Lesson 7 of 11 · about 50 minutes · Updated November 18, 2026
Impact Fees, Urban Renewal and Who Pays for Growth
You'll be able to
- List the six kinds of public facilities and the five kinds of local government covered by Idaho's Development Impact Fee Act as amended by HB 766 (2026).
- Read a real impact fee schedule and add up the one-time public fees on a new home in a Treasure Valley or Magic Valley city.
- Tell an impact fee from a utility connection or capacity fee, and explain the Idaho Supreme Court's fee-or-tax rule.
- Explain why Idaho school districts cannot charge impact fees and what the 2023 to 2025 bills would have changed.
- Compute how much a district's property tax budget may grow from new construction and annexation under Idaho Code 63-802 and 63-301A.
- Describe how urban renewal, LIDs and CIDs shift the cost of growth, and find the public records that show the money.
Start here: the short version
- Idaho lets five kinds of local government charge impact fees. Since July 1, 2026, Idaho Code 67-8203(14) names cities, counties, single countywide highway districts, fire protection districts and ambulance service districts. House Bill 766 (2026) wrote the two district types into the definition.12
- Schools are not on the list. Impact fees can pay for water, wastewater, roads, stormwater, parks and public safety, and nothing else. School impact fee bills in 2023 (SB 1060), 2024 (HB 582) and 2025 (HB 429, a mitigation fee bill) never got a committee vote.1345
- A new 2,000 square foot house in Meridian owed about $18,822 in city impact fees, the Ada County Highway District road fee and city water and sewer assessments in mid-2026, our sum of the published schedules. The same house in Twin Falls owed about $6,049 in city impact and connection fees.6789
- ACHD's road fee for a single-family home rose 66.1 percent, from $3,493 (set Oct. 1, 2022) to $5,803 (Ordinance 254, effective March 1, 2026), our calculation from the district's figures.107
- Property taxes on growth are capped too. Under Idaho Code 63-802 a city or county may raise its property tax budget 3 percent a year plus an amount for new construction and annexation, with an 8 percent total cap set by House Bill 389 (2021). In 2026 House Bill 959 raised the total cap to 15 percent for fire and ambulance districts only.111213
- Statewide in 2025, the 3 percent allowance could add $51.6 million to local property tax budgets, new construction $30.6 million, annexation $0.8 million and expiring urban renewal areas $10.3 million, according to the Idaho State Tax Commission.14
- Urban renewal keeps new value off the new construction roll. Growth inside a revenue allocation area pays the urban renewal agency first. Since 2025 fire and ambulance districts can stay out of new areas and ask to leave old ones; the Twin Falls Ambulance District got out of two Twin Falls areas and was refused in three.151617
Law: Idaho Code as amended through the 2026 regular session (session laws through chapter 316, HB 959, signed April 10, 2026); Idaho Supreme Court opinions cited through 2018 on fees; U.S. Supreme Court through Sheetz v. County of El Dorado (2024). Fees: published schedules of the Ada County Highway District (effective March 1, 2026), Meridian (Feb. 1, 2023 and June 1, 2026), Boise (Oct. 1, 2026) and Twin Falls (Oct. 1, 2025 and Jan. 1, 2026). Data: Idaho State Tax Commission, Market Values and Property Taxes for 2025 (Dec. 22, 2025), tax year 2025. All checked Nov. 18, 2026. Fee schedules change every year or two and laws change every session; check the current schedule and statute before you rely on a number.
Every new house needs a road to reach it, a pipe to bring water, a pipe to take sewage away, a fire engine within a few minutes and, for many families, a classroom seat and a park. Someone pays for each of those. In Idaho the answer depends on which of the four or five money machines a city or district has turned on: impact fees, utility connection and capacity fees, the property tax as it grows with new construction, special assessment districts, and urban renewal. Each one has its own statute, its own limits and its own court cases, and each one puts the cost on a different person: the builder, the first buyer, every ratepayer, every taxpayer, or the owners on one street.
This lesson follows the money for a new home from the building permit counter to the tax bill. It names the fees that cities in the Treasure Valley and the Magic Valley actually charged in 2026, adds them up for a sample house, walks through the property tax growth limits as rewritten in 2021 and 2026, and covers the newest urban renewal changes. It ends with the argument that never goes away: does growth pay for itself?
Other lessons on this site cover parts of the ground, and this one does not repeat them. The basics of subdivision review and a worked proportionate-share example are in Subdivisions, Plats and Impact Fees. A section-by-section tour of the Development Impact Fee Act and the full story of the 2025 Ada County Highway District update are in Growth, Impact Fees and Who Pays in the roads course. The fee-or-tax rules and enterprise funds are in Fees and Enterprise Funds, and the basic budget cap formula is in The Three Percent Cap. How tax increment works, with a worked example, is in Urban Renewal and Tax Increment Financing in Idaho and Who Pays the Increment. Water, schools and roads as limits on growth are in Part A of this series, Water, Schools and Roads.
Within this module, the long history of the property tax is in Property Tax History, reading your own levy and bill is in Reading Your Assessment and Levy, the Legislature's habit of setting rules for cities is in State Preemption and Local Control, and the way a farm becomes a platted subdivision, where most of these fees are first set, is in Subdivisions and Plats Step by Step.
Four ways a new subdivision gets paid for
Start with a 40-acre field on the edge of a city. A builder wants 160 homes. Before the first family moves in, someone must pay for streets inside the subdivision, a bigger water main on the arterial road, a share of the next sewer plant expansion, a new fire station on that side of town, and a park. Idaho law sorts those costs into four buckets, and the bucket decides who pays.
Project improvements: what the developer builds and hands over
Streets, curbs, sidewalks, water and sewer lines, streetlights and storm drains inside the subdivision are "project improvements." The Development Impact Fee Act defines them as "site improvements and facilities that are planned and designed to provide service for a particular development project" and that are "necessary for the use and convenience of the occupants or users of the project."1 A city may require the developer to build "reasonable project improvements" as a condition of approval, and the Act says plainly that nothing in it prevents that.18 The developer pays, builds to city standards, and dedicates the improvements to the public on the plat. The cost goes into the lot price, so the first buyer pays most of it. Developers get no impact fee credit for project improvements: the Act says "Credit or reimbursement shall not be given for project improvement."19
Impact fees: a share of the bigger systems
The bigger pieces that serve many subdivisions at once are "system improvements": the arterial road, the sewer plant, the fire station, the regional park.1 An impact fee is "a payment of money imposed as a condition of development approval to pay for a proportionate share of the cost of system improvements needed to serve development."1 It is collected once, usually when the building permit is issued, and it must be spent on the category of facility and in the service area where it was collected.2021 The builder writes the check at permit time and folds it into the house price.
Connection and capacity fees: buying into the utility
Water and sewer systems owned by a city usually charge a separate one-time fee when a new building hooks up. Cities call it a connection fee, capacity fee, capitalization fee, assessment or hookup fee. These are not impact fees: the Act's definition of an impact fee expressly does not include "Connection or hookup charges."1 They rest instead on the city's utility powers in the Revenue Bond Act and on a line of Idaho Supreme Court cases about when a utility charge is a fee and when it is an illegal tax, covered below.2223
Property taxes, assessments and districts: the long tail
Once the homes are built, their owners pay property taxes for decades. Part of the growth in each taxing district's budget is tied by law to the value of new construction (Idaho Code 63-802 and 63-301A).1115 Two other tools spread costs differently. A local improvement district (LID) charges an assessment to the lots that benefit from a specific street, sidewalk or sewer project.24 A community infrastructure district (CID) lets a developer finance public infrastructure through a district that levies taxes or assessments only on property inside it, so later homebuyers pay the cost over many years on their tax bills.25 Urban renewal, the fifth machine, does not create a new tax; it redirects the growth in property taxes inside an area to an agency for up to 20 years.2627

The Idaho Development Impact Fee Act, 1992 to 2026
Idaho cities did not need a statute to require developers to build streets and pipes inside a subdivision. They did need one to charge a cash fee for a share of the bigger systems. In 1988 the Idaho Supreme Court held in Brewster v. City of Pocatello that a city "street restoration and maintenance fee" was really a tax, because a fee pays for a direct service to the person charged while a tax is a forced contribution for public needs, and a city may not tax without the Legislature's permission.23 Cities that had adopted growth fees on their own were exposed. The roads course tells the story of the Coeur d'Alene and Hayden fee refunds that followed in Growth, Impact Fees and Who Pays.
The Legislature answered in 1992 with the Idaho Development Impact Fee Act, Idaho Code Title 67, Chapter 82, enacted as chapter 282 of the 1992 session laws.28 Its purpose section says the Legislature found that "an equitable program for planning and financing public facilities needed to serve new growth and development is necessary," and that those who benefit from growth should "pay no more than their proportionate share."28 The Act gave every existing local fee ordinance one year to come into line, and after that it became the only way to charge growth for system improvements: once a government adopts an ordinance under the Act, "development requirements for system improvements shall be imposed by governmental entities only by way of development impact fees."29
What an impact fee can pay for, and what it cannot
The Act lists six kinds of "public facilities," and only these:1
- Water supply, treatment, storage and distribution.
- Wastewater collection, treatment and disposal.
- Roads, streets and bridges, including rights-of-way, traffic signals and local parts of state or federal highways.
- Stormwater, flood control, and bank and shore protection.
- Parks, open space and recreation areas.
- Public safety: law enforcement, fire stations and apparatus, emergency medical and rescue, and street lighting.
A capital improvement must have "a useful life of ten (10) years or more" and must increase a facility's capacity.1 The definition of system improvement costs then lists what fees may not pay for: projects not in the capital improvements plan, repair, operation or maintenance, upgrades to meet stricter standards for existing development, upgrades that give existing development better service, most administrative costs, and debt payments other than on bonds for projects in the plan.1 Libraries, city halls, schools and general government buildings are not named on the list. A 2026 bill, House Bill 626, would have required cities to collect any impact fee a county adopts for a county courthouse or jail; it passed the House 68-1-1 and stopped in the Senate Local Government and Taxation Committee.30
Who may charge an impact fee
From 1992 until 2026 the Act gave the power to cities, counties and single countywide highway districts, and fire and ambulance districts received impact fee money mainly through agreements with a city or county.31 Two 2021 bills widened that path: House Bill 110 added ambulance districts to the intergovernmental agreement section, and House Bill 156 added "fire stations and apparatus" to the public safety category.3233 The Ada County Highway District is the only highway district we found that fits the "single countywide" description, which is why it adopts its own road fee while the many highway districts in Canyon, Twin Falls, Jerome and Gooding counties do not.34
House Bill 766 (2026) rewrote the definition of "governmental entity" so it now reads: "cities, counties, single countywide highway districts, fire protection districts, and ambulance service districts that are each empowered in this enabling legislation to adopt a development impact fee ordinance."1 The statement of purpose, from House Speaker Mike Moyle and Rep. Mark Sauter, said the bill "adds these districts to the list of other entities empowered to do so."35 It passed the House 39-27-4 and the Senate 24-9-2, was signed March 27, 2026, and took effect July 1, 2026.2 A companion bill, House Bill 767, would have let impact fees pay half the cost of replacing fire apparatus listed in an adopted capital improvements plan. It passed the House 51-15-4 and was never heard in the Senate committee.36
Two exemptions matter for public builders. Work by a taxing district, and since 2019 (House Bill 91) by a public charter school, "in the course of carrying out its statutory responsibilities" is not "development" and pays no impact fee, unless the local ordinance expressly includes them.137 A new school or fire station built by a district therefore usually pays no impact fee to the city.
Rules every fee ordinance must follow
Section 67-8204 sets 25 minimum standards. The ones that most often decide arguments at a counter or a council meeting are these:20
- Proportionate share only. A fee "shall not exceed a proportionate share of the cost of system improvements," calculated on levels of service that also apply to existing development. A city may not use fees to fix an existing shortfall.
- When to collect. No earlier than the start of construction or the building permit (or a manufactured home installation permit), unless the developer agrees otherwise.
- Individual assessment. A developer may submit its own study and ask for a fee based on its project's actual demand, and may ask for a written certification of the fee that holds unless the project changes.
- No double payment and credits for system improvements the developer builds or pays for, including through a local improvement district.19
- Required exemptions: rebuilding after a fire within two years, remodeling that adds no service units, replacing a home on the same lot, construction trailers, additions that add no service units, and accessory uses such as clubhouses unless they clearly add a significant load.
- An optional affordable housing exemption, for housing affordable to families at or below 80 percent of median income, but only if the city's long-range plan states the policy and the exempted share is paid from another source.
Money collected goes into interest-bearing accounts by category and service area. It must be spent within eight years, first in, first out, or 20 years for wastewater and drainage, with an allowed extension to 11 years for stated cause; otherwise it is refunded to the owner of record with interest at half the legal rate.2138 The government must publish an annual report of fees collected and spent and the share of other revenue used for system improvements.21 A fee payer can pay under protest and appeal, and the ordinance must offer mediation with the cost split equally.39 If a government finds an error in its formula that overcharges, it must adjust each fee or stop collecting until the ordinance is fixed.40
Each ordinance needs an advisory committee of at least five members, two of them "active in the business of development, building, or real estate." Since July 1, 2023 (Senate Bill 1114), new members must live in the service area and may not be government employees or officials acting in that role.4142 The committee helps adopt land use assumptions, reviews the capital improvements plan, and reports at least once a year on "any perceived inequities."41
Amendments and failed bills, 1992 to 2026
The Act has been amended in at least 10 sessions since 1992, most recently in 2026. The table lists the changes that matter for housing, with the bills that failed.
| Year | Bill or law | What it did | Outcome | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1992 | Idaho Development Impact Fee Act, ch. 282 | Created chapter 67-82: public facilities list, proportionate share, capital plans, advisory committees, refunds | Law | 28 |
| 1996, 2002 | Session laws ch. 366 (1996) and ch. 347 (2002) | Added intergovernmental agreements (67-8204A, 1996); amended the standards, credits, mediation, refund and collection sections | Law | 3119 |
| 2006 | Session laws ch. 321 | Amended the hearing procedure (67-8206) and the earmarking and spending section (67-8210) | Law | 21 |
| 2019 | HB 91, ch. 70 | Public charter school projects exempt unless an ordinance names them | Law, signed March 12, 2019 | 37 |
| 2021 | HB 110, ch. 95 | Ambulance districts added to fee-sharing agreements | Law, effective July 1, 2021 | 32 |
| 2021 | HB 156, ch. 199 | "Fire stations and apparatus" added to public safety facilities | Law, effective July 1, 2021 | 33 |
| 2023 | SB 1060 | Would have added public schools and school districts | Referred to committee, no hearing shown | 3 |
| 2023 | SB 1114, ch. 146 | Advisory committee members must live in the service area | Law, effective July 1, 2023 | 42 |
| 2024 | HB 582 | Would have let school districts collect impact fees | Filed with the chief clerk, no hearing | 4 |
| 2025 | HB 429 | Would have required school districts taking subdivision mitigation money to adopt capacity plans | Filed with the chief clerk, no hearing | 5 |
| 2026 | HB 626 | County courthouse and jail fees collected by cities | Passed House 68-1-1; died in Senate committee | 30 |
| 2026 | HB 766, ch. 203 | Fire protection and ambulance service districts named as governmental entities | Law, effective July 1, 2026 | 2 |
| 2026 | HB 767 | Impact fees for half of fire apparatus replacement | Passed House 51-15-4; died in Senate committee | 36 |
| 2026 | SB 1352, ch. 264 | Starter home subdivisions may not be charged higher permit, impact or connection fees than other single-family subdivisions (cities over 10,000; by Feb. 1, 2027) | Law | 43 |

What a new house pays: real fee schedules in 2026
Impact fee schedules are public. Each city or district posts them, usually as a one-page table on the building department's website, and adopts them by ordinance after a hearing. The schedules below were in effect in 2026. They show three patterns: fees differ a great deal from city to city, they now often depend on the size of the home, and the road fee can be as large as all city fees combined.
Ada County Highway District: one road fee for the whole county
The Ada County Highway District (ACHD) is responsible for local public roads throughout Ada County, including inside Boise, Meridian, Eagle, Kuna, Star and Garden City, so a home anywhere in the county pays its road impact fee on top of any city fees. Its fee is built from traffic engineering data. Under Ordinance 246A, in effect from Oct. 1, 2022, the fee for a single-family detached home was the home's 0.470 new trips in the evening peak hour, times an average trip length of 6.17 miles, times a 0.467 network adjustment, times a cost of $2,579 per vehicle-mile of capacity: $3,493.10
On Dec. 3, 2025, ACHD's commission adopted Ordinance 254 on a 4-1 vote after a two-year update of its capital improvements plan, which lists $1.2 billion of impact fee eligible road projects over 20 years. Effective March 1, 2026, the fee is $5,803 per single-family home, $2,371 per apartment or other multifamily unit, $7,363 per 1,000 square feet of office space and $12,082 per 1,000 square feet of shopping center.734 That is a 66.1 percent increase for a house, our calculation. The Mountain States Policy Center, a Spokane-based free-market policy group, described the change as a 66 percent increase in a piece criticizing it.44 The proposals ACHD weighed before the vote, including a two-zone fee split at Cole Road, are laid out in the roads course.
Meridian: fees by home size
Meridian charges impact fees for parks and recreation, police and fire. Its 2022 study by DP Guthrie LLC led to Ordinance 22-2004, heard Nov. 9, 2022, with a schedule effective Feb. 1, 2023 that the city's building division still listed in 2026. The fee depends on the climate-controlled floor area of each home.64546
| Floor area per home | Parks and recreation | Police | Fire | Total city impact fees |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1,200 sq. ft. or less | $1,946 | $190 | $470 | $2,606 |
| 1,201 to 1,700 | $3,006 | $294 | $726 | $4,026 |
| 1,701 to 2,500 | $4,119 | $402 | $995 | $5,516 |
| 2,501 to 3,200 | $4,935 | $482 | $1,192 | $6,609 |
| 3,201 or more | $5,544 | $542 | $1,339 | $7,425 |
Tying the fee to floor area rests on the idea that larger homes hold more people on average and so use more park and public safety capacity. It also means a small starter home pays about a third of what a large home pays ($2,606 vs. $7,425).456 Meridian also charges one-time water and sewer assessments when a building connects. Effective June 1, 2026, the city raised the sewer assessment from $5,411 to $5,807 and the water assessment from $1,514 to $1,696, a combined increase of $578.8
Boise: fees by home size and planning area
Boise charges impact fees for regional parks, local parks, fire and police, and adds a 1 percent surcharge to pay for preparing its capital plans. Its schedule effective Oct. 1, 2026 varies both by home size and by planning area, because the local parks fee differs from one planning area to another. Downtown and the Airport planning area pay no local parks fee.47
| Boise planning area (sample) | 700 sq. ft. or less | 1,401 to 2,100 sq. ft. | More than 2,800 sq. ft. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Downtown | $1,443.01 | $4,313.50 | $7,463.29 |
| Central Bench | $2,185.86 | $6,534.06 | $11,305.35 |
| West Bench | $2,922.13 | $8,734.95 | $15,113.34 |
| Southeast-Barber Valley | $2,959.75 | $8,847.39 | $15,307.90 |
| South | $3,118.42 | $9,321.71 | $16,128.57 |
| Boise area of impact (Ada County permits), single family | $483.16 | $1,178.92 (more than 700 sq. ft.) | |
Amounts are before the 1 percent surcharge and before ACHD's road fee. A large new home in Boise's South planning area pays more than $16,000 in city fees alone, while a small downtown apartment pays about $1,443. Homes in Boise's area of city impact, permitted by Ada County, pay only parks fees to the city.47
Nampa and Canyon County
Nampa's largest change came in 2019. On March 4, 2019, the city council approved a schedule that raised the single-family impact fee from $1,806 to $5,459, according to Idaho News 6. The station's report carried the line "Growth should pay for growth. We should not have to pay for growth," without naming who said it. The city's consultant, Anne Wescott of Galena Consulting, said impact fees "allow new growth to pay its share of the capital infrastructure."48 KTVB reported that the city expected about $70 million in impact fee revenue over 10 years against a much larger list of growth-related police, fire, street and park needs.49 We could not confirm Nampa's current residential schedule from a primary record, so this lesson does not state a 2026 Nampa figure. Canyon County has no single countywide highway district, so there is no Canyon County counterpart to the ACHD fee; a highway district that is not countywide cannot adopt its own impact fee ordinance and must work through agreements with a city or county.131
Twin Falls
The Twin Falls City Code section on impact fees carries a history note of Ordinance 2021-017, adopted Oct. 11, 2021, and provides fees for police, fire, parks and streets collected when the building permit is issued.50 On Dec. 8, 2025 the city council set the schedule that took effect Jan. 1, 2026:9
| Twin Falls, effective Jan. 1, 2026 | Single-family (per home) | Multifamily (per unit) |
|---|---|---|
| Police | $276 | $276 |
| Fire | $1,105 | $1,105 |
| Parks | $1,918 | $1,918 |
| Streets | $1,683 | $901 |
| Total | $4,982 | $4,200 |
Twin Falls charges water and sewer separately. For the fiscal year Oct. 1, 2025 to Sept. 30, 2026, a single-family home paid a sewer capacity fee of $512.54 plus a $105 residential sewer tap, and a water meter fee of $449.28 at the building permit; when the city itself installs the 1-inch service line and meter, the installation charge is $3,088.47.5152 Part A of this series shows how water and sewer capacity has limited growth in Jerome and other cities; see Water, Schools and Roads.
Kimberly, Jerome and the small towns
Smaller Magic Valley cities are less likely to have impact fees, because the Act's study, capital plan, committee and annual reports cost money that small fee revenues may not cover. Kimberly, in Twin Falls County, is an exception: its city code chapter 17.18, adopted by Ordinance 671 after a Feb. 22, 2022 fee study and amended by Ordinance 689 in 2025, sets residential fees per home of $484 for police, $85 for police vehicles, $221 for parks and $270 for streets, plus administration and library lines, with yearly inflation adjustments from Jan. 1, 2023, as republished by Zoneomics.53 The Act's list of public facilities does not name libraries or general administration, so anyone relying on those lines should read the official ordinance and the city's capital improvements plan.1 We did not find a published impact fee schedule for the City of Jerome, Gooding, Buhl or Hagerman in the records available to us; residents can ask each city clerk whether an impact fee ordinance exists and request the latest annual impact fee report under Idaho Code 67-8210(3).21
How we figured it: the fee stack for a 2,000 square foot home
We picked a detached single-family home of 2,000 square feet of climate-controlled floor area and added the one-time public fees in each city's published 2026 schedules.
- Meridian: city impact fees for 1,701 to 2,500 sq. ft. ($4,119 parks + $402 police + $995 fire = $5,516) + ACHD $5,803 + water assessment $1,696 + sewer assessment $5,807 = $18,822.678
- Boise, Central Bench planning area: city impact fees for 1,401 to 2,100 sq. ft. ($1,721.11 + $2,220.56 + $2,056.52 + $535.87 = $6,534.06) + 1 percent surcharge ($65.34) = $6,599.40; + ACHD $5,803 = $12,402.40. Water and sewer connection charges are not included.477
- Twin Falls: city impact fees $4,982 + sewer capacity $512.54 + sewer tap $105 + water meter fee $449.28 = $6,048.82. The $3,088.47 service line installation charge is not included because it applies only when the city installs the service; the $150 charge for a city tap on a live main and the $55.35 water service permit fee listed for new subdivisions and commercial developments are also left out, because the schedule does not say when a single home pays them.95152
Not included anywhere: building permit, plan review and inspection fees (which the Act excludes from impact fees), private utility charges, irrigation or ditch company charges, school "voluntary" payments, and the cost of project improvements built by the developer. We did not verify whether each city reads "2,000 square feet" the same way (for example, whether a finished basement counts). Treat these as examples of published schedules, not quotes for a real permit.

Connection and capacity fees: the other half of the bill
In Meridian the water and sewer assessments ($7,503 together in mid-2026) are larger than the city's impact fees for most homes, yet they are not impact fees at all. The Act leaves out "Connection or hookup charges" and "Availability charges for drainage, sewer, water, or transportation charges for services provided directly to the development."1 That leaves city utility charges governed by two other bodies of law: the Revenue Bond Act's grant of power to set rates, fees and charges for city water and sewer systems (Idaho Code 50-1030(f)), and the general rule for taxing districts that fees for services "shall be reasonably related to, but shall not exceed, the actual cost of the service being rendered" (Idaho Code 63-1311(1)).2254
The fee-or-tax cases
The Idaho Supreme Court has drawn the line between a lawful utility fee and an unlawful tax in a series of cases, most of them brought by builders' associations and ratepayers:
- Brewster v. City of Pocatello (1988): a fee is "a charge for a direct public service rendered to the particular consumer," while a tax is a forced contribution for public needs; Pocatello's street charge was a tax the city had no power to levy.23
- Loomis v. City of Hailey (1991): a city may charge a one-time water or sewer "buy-in" connection fee larger than the physical cost of hooking up, figured by dividing the net replacement value of the system by the number of users it can serve, so long as the money is handled as the Revenue Bond Act requires.23
- Viking Construction, Inc. v. Hayden Lake Irrigation District (2010): a connection fee counts as an equity buy-in only if it is based on the value of the part of the system the new user will use.23
- North Idaho Building Contractors Ass'n v. City of Hayden (2015 and 2018): Hayden raised its one-time sewer capitalization fee to $2,280 per equivalent residence in June 2007 to help pay for about $20 million of projects. In 2015 the Court held that nothing in the record showed the fee reflected the actual cost of serving a new connection, so it was not authorized by 63-1311(1), and that the trial court erred in upholding it.55 In 2018 it vacated a trial court judgment that had ordered refunds of about $729,404 plus $219,708 in attorney fees, and sent the case back so the city could try to show the fee was a lawful buy-in under the Revenue Bond Act. The Court noted that Hayden had set the fee by dividing the cost of expanding the system by the added capacity, which is not the Loomis buy-in method.23
- Hill-Vu Mobile Home Park v. City of Pocatello (2017): a "payment in lieu of taxes" that Pocatello's water and sewer departments passed on to customers and moved into the general fund was neither an authorized fee nor an authorized tax.56
Together these cases mean a city may charge new connections for their share of the existing system's value, or for growth capacity through a properly adopted impact fee under the Act, but may not use a utility charge as a general revenue source. The 2018 Hayden opinion put the rule this way: when a fee is calculated to meet a public need instead of a user's actual consumption cost, "it creates a forced contribution and is properly regarded as a tax."23

Schools: the facility Idaho leaves out
School buildings are the largest public cost that a new family can bring, and Idaho's Act does not reach them. "Public facilities" stops at water, wastewater, roads, stormwater, parks and public safety, and a school district is not a "governmental entity."1 Idaho school districts pay for new buildings mostly with bonds approved by two-thirds of voters and plant facilities levies, plus state money: the Tax Commission reports that School District Facility Fund money cut school property tax levies by $215.2 million in 2025.14 Those tools are covered in School Boards, Budgets, Bonds and Levies and in Property Tax History.
The mitigation paradox in Idaho Code 67-6513
The Local Land Use Planning Act seems to point the other way. Idaho Code 67-6513 says a subdivision ordinance "may provide for mitigation of the effects of subdivision development on the ability of political subdivisions of the state, including school districts, to deliver services," but the next sentence says "Fees established for purposes of mitigating the financial impacts of development must comply with the provisions of chapter 82, title 67."57 Since chapter 82 does not cover schools, a city cannot adopt a school fee that complies with it. What is left is voluntary: a developer may agree to pay a school district as part of a development agreement, and some districts publish what they think a fair payment would be.
The Kuna School District did that. A Jan. 24, 2023 study for the district calculated a "maximum supportable" voluntary capital mitigation fee of $32,863 per single-family home and $30,719 per multifamily unit, based on students per home, about 515 new homes a year, and local building and land costs. District staff recommended asking for 10 percent of the maximum, $3,286 per single-family home.58 In 2026 the City of Caldwell posted a draft ordinance that would have tied plat approval to a school district capacity letter and barred approvals that push a school above 110 percent of capacity unless the developer provides mitigation acceptable to the city and district; we could not confirm whether the council adopted it.59 A 2025 bill by Rep. Bruce, House Bill 429, would have required any school district that receives money under 67-6513 to adopt a capacity plan and spend the money only to add student capacity. It was printed and filed without a hearing.5
The school impact fee bills
The push for school impact fees grew out of the fastest-growing districts. In 2021, Kuna and Middleton districts brought a resolution to the Idaho School Boards Association asking it to work with the Legislature, and the members passed it overwhelmingly, according to a January 2022 Idaho News 6 report.60 Rep. Lauren Necochea of Boise told the station, "All we have to do are add our school districts to the entities that are allowed to collect impact fees." Sen. Jim Rice of Caldwell, then chairman of the Senate Local Government and Taxation Committee, answered, "In my opinion, an impact fee would be unconstitutional" if used for schools, raising the rule against taxing the same property twice for the same purpose, and suggested a dedicated state school construction fund instead.60
The bills that followed went nowhere. Senate Bill 1060 (2023), with Sen. Geoff Schroeder and Rep. Jaron Crane listed as contacts, would have added public schools to the list of public facilities; its statement of purpose argued that the change "places statutory limits on the amount of school impact mitigation a local jurisdiction can exact from new development." It was printed and sent to committee on Feb. 10, 2023, and no further action is shown.3 House Bill 582 (2024), from Rep. Necochea, argued that school fees could reduce the need for bonds, "which would in turn reduce the burden on property taxes"; it was filed with the chief clerk without a hearing.4 No school impact fee bill was printed in 2026.61
Other states differ. Washington's Growth Management Act fee law lists "school facilities" among the public facilities that impact fees may fund.62 Texas, like Idaho, limits impact fees to a short list: water, wastewater, storm water and drainage, and roadway facilities.63 The national rule on all of them changed in 2024, when the U.S. Supreme Court held in Sheetz v. County of El Dorado that a $23,420 traffic impact fee charged to a California man for a small prefabricated house was not exempt from takings review just because a county board set it by general legislation: "The Takings Clause does not distinguish between legislative and administrative permit conditions."64 Idaho's Act already demanded a proportionate share; Sheetz means a fee schedule that overcharges can also be challenged under the U.S. Constitution. Property rights and takings law are covered in Property Rights and Land Use Law.
The 3 percent cap and the new construction roll
Fees are a one-time payment. The recurring question is how much a city, county or district may raise its property tax budget as homes are added. Idaho answers with a formula in Idaho Code 63-802, and the formula ties growth in each budget to the value of new construction listed on a separate assessor's roll under Idaho Code 63-301A.1115 The basic formula and forgone balances are explained in The Three Percent Cap; this section covers what changed in 2021 and 2026 and what it means for growing places.
The formula as of 2026
- Start with the base. Take the highest property tax budget the district certified in any of the three prior tax years.11
- Add up to 3 percent. The district chooses how much of a 3 percent growth factor it wants and computes a "preliminary levy rate" from the result and the current taxable value.11
- Add new construction. Multiply the preliminary levy rate by the value on the new construction roll. Under 63-301A(3), that roll counts 90 percent of the taxable value added by new structures once they are "completed and taxable," additions to nonresidential buildings, newly placed manufactured homes, and a few other items, and it may not include changes from market inflation.15
- Add annexation. Multiply the same rate by 90 percent of the value of property annexed into the district in the prior calendar year.11
- Apply the ceiling. The total increase from steps 2 to 4 "must not exceed eight percent (8%)." Fire protection and ambulance service districts have a 15 percent ceiling and use the previous year's levy rate for new construction and annexation instead of the preliminary rate.11
- Add what sits outside. Voter-approved bonds, overrides and supplemental levies, judgments and some other items are outside the cap. Budget gains from a terminating urban renewal area, and from fire district or library district annexations of territory, are not counted against the 8 percent ceiling.11
- Voters may go higher. A permanent increase needs two-thirds of voters at a May or November election; a temporary increase of up to two years needs a majority.11
School district maintenance and operation levies under Idaho Code 33-802 are not subject to this section at all.11 A district that takes less than its full increase can bank the difference as a "forgone" amount and use it later, within limits of 1 percent a year for operations and 3 percent of the budget for a capital project; since 2026, fire and ambulance districts may not add new forgone amounts.1113
What House Bill 389 (2021) changed
House Bill 389 was the Legislature's main property tax bill of 2021. Its statement of purpose says it "reduces the amount of valuation available to tax new construction and annexation, creating a total cap of 8% in any budget year," limits how forgone amounts feed ongoing budgets, and "delays the entry of an improved property's market value on the new construction roll until after the improvements are completed." The fiscal note estimated the limits "may result in curbed budget growth by as much as 23% in some cases."65 The bill passed the House 48-20-1 and the Senate 19-16-0, and Gov. Brad Little signed it May 12, 2021, as Session Laws 2021, chapter 360; most sections applied retroactively to Jan. 1, 2021.12 It also raised the homeowner's exemption to $125,000 and enlarged the circuit breaker; those parts are covered in Property Tax History and Reading Your Assessment and Levy.65
The 90 percent rule means a new home adds 10 percent less budget capacity than its full taxable value would. The 8 percent ceiling only binds where growth is very fast, so its effect falls on the fastest-growing cities and districts. Statewide, the Tax Commission estimated that the 8 percent ceiling cut potential increases by about $0.3 million in 2025.14
The 2026 fight over the cap: cities lost, fire districts won
Fast-growing cities and fire districts in the Treasure Valley argued after 2021 that the 8 percent ceiling and the 90 percent rule left them unable to staff new fire stations as subdivisions filled in. In 2026 the House considered two answers. House Bill 842, sponsored by Rep. David Cannon, would have raised the ceiling from 8 to 15 percent for cities under 30,000 people and the fire and ambulance districts serving them, "if enough new construction and annexed territory has been added to cover the cost," and let forgone amounts feed budgets at 2 percent a year instead of 1 percent. It failed in the House 28-41-1.66
A narrower bill, House Bill 959, passed both chambers without a dissenting vote (67-0-3 in the House and 33-0-2 in the Senate) and was signed April 10, 2026. For fire protection and ambulance service districts only, it raises the ceiling to 15 percent, prices new construction and annexation at the prior year's levy rate, ends the accumulation of new forgone balances, and creates a voter initiative process that lets residents raise or lower those districts' property tax budgets with a two-thirds vote.13 Its revised statement of purpose says "Very few Idaho fire protection or ambulance service districts are growing fast enough to utilize the increase."13 Two smaller 2026 laws adjusted the new construction roll: House Bill 551 (fire and ambulance districts outside urban renewal financing) and House Bill 765 (boundary swaps between fire or library districts and city fire department consolidations).6768
How we figured it: a budget cap example with invented numbers
Example City (invented) had a highest prior-year property tax budget of $20,000,000 and current taxable value of $5,000,000,000. It takes the full 3 percent: $600,000. Its preliminary levy rate is $20,600,000 divided by $5,000,000,000 = 0.00412.
- Normal growth year: new structures add $150,000,000 of taxable value; the roll counts 90 percent, $135,000,000, times 0.00412 = $556,200. Annexed land worth $20,000,000 counts at 90 percent, $18,000,000, times 0.00412 = $74,160. Total allowed increase: $600,000 + $556,200 + $74,160 = $1,230,360, or 6.15 percent. The 8 percent ceiling does not bind.
- Boom year: new structures add $300,000,000; the roll counts $270,000,000, times 0.00412 = $1,112,400. Total: $600,000 + $1,112,400 + $74,160 = $1,786,560, or 8.93 percent. The ceiling limits the increase to 8 percent, $1,600,000, so $186,560 of growth-based capacity is lost that year.
Method from Idaho Code 63-802(1)(a) and 63-301A(3) as of 2026. Real calculations use the county's certified values and the Tax Commission's worksheets, and the preliminary rate is computed on the district's own taxable value, including the treatment of urban renewal increment and operating property.1115
The statewide numbers for 2025
Every December the Tax Commission's property tax policy bureau reports what drove the change in property taxes. For 2025, total property taxes levied rose $88.2 million, about 4.0 percent, to $2.286 billion before the homeowner tax relief credit. The 3 percent allowance could add $51.6 million, new construction $30.6 million, annexation $0.8 million and terminating urban renewal areas $10.3 million; voter-approved bonds and other exempt levies added $45.6 million, and state School District Facility Fund money cut school levies by $86.8 million more than in 2024. Districts held $132.7 million in unused forgone amounts.14
Who carries the tax side of growth
Two facts from the same report explain much of the homeowner frustration. First, new construction is a large part of value growth: the Tax Commission estimated about $2.49 billion of new primary residential value, $1.49 billion of other residential and $1.29 billion of commercial and industrial value in 2025. Second, existing homes rose too: existing owner-occupied homes gained about 5.3 percent in taxable value from 2024 to 2025, and their property taxes rose about 1.9 percent on average after tax relief.14 Owner-occupied homes held 44 percent of statewide taxable value in 2025 and paid 44.3 percent of taxes after relief, down from 51 percent in 2022.14 The budget formula lets districts collect more from the new homes themselves; it does not let them collect more because existing homes appreciated.1115
Urban renewal: growth that pays the agency first
Urban renewal, under Idaho Code Title 50, Chapters 20 (the Urban Renewal Law) and 29 (the Local Economic Development Act of 1988), changes who receives the tax on new growth inside a revenue allocation area. For each taxing district, the county sets the levy rate using the area's frozen base value, applies it to all current value, and pays the district only its tax on the base inside the area; "the balance" goes to the urban renewal agency.26 Lessons 35/07 and 39/03 work through the arithmetic. Three connections to this lesson matter.
New homes inside an area do not raise other districts' budgets. The new construction roll "shall not include new construction located within an urban renewal district's revenue allocation area," except in the listed cases.15 A subdivision built inside a revenue allocation area pays full property taxes, but the growth in value feeds the agency's projects and debt, not the city's, county's or fire district's budget capacity, for up to 20 years.27
When an area ends, the value comes back in a lump. Districts may add 80 percent of the expired increment (for areas formed after 2006) to the new construction roll, and that increase does not count against the 8 percent ceiling.1511 In 2025 this was worth $9.7 million in added budget capacity to Ada County and $14.4 million to the City of Boise (including recovered forgone amounts), and $3.5 million to ACHD, according to the Tax Commission's list of significant budget changes.14
Not every levy is captured. Voter-approved bonds, supplemental school levies, judgments and, since July 1, 2020, highway district taxes in areas formed or expanded after that date (where the city does not maintain its own roads) go to the original district.26
The 2023 to 2026 changes
House Bill 328 (2023) added large data centers (at least $250 million of investment in five years and 30 new jobs) to the base assessment roll so their value cannot be captured as increment.69 House Bill 436 (2025), from Rep. Jason Monks, made three changes: it set out a process for a city to dissolve an agency, let fire protection and ambulance service districts withdraw from existing revenue allocation areas that have no debts larger than the district's share, and kept them out of any area created or modified after July 1, 2025 unless they consent. It passed the House 57-13-0 and the Senate 28-7-0 and was signed April 4, 2025.7016 A 2026 follow-up to clarify the withdrawal process, House Bill 670, passed the House 59-10-1 and was amended in the Senate but did not become law.71
The Magic Valley gave the 2025 law an early test. The Twin Falls Ambulance District asked to withdraw from all of the Twin Falls urban renewal agency's revenue allocation areas. The agency board accepted the withdrawal from the Olde Towne-2 and Southwest areas and denied it for areas 4-3 (around the Chobani plant), 4-4 (the Clif Bar area) and Orchard Drive East, because, its 2025 annual report says, "the Agency's obligations funded by revenue allocation proceeds in these areas exceed the amount of revenue allocation attributable to the Ambulance District."17 The same report notes Chobani's announced $500 million plant expansion inside area 4-3. The agency's audited statements for the year ended Sept. 30, 2024 show $5,066,006 of property taxes received for tax increment purposes and $2,997,019 of interest on long-term debt.17 Magic Valley agencies are profiled in Magic Valley Agencies.
LIDs, CIDs, local option taxes and development agreements
Local improvement districts
Idaho's Local Improvement District Code, enacted in 1976, lets a city build streets, sidewalks, curbs, gutters, sewers, storm drains, street lighting and similar works and charge the cost to the property that benefits, by assessment rather than by general tax.24 LIDs are often used to bring older neighborhoods up to current standards, for example by adding sidewalks or connecting homes on septic tanks to city sewer. For new development, the Act requires impact fee credit when a developer pays for system improvements through a local improvement district.19 The impact fee and LID laws were written to work side by side: the Act says nothing in it supersedes "requirements or procedures authorized in the Idaho Code for local improvement districts or general obligation bond issues."18
Community infrastructure districts
The Community Infrastructure District Act of 2008 was written for large planned communities. Its stated purposes are to fund "regional community infrastructure in advance of actual developmental growth," "to provide a means for the advance payment of development impact fees," and "to create additional financial tools and financing mechanisms that allow new growth to more expediently pay for itself." Only publicly owned infrastructure may be financed, and the district may be formed only after the city or county approves a petition and the project's land use approvals are in place.25 In practice a CID issues bonds to build roads, water and sewer lines or parks, and the homes inside the district repay them through a levy or assessment on their tax bills.
Two Ada County examples appear in the Tax Commission's 2025 list of significant budget changes: the Avimor CID raised its bond levy by $225,000 and the Harris Ranch CID by $350,000.14 In 2026, House Bill 926 let counties form CIDs in unincorporated areas outside a city's planning area; its statement of purpose says CIDs exist "to ensure that new development pays for required public infrastructure without shifting those costs to existing taxpayers." It passed the House 51-17-2 and the Senate 20-14-1 and took effect July 1, 2026.72 Bills in 2025 (House Bill 407) and 2026 (House Bill 811) to let CIDs charge new homes a temporary assessment for fire and emergency medical service were both returned to committee.73 Buyers in a CID should read the disclosure of the district's levy before closing; homeowners' rights in such communities are covered in Part C of this series, coming later.
Local option taxes
Most Idaho cities cannot levy a local sales tax. The exception, since 1978, is a "resort city" of no more than 10,000 people that "derives the major portion of its economic well-being from businesses catering to recreational needs"; its voters may approve local-option nonproperty taxes such as lodging or sales taxes.74 Mountain resort towns use this power, but it does not reach the larger Treasure Valley cities, which are far above 10,000 people, or any town that cannot meet the resort test. The Legislature's control over local taxing power is covered in State Preemption and Local Control.
Development agreements and "voluntary" payments
The Act preserves private agreements: nothing in it prevents agreements between developers, the Idaho Transportation Department and local governments about building system improvements and credits, and nothing obligates a government to approve development that would have an "extraordinary impact" or drop service below the levels in its ordinance.18 That leaves room for development agreements in which a developer builds a road segment, dedicates a park or school site, or pays money. Courts look hard at payments that were required as a condition of approval but called voluntary. The roads course discusses Buckskin Properties v. Valley County, a case about road payments made under a development agreement; see Growth, Impact Fees and Who Pays. How annexation and development agreements are negotiated is in Annexation Fights.
Does growth pay for itself?
No question in Idaho local government draws more testimony. Each side has a serious case.
The case that growth does not pay enough. Impact fees by law cover only a proportionate share of capital costs in six categories. They pay nothing toward schools, libraries or operating costs such as police and firefighter salaries.1 The budget formula then limits how fast districts can raise property taxes to staff new stations: 90 percent of new construction, an 8 percent ceiling, and urban renewal areas that keep growth off the roll for up to 20 years.111527 Kuna's school study put the capital cost of school seats for a new home at as much as $32,863, against zero in required fees.58 Idaho News 6's report on Nampa's 2019 increase carried the unattributed line "Growth should pay for growth."48
The case that growth already pays, or pays too much. New homes pay fees up front that existing homes never paid, and then pay full property taxes, sewer and water rates and, in a CID, extra levies. A 2,000 square foot home in Meridian carried about $18,822 in one-time public fees in 2026, our calculation, before permit fees and before the cost of streets and pipes built by the developer.678 The Act requires credits for taxes and user fees a development will pay toward the same improvements, so growth is not charged twice.7519 Fees go into the price of a new home and push up prices of existing homes too, which hurts first-time buyers. SB 1352 (2026) now forbids larger permit, impact or connection fees for starter home subdivisions in cities over 10,000 people.43 The Mountain States Policy Center, a free-market group, published a critical analysis of ACHD's 2025 increase.44
What the evidence shows. Idaho has no statewide study that adds up all growth-related costs and revenues by city. The pieces available point in both directions. The Tax Commission's 2025 numbers show new construction added up to $30.6 million of budget capacity statewide, less than the 3 percent allowance, while voter-approved levies added $45.6 million.14 The HB 389 fiscal note expected the 2021 limits to curb budget growth by up to 23 percent in some districts.65 City impact fee studies, such as Meridian's, list the share of growth projects that fees will not cover and must come from other revenue, as 67-8207 requires.4575 The honest answer is that growth pays for most of its own pipes and roads inside subdivisions, a share of the bigger systems through fees, and its schools mostly through the same bond and levy votes everyone else pays.
Pictures, Numbers and Infographics
| Measure or rule | Idaho | U.S. or other states | Place or year | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Facilities impact fees may fund | Water, wastewater, roads, stormwater, parks, public safety | Washington adds school facilities; Texas: water, wastewater, drainage, roads | 2026 | 16263 |
| Who may adopt fees | Cities, counties, single countywide highway districts, fire and ambulance districts | Varies by state | Since July 1, 2026 | 2 |
| Deadline to spend fees | 8 years (20 for wastewater, drainage), up to 11 for cause | Idaho Code 67-8210(4) | 21 | |
| ACHD road fee, single-family home | $3,493 to $5,803 (+66.1%) | Oct. 1, 2022 to March 1, 2026 | 107 | |
| Meridian city impact fees, 1,701 to 2,500 sq. ft. | $5,516 | Since Feb. 1, 2023 | 6 | |
| Meridian water and sewer assessments | $1,696 and $5,807 | June 1, 2026 | 8 | |
| Boise city impact fees, 1,401 to 2,100 sq. ft. | $4,313.50 (Downtown) to $9,321.71 (South) | Oct. 1, 2026 | 47 | |
| Twin Falls city impact fees, single-family | $4,982 | Jan. 1, 2026 | 9 | |
| Sample fee stack, 2,000 sq. ft. home | Meridian $18,822; Boise Central Bench $12,402; Twin Falls $6,049 | 2026, our calculation | 6479 | |
| Traffic impact fee in Sheetz | $23,420 (El Dorado County, California) | Decided April 12, 2024 | 64 | |
| Kuna School District "maximum supportable" school fee | $32,863 per home (recommended $3,286, voluntary) | Jan. 24, 2023 | 58 | |
| Budget growth ceiling | 8% total; 15% for fire and ambulance districts | 2021 (HB 389); 2026 (HB 959) | 1113 | |
| Share of new construction counted | 90% | Idaho Code 63-301A(3) | 15 | |
| Potential 2025 budget growth from new construction | $30.6 million statewide | Tax year 2025 | 14 | |
| Twin Falls URA tax increment received | $5,066,006 | Year ended Sept. 30, 2024 | 17 |
Common mistakes
- "The city can charge whatever fee it wants if it calls it a fee." A charge that pays for general public needs rather than a direct service is a tax, and a city needs legislative authority to tax. The Idaho Supreme Court applied that rule in Brewster (1988), the Hayden sewer cases (2015 and 2018) and Hill-Vu (2017).235556
- "Water and sewer hookup fees are impact fees." The Act expressly excludes connection and hookup charges; they are governed by the Revenue Bond Act and the buy-in cases, with different rules on how they are calculated and spent.122
- "Impact fees can fix the potholes and pay the firefighters." Fees may not pay for repair, operation or maintenance, or for curing existing deficiencies, and the capital improvements plan must commit other revenue to existing shortfalls.176
- "The highway district in my county can just adopt an impact fee." Only a single countywide highway district is on the list. A highway district that covers part of a county can share in fees only through an agreement with a city or county.131
- "Fire districts have always been able to adopt their own fees." The definition naming fire protection and ambulance service districts took effect July 1, 2026, under HB 766. Before that, most fire districts received fees through city and county agreements.231
- "New homes raise my taxes because the city gets more money every time a house goes up." A city's budget can grow by the new construction amount, but the new home also pays the tax. Rising assessed values of existing homes do not, by themselves, add budget capacity under 63-802; they shift shares among owners.1115
- "The 3 percent cap limits my tax bill to 3 percent a year." The cap limits each district's property tax budget, not any one owner's bill. An owner's taxes can rise more if the home's value rises faster than others', or if voters approve a bond or override. Lesson 09 shows how a bill is built.11
- "School districts charge impact fees in Idaho." They cannot under the Act. Any school payment by a developer is negotiated or voluntary, as in Kuna's 2023 study.158
- "Urban renewal raises my tax rate." It can, indirectly: because increment value is excluded when other districts' rates are set, owners outside the area may pay a higher rate than they would if the growth were counted. Whether that is a real loss depends on whether the growth would have happened without the agency, the "but for" question covered in 35/07.26
What we know, what we don't, and what the data can show
What we know
- Idaho impact fees may pay only for capital improvements in six categories, may be charged only by five kinds of local government since July 1, 2026, and must be spent within eight years (20 for wastewater and drainage) or refunded.121
- Published 2026 schedules put the one-time public fees on a 2,000 square foot home at about $18,822 in Meridian, $12,402 in Boise's Central Bench area (before water and sewer), and $6,049 in Twin Falls.6479
- Bills to allow school impact fees were introduced in 2023 and 2024 and a school mitigation bill in 2025; none received a hearing.345
- Property tax budgets can grow by 3 percent plus 90 percent of new construction and annexation value at the district's rate, with an 8 percent ceiling (15 percent for fire and ambulance districts since 2026).111513
- Since 2025, fire and ambulance districts can stay out of new urban renewal areas and may withdraw from old ones without outstanding debts larger than their share.16
What we don't know
- How much impact fee money each Idaho city and county collected and spent in 2025. Every fee-charging government must publish an annual report, but no state agency compiles them.21
- How many fire and ambulance districts will adopt their own impact fee ordinances under HB 766, and how cities will divide fee revenue already shared under agreements.2
- How much developers pay school districts in "voluntary" mitigation each year, because the payments sit in individual development agreements.57
- Whether Caldwell adopted its draft school capacity ordinance, and whether other cities follow.59
- Nampa's, Caldwell's, Kuna's and Jerome's current residential fee totals, which we could not confirm from a primary record for this lesson.
What the data can show
- The annual impact fee reports required by Idaho Code 67-8210(3) can show fees collected, interest, spending by category and service area, and any refunds, year by year, for each city or district.21
- Capital improvements plans and fee studies (for example Meridian's 2022 DP Guthrie study) show the projects fees are meant to pay for and the share that must come from other money.45
- The Tax Commission's annual Market Values and Property Taxes report shows statewide new construction, annexation and urban renewal effects on budgets, and its levy and value files show each district's new construction roll.14
- Urban renewal agencies' annual reports and audits, filed by March 31, show increment received and debt, as in Twin Falls' 2025 report.17
Questions people ask
Who actually pays an impact fee, the builder or the buyer?
The builder pays it at the building permit, under 67-8204(3), but builders set prices to cover their costs, so most of the cost reaches the first buyer of a new home or the renter of a new apartment. In a slow market some of it may come out of the builder's margin or the price paid for raw land. No Idaho study measures the split.20
Can I see what my city did with the impact fees it collected?
Yes. Every government that charges impact fees must prepare an annual report, as part of its audit, describing fees collected, appropriated or spent by category and service area, and the share of other revenue used for system improvements. Ask the city clerk or finance office for the latest report and the advisory committee's annual report under 67-8205.2141
Does an accessory dwelling unit pay impact fees?
It depends on the city's schedule. ACHD's 2022 schedule set a separate $1,152 fee for an accessory dwelling unit.10 Cities that charge by floor area, such as Meridian and Boise, charge a small unit at the lowest band ($2,606 in Meridian for 1,200 square feet or less; $1,443.01 to $3,118.42 in Boise for 700 square feet or less).647 The 2026 ADU law is covered in The 2026 Housing Laws.
What can I do if I think my fee is wrong?
Ask for an individual assessment or a written certification of the fee before you pull the permit, pay under protest if you must, and use the ordinance's administrative appeal. Every Idaho impact fee ordinance must offer mediation, with costs split equally, and a refund with interest if the fee is found to exceed the proportionate share.203938
Why does a bigger house pay more in some cities?
Meridian and Boise tie parks, police and fire fees to floor area on the theory that larger homes hold more people. A 3,201 square foot Meridian home pays $7,425 in city fees against $2,606 for one of 1,200 square feet or less.6
Do new homes inside an urban renewal area pay property taxes?
Yes, at the same rates as their neighbors. The difference is where the money goes: taxes on value above the base go to the agency, and the new value is kept off the new construction roll of the other districts.2615
Hard questions
Should Idaho let school districts charge impact fees?
For: School seats are the largest growth cost many families bring; districts such as Kuna estimate it in tens of thousands of dollars per home; fees would reduce reliance on bonds that need two-thirds approval and fall on all owners.584 Against: Fees raise the price of new homes when affordability is already strained; some legislators, including Sen. Rice in 2022, raised constitutional concerns about charging the same property twice for schools; the state now sends facility money to districts.6014 What the evidence shows: Washington allows school impact fees and Idaho does not; no Idaho bill has received a hearing since at least 2023, so the Legislature has not tested the constitutional argument in committee.623
Should the 8 percent ceiling bend for fast-growing cities?
For: In the fastest-growing places, new homes create demand for police and fire staff faster than the formula lets budgets grow, and HB 842's supporters said the higher cap would apply only "if enough new construction and annexed territory has been added to cover the cost."66 Against: The cap was meant to slow local budget growth; the House rejected HB 842 28-41-1 and chose to help only fire and ambulance districts.6613 Evidence: The Tax Commission estimated about $0.3 million of statewide increases lost to the 8 percent ceiling in 2025, so the binding effect is concentrated in a few places, which is where the argument lives.14
Is one countywide road fee fair to every part of the county?
For a single area: Roads form one network; drivers from every subdivision use the arterials; one fee is simpler and ACHD has used it since 2012.7 For two or more areas: Most new road projects are on the growing west and south sides, so homes in built-out areas may pay for roads they will rarely use. The roads course reports the draft two-zone figures ACHD considered. Evidence: The Act allows service areas drawn "on the basis of sound planning or engineering principles," leaving the choice to the governing board.1
Should fire and ambulance districts be able to leave urban renewal areas?
For: These districts must answer every call in a growing area, and their budgets lose the growth inside revenue allocation areas for up to 20 years.2770 Against: Agencies borrowed against expected increment; Twin Falls' agency denied the ambulance district's withdrawal from three areas because its obligations exceeded the district's share.17 Evidence: The 2025 law protects existing debt; its effect on new projects depends on whether fire districts consent to new areas, which the record will show over the next few years.16
For reporters and advocates
Records to request. Under the Idaho Public Records Act (Idaho Code Title 74, Chapter 1; see Idaho Public Records Requests), ask any city, county, ACHD, fire or ambulance district for: the impact fee ordinance and current schedule; the capital improvements plan and the fee study behind it; the land use assumptions; the annual impact fee report under 67-8210(3); the advisory committee's annual report, roster and minutes; the list of individual assessments, credits, reimbursement agreements and refunds; and fee balances by category and service area with the date each dollar was collected (to test the eight-year rule).214119
Questions to ask. Which projects in the capital plan have been built, and which have slipped? How much of each project is paid by fees and how much by taxes? Were any fees held past eight years, and were refunds sent? Has the plan been updated within five years, as 67-8208(2) requires?76 For utilities: how is the connection fee calculated, as a buy-in on existing system value or as a share of expansion cost?23 For the budget cap: what was the district's new construction roll value and how much did it add to the budget? For urban renewal: how much increment did each area produce, which districts asked to withdraw, and when does each area end?1715
Where the numbers are. Fee schedules on city and district websites; ordinances in the city code (often on American Legal or Code Publishing); budgets and audits on city sites; the Tax Commission's annual property tax reports and value files; urban renewal annual reports, which must be filed and noticed by March 31 under Idaho Code 50-2006(5)(c).1417 Meetings where fees are set are subject to the Open Meeting Law; see Idaho Open Meetings.
The Magic Valley angle. Twin Falls set new impact fees effective Jan. 1, 2026 and runs its own water and sewer connection charges; Kimberly has an impact fee chapter; Jerome, Gooding, Buhl and Hagerman did not have schedules we could find. Ask each smaller city whether it has considered impact fees, what its water and sewer connection fees are based on, and whether its highway district has any fee-sharing agreement with the city or county. Ask the Twin Falls urban renewal agency for the Chobani-area increment and debt schedule now that the ambulance district's withdrawal was denied there.95317 Growth data for these towns is in The Magic Valley Case Study.
Where to go next
- Idaho Statutes search (Idaho Legislature): Free official text of Idaho Code with history notes showing each session law that changed a section. Search 67-82 for impact fees or 63-802 for the budget cap.
- Idaho Legislature bill search, 2026 session: Free. Each bill page has the text, statement of purpose, votes and session law chapter; the index at the bottom lists every 2026 law by chapter number.
- Idaho State Tax Commission property tax reports: Free annual report on what changed property taxes statewide, with tables on new construction, urban renewal and taxes by type of government. Published each December.
- ACHD impact fees page: Free. Ada County Highway District's current ordinance, capital improvements plan and individual assessment forms; useful for anyone building in Ada County.
- Idaho State Controller, local government and urban renewal reports: Free. The Controller's site hosts local government financial filings, including urban renewal agency reports and audits; search by agency name.
- Growth, Impact Fees and Who Pays (roads course): Free companion lesson on this site with a section-by-section tour of the Act and the full ACHD 2025 update; read it next if roads are your focus.
Still being checked (9 items)
These points could not be fully confirmed against a primary source when this lesson was written and fact checked in November 2026. The text above states each one as uncertain.
- Nampa, Caldwell, Kuna and Jerome current residential impact fee or connection fee totals: not confirmed from a primary record; the lesson gives only Nampa's 2019 change as reported by Idaho News 6 and KTVB.
- Kimberly's impact fee amounts come from the Zoneomics republication of Kimberly City Code chapter 17.18; the official American Legal copy returned an access error. The library and administration lines should be checked against the official ordinance.
- Whether Caldwell adopted its 2026 draft school capacity ordinance.
- The exact square-foot definitions each city uses (for example, treatment of basements) in the sample fee stack.
- Meridian's posted water and sewer assessment amounts are treated as the amounts for one single-family residence; the notice does not state the unit basis.
- Idaho Supreme Court opinions were read through Justia because the older isc.idaho.gov opinion links returned errors on Nov. 18, 2026.
- That the Ada County Highway District is the only single countywide highway district in Idaho: not stated in the ACHD page cited (note 34); the text now says it is the only one we found.
- Retroactive date of HB 328 (2023), given in note 69 as March 16, 2023, was not rechecked against the bill status page by the fact checker.
- RCW 82.02.090 (note 62) could not be reopened on Nov. 18, 2026 (the Washington Legislature site blocked the automated reader); the "school facilities" wording was not rechecked.
Last verified November 18, 2026. General education, not legal, tax, financial or real estate advice; every figure names its source and year in the Notes and Sources below. Data is revised: check the newest release before relying on any number.
Notes
- Idaho Code section 67-8203, "Definitions," added 1992, ch. 282; amended 1996, 2002, 2007, 2008, 2019 (ch. 70), 2021 (ch. 199) and 2026 (ch. 203). Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 766 (2026), Ways and Means Committee, floor sponsors Rep. Mark Sauter (House) and Sen. Okuniewicz (Senate): revises the definition of "governmental entity" in 67-8203(14); passed House 39-27-4 on March 9, 2026 and Senate 24-9-2 on March 24, 2026; signed March 27, 2026; Session Laws 2026, ch. 203; effective July 1, 2026. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Senate Bill 1060 (2023), Local Government and Taxation Committee, contacts Sen. Geoff Schroeder and Rep. Jaron Crane: would have added public schools to "public facilities" and school districts to the entities allowed to charge impact fees (statement of purpose RS29965C2); printed and referred to Senate Local Government and Taxation Feb. 10, 2023, with no further action shown. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 582 (2024), sponsored by Rep. Lauren Necochea: would have let public school districts collect impact fees for capital improvements (statement of purpose RS31384); introduced Feb. 16, 2024, printed and filed in the Office of the Chief Clerk Feb. 19, 2024, with no hearing shown. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 429 (2025), sponsored by Rep. Bruce: would have required a school district receiving subdivision mitigation money under 67-6513 to adopt a capacity plan (statement of purpose RS32711); printed and filed in the Office of the Chief Clerk, no hearing shown. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- City of Meridian, Ordinance No. 22-2004, accepting the 2022 Development Impact Fees Study and amending Meridian City Code 10-7-12(E)(2); public hearing Nov. 9, 2022; fee schedule effective Feb. 1, 2023 (council meeting attachment) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Ada County Highway District, "ACHD NEWS: Impact Fee, CIP Update Approved," Dec. 5, 2025: Ordinance No. 254 adopted 4-1, effective March 1, 2026; $5,803 per single-family home, $2,371 per multifamily unit; $1.2 billion of impact fee eligible projects over 20 years; single service area since 2012 (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- City of Meridian, "Water and Sewer Assessments," effective June 1, 2026: sewer assessment $5,807 (was $5,411), water assessment $1,696 (was $1,514) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- City of Twin Falls Planning and Zoning Department, "Impact Fees (Jan 2026)": per City Council decision of Dec. 8, 2025, effective Jan. 1, 2026; single-family total $4,982 (police $276, fire $1,105, parks $1,918, streets $1,683) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- City of Meridian Building Division, "ACHD Fee Increase, Effective October 1, 2022," with ACHD Ordinance 246A Exhibit A traffic impact fee table (single-family detached, ITE code 210: 0.470 PM peak trips x 6.17-mile average trip length x 0.467 network factor x $2,579 cost per vehicle-mile = $3,493) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 63-802, "Limitation on budget requests, limitation on tax charges, exceptions," added 2012, ch. 339; amended through 2021 (HB 389, ch. 360), 2025 (ch. 300) and 2026 (HB 765, ch. 197, and HB 959, ch. 316). Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 389 (2021), Ways and Means Committee, floor sponsors Rep. Mike Moyle (House) and Sen. Jim Rice (Senate): passed House 48-20-1 and Senate 19-16-0; signed May 12, 2021; Session Laws 2021, ch. 360; sections 1 to 7 and 12 retroactive to Jan. 1, 2021, sections 8 to 11 effective Jan. 1, 2022. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 959 (2026), Ways and Means Committee, floor sponsors Rep. Mike Moyle (House) and Sen. Okuniewicz (Senate): fire protection and ambulance service districts get a 15 percent total cap, new construction priced at the prior year's levy rate, no new forgone balances after 2025, and a voter initiative to raise or lower their budgets (revised statement of purpose RS33842C1); passed House 67-0-3 and Senate 33-0-2; signed April 10, 2026; Session Laws 2026, ch. 316. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho State Tax Commission, Alan S. Dornfest and Ben Seloske, Market Values and Property Taxes for 2025, EPB00132, Dec. 22, 2025, Tables 3, 4, 7 and 8 (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 63-301A, "New construction roll," added 1997, ch. 117; amended through 2021 (HB 389, ch. 360), 2022 (HB 673, ch. 310), 2025 (ch. 300) and 2026 (HB 551, ch. 19; HB 765, ch. 197). Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 50-2906, "Public hearing and ordinance required, special rules for certain taxing districts," added 1988, ch. 210; amended 1994, 2000 and 2025 (HB 436, ch. 300). Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Urban Renewal Agency of the City of Twin Falls, 2025 Annual Report, Shawn Barigar, executive director, March 16, 2026, filed under Idaho Code 50-2006(5)(c), including the audited financial statements for the year ended Sept. 30, 2024 (Mahlke Hunsaker and Company) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8214, "Other powers and rights not affected," added 1992; amended 1996. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8209, "Credits," added 1992; amended 1996, 1999 and 2002. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8204, "Minimum standards and requirements for development impact fees ordinances," added 1992, ch. 282; amended 1996 and 2002. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8210, "Earmarking and expenditure of collected development impact fees," added 1992; amended 1996, 2002 and 2006. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 50-1030, "Powers of cities (Revenue Bond Act)," see subsection (f) on rates, fees and charges for city utility systems. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- North Idaho Building Contractors Ass'n v. City of Hayden, Idaho Supreme Court, Docket No. 45181, Dec. 28, 2018 (vacating the refund judgment and remanding so the city could try to show the 2007 fee complied with the Revenue Bond Act, Idaho Code 50-1030(f); discussing Brewster v. City of Pocatello, 115 Idaho 502 (1988), Loomis v. City of Hailey, 119 Idaho 434 (1991), and Viking Construction, Inc. v. Hayden Lake Irrigation District, 149 Idaho 187 (2010)) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 50-1703, "Powers conferred (Local Improvement District Code)," added 1976, ch. 160; amended 1999 and 2001. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 50-3101, "Purpose, relationship with other laws and short title (Community Infrastructure District Act)," added 2008, ch. 410; amended 2026 (HB 926, ch. 300). Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 50-2908, "Determination of tax levies, creation of special fund," added 2012, ch. 339; amended 2015, 2019, 2020 (ch. 259) and 2025 (HB 436, ch. 300). Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 50-2904, "Authority to adopt revenue allocation financing provision, duration," added 1988, ch. 210; amended through 2025 (ch. 300). Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8202, "Purpose," added 1992, ch. 282 (the Idaho Development Impact Fee Act). Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8215, "Transition," added 1992, ch. 282. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 626 (2026), Local Government Committee, contact Rep. Joe Alfieri: would have required cities to collect any county impact fee adopted for a county courthouse or jail (statement of purpose RS33155); passed House 68-1-1 on March 5, 2026; referred to Senate Local Government and Taxation, no further action shown. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8204A, "Intergovernmental agreements," added 1996, ch. 366; amended 2007 and 2021 (ch. 95). Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 110 (2021), Local Government Committee: adds ambulance districts to the impact fee intergovernmental agreement section; passed House 66-0-4 and Senate 34-0-1; signed March 19, 2021; Session Laws 2021, ch. 95; effective July 1, 2021. Bill status page and statement of purpose RS28425 (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 156 (2021), Local Government Committee, floor sponsor Rep. Tammy Nichols: adds "fire stations and apparatus" to the public safety facilities that impact fees may fund; passed House 67-0-3 and Senate 35-0-0; signed April 13, 2021; Session Laws 2021, ch. 199; effective July 1, 2021. Bill status page and statement of purpose RS28520 (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Ada County Highway District, "Impact Fees" page (Ordinance 254 approved Dec. 3, 2025, effective March 1, 2026; Ordinance 246A) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Statement of purpose RS33531 / H0766 (2026), contacts Rep. Mike Moyle and Rep. Mark Sauter: the bill "adds these districts" (fire and ambulance service districts) "to the list of other entities empowered" to adopt impact fee ordinances; no fiscal impact (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 767 (2026), Ways and Means Committee: would have let impact fees pay for 50 percent of fire apparatus replacement listed in an adopted capital improvements plan (statement of purpose RS33532); passed House 51-15-4 on March 9, 2026; referred to Senate Local Government and Taxation on March 10, 2026, with no further action shown. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 91 (2019), Local Government Committee, "Development impact fees" (excludes public charter school activities from "development"): passed House 60-9-1 and Senate 35-0-0; signed March 12, 2019; Idaho Session Laws 2019, ch. 70; effective March 12, 2019. Idaho Legislature bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8211, "Refunds," added 1992; amended 2002. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8212, "Appeals," added 1992; amended 1996. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8213, "Collection," added 1992; amended 2002. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8205, "Development impact fee advisory committee," added 1992; amended 2021 (ch. 136) and 2023 (ch. 146). Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Senate Bill 1114 (2023), floor sponsor Sen. Geoff Schroeder: advisory committee members must live in the service area and may not be government employees or officials acting in that capacity; passed Senate 34-0-1 and House 59-9-2; signed March 27, 2023; Session Laws 2023, ch. 146; effective July 1, 2023. Bill status page and revised statement of purpose RS30382 (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-6542 (printed as 67-6541), "Starter home subdivisions," added by Senate Bill 1352 (2026), Session Laws 2026, ch. 264; subsection (2)(e) bars higher permit, impact or connection fees for starter home subdivisions; subsection (4) applies it only to cities with a population greater than 10,000, and the statute does not say which population figure (2020 Census, a later estimate or another count) decides (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Mountain States Policy Center (a Spokane-based free-market policy group), "Ada County Highway District increases impact fees by 66%" (undated web article on the December 2025 decision) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- DP Guthrie LLC, Meridian Development Impact Fees Study, Sept. 16, 2022, prepared for the City of Meridian (council meeting attachment) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- City of Meridian Building Division, "Fee Schedules, Calculators and Estimating" page, listing the police, fire and parks impact fee schedule effective Feb. 1, 2023 and ACHD fees (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- City of Boise, "Boise City Impact Fee Schedule effective October 1, 2026" (regional parks, local parks, fire and police fees by planning area and dwelling size; 1 percent surcharge for capital plan preparation) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho News 6 (KIVI), "Nampa approves major increase to impact fees," March 5, 2019 (single-family fee from $1,806 to $5,459; quotes consultant Anne Wescott of Galena Consulting; the line "Growth should pay for growth. We should not have to pay for growth." appears without attribution) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- KTVB, "Nampa City Council approves new impact fees projected to generate $70 million over 10 years" (2019) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Twin Falls City Code, development impact fee provisions, subsections (A) to (E) (fee obligation; collection at building permit), history note Ord. 2021-017, adopted Oct. 11, 2021, American Legal Publishing (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- City of Twin Falls, "2025-26 Sewer Connection Fees," effective Oct. 1, 2025 to Sept. 30, 2026 (single-family capacity fee $512.54; 4-inch residential tap $105.00) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- City of Twin Falls, "2025-26 Water Connection Fees," effective Oct. 1, 2025 to Sept. 30, 2026 (1-inch residential: service line, meter and installation $3,088.47 when the city installs; water meter fee $449.28 assessed at building permit) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Kimberly City Code, chapter 17.18, "Schedule of Development Impact Fees, and Assessment Criteria" (Ord. 671, 2022 and 2023; Ord. 689, 2025; fee study dated Feb. 22, 2022), as republished by Zoneomics. The official American Legal copy could not be opened from our location (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 63-1311, "Fees for services," added 1996, ch. 98; amended 1997. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- North Idaho Building Contractors Ass'n v. City of Hayden, Idaho Supreme Court, Docket No. 41316-2013 (2015) (sewer capitalization fee raised to $2,280 per equivalent residence in 2007 not shown to be authorized under Idaho Code 63-1311(1)). Opinion text at Justia (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Hill-Vu Mobile Home Park v. City of Pocatello, Idaho Supreme Court, Docket No. 44074-2016, Opinion No. 96, Sept. 6, 2017 (a "payment in lieu of taxes" charge on city water and sewer bills was neither an authorized fee nor an authorized tax; vacated and remanded) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-6513, "Subdivision ordinance," as added by 1975, ch. 188; amended 1992 (ch. 269), 1999 and 2003; says fees to mitigate the effects of development on political subdivisions "including school districts" must comply with chapter 82, title 67. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Kuna School District, Voluntary Capital Mitigation Fee study, Jan. 24, 2023 (maximum supportable fee $32,863 per single-family home; staff recommended 10 percent, $3,286), as posted by Idaho Education News, May 2023 (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- City of Caldwell, draft omnibus ordinance adding section 10-03-19, "Adequate Public Facilities: Public School Districts" (ordinance number blank, marked for March 2026 and under legal review), posted on the mayor's office transparency page. We could not confirm whether it was adopted (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Anna Azallion, "Education advocates push for new way to fund school construction costs," Idaho News 6 (KIVI), Jan. 26, 2022 (updated Jan. 31, 2022). Quotes from Rep. Lauren Necochea, Sen. Jim Rice and West Ada School District staff (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Legislature, 2026 Legislation index, session law chapter table (ch. 19 HB 551; ch. 197 HB 765; ch. 203 HB 766; ch. 300 HB 926; ch. 316 HB 959) (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Revised Code of Washington 82.02.090(7), definition of "public facilities" for impact fees: streets and roads, parks, "school facilities," and fire protection facilities. Washington State Legislature (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Texas Local Government Code, chapter 395, sections 395.001(1) (capital improvements: water, wastewater, storm water and drainage, and roadway facilities) and 395.013 (uses not allowed). Texas Legislature (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Sheetz v. County of El Dorado, U.S. Supreme Court, No. 22-1074, April 12, 2024 (9-0; opinion by Justice Barrett; $23,420 traffic impact fee on a small prefabricated home): "The Takings Clause does not distinguish between legislative and administrative permit conditions." (The syllabus words it "land-use permit conditions.") Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Statement of purpose RS28965 / H0389 (2021): "creating a total cap of 8% in any budget year"; fiscal note says limits on new construction, annexation and forgone amounts "may result in curbed budget growth by as much as 23% in some cases" (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 842 (2026), Revenue and Taxation Committee, floor sponsor Rep. David Cannon: would have raised the 8 percent cap to 15 percent for cities under 30,000 people and the fire and ambulance districts serving them (statement of purpose RS33625); failed in the House 28-41-1. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 551 (2026), Revenue and Taxation Committee, floor sponsor Rep. Richard Cheatum: new construction roll correction for fire and ambulance districts not subject to urban renewal financing (statement of purpose RS32840); passed House 68-0-2 and Senate 31-0-4; signed March 11, 2026; Session Laws 2026, ch. 19; retroactive to Jan. 1, 2026. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 765 (2026), Ways and Means Committee, contacts Rep. Mike Moyle and Rep. Mark Sauter: budget and new construction roll adjustments when fire and library districts swap territory or a city fire department consolidates with a fire district (statement of purpose RS33530); signed March 27, 2026; Session Laws 2026, ch. 197; retroactive to Jan. 1, 2026 (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 328 (2023), contacts Rep. Jeff Ehlers and Rep. John Gannon: large data centers added to the urban renewal base assessment roll (revised statement of purpose RS30690); Session Laws 2023, ch. 308, retroactive to March 16, 2023 (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 436 (2025), Revenue and Taxation Committee, floor sponsor Rep. Jason Monks: dissolution of urban renewal agencies, fire and ambulance district opt-out and opt-in, manufacturing project extension (statement of purpose RS32716); passed House 57-13-0 and Senate 28-7-0; signed April 4, 2025; Session Laws 2025, ch. 300; retroactive to Jan. 1, 2025. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 670 (2026), Revenue and Taxation Committee, contact Rep. Jason Monks: would have clarified the 2025 fire district withdrawal process (statement of purpose RS33317); passed House 59-10-1; amended in the Senate and not enacted. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 926 (2026), Ways and Means Committee, floor sponsor Rep. David Cannon: lets counties form community infrastructure districts outside a city's planning area (statement of purpose RS33763); passed House 51-17-2 and Senate 20-14-1; signed April 2, 2026; Session Laws 2026, ch. 300; effective July 1, 2026. Bill status page (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- House Bill 407 (2025) and House Bill 811 (2026), Revenue and Taxation Committee: both would have let a community infrastructure district levy a temporary assessment on new homes for fire and emergency medical services; each was returned to committee and not enacted. Bill status pages (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 50-1044, "Authority for resort city residents to approve and resort city governments to adopt, implement and collect certain city nonproperty taxes," added 1978, ch. 261; amended 1981 and 2013. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8207, "Proportionate share determination," added 1992; amended 1996 and 2002. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
- Idaho Code section 67-8208, "Capital improvements plan," added 1992; amended 1996 and 2002. Idaho Legislature, Idaho Statutes (read Nov. 18, 2026). Read it online. ↩
Check yourself
1. Since July 1, 2026, which of these may adopt its own development impact fee ordinance under Idaho Code 67-8203(14)?
HB 766 (2026, Session Laws ch. 203) defines governmental entity as cities, counties, single countywide highway districts, fire protection districts and ambulance service districts.
2. Which cost may an Idaho impact fee pay for?
Idaho Code 67-8203(24)(f) includes fire stations and apparatus; 67-8203(29) excludes operation, maintenance and better service to existing development; schools are not public facilities under the Act.
3. Under ACHD Ordinance 254, effective March 1, 2026, what is the road impact fee for a single-family home?
ACHD's Dec. 5, 2025 bulletin lists $5,803 per single-family home; the prior fee under Ordinance 246A was $3,493 (Oct. 1, 2022).
4. Why are Meridian's water and sewer assessments not governed by the Development Impact Fee Act?
Idaho Code 67-8203(9)(b) says the term impact fee does not include connection or hookup charges; such charges rest on the Revenue Bond Act, 50-1030(f), and the fee-or-tax cases.
5. In North Idaho Building Contractors Ass'n v. City of Hayden (2018), what did the Idaho Supreme Court do with the trial court's refund judgment?
Docket No. 45181 (Dec. 28, 2018) vacated the judgment, damages and attorney fee awards and remanded for evidence on whether the 2007 capitalization fee was lawful.
6. What happened to Senate Bill 1060 (2023), which would have allowed school impact fees?
The SB 1060 bill status page shows it printed and referred to Senate Local Government and Taxation on Feb. 10, 2023, with no further action.
7. Under Idaho Code 63-301A(3) as of 2026, what share of the taxable value of a completed new structure goes on the new construction roll?
63-301A(3) says the roll shall include 90 percent of the taxable market value increase from listed new construction, a limit set by HB 389 (2021).
8. What did House Bill 959 (2026) do?
HB 959 (Session Laws 2026, ch. 316) applies only to fire and ambulance districts; the broader HB 842, which included small cities, failed 28-41-1.
9. Under the 2025 urban renewal law (HB 436), why did the Twin Falls urban renewal agency deny the ambulance district's withdrawal from area 4-3?
Idaho Code 50-2906(5) allows withdrawal only where obligations do not exceed the district's share; the agency's 2025 annual report gives that reason for areas 4-3, 4-4 and Orchard Drive East.
10. In the Tax Commission's 2025 report, about how much potential property tax budget growth statewide came from new construction?
Market Values and Property Taxes for 2025 (EPB00132), Table 3: new construction $30.6 million; annexation $0.8 million; terminating URAs $10.3 million; overall increase $88.2 million.
Terms in this lesson
- Development impact fee
- A one-time payment required as a condition of development approval to pay a proportionate share of system improvements needed to serve new development (Idaho Code 67-8203(9)).
- System improvements
- Capital improvements to public facilities that serve a whole service area, such as an arterial road or sewer plant, as opposed to improvements for one project.
- Project improvements
- Streets, pipes and other site facilities built for one development and needed by its occupants; the developer builds them and gets no impact fee credit.
- The part of system improvement costs reasonably related to a project's service demands, after credits for other payments (67-8207).
- Capital improvements plan (CIP)
- The plan required by 67-8208 listing existing deficiencies, growth projects, costs, service units and funding sources; updated at least every five years.
- Service unit
- A standard measure of demand, such as a peak-hour trip or an equivalent residence, used to convert land uses into fee amounts.
- Individual assessment
- A developer's own study asking the government to set a fee based on the project's actual demand instead of the schedule (67-8204(5)).
- Connection or capacity fee
- A one-time utility charge to connect to a water or sewer system, often a buy-in to existing capacity; not an impact fee under the Act.
- New construction roll
- The assessor's list of taxable value added by new construction (counted at 90 percent) used to let budgets grow beyond 3 percent (63-301A).
- Forgone amount
- A budget increase a district was allowed but did not take, which it may reserve and use later within limits (63-802(1)(e)).
- Revenue allocation area
- The part of an urban renewal area where growth in property tax above the base value goes to the urban renewal agency (50-2908).
- Local improvement district (LID)
- A district a city creates to build a street, sewer or similar improvement and charge the cost to benefited property by assessment (chapter 50-17).
- Community infrastructure district (CID)
- A district formed under the 2008 act to finance public infrastructure for a development, repaid by owners inside the district (chapter 50-31).
- Resort city local option tax
- A nonproperty tax that voters in a resort city of no more than 10,000 people may approve (50-1044).
Sources
- Idaho Code Title 67, Chapter 82, Development Impact Fees (2026-11-18) checked 2026-11
- Idaho Code 63-802, limitation on budget requests (2026-11-18) checked 2026-11
- Idaho Code 63-301A, new construction roll (2026-11-18) checked 2026-11
- Idaho Code 50-2906 and 50-2908, urban renewal revenue allocation (2026-11-18) checked 2026-11
- House Bill 766 (2026), development impact fees (2026-11-18) checked 2026-11
- House Bill 959 (2026), fire and ambulance district budgets (2026-11-18) checked 2026-11
- House Bill 389 (2021), property taxes (2026-11-18) checked 2026-11
- Idaho State Tax Commission, Market Values and Property Taxes for 2025 (EPB00132) (2025-12-22) checked 2026-11
- ACHD, Impact Fee and CIP update approved (Ordinance 254) (2025-12-05) checked 2026-11
- City of Meridian Ordinance 22-2004 (impact fees effective Feb. 1, 2023) (2026-11-18) checked 2026-11
- City of Boise impact fee schedule effective Oct. 1, 2026 (2026-11-18) checked 2026-11
- City of Twin Falls impact fees effective Jan. 1, 2026 (2026-11-18) checked 2026-11
- Urban Renewal Agency of the City of Twin Falls, 2025 Annual Report (2026-03-16) checked 2026-11
- North Idaho Building Contractors Ass'n v. City of Hayden, Idaho Supreme Court Docket No. 45181 (2018) (2018-12-28) checked 2026-11