Lesson 5 of 12 · about 55 minutes · Updated November 19, 2026
Short-Term Rentals After HB 583: Owners, Neighbors and HOAs
You'll be able to
- Distinguish the city and county rules in Idaho Code 67-6539 from the HOA rules in Idaho Code 55-3211.
- List the five safety requirements a city or county may still impose and several of the 17 forbidden requirements.
- Explain the facts and holding of North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton (2026) and how it differs from Adams v. Kimberley One (2015).
- Identify the state and local taxes on Idaho stays of 30 days or less and who must collect them after July 1, 2026.
- Compare Idaho's 2026 law with Arizona's and Florida's limits on local short-term rental rules.
- Find the public records that show local short-term rental rules, HOA amendments and lodging tax collections.
Start here: the short version
- Two separate laws, two separate rulers. Idaho Code 67-6539 limits what cities and counties may do about short-term rentals. Idaho Code 55-3211 limits what homeowner's associations may do about rentals of any length. One does not replace the other.12
- Since July 1, 2026, cities and counties may not license short-term rentals. House Bill 583 (2026), signed March 16, 2026 (Session Laws ch. 22), bars any "license, fee, permit, certification, or registration to operate a short-term rental," lists 17 forbidden "different restrictions or obligations," and allows only five safety rules.34
- An HOA needs the owner's written consent to add a rental limit. Under 55-3211, no association may add, amend or enforce a covenant that limits rentals "for any amount of time" unless the owner of the affected property "expressly agreed to in writing at the time of such addition or amendment."2
- That protection follows the property. In North Henry's Lake Homeowners Association, Inc. v. Norton, Docket No. 51990, filed Jan. 6, 2026, a unanimous Idaho Supreme Court held that a short-term rental ban added to a Fremont County subdivision's covenants in 2016 without the owner's written consent could not be enforced against three later buyers, even though each deed said the property was subject to the recorded covenants.56
- Covenants that were already in place still bind. A rental limit that was in the recorded covenants before 55-3211's predecessor took effect on March 24, 2016, or one an owner signed, is outside the consent rule. In Adams v. Kimberley One Townhouse Owner's Ass'n (2015), decided before that law, the court upheld an amendment that banned rentals shorter than six months.78
- Taxes on stays of 30 days or less: 6 percent plus 2 percent, and sometimes more. State sales tax is 6 percent and the travel and convention tax is 2 percent; five auditorium districts and 23 resort cities add their own taxes. Since July 1, 2026, an owner who rents directly, without a platform, carries the same collection duties as Airbnb or Vrbo.910111213
Law: Idaho Code as amended through the 2026 regular session, read on the Legislature's statute pages Nov. 19, 2026; bill histories, votes and session law chapters from legislature.idaho.gov; Idaho Supreme Court opinions through Nov. 19, 2026; Idaho State Tax Commission guidance pages as last updated (dates in the notes); other states' statutes from their legislatures' official sites, read Nov. 19, 2026. Laws, local codes and tax rates change; check the current statute, your city's current code and your association's recorded documents.
A short-term rental is the most local of housing questions. It is the house next door with a lockbox on the front door and a new car in the driveway every Friday. For the owner it may be a mortgage payment, a retirement plan or a cabin that pays its own taxes. For the neighbor it may be noise, parking and a street where fewer people know each other. For a resort town it may be the reason a teacher cannot find a place to live, or the reason the restaurants stay open in the shoulder season. Idaho's Legislature has answered the question in stages since 2016, each time moving more of the decision away from local governments and private associations and toward the individual owner.
This lesson does not repeat the bill history of House Bill 583 (2026). Part B's lesson The 2026 Housing Laws explains how the bill was drafted, who supported and opposed it, the 2025 Lava Hot Springs decision that preceded it, and the floor votes. This lesson starts where that one stops: what the law means for the people who own, live next to, and govern neighborhoods with short-term rentals, and how a separate statute, Idaho Code 55-3211, decides what a homeowner's association may do.
Two rulebooks: cities and counties, and HOAs
Two different bodies can try to limit a short-term rental in Idaho, and each runs under its own statute.
| Question | City or county | Homeowner's association |
|---|---|---|
| Statute | Idaho Code 67-6539 (Local Land Use Planning Act, Title 67, Chapter 65)1 | Idaho Code 55-3211 (Homeowner's Association Act, Title 55, Chapter 32)2 |
| Where the power comes from | Police power and zoning under the Local Land Use Planning Act | Recorded covenants, conditions and restrictions (CC&Rs), a private contract that runs with the land |
| Rentals covered | Short-term rentals: offered for a fee "for thirty (30) days or less" (63-1803(4))14 | Rentals "for any amount of time," short or long |
| What it may still do | Five listed safety rules; general noise, parking, nuisance, curfew and traffic ordinances that apply to every home1516 | Enforce rental limits that were valid when the current owner acquired the property, or that the affected owner agreed to in writing when they were added |
| What it may not do | Ban rentals; require a license, fee, permit or registration; impose any of 17 listed "different restrictions or obligations"174 | Add, amend or enforce a rental limit without the affected owner's express written consent at the time |
| Last changed | House Bill 583 (2026), effective July 1, 20263 | House Bill 511 (2016) first enacted the rule as 55-115(3); House Bill 703 (2022) moved it to 55-3211718 |
| Leading case | Idaho Association of Realtors v. City of Lava Hot Springs (2025)19 | North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton (2026)6 |
The difference matters in daily life. A city code enforcement officer can still write a noise citation to a rental's guests, because the same noise ordinance applies to every house. An HOA can still fine an owner for a parking violation under its rules if the CC&Rs give it that power and it follows the Act's notice rules, which lesson 08, Living in an HOA, explains. Neither can use those general powers as a back door to ban the rental itself: the city because 67-6539(1) forbids ordinances with the "practical effect" of prohibiting short-term rentals, and the HOA because 55-3211 forbids enforcing any covenant "in such a way that limits or prohibits the rental" without consent.12
The city and county rules after HB 583
What counts as a short-term rental
Idaho Code 67-6539(2)(b) borrows its definitions from the tax chapter, Idaho Code 63-1803. A "short-term rental" or "vacation rental" is "any individually or collectively owned single-family house or dwelling unit or any unit or group of units in a condominium, cooperative or timeshare, or owner-occupied residential home that is offered for a fee and for thirty (30) days or less." The definition excludes a unit "used for any retail, restaurant, banquet space, event center or another similar use." A "short-term rental marketplace" is a person that "provides a platform" through which an owner or agent offers the rental, which describes Airbnb, Vrbo and similar sites.1417
Three points follow from that text. The definition includes an owner-occupied home, so renting a spare bedroom for a weekend is a short-term rental. It includes condominium and townhouse units, which is where most HOA disputes arise. And the 30-day line is the same line the sales tax uses: a stay of 31 days or more under a lease is a residential tenancy governed by the landlord and tenant law in Idaho Code Title 6, Chapter 3, covered in lesson 01, Landlord and Tenant Law Basics.20
The ban on bans: subsection (1)
Subsection (1) has been in the law in some form since House Bill 216 (2017). As amended in 2026 it says neither a county nor a city "shall enact or enforce any ordinance that has the express or practical effect of prohibiting any type of short-term rentals in the county or city." The words "any type of" are new in 2026; the 2017 and 2018 versions said "short-term rentals or vacation rentals."121
The same subsection allows only "reasonable regulations as are necessary to safeguard the public health and safety," and only if they "do not impose different restrictions or obligations on short-term rentals than are imposed on single-family dwellings or similar structures not used as short-term rentals." It then classifies a short-term rental as "a non-transient residential use for zoning and building code purposes," subject "only to building codes adopted by the Idaho building code board." That last clause matters to owners: a city cannot treat a rental house as a hotel under its building code.1
The bill text shows what was struck. Before July 1, 2026, a city could adopt rules it "deems" necessary "to safeguard the public health, safety and general welfare in order to protect the integrity of residential neighborhoods in which short-term rentals or vacation rentals operate." HB 583 deleted "general welfare" and the "integrity of residential neighborhoods" purpose. Between 2018 and 2026 that neighborhood-integrity language was the legal hook for most local licensing, caps and owner-occupancy rules.2122
The 17 forbidden requirements: subsection (2)
Subsection (2)(a) defines "different restrictions or obligations" as "any requirement or regulation that would not be imposed but for a property's use as a short-term rental" and "specifically includes but is not limited to" this list:17
| No. | A city or county may not require or impose | What local rules this reaches (examples of the kind of rule, not a claim about any one city) |
|---|---|---|
| i | Owner occupation "for any amount of time" | Rules that allowed rentals only if the owner lived on site or part of the year |
| ii | Professional property management | Rules requiring a licensed local manager |
| iii | Additional insurance | Minimum liability coverage rules |
| iv | Reporting of use or other statistics | Nightly occupancy reports |
| v | Additional fire protection or fire sprinklers | Sprinklers beyond what a home needs |
| vi | Additional or improved ingress and egress | Extra exits or driveway rules |
| vii | Additional parking | One off-street space per bedroom rules |
| viii | Modification of the physical structure | Required remodels |
| ix | Inspections | Pre-license fire or code inspections |
| x | Internal or external signs, notices or diagrams | Posted permit numbers, exterior contact signs |
| xi | A limit on the days a property can be rented | Annual night caps |
| xii | Notices to neighboring properties | Mailed neighbor notice before operating |
| xiii | Increased sewer or other utility capacity | Extra hookup or capacity fees tied to rental use |
| xiv | A conditional use permit in a residential zone | Hearing-based approval |
| xv | Limits on proximity to other short-term rentals | Spacing or "one per block" rules |
| xvi | Restricting the number of short-term rentals in the city or county | Citywide or zone caps |
| xvii | Bringing the property up to current building codes, unless that would be required anyway | Code-upgrade conditions on a rental license |
Because the list "is not limited to" those 17 items, a rule that is missing from the list is still barred if it "would not be imposed but for" the rental use. A city that wanted, for example, a special trash pickup schedule only for rentals would have to fit it inside the five safety rules or apply it to every home.17
The five allowed safety rules: subsection (3)
Subsection (3) says a county or city "may, by ordinance, require an owner of a short-term rental to implement the following requirements only":15
- Functioning smoke alarms in all sleeping areas, "including when applicable, basements, living rooms, and family rooms."
- A functioning fire extinguisher and a functioning carbon monoxide detector on each floor.
- Removable escape ladders in all sleeping areas with a window located above the ground floor.
- Maximum occupancy limits that "do not exceed those non-transient residential limits as contained in the international building codes as adopted by the Idaho building code board."
- An "easily accessible informational handout" showing exits, fire extinguishers, any first aid kits, and a phone number for the owner or manager in an emergency.
The list is short and concrete. A city may require these items by ordinance, but subsection (2)(a)(ix) bars inspections and subsection (5) bars permits, so a city has no license process through which to check compliance in advance. Enforcement would come after a complaint, the same way a city enforces most code rules on owner-occupied homes.174
No licenses, and no city enforcement of covenants: subsections (4) and (5)
Subsection (5) reads in full: "No county or city shall require a license, fee, permit, certification, or registration to operate a short-term rental." That sentence ended the local rental license programs that cities such as McCall had built. At a May 14, 2025, meeting of the Legislature's Land Use and Housing Study Committee, McCall's community and economic development director, Michelle Groenevelt, told legislators the city began "requiring a rental license rather than a business license" in 2022, with health and safety inspections and parking and trash requirements, and that McCall had about 400 short-term rental units.423
Subsection (4) is easy to misread: "No county or city shall enact or enforce any covenant, condition, restriction, or contract that regulates a short-term rental except as allowed in this section." It speaks to counties and cities. It does not mention homeowner's associations. Read with the rest of the section, it keeps a local government from doing through a development agreement, a plat note or a recorded covenant what it may not do by ordinance. The Idaho REALTORS, a trade association, read it the same way in a 2026 member policy brief posted in August 2026: "HB 583 limits what cities and counties may do about short-term rentals. It does not govern private covenants." No Idaho appellate court has interpreted subsection (4) as of Nov. 19, 2026.2425
General ordinances still apply: subsections (6) and (7)
Subsection (6) keeps every short-term rental, owner and guest "subject to all other county and city ordinances and penalties that apply to other non-short-term rental residential uses, including but not limited to noise, parking, nuisance, curfew, and traffic regulations." For a neighbor, this is the part of the law that still works locally: a loud party at a rental can bring the same police response and citation as a loud party at an owner-occupied house. Subsection (7) bars cities and counties from regulating "the operation of a short-term rental marketplace," leaving platform regulation to the state tax chapter.1626
When the law took effect, and what happened to existing city codes
HB 583 passed the House 54-16-0 on Feb. 12, 2026, and the Senate 23-12-0 on March 9, 2026. Gov. Brad Little signed it March 16, 2026, as Session Laws 2026, chapter 22. Section 3 of the bill declared an emergency and set the effective date: "this act shall be in full force and effect on and after July 1, 2026." The statement of purpose, prepared by a proponent, says the bill "protects property owners by allowing local governments to regulate short-term rentals only in cases where it is in the interest of public health and safety."32127
The law did not give cities a grace period. Any local license, cap, owner-occupancy rule or fee that conflicts with 67-6539 became unenforceable on July 1, 2026. Some cities rewrote their codes to match. Sandpoint's council packet for 2026 includes a draft ordinance that repeals and replaces Title 3, Chapter 12 of the city code; its recitals quote HB 583's license ban, and its replacement chapter keeps only the five safety requirements and a section on generally applicable laws, effective "July 1st, 2026, concurrent with the effective date" of HB 583. A States Newsroom summary of laws taking effect July 1, 2026, reported that the bill would invalidate restrictions McCall and other resort cities had adopted.2829

HOAs and short-term rentals: Idaho Code 55-3211
The text, sentence by sentence
Idaho Code 55-3211 has two sentences. The first: "No homeowner's association may add, amend, or enforce any covenant, condition, or restriction in such a way that limits or prohibits the rental, for any amount of time, of any property, land, or structure thereon within the jurisdiction of the homeowner's association, unless expressly agreed to in writing at the time of such addition or amendment by the owner of the affected property."2
The second: "Nothing in this section shall be construed to prevent the enforcement of valid covenants, conditions, or restrictions limiting a property owner's right to transfer his interest in land or the structures thereon as long as that covenant, condition, or restriction applied to the property at the time the homeowner acquired his interest in the property."2
Taken apart, the first sentence covers four actions (add, amend, enforce), any covenant, condition or restriction, rentals "for any amount of time" (so long-term leases as well as nightly rentals), and every property "within the jurisdiction" of the association. The only exit it names is the owner's express written agreement "at the time of such addition or amendment." The second sentence protects covenants that were valid and already applied when the current owner bought. Terms like CC&Rs, declarant and amendment are explained in lesson 07, How HOAs Are Born and Who Controls Them.
Where 55-3211 came from: HB 511 (2016) and HB 703 (2022)
The rule began as House Bill 511 (2016), introduced by the House Business Committee. Its statement of purpose, listing Rep. Terry Gestrin as the contact, said: "if a homeowner bought a home at a time when renting the home was allowed by a Homeowner's Association (HOA), the HOA may not create new Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions (CCR's) that change the existing right to rent without written consent of the homeowner. This would not impact CCR's that were in place prior to the time a homeowner purchased the property." It passed the House 60-6-4 on Feb. 26, 2016, and the Senate 20-14-1 on March 15, 2016. Gov. C.L. "Butch" Otter signed it March 24, 2016 (Session Laws 2016, ch. 209), and it took effect that day. It was codified as Idaho Code 55-115(3).73031
In 2022 the Legislature rebuilt the Homeowner's Association Act as its own chapter. House Bill 703 (2022), from the House Ways and Means Committee, passed the House 63-3-4 on March 3, 2022, and the Senate 34-1-0 on March 23, 2022, was signed March 31, 2022 (Session Laws 2022, ch. 323), and took effect July 1, 2022. It placed the rental rule at 55-3211 and added a statement of legislative intent, 55-3202, that the Act is meant "to protect the rights of current and subsequent property owners within a homeowner's association."1832
North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton (2026)
The record. North Henry's Lake Homeowners Association, Inc. v. Bryan Norton, Henry Virgil, LLC, Properties Idaho, LLC, and C&N Perspectives, LLC, Idaho Supreme Court Docket No. 51990, November 2025 term, opinion filed Jan. 6, 2026. Justice Brody wrote for the court; Chief Justice Bevan and Justices Moeller, Zahn and Meyer concurred, with no dissent. The appeal came from the District Court of the Seventh Judicial District, Fremont County, Judge Joel E. Tingey.33
The facts. The North Henry's Lake Lodge Subdivision is near the Henry's Fork of the Snake River in Fremont County, about 20 minutes from the entrance to Yellowstone National Park, the opinion says. Shortly after the rental law took effect in 2016, the association held a written vote on banning short-term rentals. Twenty-three of 30 owners voted yes. The owner of the lot at issue, C&L Lee, L.C., opposed the amendment and did not consent. The association recorded the amended CC&Rs on Aug. 22, 2016. The lot then sold three times: to the Johnsons on Sept. 28, 2017; to Bryan and Patricia Norton and Newell and Cathie Norton (together, "the Nortons") on Aug. 3, 2022; and to Henry Virgil, LLC, on Oct. 17, 2022. Each warranty deed said the property was subject to the recorded CC&Rs. No owner ever agreed to the rental restriction in writing. In October 2022 the association learned the lot was listed on Airbnb and sued for an injunction and a declaratory judgment.5
The arguments. The association argued the statute "plainly protects only the investment-backed interests of the owner at the time the restriction was added," so its protection ended when C&L Lee sold and a new buyer took title with record notice of the ban. The owners asked the court to affirm, arguing that the association's position ran against the plain language of 55-3211; the opinion does not set out their merits argument at more length.34
The holding. The court affirmed summary judgment for the owners. It held that 55-3211 "unambiguously prohibits a homeowner's association from adding a rental restriction to any property within its jurisdiction unless the property owner expressly agrees in writing to that restriction at the time it is added." It found "nothing in the plain language of the statute that creates a temporal limitation." The statute's second sentence, the court said, protects only restrictions that were "validly added." Because the 2016 restriction was not valid at the time the current owners acquired their interest, the district court "correctly concluded that it cannot be enforced against the subsequent purchasers." In the court's words: "The HOA's only way around the statutory prohibitions is to obtain the express written consent of the owner of the affected property."6
Fees and costs. Neither side got attorney fees on appeal. The court denied the owners' request under Idaho Code 12-121 because the appeal raised an issue of first impression with arguments it called "sound and thoughtfully presented," and it denied the association's request as well. The owners received costs under Idaho Appellate Rule 40(a). The opinion also cautioned counsel to verify citations under Idaho Appellate Rule 11.2.35
What it means. For associations, a rental restriction adopted by majority vote after March 24, 2016, binds only the lots whose owners signed on in writing at the time, and it never reaches the lots whose owners did not, no matter how many times those lots sell. For buyers, a recorded amendment that looks binding may not be enforceable against a particular lot; the answer depends on who owned the lot when the amendment was recorded and whether that owner signed. For owners who did sign, the restriction binds them and, under the second sentence, later buyers. Lesson 09, HOA Disputes, places the case among Idaho's other covenant opinions, and lesson 11, Recent Disputes Casebook, lists it with other 2023 to 2026 disputes.

Adams v. Kimberley One Townhouse Owner's Ass'n (2015): the law before the statute
Nine months before HB 511 passed, the Idaho Supreme Court decided Adams v. Kimberley One Townhouse Owner's Association, Inc., 158 Idaho 770, 352 P.3d 492, Docket No. 42192, filed June 22, 2015 (rehearing denied July 28, 2015), opinion by Justice J. Jones. Virgil Adams owned a townhouse subject to a 1980 declaration that did not specifically restrict leasing. In 2013 the owners amended the declaration, with about 89 percent of the vote, to allow rentals only on conditions: a written agreement approved in advance by the board, board-approved advertising, no rentals of fewer than six months, no subleasing, and owner contact information on file. House rules set fines of $300 per rental day and $100 per advertising day.8
The court upheld the amendment because it was adopted under the declaration's own amendment clause. It said "the fact that a restriction was not previously addressed in the CC&Rs prior to an amendment does not automatically mean that amendment has gone too far," relying on its 2007 Best Hill decision, which upheld a density restriction added by amendment, and declined to adopt a bright-line rule against new restrictions added by amendment. It restated the general rule that restrictions on land are enforced "only when clearly expressed" and that "restrictions that are not clearly expressed will be resolved in favor of the free use of land." The association also won its attorney fees under the declaration's enforcement clause, in the district court and on appeal.8
Read together, the two cases show how the Legislature changed the result. Under Adams, a supermajority could add a rental limit to every unit if the declaration's amendment clause allowed it. Under HB 511 and 55-3211, as read in North Henry's Lake, a vote of other owners is not enough for any lot whose owner did not sign. The Adams amendment was adopted in 2013, before the statute, and nothing in 55-3211 says it reaches back to amendments recorded before March 24, 2016. The opinions we read do not address that question directly.86
What an HOA can still do about short-term rentals
Without written consent, an association cannot add a new rental ban or cap for an existing owner. It still has the tools any association has under its recorded documents and the Homeowner's Association Act, so long as the rule does not limit rentals as such:
- Enforce a rental restriction that was in the CC&Rs when the current owner acquired the lot and was validly adopted, including restrictions recorded with the original plat (lesson 84/06, Subdivisions and Plats Step by Step, explains how CC&Rs are recorded).2
- Enforce a restriction against an owner who signed a written agreement when it was added.2
- Enforce general use rules that apply to every lot regardless of who is staying there, such as parking, noise, trash, pets and common-area rules, under the fine and notice procedures in the Act (lesson 08).
- Ask owners, one at a time, to sign a written consent, which the court described as "the HOA's only way around the statutory prohibitions."6
Whether a particular general rule is in fact a rental limit in disguise, for example a rule that applies only to "occupants who are not owners," is the kind of question 55-3211's "in such a way that limits" language leaves to the courts. No Idaho appellate opinion we found has decided it.2
Decision tree: can my city or HOA restrict this rental?
The graphic below walks through the two statutes in order. It describes what the statutes say; how they apply to a particular property depends on that property's recorded documents and facts.
Timeline: a decade of short-term rental law in Idaho
| Date | Law, case or event | What changed | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| June 22, 2015 | Adams v. Kimberley One, Docket 42192 | Supreme Court upholds a 2013 CC&R amendment barring rentals under six months, adopted by about 89 percent of owners | 8 |
| March 24, 2016 | House Bill 511 (2016 ch. 209) signed and in effect | HOAs may not add rental limits without the owner's written consent (then 55-115(3)) | 7 |
| Aug. 22, 2016 | North Henry's Lake amended CC&Rs recorded | Short-term rental ban adopted 23 of 30, without the lot owner's consent | 5 |
| April 4, 2017 | House Bill 216 (2017 ch. 239) signed; effective Jan. 1, 2018 | Creates 67-6539 (no ordinance may prohibit short-term rentals) and the marketplace tax chapter, 63-1801 onward | 36 |
| March 14, 2018 | House Bill 452 (2018 ch. 79); effective July 1, 2018 | Lets cities and counties adopt reasonable rules for "general welfare" and "integrity of residential neighborhoods" | 22 |
| March 31, 2022 | House Bill 703 (2022 ch. 323); effective July 1, 2022 | Homeowner's Association Act rebuilt as Title 55, Chapter 32; rental rule becomes 55-3211 | 18 |
| May 21, 2025 | Idaho Association of Realtors v. City of Lava Hot Springs, Docket 50888 | Ordinance barring vacation rentals from residential zones violates 67-6539 | 19 |
| Jan. 6, 2026 | North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton, Docket 51990 | Unconsented HOA rental ban unenforceable against later buyers | 6 |
| March 16, 2026 | House Bill 583 (2026 ch. 22) signed | Strikes "general welfare"; 17 forbidden requirements; 5 allowed safety rules; no licenses; direct-booking owners take on marketplace tax duties | 3 |
| July 1, 2026 | HB 583 in effect | Conflicting local licenses, caps and owner-occupancy rules unenforceable | 21 |
Taxes on short-term rentals
State sales tax and the travel and convention tax
Two state taxes apply to every Idaho short-term rental stay of 30 days or less.
- Sales tax, 6 percent. Idaho Code 63-3619 imposes sales tax "at the rate of six percent (6%) of the sales price." Idaho Code 63-3612(2)(g) makes "providing hotel, motel, campground, or trailer court accommodations" a taxable sale "except where residence is maintained continuously under the terms of a lease or similar agreement for a period in excess of thirty (30) days."920
- Travel and convention tax, 2 percent. Idaho Code 67-4718 levies "an assessment at the rate of two percent (2%)" on each sale defined in 67-4711, which is "the renting of a place to sleep to an individual by a hotel, motel, or campground for a period of less than thirty-one (31) continuous days." The definition of "hotel/motel" includes "condominiums, townhouses or any other establishment that makes a sale." The Tax Commission says on its travel and convention tax page that "the current travel and convention tax rate is 2%."103738
The travel and convention money goes to tourism promotion. The Tax Commission's page says the Department of Commerce distributes 45 percent of the funds to nonprofit local and regional tourism organizations and another 45 percent to statewide programs. Idaho Code 67-4711(6) divides the state into seven travel planning regions; Region 4 is Camas, Cassia, Gooding, Jerome, Lincoln, Minidoka and Twin Falls counties, so Magic Valley rental stays fund Magic Valley tourism grants.3837
Who collects: platforms, and since July 1, 2026, owners who book directly
Idaho Code 63-1804, created by HB 216 (2017), requires a short-term rental marketplace to register with the Tax Commission and to "collect, report, and pay" state sales and travel and convention taxes and any local taxes the Tax Commission administers, on bookings it facilitates. It bars local governments from taxing the business of operating a marketplace. HB 583 (2026) added subsection (5): "If an owner of a short-term rental offers a short-term rental or vacation rental directly to an occupant without the use of a short-term rental marketplace, such owner shall comply with all the requirements provided in this section applicable to a short-term rental marketplace."1321
The Tax Commission's travel and convention tax page says that, "technically," an owner who rents only through marketplaces that collect and send in the taxes does not need the permits, but must get a seller's permit, a travel and convention tax permit and, where it applies, an auditorium district permit if the owner rents "anywhere else" or charges fees the platform does not collect tax on; its auditorium district page says the same of renting "by any other means." The Commission's lodging guidance, last updated April 29, 2026, lists the taxes and the duties of marketplaces and lodging providers. On Dec. 9, 2025, the Commission reminded marketplaces that "booking fees they charge customers are taxable."393840
Local lodging taxes: auditorium districts and resort cities
Auditorium districts. These special districts, created under Idaho Code Title 67, Chapter 49, may levy a tax "only for short-term lodging (30 days or less) within their district boundaries." The Tax Commission administers it for five: the Greater Boise Auditorium District, the Idaho Falls Auditorium District, the Mountain Community Center District (as of May 1, 2026, by the Commission's district page), the Nampa Auditorium District (as of April 1, 2026, on the same page; the Commission's general lodging page gives May 1, 2026 for Nampa and June 1, 2026 for the Mountain Community Center District) and the Pocatello-Chubbuck Auditorium District. The district tax does not apply to campgrounds.1139
Resort city local option taxes. Idaho Code 50-1044 lets the voters of a "resort city with a population not in excess of ten thousand (10,000)" authorize local option nonproperty taxes; a resort city is one that "derives the major portion of its economic well-being from businesses catering to recreational needs." Idaho Code 50-1046 requires a 60 percent vote and lists what may be taxed, starting with "an occupancy tax upon hotel, motel, and other sleeping accommodations rented or leased for a period of thirty (30) days or less." Idaho Code 50-1045 requires a resort city that collects more than it budgeted to use the excess to replace city property taxes the next year.414243
The Tax Commission lists 23 cities with local sales taxes: Bellevue, Bonners Ferry, Cascade, Crouch, Donnelly, Driggs, Hailey, Harrison, Irwin, Kellogg, Ketchum, Lava Hot Springs, Mackay, McCall, Ponderay, Riggins, Salmon, Sandpoint, Stanley, Sun Valley, Swan Valley, Tetonia and Victor. The Commission does not administer these taxes; owners pay them to the city. Rates and the items taxed differ city by city and are set by the voters, so this lesson does not list them; each city's current ordinance is the record.12
None of the Magic Valley's core towns, Twin Falls, Jerome, Kimberly, Gooding, Buhl or Hagerman, is on the Commission's list, and none is in one of the five auditorium districts it administers. A short-term rental stay there carries the two state taxes, 8 percent in all, unless a local tax the Commission does not administer applies.1211
How we figured it: taxes on a sample $1,000 stay
Inputs. A three-night stay with a $1,000 taxable charge (room charge plus taxable fees), at a house in Jerome or Twin Falls. Sales tax 6 percent (Idaho Code 63-3619); travel and convention tax 2 percent (67-4718); no auditorium district or city local option tax on the Tax Commission's lists for those cities.
Math. Sales tax: $1,000 times 0.06 = $60. Travel and convention tax: $1,000 times 0.02 = $20. Total state taxes: $80, so the guest pays $1,080. In a city with a local option lodging tax or inside an auditorium district, add that tax's rate times the same base. Example only: a hypothetical 3 percent local tax would add $30. That 3 percent is an illustration, not the rate of any named city.
Limits. Whether a particular fee is taxable depends on the Tax Commission's rules and its list of common charges; we did not model cleaning or pet fees separately.
Income and property tax, in brief
Rental income is income for federal and Idaho income tax purposes, and a house the owner does not occupy as a primary residence does not qualify for the property tax homeowner's exemption, which lesson 02, Owning a Rental Legally, and Part B's lesson Reading Your Assessment and Levy explain. This lesson gives no tax advice; the rules for mixed personal and rental use of a vacation home are set by the Internal Revenue Code and change with federal law.
Resort towns, counts and the housing debate
What resort towns told legislators
The most detailed public record of the resort-town case is the minutes of the Land Use and Housing Study Committee's May 14, 2025, meeting. Ketchum City Administrator Jade Riley, speaking for the Idaho Resort Cities Coalition, reported that Ketchum "now reported a +60% short-term rental housing," up from what had been a balanced mix of homeowners, long-term rentals and second homes, and described a housing needs assessment built on a historical loss of "300 units" and expected growth of "~750 units." McCall's Michelle Groenevelt cited the west central mountains housing study, which "found that ~1200 units were needed for full-time residents," and a Driggs study that found "85% of new condos/townhomes were purchased as either a second home or intended short-term rental." She said McCall had "approx. 400 units" of short-term rentals and that a planned deed-restricted apartment project's local units could not be used as short-term rentals.23
Those figures come from city officials summarizing their own studies in legislative minutes. The underlying studies are the better record for anyone checking the numbers, and the minutes do not give the years or methods behind each figure.23

How many short-term rentals Idaho has
No single public count exists. Before July 1, 2026, the best local counts were city license lists in places that licensed rentals, such as McCall. HB 583 ended those licenses and also bars cities from "requiring reporting of use or other statistics," so the local license lists that existed will not be updated. The Tax Commission holds permit and return data from marketplaces and direct-booking owners, but it does not publish a count of short-term rentals by city on the pages we read. Private firms that scrape listing sites, such as AirDNA (a commercial data company) and Inside Airbnb (a volunteer project), publish estimates; those are private estimates, not public records, and they count listings, which can differ from units.1739
The result is a data gap that will widen. The travel and convention tax collected by region, and auditorium district collections, can show the direction of short-stay lodging spending, but they combine hotels, motels and rentals.
Each side's best case
For local control. Resort cities argue that short-term rentals convert homes that once housed workers into lodging, and that a town of 3,000 or 4,000 people cannot absorb hundreds of conversions without losing teachers, nurses and firefighters. They argue caps, licenses and owner-occupancy rules were tools to keep some housing for residents, and that the state now forbids them while leaving the housing shortage to the city. Part B's lesson 03 reports that the counties' representative on the 2025 study committee asked that short-term rental control be returned to local communities.23
For the owner's right to rent. Supporters of HB 583 argue that renting a home is an ordinary use of property, that a guest for three nights is no different in law from a tenant for a year, and that cities used the 2018 "neighborhood integrity" language to ban by permit what the 2017 law said they could not ban outright. The Lava Hot Springs decision gave them a record: a city allowed owner-occupied bed and breakfasts in a residential zone but barred non-owner-occupied vacation rentals, and a unanimous court held that the ordinance "violates the Short-term Rental and Vacation Rental Act." The bill's statement of purpose frames it as protecting "the private property rights of Idaho homeowners."1927
What the evidence shows. The record shows real pressure in resort towns, from the cities' own studies, and it shows that some local rules went beyond what the 2017 law allowed, from the 2025 court ruling. It does not show, in any public Idaho data set we found, how many homes moved between long-term and short-term use in any city, or how many would move back if rules changed. National research on the link between short-term rentals and rents exists, but its results depend on the city studied, and no Idaho-specific study is in the legislative record we read.
For HOA members, neighbors and owners
For HOA boards
After North Henry's Lake, a board looking at its rental rules has a factual job before any legal one: for each lot, who owned it when each rental amendment was recorded, and whether that owner signed. The opinion makes the lot's history, not the vote total, the deciding fact. Boards also keep the powers lesson 08 describes for rules that apply to every lot, and their records duties under the Act, which lesson 07 covers. The Homeowner's Association Act gives members who win an action to protect their rights under the Act a claim to reasonable attorney fees, a point lesson 09 explains with the cases.625
For neighbors
A neighbor's tools after July 1, 2026, are the general ones: the city's noise, parking, nuisance, curfew and traffic ordinances under 67-6539(6), and, inside an HOA, the association's general use rules and any valid rental restriction. A city may no longer require a rental to post signs, notify neighbors or register, so a neighbor may have no public list to check. Recorded deeds and assessor records still show who owns a property, which lesson 12, How to Report on Housing, explains.1617
For owners
An owner who offers a short-term rental in Idaho faces three sets of rules: the five safety items if the city or county has adopted them by ordinance, plus every general ordinance; the HOA's recorded documents, read against 55-3211; and the tax duties in 63-1804, including the direct-booking duty added in 2026. The owner's lender, insurer and any condominium declaration may add private terms. Lesson 02 covers the landlord's general duties; a guest staying 30 days or less is a lodging customer for tax purposes, and the line between a guest and a tenant for eviction purposes is a question lesson 04, Evictions Step by Step, touches on.1513

How Idaho compares with other states
Several states limit local short-term rental rules. Idaho's 2026 law is among the tightest we found because it bans local licensing outright.
| State and statute | Local bans | Local permits or licenses | Other notable terms |
|---|---|---|---|
| Idaho, Idaho Code 67-6539 (as amended 2026)1 | Barred, express or practical | Barred: no license, fee, permit, certification or registration | Only five safety rules; 17 listed forbidden requirements; caps and owner occupancy barred |
| Arizona, A.R.S. 9-500.39 (first enacted by SB 1350, 2016)44 | "A city or town may not prohibit vacation rentals or short-term rentals" | Allowed: a local permit or license, fee capped at the actual cost or $250, whichever is less | Cities may require emergency contact information (civil penalty up to $1,000 per 30 days for failing to provide it) and notice to adjacent neighbors |
| Florida, Fla. Stat. 509.032(7)45 | "A local law, ordinance, or regulation may not prohibit vacation rentals" | Not barred by this paragraph | Local rules may not "regulate the duration or frequency of rental"; rules adopted on or before June 1, 2011, are exempt |
The Arizona statute's title still reflects its 2016 origin in SB 1350, but its current text, as read on the Arizona Legislature's site, includes the later-added permit, contact and notice provisions. Idaho's subsections (2)(a) and (5) forbid three tools Arizona now allows: a permit or license, notice to neighbors, and a posted permit number or other signage. Florida's grandfather date means older local rules in some Florida cities survive; Idaho's 2026 law has no grandfather clause. We did not read other states' statutes in full for this lesson and do not summarize them here.4445
Pictures, Numbers and Infographics
| Measure or rule | Idaho | U.S. or other states | Place or year | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Short-term rental definition | Offered for a fee for 30 days or less | Florida and Arizona use their own definitions | Idaho Code 63-1803(4), since 2018 | 14 |
| Forbidden local requirements | 17 listed, "not limited to" | Arizona allows permits up to $250 | Statewide, July 1, 2026 | 1744 |
| Allowed local safety rules | 5 | Arizona: health and safety rules if primary purpose is safety | Statewide, 2026 | 1544 |
| HB 583 votes | House 54-16-0; Senate 23-12-0 | n/a | Feb. 12 and March 9, 2026 | 3 |
| Days from HB 583 signing to effect | 107 (our calculation) | n/a | March 16 to July 1, 2026 | 3 |
| HB 511 votes (HOA rental consent rule) | House 60-6-4; Senate 20-14-1 | n/a | 2016 | 7 |
| North Henry's Lake vote on ban | 23 of 30 owners (76.7 percent, our calculation) | n/a | Fremont County, 2016 | 5 |
| Adams amendment vote | About 89 percent | n/a | 2013 amendment; 2015 opinion | 8 |
| State sales tax on stays | 6 percent | Rates vary by state | Statewide | 9 |
| Travel and convention tax | 2 percent | n/a | Statewide since Jan. 1, 1985 rate provision | 10 |
| Cities with local sales taxes | 23 | n/a | Tax Commission list, 2026 | 12 |
| Auditorium districts taxing lodging (Tax Commission-administered) | 5 | n/a | 2026 | 11 |
| Voter approval for resort city local option tax | 60 percent | n/a | Cities of 10,000 or fewer | 4241 |
| McCall short-term rentals | About 400 units | n/a | Stated May 14, 2025 | 23 |
How we figured it: vote shares and days
North Henry's Lake: 23 yes votes divided by 30 owners = 0.7667, or 76.7 percent. HB 583 calendar: March 16 to March 31 is 15 days; April 30, May 31 and June 30 add 91; July 1 adds 1; total 107 days from signing to the effective date.
Common mistakes
- Treating HB 583 as an HOA law. HB 583 amended 67-6539 and 63-1804; it governs counties, cities and tax collection. HOA rental limits are governed by 55-3211, which HB 583 did not amend. The Idaho REALTORS' August 2026 brief makes the same point: "HOA authority and local government authority are separate regimes."2125
- Assuming a majority vote binds every owner. In North Henry's Lake, 23 of 30 owners approved the ban. It still could not be enforced against the lot whose owner did not sign, or against the three later owners.56
- Assuming a deed that says "subject to recorded CC&Rs" is consent. Each deed in the North Henry's Lake chain said so. The court found no express written consent and held the restriction unenforceable against the later buyers.346
- Assuming 55-3211 covers only short-term rentals. The statute covers rentals "for any amount of time," so it reaches long-term lease limits as well.2
- Assuming every old rental limit is now void. The second sentence of 55-3211 protects valid restrictions that applied when the owner acquired the property. A limit in the original recorded declaration, or one the owner signed, is a different case from an unconsented amendment.2
- Reading subsection (4) of 67-6539 as voiding HOA covenants. It says "no county or city shall enact or enforce" a covenant that regulates short-term rentals. It speaks to local governments.24
- Counting the wrong days for the tax line. Sales tax and the travel and convention tax apply to stays of 30 days or less; a continuous stay of more than 30 days under a lease is exempt from both. The travel and convention definition uses "less than thirty-one (31) continuous days."2037
- Assuming a platform covers every tax. The Tax Commission says owners must hold permits if they rent "anywhere else" or charge fees the platform does not tax, and resort city local option taxes are paid to the city, not the Commission.3812
- Assuming a city can still require a business license for rentals. Subsection (5) bars any "license, fee, permit, certification, or registration to operate a short-term rental." A general business license that every business must hold is a separate question the statute does not address by name.4
What we know, what we don't, and what the data can show
What we know
- Since July 1, 2026, Idaho cities and counties may not ban, license, cap or require owner occupancy of short-term rentals, and may require only five safety items (Idaho Code 67-6539, as amended by HB 583, 2026 ch. 22).1
- Since March 24, 2016, an HOA may not add a rental limit of any length without the affected owner's express written consent, and the Supreme Court held in January 2026 that this protection runs with the property to later buyers (55-3211; Docket 51990).76
- Short stays carry 6 percent sales tax and 2 percent travel and convention tax, plus auditorium district or resort city taxes in some places, and direct-booking owners now carry marketplace collection duties (63-3619, 67-4718, 63-1804).91013
What we don't know
- How many short-term rentals operate in each Idaho city or county. No statewide public count exists, and local license lists ended with HB 583.
- How 55-3211 applies to rental limits recorded before March 24, 2016, and to "general" HOA rules that fall only on non-owner occupants. No appellate court has decided either question in the opinions we read.
- How courts will read 67-6539(4) on covenants, and whether a city's general business license, applied to all businesses, counts as a forbidden "license ... to operate a short-term rental."
- Whether HB 583 changes how many homes are used as long-term rentals in resort towns. No Idaho study measuring that is in the public record we read.
- Each resort city's current local option tax rate on lodging; we did not confirm each city's ordinance for this lesson.
What the data can show
- Travel and convention tax collections by planning region, from the Idaho State Tax Commission's and Department of Commerce's reports, can show trends in short-stay lodging spending by region, though they combine hotels and rentals.37
- Auditorium district tax collections, published by each district, can show lodging trends in Boise, Nampa, Idaho Falls, Pocatello-Chubbuck and the Mountain Community Center District.11
- Resort city local option tax reports, published by each city, can show lodging tax receipts where the tax is broken out by category.12
- Recorded CC&R amendments at county recorders, compared with deed records, can show which lots in a subdivision were owned by whom when a rental limit was recorded, the fact North Henry's Lake made decisive.6
- District court case filings on iCourt can show suits by HOAs to enforce rental limits; lesson 66/02 explains the search.
Questions people ask
Can my city still make me get a short-term rental permit?
Not since July 1, 2026. Idaho Code 67-6539(5) says no county or city "shall require a license, fee, permit, certification, or registration to operate a short-term rental." A city may still require the five safety items by ordinance and enforce general ordinances.415
My HOA voted to ban short-term rentals after I bought. Does it bind me?
Under 55-3211, a rental limit added or amended after the statute took effect binds an owner only if that owner "expressly agreed to in writing at the time." The Supreme Court applied that text in North Henry's Lake. Whether any given amendment binds a given lot depends on the recorded documents and when they were recorded.26
I am buying in an HOA with a recorded rental ban. Will it bind me?
The second sentence of 55-3211 protects valid restrictions that "applied to the property at the time the homeowner acquired his interest." North Henry's Lake held that the word "valid" matters: a ban that was never validly added to a lot does not become binding because a later buyer had notice of it. The lot's ownership history at the time the ban was recorded is the deciding fact. Lesson 10, Buying a Home in a Growing Area, covers HOA documents before closing.26
Can the HOA still enforce noise and parking rules against my guests?
55-3211 limits rules that limit or prohibit rentals. General rules that apply to every lot, adopted and enforced under the CC&Rs and the Act's notice requirements, are outside that text. Whether a rule written to fall only on renters is a disguised rental limit is an open question.2
Does HB 583 apply in small towns and rural counties?
Yes. Unlike the 2026 starter-home and ADU laws, which cover cities over 10,000 people, 67-6539 has no population threshold. It applies to every city and county, from Boise to Hagerman and Fremont County.1
What taxes does a guest pay on a short-term rental?
State sales tax of 6 percent and travel and convention tax of 2 percent on stays of 30 days or less, plus an auditorium district tax inside one of the five districts the Tax Commission administers and any resort city local option tax. In the Magic Valley's core towns the two state taxes, 8 percent in all, are the ones on the Commission's lists.9101112
Can a city limit the number of people in a rental?
Only to the extent of 67-6539(3)(d): an occupancy limit that does "not exceed those non-transient residential limits" in the building codes adopted by the Idaho Building Code Board. General noise and nuisance ordinances also apply.1516
Hard questions
Should the state or each town set short-term rental rules?
Resort towns argue that housing pressure from rentals is local and uneven, so one statewide rule fits Ketchum and Jerome equally badly. The bill's supporters argue that renting is a property right that should not depend on which side of a city line a house sits, and that local rules had already been struck down as exceeding the 2017 law. The record shows both the pressure, in the cities' own studies, and the overreach, in the 2025 Lava Hot Springs decision. It does not settle which approach produces more housing for residents.2319
Should an HOA majority be able to change rental rules for everyone?
Associations argue that CC&Rs are a contract every buyer accepts, including the amendment clause, and that 23 of 30 owners should be able to set the character of their own subdivision, the view the court applied in Adams in 2015. Owners argue that the right to rent is part of what they bought, and that a later vote of neighbors should not take it away; the Legislature adopted that view in 2016 and the court enforced it in 2026. The evidence is the statute's plain text and the votes: the House passed HB 511 60-6-4 and the Senate 20-14-1.876
Should the consent rule follow the land to buyers who knew about the ban?
The association in North Henry's Lake argued that a buyer with record notice of a ban has no investment-backed expectation to protect. The court read the statute's text as having no "temporal limitation." The policy question remains: a buyer who paid a price reflecting a recorded ban may now hold a lot that can be rented, while neighbors who voted for the ban relied on it. The Legislature can change the text; the court interprets what it says.346
How will anyone measure short-term rentals without licenses?
Local governments say licenses gave them counts, contacts and a way to reach owners. The bill's supporters say reporting rules were a burden imposed only on rental owners, and subsection (2)(a)(iv) now bars them. The data that remain are tax collections that combine hotels and rentals, private scraped estimates, and, if the Legislature or the Tax Commission chose to publish them, aggregated permit counts.17
For reporters and advocates
Records that exist.
- City council agendas, packets and ordinances repealing or rewriting short-term rental chapters after HB 583, such as Sandpoint's 2026 draft repealing Title 3, Chapter 12. Open meeting rules are in module 34.28
- Old license lists, complaint logs and code enforcement files from cities that licensed rentals before July 1, 2026. These are public records unless an exemption applies; requests go under Idaho Code Title 74, explained in module 47.
- Recorded CC&Rs, amendments and deeds at the county recorder, which show when a rental limit was recorded and who owned each lot then.
- District court files on iCourt for HOA enforcement suits, and Supreme Court opinions on isc.idaho.gov (lesson 66/09).
- Bill pages, statements of purpose, committee minutes and floor votes on legislature.idaho.gov for HB 583 (2026), HB 511 (2016) and HB 703 (2022).3718
- Tax Commission, auditorium district and resort city lodging tax reports.
Questions to ask. For a city: which parts of the old short-term rental code are still on the books, and which have been repealed or are no longer enforced? How many complaints about rentals came in before and after July 1, 2026? For an HOA board: when were rental amendments recorded, and does the association have written consents from the owners at the time? For the Tax Commission: does it publish, or will it publish, permit counts for lodging by city or county in aggregate?
The Magic Valley angle. Twin Falls, Jerome, Kimberly, Gooding, Buhl and Hagerman do not appear on the Tax Commission's list of local option cities or in an auditorium district it administers, so local lodging tax data there is limited to state collections for Region 4. Hagerman is in Gooding County; the nearest cities on the local option list are the Wood River Valley cities of Blaine County, such as Hailey, Ketchum and Sun Valley. Covenant fights in Magic Valley subdivisions are in the county recorder and district court records, not in any state registry.3712
Lesson 12, How to Report on Housing, has a step-by-step records workflow, and Part A's Economic Development and Housing Pressure gives the growth numbers behind resort-town housing demand.
Where to go next
- Idaho Statutes search (Idaho Legislature): Free official text of the Idaho Code, with a history line showing each session law that changed a section. Use it to read 67-6539 and 55-3211 as currently in force.
- Idaho Supreme Court opinions: Free official list of Supreme Court and Court of Appeals opinions by date, with PDF opinions. Search by docket number, such as 51990 for North Henry's Lake.
- Idaho State Tax Commission, lodging taxes: Free official guidance on sales, travel and convention, and auditorium district taxes on lodging of 30 days or less, and which permits a lodging provider needs.
- Idaho Business Registration: Free state online system the Tax Commission names for applying for seller's, travel and convention, and auditorium district tax permits.
- Idaho Legislature, 2026 legislation: Free official list of 2026 bills with text, statements of purpose, votes and session law chapters, including HB 583.
- Idaho iCourt Portal: Free public search of Idaho court case records, including district court suits by homeowner's associations; lesson 66/02 explains how to use it.
Still being checked (10 items)
These points could not be fully confirmed against a primary source when this lesson was written and fact checked in November 2026. The text above states each one as uncertain.
- Current local option lodging tax rates in Ketchum, McCall, Sandpoint, Sun Valley, Driggs and the other resort cities: not confirmed from each city's ordinance; the lesson gives no rates.
- Current auditorium district tax rates (for example the Greater Boise Auditorium District): not confirmed; the lesson gives no rates.
- Start dates for Tax Commission administration of the Nampa and Mountain Community Center district taxes differ between two Commission pages (April 1 vs. May 1, 2026); both are reported as stated.
- Whether Sandpoint adopted the draft ordinance repealing Title 3, Chapter 12, and its final number and date: the record read was an undated draft in a council packet.
- Which other Idaho cities (McCall, Ketchum, Coeur d'Alene, Boise, Island Park area counties, Twin Falls, Jerome) repealed or amended short-term rental code chapters after HB 583: not confirmed from their codes.
- The Idaho Supreme Court PDF for Adams (Docket 42192) did not load; the lesson relies on the Leagle text of the opinion.
- Direct downloads of the Supreme Court opinion PDFs for Dockets 51990 and 50888 from isc.idaho.gov/opinions to Jeff's PC returned HTTP 404; the opinions were read online on Nov. 19, 2026, and copies are saved in the module's 09 and 11 download folders.
- The underlying housing studies cited in the May 14, 2025, committee minutes (Ketchum needs assessment, west central mountains study, Driggs study): the lesson quotes only the minutes.
- The official Idaho Reports citation (volume and page) for North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton: not yet shown in the text we read.
- Whether the Idaho REALTORS policy brief carries an exact publication date; the PDF text shows none, and 'August 2026' rests on its web address.
Last verified November 19, 2026. General education, not legal, tax, financial or real estate advice; every figure names its source and year in the Notes and Sources below. Data is revised: check the newest release before relying on any number.
Notes
- Idaho Code section 67-6539, Limitations on regulation of short-term rentals, subsection (1) and full text; history: [added 2017, ch. 239, sec. 2, p. 592; am. 2018, ch. 79, sec. 1, p. 179; am. 2026, ch. 22, sec. 1, p. 109] (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 55-3211, Prohibited conduct: rental restrictions; history: [55-3211, added 2022, ch. 323, sec. 4, p. 1045] (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, bill page for House Bill 583 (2026), Short-Term Rentals, House Business Committee; House 54-16-0 on Feb. 12, 2026; Senate 23-12-0 on March 9, 2026; signed March 16, 2026; Session Laws 2026, ch. 22; effective July 1, 2026 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-6539(5) (no license, fee, permit, certification or registration) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- North Henry's Lake Homeowners Association, Inc. v. Norton, Idaho Supreme Court Docket No. 51990, opinion filed Jan. 6, 2026, statement of facts (subdivision location, 2016 written vote of 23 of 30 owners, Aug. 22, 2016 recording, conveyances of Sept. 28, 2017, Aug. 3, 2022 and Oct. 17, 2022, Airbnb listing in October 2022) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- North Henry's Lake Homeowners Association, Inc. v. Norton, Idaho Supreme Court Docket No. 51990 (Jan. 6, 2026), analysis and holding (statute "unambiguously prohibits" adding a rental restriction without the owner's written consent; no "temporal limitation"; restriction cannot be enforced against subsequent purchasers); judgment affirmed (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, bill page for House Bill 511 (2016), Homeowner's Associations, House Business Committee; passed House 60-6-4 on Feb. 26, 2016; Senate 20-14-1 on March 15, 2016; signed by the governor March 24, 2016; Session Laws 2016, ch. 209; effective March 24, 2016 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Adams v. Kimberley One Townhouse Owner's Association, Inc., 158 Idaho 770, 352 P.3d 492, Idaho Supreme Court Docket No. 42192, filed June 22, 2015, rehearing denied July 28, 2015 (J. Jones, J.), 2015 Opinion No. 57, appeal from the Fourth Judicial District, Ada County (Hon. Cheri C. Copsey); text as published by Leagle and in the Justia copy of the Supreme Court's slip opinion saved to the module's downloads (the Idaho Supreme Court's PDF link for this docket did not load on Nov. 19, 2026) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 63-3619, Imposition and rate of the sales tax (6 percent); history: [added 2003, ch. 318, sec. 7; am. 2006, 1st Ex. Sess., ch. 1, sec. 18] (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-4718, Assessment: council account (2 percent from and after Jan. 1, 1985) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho State Tax Commission, Auditorium District Taxes (five districts administered: Greater Boise, Idaho Falls, Mountain Community Center as of May 1, 2026, Nampa as of April 1, 2026, Pocatello-Chubbuck; not on campgrounds; owners must get permits if they rent "by any other means") (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho State Tax Commission, City Sales Taxes (list of 23 cities with local sales taxes; the Commission does not administer them) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 63-1804, Limiting tax duties of short-term rental marketplaces and owners: collection of tax, subsections (1) to (6); history: [added 2017, ch. 239, sec. 1, p. 591; am. 2026, ch. 22, sec. 2, p. 111] (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 63-1803, Definitions (short-term rental, short-term rental marketplace); history: [added 2017, ch. 239, sec. 1, p. 591] (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-6539(3)(a) to (e) (the five requirements a county or city may impose) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-6539(6) (general noise, parking, nuisance, curfew and traffic ordinances apply) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-6539(2)(a)(i) to (xvii) and (2)(b) (definition of "different restrictions or obligations"; terms of 63-1803 apply) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, bill page for House Bill 703 (2022), Homeowner's Association Act ("reestablish the Homeowner's Association Act"), House Ways and Means Committee; passed House 63-3-4 on March 3, 2022; Senate 34-1-0 on March 23, 2022; signed March 31, 2022; Session Laws 2022, ch. 323; effective July 1, 2022 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Association of Realtors, Inc. v. City of Lava Hot Springs, Idaho Supreme Court Docket No. 50888, filed May 21, 2025 (Bevan, C.J.; Brody, Moeller, Zahn and Meyer, JJ., concurring); appeal from the Sixth Judicial District, Bannock County (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 63-3612(2)(g), Sale (hotel, motel, campground and trailer court accommodations, except residence maintained continuously under a lease for more than 30 days) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 583 (2026), bill text, Sixty-eighth Legislature, Second Regular Session, sections 1 (amending 67-6539, striking "general welfare" and "integrity of residential neighborhoods"), 2 (amending 63-1804) and 3 (emergency clause; effective July 1, 2026) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, bill page for House Bill 452 (2018), Short-Term Rentals and Vacation Rentals, Revenue and Taxation Committee; House 64-5-1 on Feb. 13, 2018; Senate 30-4-1 on March 6, 2018; signed March 14, 2018; Session Laws 2018, ch. 79; effective July 1, 2018 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Minutes, Land Use and Housing Study Committee, Idaho Legislature, May 14, 2025 (presentations by Jade Riley, Ketchum and Idaho Resort Cities Coalition, and Michelle Groenevelt, McCall) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-6539(4) (no county or city shall enact or enforce any covenant, condition, restriction or contract that regulates a short-term rental except as allowed) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho REALTORS (a real estate trade association; industry source), HOA Authority in Idaho, policy brief for members, 2026 (posted August 2026, per its web address) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-6539(7) (no local regulation of short-term rental marketplaces) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Statement of Purpose and Fiscal Note, RS33170 / H0583 (2026), contacts Rep. Mike Moyle, Rep. Jordan Redman, Sen. Kelly Arthur Anthon and Sen. Todd M. Lakey; prepared by a proponent; fiscal note: no fiscal impact (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- City of Sandpoint, draft ordinance repealing and replacing Title 3, Chapter 12 (short-term rentals) to conform to HB 583, council meeting attachment, 2026 (ordinance number and adoption date blank in the draft) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Laura Guido, "These new laws are set to go into effect in Idaho on July 1," States Newsroom (Idaho Capital Sun photos), June 30, 2026 (news; event summary only) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Statement of Purpose and Fiscal Note, RS24431 / H0511 (2016), contact Rep. Terry Gestrin (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton, Docket No. 51990 (Jan. 6, 2026), citing Act of Mar. 24, 2016, ch. 209, 2016 Idaho Sess. Laws 592 (originally codified as Idaho Code 55-115(3)), and Act of Mar. 31, 2022, ch. 323, 2022 Idaho Sess. Laws 1039, 1045 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 55-3202, Legislative intent; history: [added 2022, ch. 323, sec. 4, p. 1039] (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- North Henry's Lake Homeowners Association, Inc. v. Bryan Norton, Henry Virgil, LLC, Properties Idaho, LLC, and C&N Perspectives, LLC, Idaho Supreme Court Docket No. 51990, Boise, November 2025 Term, filed Jan. 6, 2026 (Brody, J.; Bevan, C.J., and Moeller, Zahn and Meyer, JJ., concurring); appeal from the District Court of the Seventh Judicial District, Fremont County, Hon. Joel E. Tingey (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton, Docket No. 51990 (Jan. 6, 2026), summary of the association's argument that the statute protects "only the investment-backed interests of the owner at the time the restriction was added," and the deeds' recitals that the property was subject to the recorded CC&Rs (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton, Docket No. 51990 (Jan. 6, 2026), attorney fees and costs (fees denied to both sides under Idaho Code 12-121; costs to respondents under I.A.R. 40(a); caution under I.A.R. 11.2) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, bill page for House Bill 216 (2017), Vacation Rentals, Revenue and Taxation Committee; House 63-5-2 on March 3, 2017; Senate 35-0-0 on March 20, 2017; signed April 4, 2017; Session Laws 2017, ch. 239; effective Jan. 1, 2018 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-4711, Definitions (hotel/motel includes condominiums and townhouses; sale means renting a place to sleep for less than 31 continuous days; seven planning regions, Region 4 = Camas, Cassia, Gooding, Jerome, Lincoln, Minidoka and Twin Falls counties); history through 2018, ch. 71 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho State Tax Commission, Travel and Convention Tax ("The current travel and convention tax rate is 2%"; permits, including "Technically, you don't need these permits" if renting only through marketplaces that collect the taxes; 45 percent regional and 45 percent statewide distribution) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho State Tax Commission, Lodging: Basics, last updated April 29, 2026 (taxes on lodging of 30 days or less; marketplace and lodging provider duties; auditorium districts) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho State Tax Commission, news release, Idaho Short-Term Rental Marketplaces Reminded to Charge Taxes on Booking Fees, Dec. 9, 2025 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 50-1044, resort city local-option nonproperty taxes (cities of 10,000 or fewer; definition of resort city); history: [added 1978, ch. 261; am. 1981, ch. 328; am. 2013, ch. 135] (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 50-1046, City local-option nonproperty taxes permitted by sixty per cent majority vote (occupancy tax on sleeping accommodations of 30 days or less) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 50-1045, City property tax relief fund (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Arizona Revised Statutes section 9-500.39, Limits on regulation of vacation rentals and short-term rentals, subsections A and B, Arizona Legislature (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Florida Statutes section 509.032(7), Preemption authority, The Florida Legislature, Online Sunshine (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
Check yourself
1. Since July 1, 2026, which of these may an Idaho city require of a short-term rental owner?
Idaho Code 67-6539(3)(b) allows a functioning fire extinguisher and carbon monoxide detector on each floor; subsection (5) bars licenses and fees, and (2)(a)(i) and (xi) bar owner occupancy and night caps.
2. Which statute governs whether a homeowner's association may add a rental restriction?
Idaho Code 55-3211 bars an HOA from adding, amending or enforcing a rental limit without the affected owner's express written consent at the time; 67-6539 governs cities and counties.
3. In North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton (Jan. 6, 2026), how many owners voted for the 2016 short-term rental ban?
The opinion in Docket No. 51990 says 23 of 30 owners voted for the amendment; the lot owner, C&L Lee, L.C., opposed it and did not consent.
4. What did the Idaho Supreme Court hold in North Henry's Lake?
The court found no 'temporal limitation' in 55-3211 and held the unconsented restriction 'cannot be enforced against the subsequent purchasers' (Docket No. 51990).
5. When did the HOA written-consent rule for rental limits first take effect?
House Bill 511 (2016), Session Laws ch. 209, was signed and took effect March 24, 2016; HB 703 (2022) later moved it to 55-3211.
6. What is the combined state tax rate on an Idaho short-term rental stay of 30 days or less, before any local tax?
Sales tax is 6 percent (Idaho Code 63-3619) and the travel and convention tax is 2 percent (67-4718), for 8 percent.
7. What did HB 583 add to Idaho Code 63-1804?
New subsection 63-1804(5) makes an owner who offers a rental directly to an occupant comply with the marketplace collection, reporting and payment requirements.
8. In Adams v. Kimberley One Townhouse Owner's Ass'n (2015), what did the court do with the 2013 rental amendment?
The court held the amendment, barring rentals under six months and adopted with about 89 percent of the vote, was validly made under the 1980 declaration (Docket No. 42192); 55-3211's predecessor did not exist until 2016.
9. Which state allows a city to require a short-term rental permit with a fee of up to $250?
A.R.S. 9-500.39(B)(5) allows a local permit or license with a fee not to exceed the actual cost or $250, whichever is less; Idaho's 67-6539(5) bars any permit or fee.
10. What vote does Idaho Code 50-1046 require for a resort city local option lodging tax?
Idaho Code 50-1046 permits city local-option nonproperty taxes, including an occupancy tax on stays of 30 days or less, by a sixty percent majority of voters in a resort city of 10,000 or fewer (50-1044).
Terms in this lesson
- Short-term rental
- Under Idaho Code 63-1803(4), a house, dwelling unit, condominium, cooperative or timeshare unit, or owner-occupied home offered for a fee for 30 days or less.
- Short-term rental marketplace
- A person that provides a platform through which an owner or agent offers a short-term rental to an occupant (Idaho Code 63-1803(5)); examples include Airbnb and Vrbo.
- Different restrictions or obligations
- Under Idaho Code 67-6539(2)(a), any requirement a city or county would not impose but for a property's use as a short-term rental, including the 17 listed items.
- Non-transient residential use
- The zoning and building code class Idaho Code 67-6539(1) assigns to short-term rentals, the same class as an ordinary home.
- Express written consent
- A written agreement by the owner of the affected property, made at the time a rental limit is added or amended, which Idaho Code 55-3211 requires before an HOA may apply that limit.
- Subsequent purchaser
- A later buyer of a property; in North Henry's Lake (2026) the court held an unconsented rental ban could not be enforced against subsequent purchasers.
- Record notice
- Notice a buyer is treated as having of documents recorded with the county recorder, such as amended CC&Rs.
- Preemption
- A higher level of government's law displacing a lower level's rule on the same subject, as 67-6539 limits city and county short-term rental ordinances.
- Travel and convention tax
- A 2 percent state assessment on lodging of less than 31 continuous days (Idaho Code 67-4711 and 67-4718), used for tourism promotion.
- Auditorium district tax
- A local tax on short-term lodging of 30 days or less within an auditorium district created under Idaho Code Title 67, Chapter 49.
- Resort city local option tax
- A city nonproperty tax, such as a lodging occupancy tax, that voters in a resort city of 10,000 or fewer may approve by 60 percent (Idaho Code 50-1044 and 50-1046).
- Emergency clause
- A bill section declaring an emergency so the act takes effect on a stated date; HB 583's section 3 set July 1, 2026.
- Summary judgment
- A court ruling without a trial because the material facts are not in dispute; the North Henry's Lake district court granted it to the owners.
- Issue of first impression
- A legal question an appellate court has not decided before; the court cited this in denying fees in North Henry's Lake.
Sources
- Idaho Code 67-6539, Limitations on regulation of short-term rentals (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Idaho Code 55-3211, Prohibited conduct: rental restrictions (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton, Idaho Supreme Court Docket No. 51990 (Jan. 6, 2026) (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Idaho Association of Realtors v. City of Lava Hot Springs, Docket No. 50888 (May 21, 2025) (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- House Bill 583 (2026) bill page (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- House Bill 583 (2026) bill text (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- House Bill 511 (2016) bill page (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- House Bill 703 (2022) bill page (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Idaho Code 63-1804, tax duties of short-term rental marketplaces and owners (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Idaho Code 67-4718, travel and convention assessment (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Idaho State Tax Commission, Auditorium District Taxes (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Idaho State Tax Commission, City Sales Taxes (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Land Use and Housing Study Committee minutes, May 14, 2025 (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Arizona Revised Statutes 9-500.39 (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11