Lesson 3 of 10 · about 55 minutes
The Political Cartoon, 1945 to 2000: Herblock, Mauldin, Conrad, Trudeau and the Syndicated Age
You'll be able to
- Describe the March 29, 1950 Herblock cartoon at the Library of Congress and what the Library says it introduced
- List Herblock's Pulitzers (1942, 1954, 1979) and the 1973 Watergate public service prize he shared, and say how each is credited
- Read the Pulitzer category page for 1945 to 2000, including the years it lists no winner and the cited works
- Explain what happened to the May 1973 Doonesbury strip about John Mitchell and correct the claim that it was banned
- Use the Herb Block Foundation's 2011 report and the Columbia Journalism Review's 2012 article to describe the syndication economy, stating what was and was not verified
Start here: the short version
- Herbert Block, "Herblock" (born October 13, 1909; died October 7, 2001), is the central figure.1 The Library of Congress says he coined the word McCarthyism in a cartoon dated March 29, 1950.2 The Herb Block Foundation lists his cartooning Pulitzers for 1942, 1954 and 1979, plus a share of the 1973 Public Service prize the Washington Post won for Watergate.3
- The Pulitzer site's Editorial Cartooning page, read here from 1945 to 2000, lists a winner for every year except 1960, 1965 and 1973.4 It credits some winners for a single cartoon, some for a year's work, and one, Garry Trudeau in 1975, for a comic strip: "For his cartoon strip Doonesbury."5
- Strips and cartoons still got pulled. In May 1973 more than a dozen of the roughly 300 newspapers carrying Doonesbury declined a strip in which a character calls John Mitchell guilty, and the Washington Post ran it 41 years later, in 2014.6 The strip was not banned from American papers.
- Women entered the winners' list late. The Philadelphia Inquirer says Signe Wilkinson became the first woman to win the prize, in April 1992.7 The Pulitzer site lists Ann Telnaes as the 2001 winner.8
- The staff job shrank. The Herb Block Foundation's 2011 report says about 2,000 cartoonists were employed in the early 1900s and fewer than 40 staff cartoonists remained, while an essay in the same report says just over 60.9 This course could not verify figures for 1980 or 2000 and does not print any.
Lesson 02 ended with a sergeant's Pulitzer for drawing two tired infantrymen. The cartoonists of 1945 to 2000 inherited a different industry: fewer cities with competing papers, more syndication, television news as a rival, and a federal government that had become the cartoonist's daily subject. This lesson follows them. Because nearly every postwar cartoon is still under copyright, there are no embedded images here. Each work is described from a catalog record or a museum or prize page and linked to the page that holds it. That is the rule for this course, and it is also how a reporter should handle them.
Herblock and the word McCarthyism
The Herb Block Foundation's biography says Herbert Block was born in Chicago on October 13, 1909, and died on October 7, 2001.10 He studied at Lake Forest College for two years and took part-time classes at the Art Institute of Chicago. He drew editorial cartoons for the Chicago Daily News and for Newspaper Enterprise Association (NEA) in Cleveland, served in the U.S. Army from 1943 to 1945, and joined the Washington Post in 1946.11 The Foundation describes a career of 72 years.12 It lists his Pulitzer Prizes for cartooning in 1942, 1954 and 1979, and notes that in 1973 he was one of four Post staff members named in the Public Service prize for Watergate coverage.13 Other honors include the Presidential Medal of Freedom (1994) and the Library of Congress Living Legends Medal (2000).14 The Pulitzer site's category page credits the 1942 prize to NEA for the cartoon "British Plane," the 1954 prize to the Post and Times-Herald for a cartoon of Death addressing Stalin, captioned in part "You Were Always A Great Friend of Mine, Joseph," and the 1979 prize to the Washington Post "for the body of his work."15
The cartoon that made his name in politics is catalogued in the Library of Congress's exhibit Herblock's History. The page says Herb Block coined the term "McCarthyism" in a cartoon dated March 29, 1950, weeks after Senator Joseph McCarthy claimed to hold a list of communists in the State Department.16 Its caption is "You mean I'm supposed to stand on that?"17 The Library describes the picture as Republican senators Kenneth S. Wherry, Robert A. Taft and Styles Bridges, with Republican National Chairman Guy Gabrielson, pushing a reluctant GOP elephant onto an unsavory platform, and calls it the first use of the word McCarthyism.18
Read what the word did. Before the cartoon, there was a senator and a set of accusations. After it, there was an "-ism," a name for a method, one that could be applied to people who had never met McCarthy. The cartoon also put the blame on McCarthy's allies in his own party and not only on him. The Library's page describes the platform as unsavory and the elephant as reluctant, so the argument of the picture is that a party was being asked to stand on something it should not. A reader who wants to check the claim should open the Library's page and compare the date and caption to the cartoon's reproduction there. The cartoon is under copyright and is described here, not embedded.
Nixon in the cartoons
The same Library exhibit follows Herblock's drawings of Richard Nixon from 1954 into the Watergate years. The "Fire" page notes Herblock's 1954 depiction of Nixon as an emerging campaigner, "Here he comes now," which the page says stuck with Nixon throughout his career.19 A companion page, "Crook," lists the Nixon cartoons from 1970 to 1974 with the events they answered:
| Cartoon title (Library of Congress) | Year | What the Library says it addressed | 20
|---|---|---|
| "Taped" | 1970 | Government wiretapping and surveillance of citizens |
| "New figure on the American scene" | 1971 | Nixon's efforts to curb press coverage, including during the Pentagon Papers dispute |
| "For the championship of the United States" | 1971 | Campaign finance and Nixon's opposition to public financing |
| "Now, as I was saying four years ago" | 1972 | Nixon's claims about ending the Vietnam War |
| "There's no need for an independent investigation" | 1972 | Early Watergate-related questions about campaign irregularities |
| "Nixon awash in his office" | 1973 | John Dean's testimony first accusing Nixon of involvement in the cover-up |
| "Move over" | 1973 | Nixon's other scandals, including tax deductions and taxpayer-funded home improvements |
| "I am not a crook" | 1974 | Nixon's November 1973 statement, "Well, I'm not a crook"21 |
| "Nixon hanging between the tapes" | 1974 | The Oval Office recordings that became key evidence |
| "Nixon, 'unindicted co-conspirator'" | 1974 | Appeared shortly before Nixon's resignation on August 9, 197422 |
The Library page also notes that Herblock's cartoons responded to the June 1972 Watergate break-in and that he published Herblock Special Report in 1974, a book of cartoons on Nixon's career.23 A fair reader asks what the list shows. It shows a cartoonist who treated one man as a subject for twenty years. It also shows that his best-known cartoons were made in answer to news, which is the cartoon's usual relation to events. The cartoons carry a position on each, and the Library's page is a place to check that position against its date. The "five o'clock shadow" that many people associate with Herblock's Nixon is not on either Library page, and no source fetched for this lesson verified when it first appeared, so this lesson does not describe it.
How to: use the Library's Herblock pages as a primary source
- Open the exhibit page (Fire or Crook) and write down the cartoon's title, date and the event the Library says it answers.
- Check the event independently. For the March 29, 1950 cartoon, McCarthy's claim to hold a list of State Department communists is the Library's own context; confirm the date of that claim in a second source before you build a timeline on it.
- Name the technique with the Archives worksheet: what are the symbols (an elephant for the Republican Party), the words (the caption), the exaggeration, and the irony? Then state the message in one sentence.
- Say who held the copyright. The Library does not license these, and a reporter who wants to reproduce one should find the rightsholder, which is covered in lesson 10.
- Note the limits of the page. The Library's pages do not address the nickname or the shadow some readers remember. When your memory and the catalog differ, the catalog is what you can cite.
The Pulitzers, 1945 to 2000
The table below is the Pulitzer site's Editorial Cartooning page for these years, cited works as the page gives them. The page lists no winner for 1960, 1965 or 1973 and does not say why.24 For many years after 1975 the page gives no cited work, only the winner and outlet, so a blank in the third column means the page cites none.
| Year | Winner | Outlet | Cited work | 25
|---|---|---|---|
| 1945 | Bill Mauldin (rank listed as Technician Third Grade on the category page, Sergeant on another Pulitzer page) | United Feature Syndicate | Series "Up Front With Mauldin" |
| 1946 | Bruce Alexander Russell | Los Angeles Times | "Time to Bridge That Gulch" |
| 1947 | Vaughn Shoemaker | Chicago Daily News | "Still Racing His Shadow" |
| 1948 | Reuben L. Goldberg | New York Sun | "Peace Today" |
| 1949 | Lute Pease | Newark Evening News | "Who Me?" |
| 1950 | James T. Berryman | The Evening Star, Washington | "All Set for a Super-Secret Session in Washington" |
| 1951 | Reg Manning | Arizona Republic | "Hats" |
| 1952 | Fred L. Packer | New York Mirror | "Your Editors Ought to Have More Sense Than to Print What I Say!" |
| 1953 | Edward D. Kuekes | Cleveland Plain Dealer | "Aftermath" |
| 1954 | Herbert L. Block (Herblock) | The Washington Post & Times-Herald | A cartoon of Death addressing Stalin, captioned in part "You Were Always A Great Friend of Mine, Joseph" |
| 1955 | Daniel R. Fitzpatrick | St. Louis Post-Dispatch | "How Would Another Mistake Help?" (June 8, 1954) |
| 1956 | Robert York | Louisville Times | "Achilles" |
| 1957 | Tom Little | The Nashville Tennessean | "Wonder Why My Parents Didn't Give Me Salk Shots?" (January 12, 1956) |
| 1958 | Bruce M. Shanks | Buffalo Evening News | "The Thinker" (August 10, 1957) |
| 1959 | William H. (Bill) Mauldin | St. Louis Post-Dispatch | "I won the Nobel Prize for Literature. What was your crime?" (October 30, 1958) |
| 1961 | Carey Orr | Chicago Tribune | "The Kindly Tiger" (October 8, 1960) |
| 1962 | Edmund S. Valtman | The Hartford Times | "What You Need, Man, Is a Revolution Like Mine" (August 31, 1961) |
| 1963 | Frank Miller | Des Moines Register | A cartoon of a destroyed world, captioned in part "I said we sure settled that dispute, didn't we!" |
| 1964 | Paul Conrad | The Denver Post | Editorial cartooning during the past year |
| 1966 | Don Wright | The Miami News | "You Mean You Were Bluffing?" |
| 1967 | Patrick B. Oliphant | The Denver Post | "They Won't Get Us To The Conference Table...Will They?" (February 1, 1966) |
| 1968 | Eugene Gray Payne | The Charlotte Observer | Editorial cartooning in 1967 |
| 1969 | John Fischetti | Chicago Daily News | Editorial cartooning in 1968 |
| 1970 | Thomas F. Darcy | Newsday, Garden City, NY | Editorial cartooning in 1969 |
| 1971 | Paul Conrad | Los Angeles Times | Editorial cartooning in 1970 |
| 1972 | Jeffrey K. MacNelly | Richmond News-Leader | Editorial cartooning in 1971 |
| 1974 | Paul Szep | The Boston Globe | Editorial cartooning in 1973 |
| 1975 | Garry Trudeau | Universal Press Syndicate | The comic strip "Doonesbury" |
| 1976 | Tony Auth | The Philadelphia Inquirer | A cartoon referencing "America the Beautiful" (July 22, 1975) |
| 1977 | Paul Szep | The Boston Globe | |
| 1978 | Jeffrey K. MacNelly | Richmond News Leader | |
| 1979 | Herbert L. Block | The Washington Post | Body of his work |
| 1980 | Don Wright | The Miami News | |
| 1981 | Mike Peters | Dayton Daily News | |
| 1982 | Ben Sargent | Austin American-Statesman | |
| 1983 | Richard Locher | Chicago Tribune | |
| 1984 | Paul Conrad | Los Angeles Times | |
| 1985 | Jeff MacNelly | Chicago Tribune | |
| 1986 | Jules Feiffer | The Village Voice, New York | |
| 1987 | Berke Breathed | The Washington Post Writers Group | |
| 1988 | Doug Marlette | The Atlanta Constitution and Charlotte Observer | |
| 1989 | Jack Higgins | Chicago Sun-Times | |
| 1990 | Tom Toles | The Buffalo News | "First Amendment" |
| 1991 | Jim Borgman | The Cincinnati Enquirer | |
| 1992 | Signe Wilkinson | The Philadelphia Daily News | |
| 1993 | Stephen R. Benson | The Arizona Republic | |
| 1994 | Michael P. Ramirez | Commercial Appeal, Memphis | |
| 1995 | Mike Luckovich | The Atlanta Constitution | |
| 1996 | Jim Morin | The Miami Herald | |
| 1997 | Walt Handelsman | Times-Picayune, New Orleans | |
| 1998 | Stephen P. Breen | Asbury Park Press, Neptune, NJ | |
| 1999 | David Horsey | Seattle Post-Intelligencer | |
| 2000 | Joel Pett | Lexington Herald-Leader |
Three patterns show up. Repeat winners are common: Paul Conrad (1964, 1971, 1984), Jeff MacNelly (1972, 1978, 1985), Paul Szep (1974, 1977), Don Wright (1966, 1980), Herblock (1954, 1979 here, plus 1942), Mauldin (1945, 1959) and Fitzpatrick (1955, after 1926).26 Second, the address changes. The early winners are at metropolitan dailies in the East and Midwest. By the 1980s and 1990s they include papers in Dayton, Austin, Cincinnati and Seattle. Third, three winners are credited to non-newspaper outlets: United Feature Syndicate for Mauldin in 1945, Universal Press Syndicate for Trudeau in 1975, and The Village Voice for Jules Feiffer in 1986. The Voice's page says the winning work was eleven cartoons dated February to December 1985, and names a jury of Howard Simons (chair), Skeeter Hagler, Pam McAllister Johnson, David Lipman and Arnold Ropeik.27
How to: verify a Pulitzer claim for a cartoonist
- Go to the category page on pulitzer.org (Editorial Cartooning) and find the year. Copy the winner, outlet and cited work exactly.
- Open the individual winner page for any detail the category page lacks. The Trudeau and Wilkinson pages give the citation or no description at all, and neither says "first." Attribute "first" claims to the source that makes them.
- Check whether the prize is for a cartoon, a year's work or a body of work. Herblock's 1979 prize was for his body of work. Conrad's 1964 prize was for editorial cartooning "during the past year."28
- For a claim of a missing year, say the page lists no winner and do not say why unless the Board has said.
- Check the year of the work against the year of the prize. Oliphant's cartoon was published February 1, 1966, and the prize is listed in 1967.29 The Library's Oliphant page says he won in 1966, a one-year conflict with the Pulitzer site; use the prize site for prize dates.30
- Note separate prizes. The 1973 Public Service prize that named Herblock among four Post staff members is not the cartooning prize.
Mauldin after the war
Bill Mauldin's postwar career produced two more entries in this lesson. The Pulitzer site lists his 1959 prize for a St. Louis Post-Dispatch cartoon published October 30, 1958 and captioned "I won the Nobel Prize for Literature. What was your crime?"31 The page gives no gloss on the caption, and this lesson supplies none. By 1963 Mauldin was at the Chicago Sun-Times.32 The University of South Florida's digital exhibit catalogues Figure of weeping Lincoln monument: a silent cartoon, dated November 22, 1963, in the Chicago Sun-Times, of a weeping Lincoln Memorial, linked in the catalog's subject headings to the assassination of President John F. Kennedy.33 The record says "Copyright 1963 by Bill Mauldin. Courtesy of Bill Mauldin Estate LLC,"34 so it is linked here and not embedded.
Read it with the method. It has no words, so there is no label to fall back on. The symbol is a monument, and the irony is that stone shows grief. The context is the date: the cartoon is catalogued with the date of the assassination itself. Whether Mauldin drew it that day or the next morning is not in the record. Take care with that: "Mauldin drew it the day Kennedy died" is a claim the catalog does not make.
Conrad, Oliphant, MacNelly and the generation of the 1960s and 1970s
Paul Conrad won three Pulitzers: 1964 at The Denver Post and 1971 and 1984 at the Los Angeles Times (Pulitzer site).35 The Associated Press obituary of September 2010 says he died at 86 at his home in Rancho Palos Verdes, California, that he worked at the Denver Post for 14 years and the Los Angeles Times for 30,36 and that his son David said his father "always said he was most proud of being on Nixon's enemies list."37 That is the verified form of the enemies-list story: a son's statement in an obituary. This lesson did not find the list itself, a Nixon White House document, in a source fetched here, so it does not say what is on it.
Pat Oliphant won in 1967 at The Denver Post for "They Won't Get Us To The Conference Table...Will They?", published February 1, 1966.38 The Library of Congress's exhibit says he left his native Australia for an American career in 1964, that his work addresses Watergate, Vietnam, the collapse of communism in Europe and the Gulf War, that he has caricatured seven U.S. presidents from Lyndon Johnson to Bill Clinton, and that his cartoons and sketchbooks will be preserved at the Library.39 It describes his style as combining the subtle wit and detailed artistry of the British satirical tradition with the blunter, spare style common in America. That is a statement about method that a reader can test against his cartoons.
Jeffrey MacNelly was 24, per the Pulitzer page, when he won in 1972 for his 1971 work at the Richmond News-Leader.40 He grew up in Cedarhurst, New York, attended Phillips Academy and the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and joined the News Leader's editorial staff in December 1970.41 He won again in 1978 and in 1985, then at the Chicago Tribune. The Pulitzer page gives no cited work for those later prizes, and the page fetched does not mention his comic strip, so this lesson does not.
Tony Auth's 1976 prize at the Philadelphia Inquirer is credited to a cartoon of July 22, 1975, that references the song "America the Beautiful."42 Mike Peters (1981), Ben Sargent (1982), Richard Locher (1983), Berke Breathed (1987), Doug Marlette (1988), Jack Higgins (1989), Tom Toles (1990, "First Amendment"), Jim Borgman (1991), Stephen Benson (1993), Michael Ramirez (1994), Mike Luckovich (1995), Jim Morin (1996), Walt Handelsman (1997), Stephen Breen (1998), David Horsey (1999) and Joel Pett (2000) round out the list. None of these entries comes with a cited cartoon on the page, apart from Toles, and this lesson makes no claim about any of their individual cartoons.
Jules Feiffer and Garry Trudeau: the strip as editorial
Two winners complicate the word "cartoonist." Jules Feiffer's 1986 prize, at The Village Voice, was for eleven cartoons from 1985.43 Garry Trudeau's 1975 prize was for something else entirely. The Pulitzer page for Trudeau gives the citation "For his cartoon strip Doonesbury," lists the work as Universal Press Syndicate's, and places the prize in the Editorial Cartooning category.44 The Pulitzer page does not say it was the first for a comic strip. The Comic Book Legal Defense Fund calls it "the first comic strip ever to win the editorial cartooning prize," and that is the source for the claim; the Pulitzer site itself does not state it.45
The strip's most-discussed week came two years earlier. The Comic Book Legal Defense Fund reports that in May 1973 Doonesbury showed the character Mark Slackmeyer, described there as a radio commentator, declaring former Attorney General John Mitchell "guilty, guilty, guilty!!"46 The Fund says the strip mocked people who were overreacting to the Watergate scandal and not Mitchell himself, since Mitchell's guilt had not yet been established. More than a dozen of the roughly 300 papers carrying the strip declined to run it, because they worried that the strip's apparent claim of Mitchell's guilt would undermine their journalistic integrity even on the comics page.47 The Fund calls one paper's justification "rather weak" without detailing it. The Washington Post, according to the Fund's headline, finally ran the strip 41 years later, in 2014.48
Myth: the 1973 Doonesbury Mitchell strip was banned
The record is narrower and more interesting. Each paper that declined it made its own decision about its own comics page. By the Fund's count more than a dozen papers, out of roughly 300 that carried the strip, did so. No government acted; the editors weighed whether a comics page could say a man was guilty before a court had. The strip's own target was the overreaction. If you write "banned," you have changed an editorial choice into censorship, and the facts in the Fund's account do not support it. If you write "pulled by more than a dozen papers," you are accurate and the story is still good.
The first women on the list
The Philadelphia Inquirer's history page says that in April 1992 Daily News cartoonist Signe Wilkinson "became the first woman to win a Pulitzer Prize for editorial cartooning."49 The Pulitzer site lists her under 1992 for the Philadelphia Daily News and, on her page, gives no description and does not say "first woman." The Penn State oral-history biography adds that she joined the San Jose Mercury News as a full-time editorial cartoonist in 1982, stayed three years and returned to the Daily News in 1985.50 (That page mentions a 1994 prize in its interview highlights, a conflict with the 1992 date on the Pulitzer site, so use the Pulitzer date.)
Ann Telnaes won in 2001. The Pulitzer page lists Tribune Media Services and gives no written citation. Her biography there says her cartoons appeared in the Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times and the New York Times, that she was born in Stockholm, earned a character animation degree at CalArts, worked earlier at Warner Bros. and Walt Disney Imagineering, and lives in Washington, DC.51 The page does not call her the second woman to win. Her prize came nine years after Wilkinson's. Her later career, including her 2025 events, belongs to lesson 04.
The economics: syndication, staff jobs and the figures that exist
The brief for this course asked for counts of staff cartoonists in 1980 and 2000. This lesson could not verify either. The Herb Block Foundation's December 2011 report says approximately 2,000 editorial cartoonists were employed by U.S. newspapers in the early 1900s and that fewer than 40 staff cartoonists remained, and that the number was still shrinking.52 The full white paper repeats both numbers on its third page and names no source for either.53 On page 19 the cartoonist Clay Bennett puts full-time staff cartoonists at just over 60, calling it an all-time low, with no source, which conflicts with the report's own introduction.54 The report found no figures for 1950, 1980, 2000 or 2008 in the pages that could be read, and the document appeared truncated, so those figures may exist in an unread portion. Where you need a number, attribute it and give the date.
The report's survey is a more reliable source about the work itself. The Foundation sent the survey to 125 members of the Association of American Editorial Cartoonists and received 68 responses, a 54 percent return.55 Of respondents, 41 percent earn more than half their income from their main employer and 45 percent earn less than a quarter.56 Fifty-six percent report syndication income, 18 percent earn more than half their income from syndication, and 38 percent earn less than 20 percent of income that way.57 The survey does not report how many respondents were full-time staff. Its 21 percent figure for full-time employment is a prediction for ten years out.58 Eleven essays by AAEC members make up the rest.59
| Measure | Figure | Source and date | Caution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cartoonists employed, early 1900s | About 2,000 | Herb Block Foundation, 2011 report, p. 3 | No source named for the number |
| Staff cartoonists, 2011 | Fewer than 40 | Same report, p. 3 | Conflicts with Bennett's essay, p. 19 ("just over 60") |
| Staff cartoonists, 1980 | Not verified | None found | Do not print a figure |
| Staff cartoonists, 2000 | Not verified | None found | Do not print a figure |
| AAEC survey | 125 sent, 68 returned (54 percent) | 2011 report, p. 6 | Members only, self-reported |
| Respondents with syndication income | 56 percent | 2011 report, p. 7 | 18 percent earn more than half their income this way |
| Typical reprint fee, paper of the New York Times's size | $250 (original work roughly $1,500 to $2,000) | Ted Rall's draft reply to the Times, quoted by CJR, February 7, 2012 | One cartoonist's statement |
The Columbia Journalism Review article of February 7, 2012, by Alysia Santo, is the source for the money. It says most cartoonists make their living from a mix of syndication and independent contracts and that only a small minority hold staff jobs. Ted Rall told CJR he earned about a third of what he made in the 1990s.60 CJR also quotes his draft reply to the New York Times, which called a $250 offer far below market and said a reprint for a paper of that size typically pays $250 while original work should pay roughly $1,500 to $2,000.61 The Times's solicitation, CJR reports, asked for original, unsyndicated work on spec, with one cartoon chosen each week for $250.62 Scott Stantis, Mark Fiore and Rall described other income: a syndicated strip, a blog, a podcast, a radio show, YouTube advertising and an auction of dinner and the right to pick a cartoon's subject.63 Aspiring cartoonists, the article says, are often offered "exposure" instead of pay.64 Those are the 2012 facts. What happened to the numbers after that is lesson 04's subject.
Why the syndicate model mattered
A syndicate sells the same drawing to many papers. For the cartoonist, that turns one cartoon into many small payments and ends the dependence on a single editor. For readers, it means the same cartoon appears in cities with different politics, and it means a local paper can run a national voice and need no local one. Mauldin (United Feature), Trudeau (Universal Press Syndicate) and Berke Breathed (the Washington Post Writers Group) are all credited to syndicates on the Pulitzer page. The staff cartoonist, by contrast, knew the city, was tied to one editor, and could be fired by one. Both arrangements are visible in the Pulitzer list. They also meant different things when a paper chose to drop a cartoon: a syndicated strip cut by one paper still ran in others, while a staff cartoonist's cartoon, once killed, had no other place to run.
If you report on this
- For McCarthyism, cite the Library of Congress exhibit page and the date March 29, 1950, and say the Library calls it the first use of the word. Do not add a quotation from the cartoon beyond its caption.
- For Herblock's prizes, give 1942, 1954 and 1979 for cartooning, and separately say he was one of four named in the 1973 Public Service prize.
- For Doonesbury, write "more than a dozen of about 300 papers declined" and cite the CBLDF article. Do not write "banned," and give the year the Post ran the strip (2014).
- For Conrad and the enemies list, write that his son said he was most proud of being on it. Do not state what the list contains without a primary source.
- For staff-cartoonist counts, attribute each figure and give the date. The 2011 report says fewer than 40 and an essay in it says just over 60. Print neither without saying which.
- For "first woman" claims, attribute the Inquirer for Wilkinson and note that the Pulitzer pages do not make the claim.
Go further
- Library of Congress, Herblock's History: Fire and Crook, and the Herb Block Foundation biography.
- The Pulitzer category page and the individual pages for Trudeau, Wilkinson, Telnaes, MacNelly, Feiffer and Oliphant.
- The Herb Block Foundation's 2011 white paper with its AAEC survey and eleven essays, and CJR's "Drawing the News Ain't Easy".
- The Comic Book Legal Defense Fund's account of the Doonesbury strip the Post ran in 2014.
- The Library's Oliphant exhibit and the University of South Florida's catalog entry for Mauldin's weeping Lincoln.
- Herblock's own books, listed by the Foundation: The Herblock Book (1952) and Herblock: A Cartoonist's Life (1993).
Questions and answers
Did Herblock really coin "McCarthyism"?
The Library of Congress's exhibit says so, dating the cartoon March 29, 1950, with the caption "You mean I'm supposed to stand on that?" It calls the cartoon the first use of the word. Other accounts may credit the word differently, and a careful writer attributes: "according to the Library of Congress." See the exhibit page.
How many Pulitzers did Herblock win?
Three for cartooning (1942, 1954 and 1979), per the Herb Block Foundation and the Pulitzer site. He was also one of four Washington Post staff named in the 1973 Public Service prize for Watergate coverage. The Foundation lists the Presidential Medal of Freedom (1994) and the Library's Living Legends Medal (2000) among other honors.
Was Doonesbury the first comic strip to win a Pulitzer?
The Pulitzer site lists Trudeau's 1975 prize in the Editorial Cartooning category for "his cartoon strip Doonesbury" and does not call it a first. The Comic Book Legal Defense Fund calls it "the first comic strip ever to win the editorial cartooning prize," so the claim has that one source and not the Pulitzer Board.
Was the Doonesbury strip about John Mitchell banned?
No. According to the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, more than a dozen of about 300 newspapers declined to run the May 1973 strip. The strip's target was people overreacting to Watergate, since Mitchell's guilt had not been established. The Washington Post ran it in 2014.
Who was the first woman to win the editorial cartooning Pulitzer?
The Philadelphia Inquirer says Signe Wilkinson, in April 1992. The Pulitzer site lists her for 1992 and does not use the word "first." Ann Telnaes is listed for 2001.
How many staff cartoonists are there?
The Herb Block Foundation's 2011 report says fewer than 40, and one essay in the same report says just over 60. Neither names a source. This course gives no 1980 or 2000 figure because none was verified, and lesson 04 deals with the present.
Why do some Pulitzer entries cite a cartoon and others do not?
The early entries cite a single work, a practice that fades after 1975. Some prizes are for a year of work (Conrad, 1964; MacNelly, 1972) and one is for a body of work (Herblock, 1979). The page does not explain the change. If you need the cartoon behind a prize, check the winner's page and the newspaper archive for the year.
What did Mauldin draw on the day of the Kennedy assassination?
The University of South Florida's catalog dates a silent weeping Lincoln Memorial cartoon from the Chicago Sun-Times November 22, 1963, copyrighted by Bill Mauldin and held courtesy of the Bill Mauldin Estate. The record does not say when in the day it was drawn, so a careful writer says "dated November 22, 1963."
Hard questions
The Herblock cartoons in this lesson target Republicans. Isn't that bias?
It is a position. The Library's pages show him drawing Republican senators in 1950 and Nixon from 1954 to 1974, and the Pulitzer page lists him winning for the Washington Post in 1954 and 1979 (the 1954 prize was for a cartoon of Death addressing Stalin). The Library's Nixon page also shows him answering events, such as the June 1972 Watergate break-in. A fair reader checks each cartoon against its date and the event it addressed. The standard for political cartooning has never been balance. It is accuracy about the facts a cartoon rests on.
Is it fair to credit Herblock with a word that was already in the air?
The Library says he coined it, and a researcher who found an earlier use would overturn the claim. Until one is found, the best statement is "the Library of Congress credits Herblock with the first use of the word McCarthyism in a cartoon dated March 29, 1950." That wording is true to the source and does not overreach.
Doesn't pulling a strip like Doonesbury prove newspapers are cowards?
The editors' stated worry, in the CBLDF's account, was that a strip implying Mitchell's guilt would undermine their journalistic integrity. That is a judgment about where opinion belongs in a paper. The CBLDF calls the Post's justification "rather weak," which is an assessment by the Fund. Reasonable editors can disagree. The facts are that more than a dozen of about 300 papers declined, and the others ran it.
Do the Pulitzer winners show the best work of those years?
They show what juries chose. The page lists no winner for 1960, 1965 and 1973. Winners are credited in different ways, and many entries after 1975 cite no work. A cartoonist whose paper did not enter has no entry. Treat the list as a record of recognition, and see the individual winner pages for what was actually honored.
If staff jobs fell from about 2,000 to under 40, isn't the form dead?
The 2011 numbers describe jobs, not cartoons. CJR's 2012 article describes cartoonists making a living through syndication, contracts, blogs, podcasts and online ad revenue, with Rall's complaint that pay had fallen to about a third of his 1990s income. That is a profession in a different shape, and a worse financial one by those accounts. Whether the form survives is a question about readers and editors, not about the count alone, and lesson 04 takes it up with later evidence.
Learn more
- Library of Congress: Herblock's History, Fire: the catalog page for the March 29, 1950 cartoon and the word McCarthyism.
- Library of Congress: Herblock's History, Crook: the Nixon cartoons from 1970 to 1974 with the events each answered.
- Herb Block Foundation: Herblock biography: dates, jobs and prizes for the central figure of the lesson.
- Pulitzer Prizes: Editorial Cartooning: every winner from 1945 to 2000 with the cited work where the page gives one.
- Comic Book Legal Defense Fund: Doonesbury in the Washington Post: the account of the 1973 strip that more than a dozen papers declined.
- Philadelphia Inquirer: Signe Wilkinson wins the Pulitzer: the paper's own report of the 1992 prize.
- Herb Block Foundation: 2011 white paper: the AAEC survey and eleven essays on the state of the trade.
- Columbia Journalism Review: Drawing the News Ain't Easy: what cartoonists were paid in 2012 and by whom.
- Library of Congress: Pat Oliphant exhibit: a cartoonist's career and style in the Library's words.
- University of South Florida: Mauldin's weeping Lincoln: the catalog record for the cartoon dated November 22, 1963.
Notes
- Herb Block Foundation, Herblock biography. Read it online. ↩
- Library of Congress, Herblock's History, "Fire" (March 29, 1950 cartoon). Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, Herblock biography. Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, Editorial Cartooning winners by category. Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, winner page for Garry Trudeau (1975). Read it online. ↩
- Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, "Spiked Doonesbury Strip Runs in Washington Post After 41 Years" (2014). Read it online. ↩
- Philadelphia Inquirer, "Signe Wilkinson wins Pulitzer for editorial cartooning" (1992), history page. Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, winner page for Ann Telnaes (2001). Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, Report on Editorial Cartooning (December 2011). Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, Herblock biography. Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, Herblock biography. Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, Herblock biography. Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, Herblock biography. Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, Herblock biography. Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, Editorial Cartooning winners by category. Read it online. ↩
- Library of Congress, Herblock's History, "Fire" (March 29, 1950 cartoon). Read it online. ↩
- Library of Congress, Herblock's History, "Fire" (March 29, 1950 cartoon). Read it online. ↩
- Library of Congress, Herblock's History, "Fire" (March 29, 1950 cartoon). Read it online. ↩
- Library of Congress, Herblock's History, "Fire" (March 29, 1950 cartoon). Read it online. ↩
- Library of Congress, Herblock's History, "Crook" (Nixon cartoons, 1970 to 1974). Read it online. ↩
- Library of Congress, Herblock's History, "Crook" (Nixon cartoons, 1970 to 1974). Read it online. ↩
- Library of Congress, Herblock's History, "Crook" (Nixon cartoons, 1970 to 1974). Read it online. ↩
- Library of Congress, Herblock's History, "Crook" (Nixon cartoons, 1970 to 1974). Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, Editorial Cartooning winners by category. Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, Editorial Cartooning winners by category. Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, Editorial Cartooning winners by category. Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, winner page for Jules Feiffer (1986). Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, winner page for Paul Conrad (1964). Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, winner page for Patrick B. Oliphant (1967). Read it online. ↩
- Library of Congress, Pat Oliphant exhibit. Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, Editorial Cartooning winners by category. Read it online. ↩
- University of South Florida Libraries, Figure of weeping Lincoln monument (Bill Mauldin, November 22, 1963), digital exhibit record. Read it online. ↩
- University of South Florida Libraries, Figure of weeping Lincoln monument (Bill Mauldin, November 22, 1963), digital exhibit record. Read it online. ↩
- University of South Florida Libraries, Figure of weeping Lincoln monument (Bill Mauldin, November 22, 1963), digital exhibit record. Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, Editorial Cartooning winners by category. Read it online. ↩
- NBC News (AP), "Pulitzer-winning cartoonist Paul Conrad dies at 86." Read it online. ↩
- NBC News (AP), "Pulitzer-winning cartoonist Paul Conrad dies at 86." Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, winner page for Patrick B. Oliphant (1967). Read it online. ↩
- Library of Congress, Pat Oliphant exhibit. Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, winner page for Jeffrey K. MacNelly (1972). Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, winner page for Jeffrey K. MacNelly (1972). Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, Editorial Cartooning winners by category. Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, winner page for Jules Feiffer (1986). Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, winner page for Garry Trudeau (1975). Read it online. ↩
- Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, "Spiked Doonesbury Strip Runs in Washington Post After 41 Years" (2014). Read it online. ↩
- Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, "Spiked Doonesbury Strip Runs in Washington Post After 41 Years" (2014). Read it online. ↩
- Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, "Spiked Doonesbury Strip Runs in Washington Post After 41 Years" (2014). Read it online. ↩
- Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, "Spiked Doonesbury Strip Runs in Washington Post After 41 Years" (2014). Read it online. ↩
- Philadelphia Inquirer, "Signe Wilkinson wins Pulitzer for editorial cartooning" (1992), history page. Read it online. ↩
- Penn State Bellisario College of Communications, Newspaper Journalists Oral History Program, interview with Signe Wilkinson. Read it online. ↩
- Pulitzer Prizes, winner page for Ann Telnaes (2001). Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, Report on Editorial Cartooning (December 2011). Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, 2011 white paper on editorial cartooning (PDF). Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, 2011 white paper on editorial cartooning (PDF). Page 19, essay by Clay Bennett. Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, 2011 white paper on editorial cartooning (PDF). Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, 2011 white paper on editorial cartooning (PDF). Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, 2011 white paper on editorial cartooning (PDF). Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, 2011 white paper on editorial cartooning (PDF). Read it online. ↩
- Herb Block Foundation, 2011 white paper on editorial cartooning (PDF). Read it online. ↩
- Alysia Santo, "Drawing the News Ain't Easy," Columbia Journalism Review, February 7, 2012. Read it online. ↩
- Alysia Santo, "Drawing the News Ain't Easy," Columbia Journalism Review, February 7, 2012. Read it online. ↩
- Alysia Santo, "Drawing the News Ain't Easy," Columbia Journalism Review, February 7, 2012. Read it online. ↩
- Alysia Santo, "Drawing the News Ain't Easy," Columbia Journalism Review, February 7, 2012. Read it online. ↩
- Alysia Santo, "Drawing the News Ain't Easy," Columbia Journalism Review, February 7, 2012. Read it online. ↩
Check yourself
1. What does the Library of Congress say about Herblock's cartoon dated March 29, 1950?
The Library's exhibit page says Herb Block coined McCarthyism in the cartoon dated March 29, 1950, weeks after McCarthy claimed to hold a list of communists in the State Department. It shows Republican senators Wherry, Taft and Bridges and party chairman Gabrielson pushing a reluctant GOP elephant onto a platform of tar buckets.
2. In which years did Herblock win Pulitzer Prizes for editorial cartooning, according to the Herb Block Foundation and the Pulitzer site?
He won for cartooning in 1942 (NEA, 'British Plane'), 1954 (Washington Post) and 1979 (for the body of his work). In 1973 he was one of four Post staff members named in the Public Service prize for Watergate coverage, which is a separate prize.
3. What happened to the May 1973 Doonesbury strip in which Mark Slackmeyer declares John Mitchell 'guilty'?
The Comic Book Legal Defense Fund reports that more than a dozen of about 300 papers declined it and that the Post finally ran it 41 years later. The strip mocked people who overreacted to Watergate, since Mitchell's guilt was not yet established. Trudeau's 1975 Pulitzer was cited 'For his cartoon strip Doonesbury.'
4. Which statement about the Pulitzer site's Editorial Cartooning page between 1945 and 2000 is accurate?
The page lists no entry for 1960, 1965 or 1973 (and, earlier, 1923 and 1936) and does not say why. Do not write that the prize was 'not awarded' unless you have a Board statement.
5. What does the Herb Block Foundation's 2011 report give as the number of staff cartoonists then, and what complication does the report itself contain?
Page 3 says approximately 2,000 in the early 1900s and fewer than 40 staff cartoonists 'today.' Clay Bennett's essay on page 19 says just over 60, an all-time low, citing no source. The report's figures for 1980 and 2000 were not found in the pages read, so this course does not give them.
6. Who does the Inquirer say became the first woman to win the Pulitzer for editorial cartooning, and when?
The Philadelphia Inquirer's history page says Wilkinson became the first woman to win the Pulitzer for editorial cartooning in April 1992. The Pulitzer site lists Ann Telnaes of Tribune Media Services as the 2001 winner. The Pulitzer pages themselves do not say 'first woman,' so attribute the claim.
Terms in this lesson
- McCarthyism
- The word the Library of Congress credits Herblock with coining in a cartoon dated March 29, 1950, for Senator Joseph McCarthy's tactics of unproved accusation.
- Syndicate
- A company that sells one cartoonist's work to many newspapers, such as Universal Press Syndicate, which carried Doonesbury.
- Staff cartoonist
- A cartoonist on a single newspaper's payroll who draws editorial cartoons for that paper.
- Enemies list
- The Nixon White House list of political opponents. Paul Conrad's son said his father was proudest of being on it.
- Editorial cartooning (Pulitzer category)
- The prize category first awarded in 1922. Winners are cited by cartoon, by year of work, or by body of work.
- Reprint fee
- The payment for running an already-published cartoon. Ted Rall, in a draft reply to the New York Times quoted by CJR in 2012, said a paper of that size typically pays $250 for a reprint.
- Spec work
- Work submitted without a commitment to pay unless chosen, as in the New York Times solicitation CJR described, which offered $250 for one cartoon a week.
- Body of work
- The basis of Herblock's 1979 Pulitzer, which the Pulitzer site credits to the Washington Post for his work overall rather than one cartoon.
Sources
- Pulitzer Prizes, Editorial Cartooning winners by category checked 2026-10
- Library of Congress, Herblock's History: Fire (the March 29, 1950 McCarthyism cartoon) checked 2026-10
- Library of Congress, Herblock's History: Crook (Nixon cartoons 1970 to 1974) checked 2026-10
- Herb Block Foundation, Herblock biography checked 2026-10
- Herb Block Foundation, Report on Editorial Cartooning (December 2011) checked 2026-10
- Herb Block Foundation, 2011 white paper (PDF) checked 2026-10
- Columbia Journalism Review, Drawing the News Ain't Easy (Alysia Santo, February 7, 2012) checked 2026-10
- Pulitzer Prizes, Garry Trudeau (1975) checked 2026-10
- Pulitzer Prizes, Signe Wilkinson (1992) checked 2026-10
- Pulitzer Prizes, Ann Telnaes (2001) checked 2026-10
- Pulitzer Prizes, Paul Conrad (1964) checked 2026-10
- Pulitzer Prizes, Jules Feiffer (1986) checked 2026-10
- Pulitzer Prizes, Jeffrey K. MacNelly (1972) checked 2026-10
- Pulitzer Prizes, Patrick B. Oliphant (1967) checked 2026-10
- Library of Congress, Pat Oliphant exhibit checked 2026-10
- Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, Spiked Doonesbury Strip Runs in Washington Post After 41 Years checked 2026-10
- NBC News (AP), Pulitzer-winning cartoonist Paul Conrad dies at 86 checked 2026-10
- CBS Los Angeles, Pulitzer-winning cartoonist Paul Conrad dies at 86 (September 4, 2010) checked 2026-10
- University of South Florida Libraries, Figure of weeping Lincoln monument (Bill Mauldin, November 22, 1963) checked 2026-10
- Philadelphia Inquirer, Signe Wilkinson wins Pulitzer for editorial cartooning (1992) checked 2026-10
- Penn State Bellisario College, Signe Wilkinson oral history interview checked 2026-10
- Eisenhower Foundation, Soldier profile: William Mauldin checked 2026-10
- National Archives, Analyze a Cartoon worksheet checked 2026-10