Lesson 11 of 12 · about 50 minutes · Updated November 19, 2026
Recent Idaho Housing Disputes: A Casebook, 2023 to 2026
You'll be able to
- Summarize the holdings of North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton (2026) and Idaho Association of Realtors v. City of Lava Hot Springs (2025) and explain how they shape short-term rental disputes with HOAs and cities.
- Trace the 2024 to 2026 housing bills from introduction to law or death, using bill pages, roll calls and statements of purpose.
- Describe the Attorney General's 2026 HOA transfer fee settlements and the 2024 statute behind them, and the Justice Department's 2026 fair housing settlement in Caldwell.
- Explain how procedure (deadlines, standing, derivative claims, ripeness, reasoned statements) decided many of the cases before the merits.
- Find each dispute's record yourself: opinions by docket number, iCourt files, recorded covenants, bill pages and agency case pages.
- Identify what the public record does not show, including park sales, unappealed Magic Valley cases and Human Rights Commission housing decisions.
Start here: the short version
- The biggest HOA ruling of the period is about rentals. In North Henry's Lake Homeowners Association v. Norton (Idaho Supreme Court, Docket 51990, Jan. 6, 2026), the Court held that Idaho Code 55-3211 bars an HOA from applying a later-added rental restriction to a property unless the owner at the time it was added agreed in writing. The 2016 short-term rental ban in that Fremont County subdivision did not bind the lots of owners who never signed.12
- Cities lost the main short-term rental case. In Idaho Association of Realtors v. City of Lava Hot Springs (Docket 50888, May 21, 2025), the Court held that a city rule allowing non-owner-occupied short-term rentals only in commercial zones violated the state's short-term rental law. The Legislature then passed House Bill 583 (2026), 54-16 in the House and 23-12 in the Senate, signed March 16, 2026.34
- A neighborhood group stopped a shelter permit. In Veterans Park Neighborhood Association v. City of Boise (Docket 51027, Jan. 22, 2025), the Court held the Boise City Council's grant of a conditional use permit for Interfaith Sanctuary's new shelter was "arbitrary and capricious and based on unlawful procedure" and ordered the approval invalidated.5
- Tenant bills split. The Legislature passed a rent control and fee preemption bill (HB 545, 2024, 59-11 and 26-9) and a bill shielding dismissed eviction records after three years (SB 1327, 2024). A cap on rental application fees passed the Senate 23-12 in 2025 (SB 1042) and died in a House committee, and a 2026 version (HB 701) never got a hearing vote.6789
- The Attorney General went after HOA fees. On May 8, 2026, Attorney General Raul Labrador announced Assurances of Voluntary Compliance with two HOAs (in Ada and Kootenai counties) and an Ada County management company that serves about 70 HOAs, over transfer fees not disclosed in the governing documents.1011
- Fair housing reached a Caldwell RV park. The U.S. Justice Department sued the managers and owners of Decoy RV Park in Caldwell on Oct. 9, 2024, over an assistance dog and an eviction after a HUD complaint; a Jan. 26, 2026 settlement requires $20,000 in damages, training and a new accommodation policy.1213
- Evictions are mostly an urban docket. Boise State's Idaho Policy Institute counted 3,415 eviction filings in Idaho courts in 2025 and 1,234 formal evictions, with 1,349 filings in Ada County and 155 in Twin Falls County; counted by household, 3,039 renting households had at least one filing.14
Records: Idaho Supreme Court and Court of Appeals opinions filed Jan. 1, 2023 through Nov. 18, 2026, read from the opinion PDFs posted by the Idaho courts; bill histories, roll calls, statements of purpose and session law chapters from legislature.idaho.gov for the 2024, 2025 and 2026 sessions; Idaho Code sections as posted Nov. 19, 2026; Attorney General and U.S. Justice Department releases and case pages; news reports used only for events and quotes. All checked Nov. 19, 2026. New opinions and filings come out every week; check the court's opinion page and iCourt for the newest record.
This lesson is a casebook: a set of real Idaho housing disputes from 2023 through 2026, each tied to a record you can read yourself. Each entry says what happened, who the parties were, which record holds the story, how it came out, and what it teaches an owner, renter, HOA board, landlord, neighbor, city official or reporter. The cases come from the Idaho Supreme Court and Court of Appeals, from the Legislature's bill pages and roll calls, from the Attorney General and the U.S. Department of Justice, and, where no court record exists yet, from news reports that are labeled as such.
Other lessons in this course explain the law these cases apply. The rules for renting are in Landlord and Tenant Law Basics; evictions step by step are in Evictions Step by Step; short-term rental law after House Bill 583 is in Short-Term Rentals After HB 583; manufactured home parks are in Mobile and Manufactured Home Parks; and Idaho HOA opinions are walked through in depth in HOA Disputes and How They End. Here each HOA case gets a short entry and a pointer to lesson 09, and the depth goes to short-term rental fights, park sales, landlord-tenant and fair housing cases, Attorney General actions, the 2024 to 2026 legislative fights and the Magic Valley. Land use fights such as annexation and rezones were covered in Part B: see Annexation Fights and Property Rights and Land Use Law, which explains Crookham v. County of Canyon (2026) and the Twin Falls rezone and plat cases. They are not repeated here.
How this casebook was built
We started from the full list of opinions the Idaho courts posted from January 2023 through Nov. 18, 2026, read each caption and staff summary, and kept every civil case involving a homeowner's association, condominium or property owners' association, a landlord and tenant, an eviction, a manufactured or tiny home, a short-term rental, or a neighborhood fight over housing. We then read each kept opinion: the first page (court, county, judge, date, result), the facts, the holding and the conclusion. We added every 2024, 2025 and 2026 bill the Legislature indexed under landlords and tenants, homeowner's associations, manufactured homes and short-term rentals, with its roll call votes and its statement of purpose, the one-page description the sponsor files with each bill. We added Attorney General and U.S. Justice Department actions we could find in official releases.
Three limits matter. First, most housing disputes never reach an appellate court; they end in magistrate court, in a settlement, or with someone moving. Appellate opinions are the visible tip, and the unpublished Court of Appeals opinions cited here "shall not be cited as authority" under the court's own label. Second, news reports of park sales and tenant organizing describe events and quotes, not findings; where we use them we say so. Third, we did not find a published Idaho Human Rights Commission housing decision for 2023 to 2026 in the time available, and we found no Magic Valley housing case in the appellate record for the period beyond the land use cases Part B already covers. Both gaps are listed in "What we don't know" below.
How we figured it
Inputs. The Idaho courts' opinion records (docket number, caption, release date, staff summary and opinion file) for Supreme Court and Court of Appeals opinions released Jan. 1, 2023 through Nov. 18, 2026; the Legislature's 2024, 2025 and 2026 legislation indexes and bill pages.
Method. We filtered captions and summaries for the words homeowner, association, condominium, tenant, landlord, lease, eviction or unlawful detainer, manufactured, mobile home, short-term, rental, covenant and housing; dropped child protection, criminal and tax cases that matched by accident; and read every remaining opinion. We kept 15 opinions: 13 from the Supreme Court and 2 from the Court of Appeals. Bills were kept if the Legislature's own subject index put them under landlords and tenants, homeowner's associations, manufactured homes or short-term rentals. Counts of "passed" and "died" in this lesson are our own tallies from those bill pages.
What it misses. District and magistrate court decisions that were not appealed, settlements, agency complaints that are not public, and any opinion the filter words did not catch.
The cases at a glance
The table lists every dispute in this casebook with its record. Opinion numbers are the Idaho courts' docket numbers; search them on the courts' opinion pages or in iCourt (see The Idaho iCourt Portal and Appellate Opinions and Legal Research).
| Dispute | Type | Place | Record and date | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Greenbriar Estates HOA v. Esposito | HOA, easement | Canyon County | Idaho Supreme Court, Docket 48922, March 22, 202315 | Affirmed for the HOA: no easement because the RV lot was never formally annexed |
| North West Neighborhood Association v. City of Boise | Neighbors v. city, housing approval | Boise | Docket 49179, Sept. 7, 202316 | Council approval set aside for lack of a reasoned statement |
| Miller v. Rocking Ranch No. 3 Property Owners' Association | HOA, design review, assessments, fees | Ketchum, Blaine County | Docket 49371, Jan. 12, 202417 | Owners won on the assessment counterclaim; HOA's fee award vacated |
| Pickering v. Sanchez | Landlord-tenant, lease to own | Canyon County | Docket 49801, Feb. 22, 202418 | Affirmed for the landlords; tenant's consumer protection claim failed |
| House Bill 545 (2024) | Legislation, rent and fee preemption | Statewide | Session Laws 2024, ch. 257, signed April 1, 20246 | Law |
| Senate Bill 1327 (2024) | Legislation, eviction records | Statewide | Session Laws 2024, ch. 269, signed April 3, 20247 | Law |
| United States v. Nourse | Fair housing, disability | Caldwell | U.S. District Court for Idaho, complaint Oct. 9, 2024; settlement Jan. 26, 202612 | Settled: $20,000, training, new policy |
| Veterans Park Neighborhood Association v. City of Boise | Neighbors v. city, shelter permit | Boise | Docket 51027, Jan. 22, 20255 | Permit approval invalidated |
| Senate Bill 1162 (2025) | Legislation, short-term rentals | Statewide | Failed in the Senate 11-23, April 1, 202519 | Died |
| Idaho Association of Realtors v. City of Lava Hot Springs | Short-term rentals v. city | Lava Hot Springs, Bannock County | Docket 50888, May 21, 20253 | Reversed for the owners and Realtors; city rule violated the state act |
| Vintage II, LLC v. Teton Saddleback Vistas HOA | HOA, covenants, master plan | Teton County | Docket 51455, Sept. 10, 202520 | Reversed for the owners: master plan did not create covenants |
| Clark v. Conger | Eviction, lease with option | Mountain Home, Elmore County | Court of Appeals, Docket 52590, Oct. 24, 2025 (unpublished)21 | Landlord's eviction case dismissed; fees to tenant affirmed |
| MV Realty "Homeowner Benefit" contracts | Attorney General, homeowners | Statewide | Settlement reported Nov. 202522 | Contracts voided, five-year ban (as reported) |
| North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton | HOA, short-term rental ban | Fremont County | Docket 51990, Jan. 6, 20261 | Affirmed for the owners |
| Stunja v. High Corral No. 2 Property Owners Association | HOA, roads, attorney fees | Boise County | Court of Appeals, Docket 52026, Jan. 14, 2026 (unpublished)23 | Full fee award reversed and remanded |
| Doyle v. Harris Ranch Community Infrastructure District No. 1 | Homeowners v. infrastructure district | Boise | Docket 51175, Feb. 12, 202624 | Affirmed for the district |
| House Bill 583 (2026) | Legislation, short-term rentals | Statewide | Session Laws 2026, ch. 22, signed March 16, 20264 | Law |
| House Bill 800 (2026) | Legislation, manufactured homes | Statewide | Session Laws 2026, ch. 171, signed March 26, 202625 | Law |
| HOA transfer fee settlements | Attorney General, HOAs | Ada and Kootenai counties | Release of May 8, 202610 | Assurances of Voluntary Compliance, refunds |
| Conger v. Clark | Lease with option to buy | Mountain Home | Docket 52800, Sept. 4, 202626 | Affirmed against the tenant-buyer (bankruptcy standing) |
| K&L Crystal Beach, LLC v. Crystal Beach Condominium Association | Condo, rental rules, ownership shares | McCall, Valley County | Docket 52887, Oct. 30, 202627 | Mostly affirmed for the association; one claim sent to trial |
| Colton v. Overlook at Fox Creek Subdivision Owners' Association | HOA, road maintenance | Teton County | Docket 52603, Nov. 9, 202628 | Reversed for the neighbor; fee awards vacated |
| Decker v. City of Meridian | Tiny home rental v. city code | Meridian | Docket 52355, Nov. 9, 202629 | Affirmed for the city |
| Moscow area parks and the former Riviera Estates in Eagle | Manufactured home park rent increases | Latah County; Eagle | News reports, Jan. 13, 2025 and Oct. 26, 20253031 | Ongoing; no appellate record |

HOA and condominium cases
Lesson 09, HOA Disputes and How They End, walks through Idaho's HOA opinions in depth, including the older ones that set the rules for reading covenants. The entries below give each 2023 to 2026 case in a few lines so the casebook is complete; read lesson 09 for the full reasoning. How HOAs are created and governed is in How HOAs Are Born and Who Controls Them, and fees, fines and liens are in Living in an HOA.
North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton (2026): a rental ban that did not stick
What happened. In 2016 the North Henry's Lake subdivision in Fremont County, near Island Park, amended its covenants, conditions and restrictions (CC&Rs, the recorded rules that bind lots in a subdivision) to bar any lot from being leased as a short-term rental. The HOA later sued Bryan Norton and three LLCs (Henry Virgil LLC, Properties Idaho LLC and C&N Perspectives LLC) to enforce the ban and to stop them from renting.1
The law. Idaho Code 55-3211 says no HOA "may add, amend, or enforce any covenant, condition, or restriction in such a way that limits or prohibits the rental, for any amount of time," of property in the association, "unless expressly agreed to in writing at the time of such addition or amendment by the owner of the affected property." The section was added in 2022 (Session Laws 2022, ch. 323); before that, the same rule sat in former section 55-115(3).227
Outcome. The district court (Judge Joel E. Tingey) ruled for the owners because neither the owner in 2016 nor any later buyer had agreed to the ban in writing. The HOA argued the statute protects only the person who owned the lot in 2016, so a later buyer who took title with notice of the ban should be bound. The Supreme Court, in an opinion by Justice Brody joined by all four other justices, disagreed and held "the statute plainly exempts a property from any short-term rental restriction its homeowner's association otherwise elects to adopt unless the property owner at the time the restriction was added expressly agrees to that restriction in writing." Neither side got attorney fees because the HOA's appeal raised "an important issue of first impression."1
What it teaches. For HOAs, a rental restriction added by amendment binds only lots whose owners signed at the time; the protection runs with the lot. For buyers, a recorded rental ban does not settle the question; the record of who consented in writing does. Lesson 05 explains how this fits with House Bill 583 and city rules.
K&L Crystal Beach v. Crystal Beach Condominium Association (2026): rental rules in a McCall condo
What happened. The Crystal Beach Condominiums on the water in McCall were organized in 1971 under a declaration that could be amended only by owners holding 85 percent of the ownership interest and "all holders of any recorded Mortgage." In 2020 the association recorded an amended declaration that changed each owner's share of the common areas and assessments, and the board issued rental rules in 2020 and again in 2022 (limits on pets and occupancy, and a rule that renters' guests could not use the common areas or stay overnight). Unit owners objected in writing that the rental rules violated former section 55-115(3), now 55-3211. K&L Crystal Beach, LLC and Robert E. Bohman sued the association and former board members.27
Outcome. The district court held most of K&L's claims were derivative claims (claims that belong to the corporation, not the member) and failed for not meeting the Nonprofit Corporation Act's requirements for such suits. The Supreme Court on Oct. 30, 2026 affirmed summary judgment on the claims for declaratory relief, slander of title, quiet title, encroachment and breach of contract, but reversed on K&L's demand under the Condominium Property Act, Idaho Code 55-1505(1)(c), to remeasure units and reallocate ownership shares, and sent that claim to trial.27
What it teaches. How a condo owner frames a claim (as an owner's own injury or as the association's) can decide whether a court reaches the merits of a rental rule. The derivative-claim requirements come from Idaho's Nonprofit Corporation Act, not the HOA Act.
Colton v. Overlook at Fox Creek (2026): who plows the road
What happened. Craig Colton, who lives at the end of East 5250 South in rural Teton County, sued the Overlook at Fox Creek Subdivision Owners' Association, the developer GNJ Properties, LLC and several lot owners, asking a court to declare either that the HOA must pay for snow removal and maintenance on an unplowed road segment or that all owners who use it share the cost. The district court dismissed his complaint and ruled the HOA owed nothing because the road segment was outside the subdivision.28
Outcome. The Supreme Court (Justice Moeller) on Nov. 9, 2026 reversed, remanded for further proceedings, and vacated the attorney fee awards against Colton, who argued his own appeal.28
What it teaches. Shared rural roads are a common source of HOA conflict in fast-growing counties, and a court must address each theory a neighbor raises, not only whether the HOA itself is liable.
Vintage II v. Teton Saddleback Vistas HOA (2025): a master plan is not a covenant
Owners of land within or next to the Teton Saddleback Vistas Subdivision in Teton County sued in 2021 to clear their titles of three recorded versions of the subdivision's CC&Rs. The district court found the CC&Rs void but held a deed-referenced master plan created restrictive covenants and a public dedication. On Sept. 10, 2025 the Supreme Court reversed those conclusions and directed judgment for the owners.20 The lesson for buyers and boards: restrictions must be created with clear language in a recorded instrument; a plan drawing referenced in a deed is not enough.
Miller v. Rocking Ranch No. 3 (2024): design review and the fee bill
Glen Miller and Cynthia Anderson bought a lot in the Rocking Ranch No. 3 subdivision in Ketchum; the property owners' association denied their application to build a home, and they sued. The association counterclaimed for unpaid assessments, "the bulk of which were for legal fees the Association incurred as a result of this litigation." On Jan. 12, 2024 the Supreme Court affirmed summary judgment for the owners on that counterclaim, vacated the association's fee award, and overruled earlier cases "to the extent they suggest a non-prevailing party may receive its attorney fees on claims it did not prevail on."17 An HOA cannot turn its litigation bill into an assessment and collect it from the owner it is suing, and fee awards follow the claims actually won.
Stunja v. High Corral No. 2 (2026): fees follow the claim won
The Court of Appeals applied the same fee rule in an unpublished Jan. 14, 2026 opinion from Boise County. Vince and Lisa Stunja sued the High Corral No. 2 Property Owners Association over maintenance of dirt roads; the district court gave them all their requested attorney fees. The Court of Appeals reversed because the trial court "failed to consider the discrete claim the Stunjas prevailed on."23
Greenbriar Estates HOA v. Esposito (2023): the RV lot that was never annexed
John Esposito, the developer of Greenbriar Estates in Canyon County, kept a parcel he planned as an RV storage lot that had no access except across a lot the HOA held. The Supreme Court affirmed on March 22, 2023 that the 2012 partial settlement agreement required the HOA to formally annex the RV lot to create the easement, which never happened.15 Developer promises in side agreements are only as good as the recorded steps that carry them out.
Doyle v. Harris Ranch CID (2026): when the "HOA bill" is a tax
Some Idaho homeowners pay a community infrastructure district (CID), a taxing district that can finance roads and other public works in a new development, in addition to any HOA. Residents William Doyle and Lawrence Crowley and the Harris Ranch CID Taxpayers' Association challenged the Harris Ranch CID board's resolutions reimbursing the developers, which they said raised their taxes. On Feb. 12, 2026 the Supreme Court affirmed dismissal of their petition, in a case of first impression under the Community Infrastructure District Act, Idaho Code 50-3101 to 50-3121.24 In east Boise and other CID areas a household can owe both a CID tax and HOA dues; lesson 10, Buying a Home in a Growing Area, lists the records.
Short-term rental fights
Short-term rentals (homes rented for 30 days or less, under Idaho Code 63-1803(4)) produced the sharpest housing fights of the period. They pitted resort towns that are losing permanent residents against owners and the real estate industry, and they pitted HOAs against members who bought to rent. Three records tell the story: one Supreme Court opinion against a city, one against an HOA, and three legislative sessions that ended with House Bill 583. What HB 583 now says, section by section, is explained in Part B's The 2026 Housing Laws and for owners, neighbors and HOAs in lesson 05, Short-Term Rentals After HB 583.
Idaho Association of Realtors v. City of Lava Hot Springs (2025)
What happened. Lava Hot Springs, a small Bannock County resort town, allowed short-term rentals not occupied by an owner or manager only in its commercial zones, under its Ordinance 2006-5; owner-occupied bed-and-breakfast-style rentals were allowed in residential zones too. When the city denied John and Michelle Taylor a business license for a non-owner-occupied short-term rental in a residential zone, the Taylors and the Idaho Association of Realtors (a trade association, labeled as such) sued, asking for a declaration that the scheme exceeded the city's power under Idaho Code 67-6539.3
The city's case. The record the city built is the clearest statement of the resort-town side in any Idaho opinion. The town has no police department; Bannock County deputies do not issue citations for violating the city's building, zoning, business license, noise or parking ordinances; it has one code compliance officer. The Court noted the city's permanent population fell "from 521 in 2000 to 358 in 2020," a decline the city planner, Bruce Parker, attributed to "decreasing housing stock and increasing housing prices." The district court (Judge Robert C. Naftz) agreed the rule did not have the "express or practical effect" of prohibiting short-term rentals and was a reasonable health, safety and welfare regulation.3
Outcome. The Supreme Court, in an opinion by Chief Justice Bevan joined by the other four justices, reversed on May 21, 2025. The statute then said a short-term rental "shall be classified as a residential land use for zoning purposes," and no city may "enact or enforce any ordinance that has the express or practical effect of prohibiting short-term rentals or vacation rentals in the county or city." The Court's heading states its holding: "Ordinance 2006-5 violates the Short-term Rental and Vacation Rental Act."332
What it teaches. Even before HB 583, a city could not use zoning to keep non-owner-occupied rentals out of residential neighborhoods. The decision came the year before the 2026 law, which went further and barred city and county licenses, permits and fees to operate a short-term rental.

The legislative fight, 2024 to 2026
The short-term rental bill took three sessions. Each year a bill with nearly the same statement of purpose ("ensuring the right to rent their property is maintained") was introduced; the versions differed on whether cities could still license rentals.
- 2024: House Bill 506. Introduced by the House Business Committee on Feb. 8, 2024. Its statement of purpose said it "allows for local jurisdictions to license short-term rentals" and required safety disclosures. It was reported to the House floor on March 7 and then "Retained on General Orders" on March 8, 15 and 25 without a vote. It died when the session ended.33
- 2025: Senate Bill 1162 and Senate Bill 1163. SB 1162, from the Senate Judiciary and Rules Committee, was amended on the Senate floor and then failed on April 1, 2025, 11 ayes to 23 nays with one absent. A second bill, SB 1163, called the Tourism Revenue Protection Act, was referred to the Local Government and Taxation Committee on March 10 and went no further.1934
- 2026: House Bill 583. Introduced by the House Business Committee on Feb. 4, 2026, passed the House 54-16 on Feb. 12 (floor sponsor Rep. Redman) and the Senate 23-12 on March 9 (floor sponsor Sen. Lakey), and was signed by Gov. Brad Little on March 16, 2026, Session Laws 2026, chapter 22, effective July 1, 2026. Its statement of purpose dropped the licensing language. A competing Senate bill, SB 1263, which would have allowed business licenses only for investors running four or more rentals in a jurisdiction or a rental grossing more than $10,000 a year, was referred to the Senate Commerce and Human Resources Committee on Feb. 9 and did not come out.435
HOAs and short-term rentals after 2026
HB 583 limits what cities and counties may do; it does not touch HOA covenants. That leaves the private side of the fight to 55-3211 as the Court read it in North Henry's Lake, and to the Crystal Beach-style disputes over how a condo association writes and enforces rental rules. A restriction added by amendment binds a lot only if the lot's owner at the time signed; a later buyer of an unsigned lot takes it free of the restriction even though the amendment is recorded. Restrictions in a subdivision's original declaration raise different questions, which lesson 09 covers.12 Lesson 05 sets out the decision tree; lesson 09 covers the older Idaho cases that came before the statute.
Manufactured home parks and tiny homes
A manufactured home owner who rents a lot in a park owns a house that is expensive and sometimes impossible to move, on land someone else owns. When a park sells, the new owner's lot rent decides whether residents can stay. Idaho's Manufactured Home Residency Act (Idaho Code Title 55, Chapter 20) sets notice rules for rent increases, closures and sales; lesson 06, Mobile and Manufactured Home Parks, explains each section. For 2023 to 2026 we found no Idaho appellate opinion on a park sale or closure. The disputes are on the record in other places: news reports of rent increases and tenant organizing, a fair housing case at an RV park, and two bills.
Latah County parks and "economic eviction" (2024 to 2025)
What happened, as reported. Northwest Public Broadcasting reported on Jan. 13, 2025 that residents of four mobile home parks near Moscow owned by Hurst & Son, a real estate investment company based in Port Orchard, Washington, faced rising lot rents and notices to pay or vacate that, the report said, "eventually grew to amounts in the thousands." One Woodland Heights resident, Suzy James, said her lot rent of $340 a month was raised; the report gives both $525 and $600 as later figures without reconciling them. Residents formed a resident cooperative in 2023 and asked the City of Moscow about a housing authority; Deputy City Administrator Cody Riddle said the council would first have to decide whether to explore it. The report says that in 2024 the Intermountain Fair Housing Council (a nonprofit fair housing group) helped a tenant sue Hurst & Son and that the settlement credited the tenant for overpayments. Hurst & Son did not respond to the reporter.30
Record status. The court file for the 2024 suit is not named in the report; we did not find it in the appellate record. It would be in iCourt under Latah County civil cases if it was filed in state court.
What it teaches. Lot rent increases are the most common park dispute and rarely produce an opinion. The record a reporter or resident can check is the written rent increase notice, the rental agreement and the park rules, measured against the notice periods in Title 55, Chapter 20.
An Eagle park formerly named Riviera Estates, 2025
Idaho News 6 (KIVI) reported on Oct. 26, 2025 that residents of a mobile home community near Eagle Island State Park, formerly named Riviera Estates, formed a chapter of the Treasure Valley Tenants Union after the park was bought by a commercial real estate company based in San Diego. Union leaders said 33 of 38 occupied lots joined. Residents described rent and utility increases "by hundreds of dollars in just a few months," eviction notices, boil water notices and tree removal without notice; the station said the owner had not responded by deadline.31 No court record of the dispute was found as of Nov. 19, 2026.
Decker v. City of Meridian (2026): a tiny home on a rented pad
What happened. In 2022 Robert Calacal bought a single-family home in Meridian that had RV hookups for water, power and sewer and planned to rent them to help pay his mortgage. Chasidy Decker signed a lease and on May 18, 2022 moved her 252-square-foot tiny home, built on a chassis and certified as an RV, onto his lot. A neighbor complained the next day. Meridian's code enforcement officer told them the tiny home could not be lived in as a secondary dwelling unit because it was not on an improved foundation. They sued, represented in part by the Institute for Justice (a public interest law firm, labeled as such), claiming violations of substantive due process and equal protection through selective enforcement.29
Outcome. On Nov. 9, 2026 the Supreme Court (Justice Moeller) affirmed dismissal without prejudice of the due process claims as not ripe for decision and dismissal with prejudice of the selective enforcement claims, and awarded costs to the city.29
What it teaches. Renting space for a small home is a housing arrangement cities still regulate through zoning, and the first record in such a dispute is a code enforcement file. The 2026 ADU law (SB 1354, Idaho Code 67-6541) changes what cities over 10,000 must allow as accessory units after its Feb. 1, 2027 code deadline; Part B's lesson 03 explains it.
Park and manufactured home bills, 2024 to 2026
| Bill | What it would do (statement of purpose) | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| HB 424 (2024) | Change notice to a mobile home community resident association "when the property owner intends to sell their property" | Reached the House floor; moved to General Orders Feb. 9, then returned to the Business Committee Feb. 26, 2024; died36 |
| HB 647 (2026) | Treat manufactured duplexes as multifamily, allow manufactured homes on small lots, and bar covenants from "unreasonably restricting manufactured homes" | Referred to House Business Feb. 13, 2026; died37 |
| HB 800 (2026) | Treat manufactured duplexes as multifamily in zoning; allow single-section homes of at least 400 square feet on lots zoned single-family and multi-section homes of at least 800 square feet on lots zoned multifamily | Passed House 60-6, Senate 28-5; signed March 26, 2026; Session Laws ch. 171; effective July 1, 202625 |
HB 800 is the narrower rewrite of HB 647: it kept the zoning changes and dropped the limit on private covenants. That choice matters for HOAs: HB 800 does not tell an HOA what it may do about manufactured homes.3725
Landlord and tenant cases
Thousands of eviction cases are filed in Idaho each year, but very few reach an appellate court. The few that do tend to involve hybrid deals, where a tenant also claims a right to buy, because those cases carry more money and more legal questions than an ordinary unpaid-rent case. Eviction procedure is in lesson 04, Evictions Step by Step.
Pickering v. Sanchez (2024): lease to own or lease with option?
What happened. Melissa Sanchez and Chris and Jennifer Pickering signed an agreement for Sanchez to lease, and possibly buy, a mobile home the Pickerings owned in Canyon County. Sanchez paid a $10,000 down payment. She believed it was a "lease to own" contract; the Pickerings believed it was a "lease with purchase option." The Pickerings filed an eviction action over alleged lease violations; Sanchez tried to exercise the purchase option; and after she was forced to leave, the Pickerings sued for waste, alleging $40,000 in damage to the interior and seeking treble damages. Sanchez counterclaimed under the Idaho Consumer Protection Act, alleging, among other things, that the Pickerings did not disclose that they lacked title when they signed.18
Outcome. On appeal Sanchez did not challenge her liability for the damage or the ruling that the agreement was unenforceable. The Supreme Court (Justice Brody) affirmed the district court on Feb. 22, 2024, including its conclusion that the Pickerings did not engage in a deceptive act under the Consumer Protection Act, and awarded the Pickerings attorney fees on one issue and costs.18
What it teaches. Informal rent-to-own deals on homes are a recurring source of loss for both sides. A written agreement that does not say clearly what is being bought, when and from whom leaves the dispute to an expensive trial.
Clark v. Conger (2025) and Conger v. Clark (2026): one house, two appeals
The eviction. In 2016 Jay P. Clark leased his Mountain Home house to Jeff Conger with an option for Conger to buy it. On Oct. 10, 2022 Clark filed an unlawful detainer (eviction) case alleging late rent and serving a 30-day notice. When Clark did not file a notice of appearance within the 21 days the magistrate court ordered, the court dismissed his eviction case with prejudice and awarded Conger fees. The district court affirmed on intermediate appeal, and the Court of Appeals affirmed on Oct. 24, 2025 in an unpublished opinion.21
The option. Conger, who had paid $8,000 for the option, sued to enforce it after Clark refused it in December 2022. The district court held he lacked standing because he had not disclosed the contract in an earlier bankruptcy, so it remained property of the bankruptcy estate. The Supreme Court affirmed on Sept. 4, 2026.26
What it teaches. Procedure decides many housing cases: a landlord who misses a court deadline loses the eviction case, and a tenant who leaves an asset off a bankruptcy schedule loses the right to enforce it.
Squatters, sheriffs and eviction records: the 2024 to 2026 tenant bills
The Legislature changed the eviction system three times in three years.
- Shielding dismissed eviction records (SB 1327, 2024). The statement of purpose says records of an unlawful detainer case that is dismissed will be shielded from public view automatically "three years after the unlawful detainer is filed," if no appeal is pending; court staff and the parties keep access. The bill passed the Senate 31-3 and the House 67-0, was signed April 3, 2024, and became Session Laws 2024, chapter 269, effective July 1, 2024.7
- A sheriff's removal process for unauthorized occupants (HB 321, 2025). New Idaho Code 6-310A lets an owner ask the sheriff to remove "unauthorized persons" from a residential dwelling if eight conditions are met, including that the occupants "are not current or former tenants pursuant to a written or oral rental agreement." It created crimes for presenting a false lease and for fraudulently selling or leasing residential property. It passed the House 64-3 and the Senate 35-0 and was signed March 31, 2025 (Session Laws 2025, ch. 222).3839
- A one-word fix (HB 695, 2026). The 2026 bill changed "possession" to "restitution" in 6-310A; it passed 68-0 and 34-0 and was signed March 20, 2026 (ch. 82).40
Because 6-310A excludes current and former tenants, it does not replace the eviction process; lesson 04 explains the difference. A 2024 bill to add a process when a landlord of a hotel or short-term rental believes a tenant is engaged in illegal drug activity (HB 641) was referred to the House Judiciary, Rules and Administration Committee on Feb. 26, 2024 and went no further.41
Fees, rent and local control: the bills that passed and the ones that did not
House Bill 545 (2024). Sponsored by the House State Affairs Committee, HB 545 amended the state's ban on local rent control (then Idaho Code 55-307) so that no local government may "enact, maintain, or enforce" an ordinance that forces participation in an optional federal housing assistance program, such as housing choice vouchers, or that regulates rent, fees or deposits for private residential leases. It passed the House 59-11 on Feb. 26, 2024 and the Senate 26-9 on March 25, and was signed April 1, 2024 (Session Laws 2024, ch. 257).6 The roll calls are on the bill page; the committee minutes record who testified for and against. The 2025 reorganization, SB 1043, moved the provision to 55-306 without changing it; lesson 01 explains the renumbering.42
Rental application fee limits (SB 1042, 2025, and HB 701, 2026). SB 1042's statement of purpose would have allowed only two applicant households to be charged application fees at a time, required that the rental be available or expected to be available within 60 days, and required ads to disclose screening criteria. It was amended on the Senate floor and passed 23-12 on Feb. 19, 2025, then was referred to the House Business Committee on Feb. 20 and never received a vote. The 2026 version, HB 701, with nearly the same terms, was referred to House Business on Feb. 17, 2026 and died there.89
What the pair teaches. In this period the Legislature consistently limited what cities may require of landlords and declined to set new statewide rules for landlords on application fees. A renter's remedies on fees remain the lease, the notice rules now in 55-304 and 55-305, and the Consumer Protection Act. Lesson 02, Owning a Rental Legally, and lesson 03, Renting Safely: Tenant Rights, explain both sides.
HOA bills and the Attorney General
From 2024 through 2026, HOA rules were among the most-filed housing subjects in the Legislature. Four HOA bills became law; at least seven died in committee.
| Bill | Subject | Votes and result |
|---|---|---|
| HB 543 (2024) | HOAs may not add restrictions barring a family daycare home unless the restriction was in the CC&Rs when the property was bought | House 68-0, Senate 34-1; signed March 25, 2024; ch. 19143 |
| HB 589 (2024) | No fee for an owner's statement of assessment account; no transfer fee "unless it is expressly allowed by the CC&Rs" | House 67-0, Senate 33-1; signed March 22, 2024; ch. 16211 |
| HB 621 (2024) | Defines "community manager"; board members must declare conflicts of interest or family ties with contractors | House 69-0, Senate 31-3; signed March 28, 2024; ch. 21444 |
| HB 657 (2024) | Owner seats on the board at 75 percent build-out, full turnover at 95 percent, proxy limits, 15-business-day replies | Referred to House Business Feb. 26, 2024; died45 |
| SB 1286 (2024) | HOAs may not require grass lawns (xeriscaping option) | Referred to Senate Commerce Feb. 8, 2024; died46 |
| HB 361 (2025) | For HOAs formed after July 1, 2025: at least one-third of board seats for owners within 180 days after 75 percent of lots are conveyed; full turnover begun once 95 percent is built and occupied and completed within 12 months; proxy rules | House 66-0, Senate 35-0; signed March 28, 2025; ch. 20447 |
| HB 404 (2025) | Residential chicken ownership, including in HOAs | Referred to House Agricultural Affairs March 14, 2025; died48 |
| HB 708 (2026) | Automatic HOA dissolution unless members vote every 10 years to keep it | Referred to House Business Feb. 17, 2026; died49 |
| SB 1277 (2026) | ADUs by right; covenants may not ban them | Referred to Senate Commerce Feb. 12, 2026; died (SB 1354 carried the HOA ADU rule instead)50 |
| SB 1280 (2026) | Twin homes and duplexes allowed where single-family homes are; covenants may not ban them | Referred to Senate Commerce Feb. 12, 2026; died51 |
| HB 963 (2026) | HOA quorum definition; new "joint ownership association" without power over aesthetics; members vote every 10 years | Introduced March 27, 2026, referred to Ways and Means; died52 |
HB 361's turnover rules are the subject of lesson 07, and the HOA part of SB 1354 (Idaho Code 55-3212 on ADUs) is explained in Part B's lesson 03. Two features of this list stand out. HOA bills that set a single, narrow rule (daycare, transfer fees, conflicts, turnover) passed with almost no opposition. Bills that would have changed what kinds of housing an HOA may forbid (duplexes, manufactured homes, lawns) or whether an HOA exists at all died without a floor vote. The one exception is ADUs, where SB 1354 passed in 2026.
The Attorney General's HOA transfer fee settlements (2026)
What happened. On May 8, 2026, Attorney General Raul Labrador announced that Pristine Springs Homeowners Association (Ada County), Armstrong Park Homeowners Association (Kootenai County) and Park Pointe Management Services (Ada County), which the release says contracts with about 70 HOAs across Idaho, signed Assurances of Voluntary Compliance after homeowners complained of transfer fees not disclosed in the governing documents. An Assurance of Voluntary Compliance is a written agreement with the Attorney General under the Idaho Consumer Protection Act in which a business agrees to change its practices.10
Terms. Armstrong Park must refund $195 to any homeowner improperly charged a transfer fee within 30 days; Park Pointe must identify and refund all homeowners from whom it improperly collected transfer fees within 90 days; the release states no refund terms for Pristine Springs. The office will monitor all three. The release says management companies have "no authority under Idaho law" to charge transfer fees and quotes Labrador: "Hidden fees collected without legal authority violate Idaho law."10
What it teaches. The 2024 statute (HB 589) gave the Attorney General a clear rule to enforce: a transfer fee must be "expressly allowed" by the CC&Rs. It also shows the Attorney General using the Consumer Protection Act to enforce it.1110
MV Realty "Homeowner Benefit" contracts (2025)
HousingWire, a real estate trade publication, reported on Dec. 2, 2025 that the Idaho Attorney General's office reached a settlement in November 2025 with MV Realty, whose "Homeowner Benefit Program" paid homeowners a small one-time sum for the exclusive right to list their homes for up to 40 years. As reported, the contracts are voided, MV Realty must ask every Idaho county recorder to remove the recorded contracts, and the company and three executives are barred from Idaho residential real estate for five years.22 We could not retrieve the Attorney General's own release or the court record on Nov. 19, 2026; the terms are listed as unverified below. The records to check are the recorded memoranda of the agreements at each county recorder.
Fair housing cases
United States v. Nourse (2024 to 2026): an assistance dog at a Caldwell RV park
What happened. The U.S. Department of Justice filed suit on Oct. 9, 2024 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Idaho against Joy Nourse and others, the managers and owners of Decoy RV Park in Caldwell. The complaint alleged they refused a reasonable accommodation to a tenant with disabilities by barring her assistance dog because it weighed more than 15 pounds, charged her a "pet fee," made statements that assistance animals over 15 pounds would not be allowed, and evicted her shortly after she asked for the accommodation and filed a complaint with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). The case came to the Justice Department after HUD investigated and issued a charge of discrimination.12
Outcome. Under a settlement agreement dated Jan. 26, 2026, the defendants agreed to pay $20,000 in damages to the tenant, take fair housing training, and adopt a new reasonable accommodation policy.13
What it teaches. The government's case treated the assistance dog as a reasonable accommodation under the federal Fair Housing Act rather than a pet subject to the park's weight limit and pet fee, and treated the eviction that followed the HUD complaint as retaliation. The rule applies to an RV park used as a home just as it does to an apartment. Lesson 01 explains the Fair Housing Act and the Idaho Human Rights Act; lesson 02 covers assistance animals.

Neighbors, shelters and city approvals
These two Boise cases are land use cases, but they touch renters and the unhoused directly, so they belong in this casebook. The land use doctrine behind them (judicial review under the Local Land Use Planning Act and who has standing) is in Part B's Property Rights and Land Use Law.
Veterans Park Neighborhood Association v. City of Boise (2025): the Interfaith Sanctuary shelter
What happened. Interfaith Sanctuary Housing Services, which runs a downtown Boise shelter, applied for a conditional use permit (CUP, a permit for a use allowed in a zone only with conditions) to move to a new shelter in Northwest Boise. The Planning and Zoning Commission denied it; Interfaith appealed to the City Council, which reversed and granted the permit. The Veterans Park Neighborhood Association asked the council to reconsider, was refused, and petitioned for judicial review. District Judge Cynthia Yee-Wallace upheld the council.5
Outcome. On Jan. 22, 2025 the Supreme Court (Justice Moeller, joined by the other four justices) reversed. It concluded "the City Council's decision to grant the CUP was arbitrary and capricious and based on unlawful procedure," that the council's reasoned statement was inadequate under the Local Land Use Planning Act, and that the association "suffered prejudice to its substantial rights," and it remanded "with instructions to invalidate the actions of the City Council." The association received costs but no attorney fees.5 Boise State Public Radio reported the same day that Interfaith's executive director, Jodi Petersen-Stigers, said Interfaith would petition for rehearing, and that the city was reviewing the ruling.53
What it teaches. When a council overturns its planning commission on a contested permit, its written decision has to explain why with reference to the code and the evidence. Shelter and supportive housing projects are permits like any other under that rule.
North West Neighborhood Association v. City of Boise (2023)
The North West Neighborhood Association, neighbors in the "Old Hill Road" area of northwest Boise annexed into the city in 2014, challenged the City Council's approval of three related land use applications for a development there. On Sept. 7, 2023 the Supreme Court held the council failed to give the reasoned statement Idaho Code 67-6535(2) requires and ordered the approvals set aside and returned to the council.16 The two Boise cases, 16 months apart, rest on the same rule.
The Magic Valley record
For Twin Falls, Jerome, Gooding, Kimberly, Buhl and Hagerman, we found no 2023 to 2026 appellate opinion on an HOA, a landlord and tenant, a manufactured home park or a short-term rental. That is a finding, not a gap in effort: the opinions filter covered every Supreme Court and Court of Appeals civil opinion in the period. The Magic Valley's appellate housing record is land use, and Part B covers it: Renaissance Project Development v. Twin Falls County (2024), on a preliminary plat, and HMI, Hamilton Manufacturing v. City of Twin Falls (2026), both in Property Rights and Land Use Law, and the Jerome and Twin Falls County annexation fights in Annexation Fights.
The trial-court record is larger. Boise State's Idaho Policy Institute, using Idaho Supreme Court eviction case data, counted 155 eviction filings in Twin Falls County in 2025 and 88 formal evictions, 56.8 percent of filings, compared with 19.3 percent in Ada County. The institute's county table does not list Jerome, Gooding or Lincoln counties.14 Each Magic Valley eviction, HOA collection suit and quiet title case is a public file in the Fifth Judicial District, searchable by party name in iCourt.
The statewide laws in this casebook reach the Magic Valley in different ways. HB 583 on short-term rentals applies to every city and county. HB 800 on manufactured homes amends the statute that applies to every city and county. The HOA statutes (55-3211 on rentals, the 2024 transfer fee and conflict rules, and HB 361) apply to HOAs in Twin Falls, Jerome and Gooding counties as they apply statewide; HB 361's turnover rules in 55-3204A reach only HOAs formed after July 1, 2025. The 2026 ADU and starter home laws apply only in cities over 10,000, which in the Magic Valley are Twin Falls, Jerome and Burley, as Part B's lesson 03 explains.425247

Patterns across the cases
Written consent decides rental fights inside HOAs
From the 2020 Crystal Beach objections under former 55-115(3) to North Henry's Lake in 2026, the private short-term rental fight turned on one fact: whether the owner of the affected property signed when the restriction was added. The Court read the statute literally and said it would apply it "as written, irrespective of any concerns that may arise in determining whether a particular property is subject to a rental restriction."127
The state kept limiting local rules
HB 545 (2024) widened the ban on local rent, fee and deposit rules; Lava Hot Springs (2025) struck a city's zoning limit on non-owner-occupied rentals; and HB 583 (2026) barred licenses and permits to operate short-term rentals. Bills that would have put new statewide rules on landlords' fees (SB 1042, HB 701) died. Part B's State Preemption and Local Control explains the long history of this pattern.6348
Attorney fees often decide who can afford to fight
Four of the HOA opinions turned partly on fees. Miller overruled precedent so a party recovers fees only for claims it won; Stunja applied that rule against homeowners; Colton vacated fee awards against a self-represented neighbor; and North Henry's Lake denied fees to the winning owners because the HOA's appeal was not frivolous.1723281
Procedure ends many cases before the merits
The Mountain Home landlord lost his eviction for missing a filing deadline; the tenant-buyer lost his option for leaving it off a bankruptcy schedule; the McCall condo owners lost most claims because they were framed as the association's claims; and the Meridian tiny home owners' due process claims were dismissed as not ripe.21262729
City decisions must explain themselves
Both Boise neighborhood cases were won on the same ground: the council's written decision did not explain how the approval met the code. Neither opinion decided whether a shelter or a development was good or bad for the neighborhood.516
Does a later HOA rental rule bind this lot?
The question at the center of the HOA rental cases can be laid out as a short decision path built from the words of Idaho Code 55-3211 and the holding in North Henry's Lake. It describes how the Court read the statute; it is not a ruling on any particular lot, and covenants, condominium declarations and facts differ.21
Pictures, Numbers and Infographics
The key numbers and dates in this casebook, each with its source.
| Measure or rule | Idaho | U.S. or other states | Place or year | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eviction filings in Idaho courts | 3,415 filings; 1,234 formal evictions (36.1 percent); the source's county table prints 3,283 and 1,308 in its statewide row, which do not match its own 36.1 percent, so the chart and text values are used here | Not compared in the source | 2025, statewide | Idaho Policy Institute14 |
| Share of filings ending in formal eviction | Ada 19.3 percent; Twin Falls 56.8 percent; Bonneville 60.9 percent | Not compared | 2025, by county | Idaho Policy Institute14 |
| Change in filings from 2024 | Down 6.2 percent; formal evictions down 5.7 percent | Not compared | 2024 to 2025 | Idaho Policy Institute14 |
| Dismissed eviction records shielded | Automatically, three years after filing, if no appeal pending | See lesson 04 for other states | Law since July 1, 2024 | SB 1327 (2024)7 |
| Later HOA rental restriction | Binds a lot only if its owner agreed in writing when added | See lesson 09 | Supreme Court, Jan. 6, 2026 | 55-3211; North Henry's Lake1 |
| HOA transfer fee | Only if "expressly allowed" by the CC&Rs | See lesson 08 for other states | Law since July 1, 2024 | HB 589 (2024)11 |
| HOA transfer fee refund (Armstrong Park HOA) | $195 per improperly charged owner, within 30 days | Not applicable | Kootenai County, May 8, 2026 | Attorney General10 |
| HOA owner board seats and turnover | HOAs formed after July 1, 2025 only: one-third of seats within 180 days after 75 percent of lots conveyed; full turnover within 12 months after 95 percent built and occupied | See lesson 07 for other states | Law since July 1, 2025 | HB 361 (2025)47 |
| Fair housing settlement | $20,000 damages, training, new policy | Federal Fair Housing Act case | Caldwell, Jan. 26, 2026 | United States v. Nourse13 |
| Lava Hot Springs permanent residents | 521 in 2000; 358 in 2020 (city planner's figures in the record) | Not compared | Bannock County | Lava Hot Springs opinion3 |
| HB 583 short-term rental votes | House 54-16; Senate 23-12; signed March 16, 2026 | See lesson 05 for other states | Effective July 1, 2026 | HB 583 bill page4 |
| Application fee cap bill | Senate 23-12 (2025); no House vote in 2025 or 2026 | See lesson 02 for other states | 2025 and 2026 | SB 1042; HB 70189 |
| Tiny home in the Meridian case | 252 square feet, on a chassis, certified as an RV | Not compared | Meridian, 2022 facts; decided Nov. 9, 2026 | Decker opinion29 |
Common mistakes
Assuming a recorded rental ban binds every later buyer
The HOA in North Henry's Lake argued exactly this: a buyer who takes title with notice of a recorded short-term rental ban should be bound. The Supreme Court rejected it. Under 55-3211, a restriction added by amendment does not reach a lot whose owner at the time did not agree in writing, and that protection stays with the lot.1
Assuming a city can confine short-term rentals to commercial zones
Lava Hot Springs did exactly that, and the district court agreed. The Supreme Court reversed in 2025 because the state act classifies short-term rentals as a residential use and bars rules with the "practical effect" of prohibiting them. HB 583 (2026) narrowed local power further.34
Treating an HOA's legal bills as an assessment
In Miller, the Rocking Ranch No. 3 association billed the owners it was suing for its own legal fees as "assessments." The Supreme Court affirmed judgment for the owners on that counterclaim and limited fee awards to claims actually won.17
Charging transfer fees the CC&Rs do not allow
Since July 1, 2024, an HOA may charge a transfer fee only if the CC&Rs expressly allow it. The Attorney General's 2026 settlements required refunds where fees were charged anyway, including by a management company.1110
Applying pet rules to an assistance animal
The Decoy RV Park case began with a 15-pound weight limit and a pet fee applied to a tenant's assistance dog, and the eviction that followed her HUD complaint was alleged as retaliation. It ended in a $20,000 settlement.1213
Using the 2025 sheriff removal law against a tenant
Idaho Code 6-310A applies only if the occupants "are not current or former tenants pursuant to a written or oral rental agreement." A tenant, even one who stopped paying, is removed through an unlawful detainer case, not a sheriff's complaint under 6-310A.39
Missing a court deadline in a simple eviction
The Mountain Home landlord in Clark v. Conger lost his eviction case, with prejudice, and paid the tenant's fees after he did not file a notice of appearance within the 21 days the magistrate ordered.21
A council reversing its commission without written reasons
Boise lost both neighborhood cases because the council's written decision did not explain its reasoning under the code. A council's vote is not the end of the record; the reasoned statement is.516
What we know, what we don't, and what the data can show
What we know
- From January 2023 through Nov. 18, 2026, the Idaho Supreme Court issued 13 opinions and the Court of Appeals 2 opinions in the housing disputes listed in this casebook; the most important for HOAs is North Henry's Lake (2026), and for cities, Lava Hot Springs (2025).13
- The Legislature passed HB 545 and SB 1327 (2024), HB 321 and SB 1043 (2025), and HB 583, HB 800 and HB 695 (2026) on renting, evictions, short-term rentals and manufactured homes, and four HOA bills in 2024 and 2025.6738425
- Rental application fee limits passed the Senate once (2025) and never received a House vote.89
- The Attorney General used the Consumer Protection Act against HOA transfer fees in 2026, and the U.S. Justice Department settled a fair housing case in Caldwell in 2026.1013
- Idaho courts saw 3,415 eviction filings in 2025.14
What we don't know
- How many HOA lawsuits, HOA lien foreclosures and rental restriction disputes are filed in district courts each year; no one publishes a count.
- How many manufactured home parks in Idaho were sold or closed from 2023 to 2026, and what happened to lot rents after each sale; no state agency tracks park sales.
- Whether the Idaho Human Rights Commission resolved housing complaints in this period and on what terms; we did not find published housing decisions.
- Whether Interfaith Sanctuary's rehearing petition or a new application changed the outcome after January 2025; we did not read a later record.
- The full terms of the MV Realty settlement and the court in which it was entered, which we could read only in a trade news report.
- Any Magic Valley housing dispute that ended in a trial-court judgment but was not appealed.
What the data can show
- Eviction trends by county, from the Idaho Supreme Court's eviction case data as compiled by the Idaho Policy Institute each year, and from iCourt case searches.
- HOA collection and lien activity, from county recorder indexes (search the HOA's name as grantor of liens and releases) and iCourt civil cases naming an HOA as plaintiff.
- Who wins housing appeals, from the Idaho courts' opinion records, which carry docket numbers, dates and outcomes that can be coded by type of party.
- Legislative patterns, from the Legislature's bill pages and roll calls, which allow every vote on every housing bill to be tabulated by member and year.
- Short-term rental tax permits, from the Idaho State Tax Commission if it releases counts by city or county; lesson 05 describes what is published.
Questions people ask
My HOA voted to ban short-term rentals after I bought. Does that apply to my lot?
Under Idaho Code 55-3211 as the Supreme Court read it in North Henry's Lake (2026), an HOA may not enforce a rental restriction added by amendment against a lot unless that lot's owner at the time agreed in writing. The opinion and the statute are the starting points; how they apply depends on the covenants and the record of who signed. Lesson 09 walks through the cases.12
Can my city still require a short-term rental license?
As amended by HB 583 (2026), Idaho Code 67-6539 bars cities and counties from requiring a license, fee, permit or registration to operate a short-term rental, and lists a few safety rules they may still impose. Part B's lesson 03 and lesson 05 here set out the full text.432
Will an eviction case show up forever?
Not if it was dismissed. Under SB 1327 (2024), records of a dismissed unlawful detainer case are shielded from public view automatically three years after filing if no appeal is pending. Cases that ended in a judgment are not covered by that bill.7
Can my HOA or its manager charge a transfer fee when I sell?
Only if the CC&Rs expressly allow it, under HB 589 (2024). The Attorney General's office took that position against two HOAs and a management company in May 2026 and required refunds.1110
What happens when a mobile home park is sold?
The Manufactured Home Residency Act sets notice rules for rent increases, rule changes and closures; lesson 06 explains each. A 2024 bill to change how resident associations are notified of a planned sale (HB 424) died. In this period, park sale disputes appeared in news reports, not appellate opinions.3630
Can a sheriff remove squatters without a court case now?
Since July 1, 2025, Idaho Code 6-310A lets an owner ask the sheriff to remove unauthorized occupants of a residential dwelling if eight conditions are met, one of which is that they are not current or former tenants. It does not apply to tenants.3938
Where can I read these cases?
Every opinion here is posted free by the Idaho courts by docket number, and the trial-court files are searchable in iCourt. Lesson 12, How to Report on Housing, walks through the searches.
Hard questions
Should HOAs be able to ban rentals by majority vote?
For owner consent (the current law). An owner who bought a lot that could be rented paid for that right; a later vote by neighbors should not take it away without the owner's agreement. The Legislature wrote that rule in 2022 and the Court enforced it literally.21 For majority rule. An HOA is a private self-governing community; owners agreed to covenants that can be amended, and short-term rentals can change a small subdivision or a condo building in ways owners did not expect, as the Crystal Beach rental rules show.27 What the evidence shows. The record shows the rule; it does not show how many Idaho subdivisions have tried to add rental bans or how rentals affect them. No state data exist.
Should resort towns be able to keep short-term rentals out of residential neighborhoods?
For local limits. Lava Hot Springs' record shows a town losing permanent residents (521 to 358 from 2000 to 2020), with one code officer and no police department. Resort towns argue only local rules can protect housing for workers.3 For statewide limits. Owners argue renting a house is a residential use and a property right; the Legislature agreed in HB 583, 54-16 and 23-12.4 What the evidence shows. The opinion records the city's figures; it does not measure how much of the decline short-term rentals caused. The 2025 Senate vote (11-23 against SB 1162) shows the Senate was split on how far to go a year before HB 583 passed.19
Should Idaho cap rental application fees?
For a cap. SB 1042's sponsors wrote that tenants are charged fees for units they have little chance of renting, and proposed limiting fees to two applicant households at a time. Against. Twelve senators voted no, and the House never took it up in two sessions; opponents can point to landlords' screening costs, and the Legislature has preferred not to add new statewide rules on landlords' fees.89 What the evidence shows. No Idaho data on application fees or the number of applications per vacancy were in the bill record.
Who should decide where a shelter goes?
For the council's power. Cities must site shelters somewhere, and elected councils weigh need against neighborhood impact. For neighbors' review. The Veterans Park case shows the procedure protects neighbors when a council's decision does not explain itself. What the evidence shows. The Supreme Court decided procedure, not the merits of the shelter.5
For reporters and advocates
Records that exist. Appellate opinions by docket number on the Idaho courts' site; trial-court files, including every eviction, HOA collection suit and quiet title action, in iCourt (see Reading a Docket); recorded CC&Rs, amendments, consents, HOA liens and releases at the county recorder; the Legislature's bill pages with roll calls, statements of purpose and committee minutes; Attorney General press releases and, on request, Assurances of Voluntary Compliance; the Justice Department's case pages with complaints and settlements; city planning files with staff reports and reasoned statements; and city code enforcement files, as in the Meridian tiny home case.
Questions to ask.
- For an HOA rental ban: when was it added, by what vote, and which owners signed written consents at that time? Are the consents recorded?
- For an HOA fee: which CC&R section authorizes it, and who collects it, the HOA or a manager?
- For a park sale: what notices went to residents and when, and what is the new lot rent compared with the old?
- For an eviction story: was the case dismissed, and will it be shielded under SB 1327? Should the tenant be named at all? (Lesson 12 covers privacy.)
- For a council decision: does the written reasoned statement explain how the approval meets each code standard?
- For a bill: who testified, and what do the committee minutes record as each side's evidence?
Public records requests. City code enforcement logs, short-term rental complaint files, Attorney General consumer complaints, and Human Rights Commission records can be requested under the Idaho Public Records Act, Idaho Code Title 74, Chapter 1, with some exemptions; see Idaho Public Records Requests.
The Magic Valley angle. The appellate record is quiet, so the stories are in the Fifth Judicial District's files: Twin Falls County's 155 eviction filings in 2025 and 56.8 percent formal eviction rate; HOA suits in new Twin Falls and Jerome subdivisions; manufactured home placement under HB 800; and how Twin Falls and Jerome rewrite their codes for the 2026 ADU and starter home laws.1425
Where to go next
- Idaho Supreme Court opinions: Free official list of Supreme Court opinions with staff summaries; search by docket number (51990, 50888, 51027) or party name. Court of Appeals opinions are linked from the same page.
- Idaho iCourt Portal: Free public search of Idaho trial-court cases, including evictions and HOA suits, by party name or case number; some documents cost a fee to view or copy. Lesson 66/02 explains how to use it.
- Idaho Legislature legislation pages: Free bill lists for each session with bill text, statements of purpose, roll call votes and session law chapters; change the year in the address for 2024 or 2025.
- Idaho Attorney General consumer protection: Official site with consumer complaint forms, the Landlord and Tenant Manual and press releases on settlements such as the 2026 HOA transfer fee agreements; free.
- U.S. Department of Justice Housing and Civil Enforcement Section cases: Free federal list of fair housing cases with complaints and settlements, including United States v. Nourse (D. Idaho); search 'Idaho'.
- Idaho Policy Institute eviction data: Free annual county counts of eviction filings and formal evictions from Boise State University, built on Idaho Supreme Court data; a university research institute.
- Idaho Legal Aid Services: A nonprofit that provides free civil legal help to eligible low-income Idahoans and publishes free self-help guides on housing, evictions and manufactured homes.
Still being checked (6 items)
These points could not be fully confirmed against a primary source when this lesson was written and fact checked in November 2026. The text above states each one as uncertain.
- MV Realty settlement: the November 2025 date, the voiding of contracts, the recorder removals and the five-year ban come from a HousingWire report; we could not retrieve the Attorney General's release or the court record on Nov. 19, 2026.
- Whether Interfaith Sanctuary's petition for rehearing was filed or decided, and what happened to the shelter project after Jan. 22, 2025; we read only the opinion and a same-day news report.
- The Latah County park facts (lot rents of $340, $525 and $600; a 2024 Intermountain Fair Housing Council suit and settlement) and the facts about the former Riviera Estates park in Eagle come from news reports only; we found no court record.
- We found no Idaho Human Rights Commission housing decision for 2023 to 2026 and did not search its files; none is reported here.
- We read the staff summary, not the full opinion, of Conger v. Clark (Docket 52800, 2026).
- Our opinion filter may have missed housing opinions whose captions and summaries did not contain the search words; trial-court decisions that were not appealed are not covered.
Last verified November 19, 2026. General education, not legal, tax, financial or real estate advice; every figure names its source and year in the Notes and Sources below. Data is revised: check the newest release before relying on any number.
Notes
- Idaho Supreme Court, North Henry's Lake Homeowners Association, Inc. v. Norton, Docket No. 51990, opinion filed Jan. 6, 2026 (Brody, J.; Bevan, C.J., and Moeller, Zahn and Meyer, JJ., concurring), appeal from the Seventh Judicial District, Fremont County, Judge Joel E. Tingey; affirmed (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 55-3211, Prohibited conduct, rental restrictions, Idaho Legislature statute page; history: added 2022, ch. 323, sec. 4, p. 1045 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Supreme Court, Idaho Association of Realtors, Inc. v. City of Lava Hot Springs, Docket No. 50888, opinion filed May 21, 2025 (Bevan, C.J.; Brody, Moeller, Zahn and Meyer, JJ., concurring), appeal from the Sixth Judicial District, Bannock County, Judge Robert C. Naftz; reversed (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 583 (2026), Business Committee, Short-term rentals: bill page with roll calls (House 54-16-0 on Feb. 12; Senate 23-12-0 on March 9), statement of purpose RS33170; signed March 16, 2026; Session Laws 2026, ch. 22; effective July 1, 2026 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Supreme Court, Veterans Park Neighborhood Association, Inc. v. City of Boise, Docket No. 51027, opinion filed Jan. 22, 2025 (Moeller, J.; Bevan, C.J., and Brody, Zahn and Meyer, JJ., concurring), appeal from the Fourth Judicial District, Ada County, Judge Cynthia Yee-Wallace; reversed and remanded with instructions to invalidate the City Council's action; Interfaith Sanctuary Housing Services, Inc. was intervenor (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 545 (2024), State Affairs Committee, Property (local governments may not force participation in optional federal housing assistance or regulate rent, fees or deposits): bill page with roll calls (House 59-11-0 on Feb. 26; Senate 26-9-0 on March 25), statement of purpose RS31242; signed April 1, 2024; Session Laws 2024, ch. 257; effective July 1, 2024 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, Senate Bill 1327 (2024), Judiciary and Rules Committee, Unlawful detainer (shielding of records): bill page with roll calls (Senate 31-3-1 on Feb. 27; House 67-0-3 on March 26), statement of purpose RS31120; signed April 3, 2024; Session Laws 2024, ch. 269; effective July 1, 2024 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, Senate Bill 1042 (2025), Judiciary and Rules Committee, Rental applications (limits on application fees): amended in Committee of the Whole Feb. 13; passed Senate as amended 23-12-0 on Feb. 19, 2025; referred to House Business Committee Feb. 20, 2025, with no further action; statement of purpose RS31865C2 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 701 (2026), Business Committee, Housing (limitations on rental application fees): introduced Feb. 16, 2026, referred to House Business Committee Feb. 17, 2026, no further action; statement of purpose RS33282 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Office of the Idaho Attorney General, news release, "AG Labrador cracks down on HOAs charging illegal fees to Idaho homeowners," May 8, 2026 (Pristine Springs HOA, Armstrong Park HOA, Park Pointe Management Services; Assurances of Voluntary Compliance) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 589 (2024), Ways and Means Committee, Homeowner's associations (disclosures; transfer fees): bill page with roll calls (House 67-0-3 on March 4; Senate 33-1-1 on March 18), statement of purpose RS31327; signed March 22, 2024; Session Laws 2024, ch. 162; effective July 1, 2024 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division, case page, United States v. Joy Nourse, et al. (D. Idaho), complaint filed Oct. 9, 2024 (Decoy RV Park, Caldwell; Fair Housing Act, disability, reasonable accommodation and retaliation; referred after a HUD charge of discrimination) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- U.S. Department of Justice, settlement agreement, United States v. Nourse (D. Idaho), dated Jan. 26, 2026 ($20,000 damages to the complainant, fair housing training, reasonable accommodation policy), as summarized on the Justice Department case page (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Policy Institute, Boise State University, "2025 Eviction" infographic (county table of 2025 eviction filings and formal evictions; statewide 3,415 filings and 1,234 formal evictions in 2025 per its 2019 to 2025 chart, which match its stated 36.1 percent and its 6.2 and 5.7 percent declines (the county table, which lists the six largest counties, prints 3,283 and 1,308 in its statewide row, inconsistent with its own 36.1 percent); by household, 3,039 renting households with at least one filing and 1,234 formally evicted; filings down 6.2 percent and formal evictions down 5.7 percent from 2024), based on Idaho Supreme Court eviction case data; page last modified May 14, 2026. A university research institute (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Supreme Court, Greenbriar Estates Homeowners' Association, Inc. v. Esposito, Docket No. 48922, opinion filed March 22, 2023 (Stegner, J.), appeal from the Third Judicial District, Canyon County, Judge Davis F. VanderVelde; affirmed (2012 Partial Settlement Agreement required annexation of the RV lot) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Supreme Court, North West Neighborhood Association v. City of Boise, Docket No. 49179, opinion filed Sept. 7, 2023 (Brody, J.; Bevan, C.J., and Stegner, Moeller and Zahn, JJ., concurring), appeal from the Fourth Judicial District, Ada County, Judge Darla Williamson; affirmed in part, reversed in part, remanded to invalidate the council's actions for adoption of a reasoned statement under Idaho Code 67-6535(2) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Supreme Court, Miller v. Rocking Ranch No. 3 Property Owners' Association, Inc., Docket No. 49371, opinion filed Jan. 12, 2024 (Stegner, J.), appeal from the Fifth Judicial District, Blaine County, Judge Ned C. Williamson; affirmed in part, vacated and remanded in part (overruling Farm Credit Bank and its progeny to the extent stated) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Supreme Court, Pickering v. Sanchez, Docket No. 49801, opinion filed Feb. 22, 2024 (Brody, J.; Bevan, C.J., Moeller and Zahn, JJ., and Gratton, J. pro tem, concurring), appeal from the Third Judicial District, Canyon County, Judge Thomas Whitney; affirmed (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, Senate Bill 1162 (2025), Judiciary and Rules Committee, Short-term rentals and vacation rentals: amended in Committee of the Whole March 27; failed on third reading as amended April 1, 2025, 11-23-1; statement of purpose RS32466 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Supreme Court, Vintage II, LLC v. Teton Saddleback Vistas Homeowners Association, Inc., Docket No. 51455, opinion filed Sept. 10, 2025 (Moeller, J.; Bevan, C.J., and Brody, Zahn and Meyer, JJ., concurring), appeal from the Seventh Judicial District, Teton County, Senior Judge Alan C. Stephens; affirmed in part, reversed in part, judgment vacated and remanded for judgment for the appellants (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Court of Appeals, Clark v. Conger, Docket No. 52590, unpublished opinion filed Oct. 24, 2025 (Gratton, C.J.; Huskey and Tribe, JJ., concurring), intermediate appeal from the magistrate division, Elmore County (Senior District Judge Gerald F. Schroeder; Magistrate Brent A. Ferguson); affirmed. Labeled by the court as unpublished and not to be cited as authority (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- HousingWire (real estate trade publication), "Idaho MV Realty settlement," Dec. 2, 2025, reporting a November 2025 settlement by the Idaho Attorney General's office (used for the event only; the Attorney General's release and court record were not retrieved) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Court of Appeals, Stunja v. High Corral No. 2 Property Owners Association, Inc., Docket No. 52026, unpublished opinion filed Jan. 14, 2026 (Tribe, C.J.; Gratton and Huskey, JJ., concurring), appeal from the Fourth Judicial District, Boise County, Judge Theodore J. Fleming; amended judgment reversed and remanded. Labeled by the court: "This is an unpublished opinion and shall not be cited as authority" (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Supreme Court, Doyle v. The Harris Ranch Community Infrastructure District No. 1, Docket No. 51175, opinion filed Feb. 12, 2026 (Meyer, J.; Bevan, C.J., and Brody, Moeller and Zahn, JJ., concurring), appeal from the Fourth Judicial District, Ada County, Judge Nancy A. Baskin; affirmed (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 800 (2026), Ways and Means Committee, Manufactured homes (siting in residential areas): bill page with roll calls (House 60-6-4 on March 9; Senate 28-5-2 on March 24), statement of purpose RS33501; signed March 26, 2026; Session Laws 2026, ch. 171; effective July 1, 2026 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Supreme Court, Conger v. Clark, Docket No. 52800, opinion released Sept. 4, 2026, court staff summary statement (affirming judgment for Clark on standing because the lease-option was not disclosed in Conger's bankruptcy). Summary read; the staff summary is not part of the opinion (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Supreme Court, K & L Crystal Beach, LLC v. The Crystal Beach Condominium Association, Inc., Docket No. 52887, opinion filed Oct. 30, 2026 (Meyer, J.; Brody, C.J., and Bevan, Moeller and Zahn, JJ., concurring), appeal from the Fourth Judicial District, Valley County, Judge Jason D. Scott; affirmed in part, reversed in part and remanded for trial on the claim under Idaho Code 55-1505(1)(c) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Supreme Court, Colton v. The Overlook at Fox Creek Subdivision Owners' Association, Inc., Docket No. 52603, opinion filed Nov. 9, 2026 (Moeller, J.; Brody, C.J., and Bevan, Zahn and Meyer, JJ., concurring), appeal from the Seventh Judicial District, Teton County, Judge Steven W. Boyce; reversed and remanded, fee judgments vacated (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Supreme Court, Decker v. City of Meridian, Docket No. 52355, opinion filed Nov. 9, 2026 (Moeller, J.; Brody, C.J., and Bevan, Zahn and Meyer, JJ., concurring), appeal from the Fourth Judicial District, Ada County, Judge Jason D. Scott; affirmed (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Lauren Paterson, "Amid 'economic eviction,' residents find hope for housing authority," Northwest Public Broadcasting, Jan. 13, 2025 (news report, used for events and quotes) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Allie Triepke, "Tenants form union at Eagle mobile home community, calling out rent hikes," Idaho News 6 (KIVI), Oct. 26, 2025 (news report, used for events and quotes) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-6539, Limitation on regulation of short-term rentals and vacation rentals, Idaho Legislature statute page, as amended by HB 583 (2026), Session Laws 2026, ch. 22 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 506 (2024), Business Committee, Short-term rentals: introduced Feb. 8, 2024; reported to General Orders March 7; retained on General Orders March 8, 15 and 25, 2024; no floor vote; statement of purpose RS31214 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, Senate Bill 1163 (2025), State Affairs Committee, Tourism revenue and short-term rentals: referred to Local Government and Taxation Committee March 10, 2025, no further action; statement of purpose RS32598 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, Senate Bill 1263 (2026), Commerce and Human Resources Committee, Short-term rentals: referred to Commerce and Human Resources Feb. 9, 2026, no further action; statement of purpose RS33116 (licenses only for operators of four or more rentals in a jurisdiction or a rental grossing more than $10,000 a year) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 424 (2024), Business Committee, Community resident associations: placed on General Orders Feb. 9, 2024 and returned to the Business Committee Feb. 26, 2024, no further action; statement of purpose RS30915 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 647 (2026), Business Committee, Manufactured homes: referred to House Business Committee Feb. 13, 2026, no further action; statement of purpose RS33065 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 321 (2025), Ways and Means Committee, Property rights (removal of unauthorized persons; false lease and fraudulent sale or lease crimes): bill page with roll calls (House 64-3-3 on March 13; Senate 35-0-0 on March 25), statement of purpose RS32452; signed March 31, 2025; Session Laws 2025, ch. 222; effective July 1, 2025 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 6-310A, Limited alternative remedy to remove unauthorized persons from residential real property, Idaho Legislature statute page (added by HB 321 (2025); amended by HB 695 (2026)) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 695 (2026), Judiciary, Rules and Administration Committee, Forcible entry and unlawful detainer: bill page with roll calls (House 68-0-2 on March 3; Senate 34-0-1 on March 17), statement of purpose RS33319; signed March 20, 2026; Session Laws 2026, ch. 82; effective July 1, 2026 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 641 (2024), Ways and Means Committee, Unlawful detainer (illegal drug activity): referred to House Judiciary, Rules and Administration Committee Feb. 26, 2024, no further action; statement of purpose RS31456 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, Senate Bill 1043 (2025), Judiciary and Rules Committee, Landlords and tenants (reorganization): Senate 35-0-0 on Feb. 19; House 67-0-3 on March 10; signed March 13, 2025; Session Laws 2025, ch. 65; effective July 1, 2025; statement of purpose RS31962 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 543 (2024), Health and Welfare Committee, Family daycare homes: House 68-0-2 on Feb. 27; Senate 34-1-0 on March 20; signed March 25, 2024; Session Laws 2024, ch. 191; statement of purpose RS31192 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 621 (2024), Ways and Means Committee, Homeowner's associations (community managers; conflicts of interest): amended; House 69-0-1 on March 12; Senate 31-3-1 on March 25; signed March 28, 2024; Session Laws 2024, ch. 214; statement of purpose RS31427 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 657 (2024), Ways and Means Committee, Homeowner's associations (board membership, proxies): referred to House Business Committee Feb. 26, 2024, no further action; statement of purpose RS31515 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, Senate Bill 1286 (2024), Commerce and Human Resources Committee, Homeowner's associations (grass lawns): referred to Commerce and Human Resources Feb. 8, 2024, no further action; statement of purpose RS31102 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 361 (2025), Ways and Means Committee, Homeowner's associations (declarant control, board membership, proxies): House 66-0-4 on March 13; Senate 35-0-0 on March 24; signed March 28, 2025; Session Laws 2025, ch. 204; effective July 1, 2025; statement of purpose RS32550 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 404 (2025), Ways and Means Committee, Urban agriculture (residential chickens): referred to House Agricultural Affairs Committee March 14, 2025, no further action; statement of purpose RS32657C1 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 708 (2026), Business Committee, Homeowner's associations (automatic dissolution): referred to House Business Committee Feb. 17, 2026, no further action; statement of purpose RS33345 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, Senate Bill 1277 (2026), Local Government and Taxation Committee, Accessory dwelling units: referred to Commerce and Human Resources Feb. 12, 2026, no further action; statement of purpose RS33075C1 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, Senate Bill 1280 (2026), Local Government and Taxation Committee, Housing (twin homes and duplexes): referred to Commerce and Human Resources Feb. 12, 2026, no further action; statement of purpose RS33083C1 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, House Bill 963 (2026), Ways and Means Committee, Housing (HOA quorum; joint ownership associations): introduced and referred to Ways and Means March 27, 2026, no further action; statement of purpose RS33713 (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Jaxon Holmes, "Idaho Supreme Court overturns approval of new Interfaith Sanctuary shelter," Boise State Public Radio, Jan. 23, 2025 (news report, used for the reaction and next steps) (read Nov. 19, 2026). Read it online. ↩
Check yourself
1. In North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton (2026), what did the Idaho Supreme Court hold about a short-term rental ban the HOA added in 2016?
The Court held Idaho Code 55-3211 'plainly exempts a property' from a later short-term rental restriction 'unless the property owner at the time the restriction was added expressly agrees to that restriction in writing' (Docket 51990, Jan. 6, 2026).
2. Why did the Supreme Court reverse in Idaho Association of Realtors v. City of Lava Hot Springs (2025)?
The opinion holds that 'Ordinance 2006-5 violates the Short-term Rental and Vacation Rental Act,' which classified short-term rentals as a residential use and barred rules with the 'express or practical effect' of prohibiting them (Docket 50888, May 21, 2025).
3. What were the final floor votes on House Bill 583 (2026), the short-term rental bill?
The HB 583 bill page records House passage 54-16-0 on Feb. 12 and Senate passage 23-12-0 on March 9, 2026; it was signed March 16, 2026 (Session Laws 2026, ch. 22). The 11-23 failure was SB 1162 in 2025.
4. Under Senate Bill 1327 (2024), what happens to records of a dismissed eviction case?
SB 1327's statement of purpose says records of a dismissed unlawful detainer are shielded automatically 'three years after the unlawful detainer is filed' if no appeal is pending (Session Laws 2024, ch. 269).
5. What did the Attorney General's May 8, 2026 settlements with two HOAs and a management company concern?
The Attorney General's release says homeowners were charged transfer fees not disclosed in the governing documents; HB 589 (2024) bars transfer fees unless expressly allowed by the CC&Rs.
6. In United States v. Nourse, what was the Decoy RV Park in Caldwell accused of?
The Justice Department case page describes the complaint filed Oct. 9, 2024 and a Jan. 26, 2026 settlement of $20,000, training and a new accommodation policy.
7. Why did the Boise City Council lose Veterans Park Neighborhood Association v. City of Boise (2025)?
The Court concluded the CUP decision 'was arbitrary and capricious and based on unlawful procedure' and the reasoned statement was inadequate under LLUPA (Docket 51027, Jan. 22, 2025).
8. What happened to the rental application fee bill SB 1042 in 2025?
The SB 1042 bill page shows Senate passage as amended 23-12-0 on Feb. 19, 2025 and referral to House Business on Feb. 20 with no further action; HB 701 (2026) also died in House Business.
9. Which statement about Idaho Code 6-310A (HB 321, 2025) is correct?
Section 6-310A(2)(f) requires that the occupants 'are not current or former tenants pursuant to a written or oral rental agreement'; HB 321 was signed March 31, 2025 (ch. 222).
10. In Miller v. Rocking Ranch No. 3 (2024), what did the Supreme Court say about attorney fees?
The Court overruled earlier cases to the extent they let a non-prevailing party recover fees on claims it lost, and clarified that fees are recoverable only for the discrete claim a party prevailed on (Docket 49371, Jan. 12, 2024).
Terms in this lesson
- Docket number
- The number an Idaho appellate court assigns to an appeal, such as 51990; it is the easiest way to find an opinion and its trial-court record.
- Unpublished opinion
- A Court of Appeals opinion the court marks as not to be cited as authority; it decides the case in front of it but does not set precedent.
- Express written consent (55-3211)
- The written agreement, given when a rental restriction is added or amended, that Idaho Code 55-3211 requires before an HOA may apply that restriction to a property.
- Assurance of Voluntary Compliance
- A written agreement between a business and the Idaho Attorney General under the Consumer Protection Act in which the business agrees to change its practices, often with refunds and monitoring.
- Transfer fee
- A fee an HOA or its manager charges when a home in the association is sold; since July 1, 2024 an HOA may charge one only if the CC&Rs expressly allow it.
- Derivative claim
- A claim that belongs to a corporation, such as an HOA or condo association, brought by a member on its behalf; it must meet the Nonprofit Corporation Act's requirements.
- Conditional use permit (CUP)
- City permission for a use allowed in a zone only after a hearing and with conditions, such as a shelter in a particular district.
- Reasoned statement
- The written explanation Idaho Code 67-6535(2) requires a city or county to give for approving or denying a land use application, tying the decision to the code and the evidence.
- Statement of purpose
- The short description a bill's sponsor files with each Idaho bill explaining what it would do; it is on the bill page with the fiscal note.
- Lease with option to purchase
- A lease that gives the tenant the right, but not the duty, to buy the home on stated terms; disputes over these deals appear in Pickering v. Sanchez and Clark v. Conger.
- Community infrastructure district (CID)
- A special taxing district under Idaho Code 50-3101 to 50-3121 that can finance public infrastructure in a development; homeowners may pay its tax in addition to HOA dues.
- Ripeness
- A court rule that a claim is not ready to decide until the facts are settled enough, such as a final decision by the city; the Meridian tiny home due process claims were dismissed as not ripe.
- General Orders
- A stage in the Idaho House where a bill reported from committee waits for amendment or floor action; a bill 'retained on General Orders' until adjournment dies.
Sources
- North Henry's Lake HOA v. Norton, Idaho Supreme Court Docket 51990 (Jan. 6, 2026) (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Idaho Association of Realtors v. City of Lava Hot Springs, Docket 50888 (May 21, 2025) (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Veterans Park Neighborhood Association v. City of Boise, Docket 51027 (Jan. 22, 2025) (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- K&L Crystal Beach v. Crystal Beach Condominium Association, Docket 52887 (Oct. 30, 2026) (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Decker v. City of Meridian, Docket 52355 (Nov. 9, 2026) (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Pickering v. Sanchez, Docket 49801 (Feb. 22, 2024) (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Idaho Code 55-3211, HOA rental restrictions (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Idaho Code 6-310A, removal of unauthorized persons (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- House Bill 583 (2026) bill page (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Senate Bill 1327 (2024) bill page (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- House Bill 589 (2024) bill page (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Idaho Attorney General release on HOA transfer fees, May 8, 2026 (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- U.S. Department of Justice, United States v. Nourse (D. Idaho) case page (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11
- Idaho Policy Institute, Boise State University, 2025 eviction infographic (2026-11-19) checked 2026-11