Lesson 4 of 9 · about 16 minutes
Land, Noise, Diesel Generators, Light and Traffic
You'll be able to
- Estimate how many backup generators a campus needs and what the air permit should show
- Explain why data center noise is a low-frequency complaint that ordinances often miss
- Use the federal 100-hour rule for emergency engines when reading a permit
- List the land-use questions to ask at a rezoning hearing
Big campuses take big land. The Gemstone Technology Park near Kuna, Idaho covers about 620 acres, and Meta's nearby site about 485, according to a February 2026 guest column in the Idaho Capital Sun by Adam Young, a Bingham County farmer. The Idaho Conservation League puts Gemstone at 600 to 800 MW. Tucson's Project Blue sat on 290 acres with up to 10 buildings and about two million square feet planned, according to Data Center Dynamics. Most buildings are one or two stories, so a campus spreads out more than it rises.
At a hearing, size matters less than zoning. Ask what zone the parcel is in, what the zone allows, what it sits next to, and whether the county is being asked to change any of that.
Zoning and land use
Many county codes written before 2020 do not mention data centers at all. Planners then slot them into "warehouse," "light industrial" or "utility," each of which may carry different setbacks and noise rules. Watch for these moves at a hearing:
- Rezone from agricultural or rural residential to industrial.
- Conditional use permit where the zone allows the use only with conditions.
- Text amendment that adds "data center" as a permitted use, sometimes countywide.
- Annexation into a city to get city water and sewer, the step that sank Project Blue in Tucson.
- Development agreement, a contract spelling out roads, utilities and payments.
A text amendment deserves the most attention. It applies to every parcel in the zone, including ones nobody at the hearing is thinking about.
Noise
The sound comes mostly from rooftop and yard cooling equipment: fans, chillers, dry coolers, transformers. It runs day and night. Virginia's JLARC concluded in 2024 that data center noise is low-frequency and generally not loud enough to damage hearing or break noise ordinances, but that some nearby residents say the constant hum affects their well-being. JLARC also found that most data centers generate no noise complaints at all.
Most limits use dBA, which discounts low frequencies, so a hum can annoy people while the meter stays under the limit. Ask whether the ordinance or the developer's study includes a C-weighted or octave-band measure. Distance also matters. Sound from a single point source drops about 6 dB each time distance doubles. A unit measured at 70 dBA at 50 feet is about 64 at 100 feet, 58 at 200 and 52 at 400, before walls and berms. A yard of 40 units is not one point source, so a developer's model matters more than this rule of thumb.
Backup diesel generators and air permits
Nearly every data center keeps diesel generators to ride through outages. JLARC found almost all Virginia sites used them, mostly EPA Tier 2 units permitted for emergencies and maintenance testing only.
Example: counting generators
A campus needs 100 MW of backup. The developer plans 2.5 MW generators with one spare for every five ("N+1 per block" designs vary; ask).
- Units to carry the load: 100 / 2.5 = 40.
- Spares at one per five: 40 / 5 = 8.
- Total: 48 generators, about 120 MW of diesel capacity.
Testing: if each unit runs the federal maximum of 100 hours a year for maintenance and readiness, that is 4,800 engine-hours. Pull the fuel rate from the manufacturer's spec sheet in the permit file and multiply to get gallons burned per year. Many sites test well below the cap. The permit and the operating log say what actually happens.
The federal rule at 40 CFR 60.4211(f) caps maintenance and readiness testing at 100 hours a year per emergency engine, of which up to 50 may be used for limited non-emergency purposes. It bars using emergency engines for routine peak shaving. Emergency hours are unlimited. State permits often set tighter limits.
JLARC found Northern Virginia's data center generators produced less than 4 percent of regional nitrogen oxide emissions and 0.1 percent or less of carbon monoxide and particulates. Regional shares can still hide local exposure next to a yard of 100 engines on a test day, which is why Virginia DEQ was studying local effects.
A generator fleet that size usually needs a state air permit before construction. In Idaho, the Department of Environmental Quality applies the Rules for the Control of Air Pollution in Idaho, IDAPA 58.01.01, with permit-to-construct requirements in sections 200 to 228 and exemption categories in sections 220 to 223. The application lists every engine, its tier, its hours and modeled emissions at the fence line. Ask DEQ whether the permit will go out for public comment, and when and where the notice will be posted.
| What to find in the air permit file | Why |
|---|---|
| Number, size and EPA tier of engines | Tier 4 units emit far less than Tier 2 |
| Hour limits per engine and fleet-wide | Caps on testing and non-emergency use |
| Testing schedule (one engine at a time or many) | Simultaneous tests create local peaks |
| Modeled concentrations at the property line | Shows nearest-neighbor exposure |
| Fuel storage volume | Spill planning and fire code |
| Reporting and recordkeeping | What logs you can request later |
Light and traffic
Security lighting runs all night. Ask whether the county has a dark-sky or shielded-fixture standard and whether it is written into the conditions.
Traffic is mostly a construction problem. JLARC reported that each building takes 12 to 18 months with up to about 1,500 workers at peak. Add concrete trucks, steel and transformers on oversize loads. Once open, a typical 250,000-square-foot building has about 50 workers, so daily traffic drops sharply. The county road department or state transportation agency will have the haul route and any road use agreement.
Common mix-ups
- Claim: The generators run all the time. What the evidence shows: Emergency engines are limited to 100 hours a year for testing under federal rules, and usually run less. They do run without limit in real outages.
- Claim: If it meets the noise ordinance, nobody will be bothered. What the evidence shows: JLARC documented complaints from residents near sites that complied. Low-frequency hum is the issue.
Reporting angle
- Request the full air permit application from the state DEQ, including emissions modeling.
- Ask the county for the noise study and whether it measured low frequencies.
- Get the site plan with setbacks, berms and lighting plan.
- Ask whether the conditions of approval include enforceable noise limits and who measures.
- Find the haul route and road agreement for construction.
Research angle
- 40 CFR 60.4211: Federal rule on emergency generator engines.
- IDAPA 58.01.01: Idaho air pollution control rules.
- JLARC Data Centers in Virginia: Virginia's state audit of the industry.
- DCD on Tucson and Project Blue: Trade coverage of the rejection.
- ICL Dark Side of Data Centers, Part 3: Advocacy group outlook for Idaho.
- Idaho Capital Sun column on farm bills: Local account of rate pressure.
Check yourself
1. Under the federal rule at 40 CFR 60.4211(f), how many hours a year may an emergency stationary engine run for maintenance and readiness testing?
The rule caps maintenance and testing at 100 hours per calendar year, with up to 50 of those allowed for limited non-emergency use. Emergency operation has no limit.
2. Virginia's JLARC found backup generators in Northern Virginia accounted for what share of regional nitrogen oxide emissions?
JLARC reported less than 4 percent of regional NOx and 0.1 percent or less of carbon monoxide and particulate matter, and noted DEQ was studying local effects.
3. Why do neighbors complain about data center noise that meets a decibel limit?
JLARC found the noise usually does not break ordinances but that constant low-frequency sound affects some residents' well-being.
4. A campus needs 100 MW of backup with one spare generator for every five. Using 2.5 MW generators, about how many units is that?
100 / 2.5 = 40 units to carry the load. One spare per five adds 8, for 48.
5. For a simple point source in open air, how much does sound level drop each time you double the distance?
Inverse-square spreading gives about 6 dB per doubling of distance. Real sites differ because of ground, walls and many sources.
6. At a county rezoning hearing, which document typically lists the conditions the county attaches to an approval?
Staff reports recommend conditions, and the board's adopted findings and conditions of approval make them binding.
Terms in this lesson
- Emergency stationary engine
- A backup generator permitted to run without limit only during real emergencies, with capped hours for testing.
- Tier 2 / Tier 4 engine
- EPA emission tiers for diesel engines. Tier 4 units emit far less NOx and particulates than Tier 2.
- Permit to construct
- A state air permit required before building a new source of air pollution above set thresholds.
- dBA
- Decibels with A-weighting, a scale that discounts low frequencies, roughly matching how people hear quiet sounds.
- Conditions of approval
- Binding requirements a local government attaches to a rezoning or permit, such as setbacks, berms or noise limits.
Sources
- eCFR, 40 CFR 60.4211 (emergency stationary engines) checked 2026-10
- JLARC, Data Centers in Virginia (2024) checked 2026-10
- IDAPA 58.01.01, Rules for the Control of Air Pollution in Idaho checked 2026-10
- Idaho Conservation League, The Dark Side of Data Centers, Part 3 checked 2026-10
- Idaho Capital Sun, guest column by Adam Young (Feb. 23, 2026) checked 2026-10
- Data Center Dynamics, Tucson rejects Project Blue (Aug. 2025) checked 2026-10