
- FOX 29 Philadelphia, arrest report (2020-07-27) checked 2026-11-07
- NBC News, report on fines and the arrest (2020-08) checked 2026-11-07
- Law360, $134K sanctions report (2020-08-19) checked 2026-11-07
- Athletic Business, probation report (2022-02-01) checked 2026-11-07
- Washington Examiner, probation report (2022-01-28) checked 2026-11-07
- PhillyVoice, Smith campaign report (2022-02-05) checked 2026-11-07
- Patch, Smith candidate profile (2022-05-08) checked 2026-11-07
- Patch, Smith driving case report (2022-10-14) checked 2026-11-07
- New Jersey 101.5, Smith 2007 crash report (2021-02-26) checked 2026-11-07
- The Philadelphia Inquirer, appeal report (2023-03-15) checked 2026-11-07
- New Jersey 101.5, appeal report (2023-03-15) checked 2026-11-07
- New Jersey 101.5, dismissed citations report (2024-05-21) checked 2026-11-07
- NBC10 Philadelphia, dismissed charges report (2024-05-22) checked 2026-11-07
- Courier-Post, federal suit report (2025-04-30) checked 2026-11-07