Lesson 2 of 9 · about 16 minutes
Battery Chemistries: LFP, NMC, Sodium-Ion, Flow and the Rest
You'll be able to
- Compare LFP, NMC and NCA, sodium-ion, vanadium flow and other storage chemistries on safety, life and maturity
- Explain why 'safer chemistry' does not mean a battery cannot burn or explode
- Read EPRI's chemistry data with the right caution
- Do cycle-life and augmentation arithmetic for a grid battery
Nearly every grid battery being built in the U.S. is lithium-ion. "Lithium-ion" is a family, though, and the members burn differently. The batteries and storage lesson compares LFP and NMC on price, density and cycle life. This lesson adds the safety chemistry, the newer alternatives and how to read chemistry claims at a hearing.
What is inside a lithium-ion cell
Sandia's Energy Storage Handbook lists five key parts: a negative electrode (usually graphite), a positive electrode (the cathode, which names the chemistry), a liquid organic electrolyte, a thin plastic separator between the electrodes, and metal current collectors. The electrolyte is flammable. The separator is what keeps the two electrodes from touching; conventional polyolefin separators melt at about 130 to 170 degrees Celsius, and when they do, the cell shorts internally.
Sandia puts the fire problem plainly: a lithium-ion cell with a metal-oxide cathode carries fuel (the electrolyte), oxygen (released by the hot cathode) and, once it fails, its own ignition source. That is why smothering a lithium-ion fire works poorly. The fire is partly feeding itself.
The chemistries side by side
| Chemistry | How it stores energy | Safety profile | Status in grid storage |
|---|---|---|---|
| LFP (lithium iron phosphate) | Lithium-ion, iron phosphate cathode | More heat-stable; cathode releases far less oxygen; still has flammable electrolyte; off-gas is hydrogen-rich | Dominant in new U.S. projects |
| NMC (nickel manganese cobalt) | Lithium-ion, layered metal-oxide cathode | Higher energy density; cathode releases oxygen in runaway; burned at Moss Landing | Common in many older systems, including Moss Landing; still sold |
| NCA (nickel cobalt aluminum) | Lithium-ion, high-nickel cathode | Similar family to NMC | Used in some grid products |
| Sodium-ion | Sodium ions instead of lithium | Makers claim better abuse tolerance; independent test data is still thin | Early utility projects, mostly in China |
| Vanadium redox flow | Liquid vanadium electrolytes pumped through a stack | Water-based electrolyte, which is why makers describe it as nonflammable; Sandia notes designs use secondary containment against leaks | Small U.S. market; large projects in China |
| Iron-air (Form Energy) | Reversible rusting of iron | Water-based; designed for up to 100 hours | Early commercial deployments |
| Sodium-sulfur | Molten sodium and sulfur at high temperature | Runs hot; one fire in EPRI's table | Niche |
| Lead-acid | Lead plates in sulfuric acid | Hydrogen during charging; acid spills | Backup power; two incidents in EPRI's table |
"Safer" is a comparison
LFP is harder to push into thermal runaway than NMC, and when it does run away it releases less heat and much less oxygen. That is real. It does not follow that LFP systems don't burn or explode.
A 2024 review in the Journal of Energy Storage by researchers at the University of Sheffield, Imperial College London and the University of St Andrews pooled results from 60 papers on gas released during thermal runaway. NMC cells released more gas. LFP gas had more hydrogen, and its lower flammability limit was 6.2 percent against 7.9 percent for NMC. Using median gas volumes, the authors calculated that LFP off-gas reaches its lower flammability limit at a volume 18 percent smaller than NMC off-gas. The authors concluded LFP presents a greater flammability hazard even though LFP cells show flames less often in tests. For a battery inside a closed container, the gas that piles up without burning is the explosion risk; the failure modes lesson returns to this.
The fire record has LFP entries too. EPRI's database lists the April 16, 2021 explosion at a 25 MWh LFP system in Beijing that killed two firefighters, the June 2023 failures at two LFP sites in Warwick, New York (one with an explosion), and an October 2023 fire at a 2 MW / 8 MWh LFP system at an Idaho Power substation south of Melba.
What EPRI's chemistry data can and cannot show
In EPRI's stationary table as of its September 2026 update, incidents since 2023 with a named chemistry break down as 15 NMC and 11 LFP, with 36 more listed only as "Li ion." That count alone means little, because the share of LFP in the fleet rose fast over the same years. EPRI's October 2026 report tried to account for this and still could not separate chemistry from design maturity, so it did not conclude that cell chemistry alone is a risk factor for system-level failure. Industry groups cite that to say design matters more than chemistry. Residents cite the same finding to say a developer cannot rely on "we use LFP" as a safety answer. Both readings are fair. The practical upshot is the same: ask for test data on the specific product.
Sodium-ion and flow: the alternatives
Sodium-ion swaps lithium for sodium, which is cheap and abundant. Datang Hubei Energy Development brought the first 50 MW / 100 MWh phase of what was billed as the world's largest sodium-ion BESS online in Qianjiang, China, in July 2024, using cells from HiNa Battery, with 100 MW / 200 MWh planned. HiNa claims better performance in cold and in abuse tests. Energy-Storage.news reported that sodium-ion still cost more than lithium-ion at that point because of smaller scale. Treat cold-weather and safety claims as manufacturer claims until independent test reports exist for a given product.
Flow batteries keep their energy in tanks of liquid electrolyte, pumped through a cell stack where the reaction happens. Tank size sets the hours; stack size sets the megawatts. Rongke Power completed a 175 MW / 700 MWh vanadium flow project in Xinjiang in December 2024, described as the largest of its kind. Flow batteries take more space per MWh than lithium-ion and the U.S. market is small, but they shift the hazard from fire toward spill containment.
Form Energy's iron-air battery, covered in the storage lesson, targets multi-day discharge rather than the four-hour market.
How long the cells last
Cells lose capacity with every cycle and with time. Sandia notes that cycle aging depends on depth of discharge, charge rate and temperature, and that calendar aging depends on state of charge and temperature, rising with heat. Charging too fast, especially when cold, can plate lithium metal on the graphite, which costs capacity and can grow dendrites, a safety risk.
Worked example: cycles, years and augmentation
An invented 100 MW / 400 MWh battery in Copper Basin cycles once a day. Its hypothetical datasheet says the cells reach 80 percent of original capacity after 6,000 full cycles.
Years to 80% from cycling alone:
6,000 cycles / 365 per year = about 16.4 years
Energy left at 80%:
400 MWh x 0.80 = 320 MWh
To keep selling 400 MWh, the owner must add:
400 - 320 = 80 MWh of new modules (augmentation)
If the contract runs 20 years at one cycle a day:
20 x 365 = 7,300 cycles, past the 6,000 rating
Real aging is not linear and calendar aging adds to it, so the number arrives sooner than the simple division says. For a county, augmentation means more containers may arrive during the project's life. A permit should say whether added modules need a new review.
Common mix-ups
- Claim: "Iron-based" batteries can't burn. What the evidence shows: In grid sales talk "iron-based" usually means LFP, which is lithium-ion with a flammable electrolyte. Iron-air is a different, water-based technology. Ask which one.
- Claim: LFP batteries don't explode. What the evidence shows: LFP systems have exploded (Beijing 2021, Warwick 2023 in EPRI's table), and LFP off-gas is hydrogen-rich.
- Claim: Chemistry is the whole safety story. What the evidence shows: EPRI could not isolate chemistry as a cause. Spacing, enclosure, controls, ventilation and installation quality matter at least as much.
Reporting angle
- Ask for the cell manufacturer, cell model and the datasheet, not just "LFP." The UL 9540A test report names the exact cell and module tested.
- Ask whether the product in the application is the product in the fire test report. Model numbers change.
- Ask the developer for its augmentation plan: how many MWh will be added, when, and whether added units get a new fire review.
- Check EPRI's database for past incidents involving the same cell maker or integrator; both are columns in the table.
- When a developer says "safer chemistry," ask: safer than what, measured how, and in which test.
Research angle
- How lithium-ion cells are built and fail: Sandia Energy Storage Handbook, Chapter 3.
- The gas emissions review and its authors: University of Sheffield summary and pv magazine coverage.
- Incident-level chemistry, cell maker and integrator data: EPRI BESS Failure Incident Database (downloadable table).
- EPRI's 2026 risk factor findings: Energy-Storage.news report.
- Long-duration alternatives: Form Energy.
Check yourself
1. A 2024 Journal of Energy Storage review of 60 papers compared thermal runaway gas from LFP and NMC cells. What did it find?
The review reported LFL values of 6.2 percent for LFP and 7.9 percent for NMC off-gas and concluded that LFP presents a greater flammability hazard despite fewer flames in cell tests.
2. Why do metal-oxide cathodes like NMC make lithium-ion fires harder to smother?
Sandia's Energy Storage Handbook notes that metal-oxide positive electrodes release oxygen at high temperature, while the organic electrolyte is the fuel.
3. EPRI's October 2026 report could not conclude that cell chemistry alone is a risk factor for system failures. Why?
Newer systems are both more often LFP and better designed. The report could not untangle the two.
4. Which chemistry runs the world's largest sodium-ion BESS, Datang Hubei's project in Qianjiang, China?
Phase 1 came online in July 2024 at 50 MW / 100 MWh using HiNa cells; the full plan is 100 MW / 200 MWh.
5. What sets a flow battery's energy capacity apart from its power rating?
Bigger tanks add hours; bigger stacks add megawatts. Rongke Power's Xinjiang project is 175 MW / 700 MWh.
6. A battery cycles once a day. Its cells are rated (in this hypothetical) for 6,000 cycles to 80 percent of original capacity. About how many years until it reaches that point?
6,000 cycles / 365 cycles a year = about 16.4 years, ignoring calendar aging, which also wears cells.
Terms in this lesson
- Cathode chemistry
- The material of a lithium-ion cell's positive electrode, which gives the chemistry its name: LFP, NMC, NCA and so on.
- NCA
- Lithium nickel cobalt aluminum oxide, a high-nickel cathode in the same family as NMC.
- Sodium-ion
- A battery that shuttles sodium ions instead of lithium ions, using more abundant materials, with lower energy density so far.
- Flow battery
- A battery that stores energy in liquid electrolytes held in tanks and pumped through a cell stack.
- Lower flammability limit (LFL)
- The lowest concentration of a flammable gas in air that can ignite.
- Augmentation
- Adding or swapping battery modules during a project's life to make up for capacity lost to aging.
Sources
- Sandia National Laboratories, DOE-OE Energy Storage Handbook, Chapter 3: Lithium-ion Batteries checked 2026-10
- pv magazine USA, How safe are LFP batteries? (Apr. 10, 2024), on the Journal of Energy Storage review of thermal runaway gas emissions checked 2026-10
- University of Sheffield, New research paves the way for safer batteries with reduced fire and toxicity risks checked 2026-10
- Energy-Storage.news, Global BESS failure rates declined 98% between 2018 and 2025 (EPRI report, Oct. 8, 2026) checked 2026-10
- EPRI, BESS Failure Incident Database (stationary storage table, Sept. 2026 update) checked 2026-10
- Energy-Storage.news, World's largest sodium-ion BESS comes online in China (July 2024) checked 2026-10
- pv magazine, World's largest vanadium redox flow project completed (Dec. 10, 2024) checked 2026-10
- Form Energy, Battery technology checked 2026-10